Full Transcript Introduction to the podcast and Dr. Jim Adams 0:00 A normal person has about 500 species of bacteria in their gut, whereas kids with autism are missing on average about 100 of those. 0:07 So they're missing about 25% of their normal gut bacteria, but it's very different from one child to another. 0:13 And also there are about 500 bacteria that are elevated in kids with autism. 0:18 So that's one major clue. 0:20 They have too few of the good bacteria, too many of the harmful ones. 0:24 Welcome to Demystifying Pans and Pandas, the podcast where we uncover the mysteries, breakthroughs, and hope behind these life-altering conditions. 0:34 I'm Dr. 0:35 Nancy O'Hara, a board-certified pediatrician, educator, and advocate with over three decades of experience helping children and families navigate the challenges 0:46 of neurodevelopmental and neuropsychiatric conditions, especially pans and pandas. 0:52 These disorders can feel overwhelming, but here we'll break down the science, explore transformative treatments, and share stories of resilience and recovery. 1:04 If you've ever wondered what's possible for your child or how to find answers, this is the place to start. 1:11 Let's dive in. 1:12 Hi everybody, and welcome back to Demystifying Pan's Pandas. 1:16 I'm Dr. 1:16 Nancy O'Hara, and I'm really excited to welcome Dr. 1:20 Jim Adams to our podcast today. 1:23 Jim is a professor at Arizona State University, a leader in their autism research group there, and really an instrumental leader in the field and research 1:35 of autism in general, uncovering biological causes, innovative treatments for autism. 1:41 And Jim, it's just such a pleasure to have you on the podcast. 1:45 Great to have a chance to chat with you again, Nancy. 1:47 I think we've known one another close to 20 years, so it's great. 1:51 Absolutely. 1:52 And your work in the Autism Research Institute and your work at Arizona and especially the plethora of research you have done has just been so instrumental 2:04 in all of our kids, especially those with autism.
How Dr. Adams entered autism research 2:07 So I really personally appreciate it and professionally thank you also. 2:12 Well, thanks. 2:13 Again, I think in the autism field, so much of the research has been really driven by what the parents then tell the physicians, 2:20 the physicians then tell the researchers, and then we go and follow up on it. 2:24 So it's very much a great collaboration. 2:27 Yeah. 2:28 So just for those listening or watching that don't know you, how did you get into this in the first place? 2:34 So I have a daughter with autism, and when she didn't talk at age two and just ignored us, that was a big clue. 2:41 At age two and a half, she was diagnosed with both severe autism and severe intellectual disability, and we were told just a matter of time until we'd 2:49 have to institutionalize her, and it was crushing. 2:51 But my wife and I decided we were just going to love her. 2:54 Then my wife went to an ARI conference and came away thinking there was something there we could do biologically, and I was very skeptical. 3:04 I said, vitamins and minerals? 3:06 How could those possibly be important for children with autism? 3:09 We've known about them for decades. 3:11 And then when I looked at the research by Bernie Rimland and other studies, I was rapidly convinced. 3:17 And now for 13 years, we've had our own vitamin mineral supplement company. 3:22 So thanks to the work by you and many others at ARI and other groups. 3:27 Yeah, it's just incredible. 3:29 And as a background, there have been dozens of research studies demonstrating that bacterial and yeast infections in the gut are just so common in people 3:44 with autism. 3:44 And as you know, and many of our listeners know, Sid Baker was my mentor, so I was I was on this 30 years ago because of CID. 3:53 And, you know, the bacteria in the yeast produce toxins that affect our gut and our body and our brain. 4:00 But, you know, there are obviously gut symptoms, constipation, diarrhea, but a lot of these things also worsen symptoms of autism and also symptoms of pans-pandas. 4:12 So can you talk a little bit more about that, the effect of the microbial metabolites, all of that? 4:18 Yeah, there's so much we can say. 4:20 We know that in our medical histories, we've done of children with autism, even of adults with autism. 4:26 In almost all cases, the gut symptoms begin in infancy and can continue on for many decades if not treated. 4:34 We published a study 15 years ago showing a very high correlation between severity of gut symptoms and severity of autism. 4:42 There was a study 25 years ago by Lucin Feingold and Ellen Bolte showing that vancomycin, very effective in wiping out harmful bacteria temporarily and
Gut bacteria, metabolites, and autism symptoms 4:53 greatly improving GI and autism symptoms. 4:55 But when you stop treatment, The benefits were lost within a month, even with standard probiotics. 5:01 So now we know from some meta-analyses done by Jamie Morton of our work and others, a normal person has about 500 species of bacteria in their gut, 5:11 whereas kids with autism are missing on average about 100 of those. 5:14 So they're missing about 25% of their normal gut bacteria, but it's very different from one child to another. 5:21 And also there are about 500 bacteria that are elevated in kids with autism. 5:26 So that's one major clue. 5:28 They have too few of the good bacteria, too many of the harmful ones. 5:32 And so also we've been lately very focused on the metabolites these gut bacteria make. 5:38 And so one of the best known ones, Paracresol, 17 studies have it for autism. 5:44 Every study shows it's elevated in a subset of kids with autism. 5:49 It's really nasty. 5:51 We know that if you administer to mice, it causes autistic symptoms in the mice. 5:57 If the mice get a fecal transplant from a healthy mouse, they recover. 6:01 We know that it not only damages the gut, it acts as an antibiotic in the gut to kill off the competition. 6:07 It damages the kidneys. 6:09 It damages the mitochondria. 6:12 We think that's one of the major reasons for mitochondrial dysfunction. 6:17 in autism, causing a lot of oxidative stress. 6:19 And in the brain, it acts to disrupt normal dopamine function. 6:25 So it turns out people with Parkinson's have extremely high levels, about eight times the normal amount of P-Cresol in their brain. 6:32 And we know that's the key issue in Parkinson's is dopamine disruption. 6:36 And sadly, we know that adults with autism, much higher risk of Parkinson's, and they get it much earlier. 6:42 And again, it's the same with chronic kidney disease. 6:45 Adults with autism have a higher rate of it and comes on earlier. 6:49 And again, this, we believe, P-creasal is one of the major factors. 6:54 So we've followed research or over 50 research studies now showing kids with autism have elevated levels of these microbial metabolites. 7:04 Some of them affect the dopamine system. 7:08 The others affect the serotonin system, which then goes on to make melatonin and hence causes sleep issues. 7:15 So we think many of the sleep problems in autism are due to these, but together by affecting dopamine or serotonin, They're affecting mood. 7:23 They're affecting cognition. 7:25 So they're affecting anxiety and depression. 7:29 AD probably contributing to repetitive behaviors and interests and many other related issues. 7:35 So this is really important. 7:37 That's why we've now developed a test. 7:39 We've worked for several years with our colleagues at Andalutos in the United Kingdom, and now we have a test. 7:46 We can measure 17 of these. 7:48 We have a paper under review right now, but the preprint is out, showing that roughly 90% of kids with autism have high levels of one or more of these 8:01 metabolites versus none of the typical kids. 8:04 And so our test is able to differentiate kids with autism from typical kids with just a urine sample, just measuring how many of these harmful metabolites 8:14 are in the gut. 8:15 And so roughly 90% accurate in distinguishing kids with autism from typical kids. 8:20 But what's even more important, it lets you know what is the problem. 8:24 Is it a yeast problem? 8:25 Is it a bacterial problem? 8:27 For many kids, it's both. 8:29 So I'll pause there, but we can also chat more about yeast. 8:33 Yeah. 8:33 So let's go first. 8:34 Since you mentioned the test, I know everybody's going to be asking, is that the microbial derived metabolite gut health test? 8:41 This is our new microbially derived metabolite system test that we've trademarked that is now available from the UK. 8:49 Anyone in the world can now order a copy of the test and can order the test kit mailed to their home. 8:56 You just pee in a cup and you get a FedEx return label and you just send it back to the UK. 9:01 So very, very easy to do. 9:04 And it's testing for these metabolites of Clostridia, of bacteria, of yeast, et cetera, within that test. 9:12 That's right, that's right. 9:14 And so again, roughly 90% of children with autism have high levels of one of these, often both, but it's very important to not just tell it to help diagnose 9:24 autism early. 9:24 Our dream is that to test every child at the age of two years or so to see if they're have a gut dysbiosis and let's treat them before severe symptoms develop, 9:36 before they usually lose years of development. 9:38 But also, it's a very important guide for how changes continue. 9:43 Sorry, Nancy. 9:44 Go ahead. 9:44 Right. 9:45 No, no, no. 9:45 I was just going to say, and it's more than just those with autism, because as you said, we know that these metabolites affect dopamine. 9:55 affect serotonin and therefore are going to affect the symptoms that many of our children, especially those with pans and pandas may have, 10:04 anxiety, OCD or perseverations, tics even, and many of the Parkinsonian effects we see in very severe cases with catatonia and things like that. 10:17 So it can apply to many more than just those with autism, correct? 10:23 That's right. 10:24 Right now we're doing a study with about 140 children who have a variety of health disorders. 10:29 So children with anxiety, children with depression, children with intellectual disability. 10:36 And so we're testing, as well as children with autism and healthy children. 10:40 And that's a key part of our test is we have lots of samples from very healthy children to compare against. 10:45 We have a really good reference range. 10:47 But yes, we suspect that kids with autism have very high levels, ADHD probably a bit lower. 10:54 For pans and pandas, we don't know yet. 10:56 It's probably higher during a flare-up, I would guess, but that's again why we'd love to do research with that group too. 11:03 So when people send in a sample, we just ask them voluntarily, you know, tell us what the condition is, and then we'll soon build up data for a wide variety 11:13 of different groups. 11:15 That's amazing and will be a great test.
Testing microbial metabolites in urine 11:17 We'll talk about how to order that more toward the end of the podcast. 11:21 But let's go back a little bit. 11:22 What percentage of children with autism have gut issues? 11:27 That's a great question. 11:28 It depends on how you ask it. 11:30 So the data, the researchers are all over the place because if you ask the question, have you ever had a GI symptom? 11:38 Well, that's 90% of kids with autism. 11:41 It's 90% of the general public. 11:43 The real question. 11:45 But if you actually compare side to side and say, are you having current cup problems? 11:50 Roughly 40% of children with autism and many adults with autism have a chronic gut issue, constipation, diarrhea, abdominal pain, 12:02 sometimes reflux, which we think is almost always due to constipation. 12:06 Cause when we treat the constipation, the reflux disappears. 12:09 And often that constipation and diarrhea, as you know, is alternating that the kids are so constipated. 12:15 you have overflow diarrhea. 12:17 But it's important to distinguish that because then the treatment for overflow diarrhea is very different from that for regular diarrhea. 12:24 Absolutely. 12:25 Yeah. 12:26 And I think that specifically you and I both look at yeast overgrowth and it's something that I think the general public or conventional medicine doesn't 12:38 look at in the same way. 12:39 What would you say specifically about yeast overgrowth or yeast metabolites that you may have found in kids with autism or others? 12:47 Yeah, we've done a lot of research on this. 12:49 In the first paper we published 15 years ago, we found that the kids with autism who had a positive yeast culture did not have worse gut symptoms, 12:59 but they had worse autism symptoms. 13:02 So the only symptom, again, was worse autism. 13:06 And if you think about it, if you think about some of the toxins that yeast make, like alcohol, alcohol has a big effect on your brain function, 13:14 on your cognition. 13:16 It can affect slurring of speech. 13:18 It can affect, of course, your emotion regulation. 13:20 Are you happy? 13:21 Are you angry? 13:21 Just hard to control your emotions. 13:23 And at a higher level, it affects your coordination. 13:27 So many of the symptoms with autism could be explained by yeast-like metabolites. 13:33 But we found in kids with autism, they have other yeast-derived metabolites that are up to 100 times more toxic. 13:41 And again, in a study we published just a year ago, We found the kids who had higher levels of Candida, especially Candida albicans, 13:49 had worse autism symptoms, but not worse gut symptoms. 13:53 So we call it a hidden gut problem because the only symptom is worse autism symptoms. 13:59 That's why, although 40% of kids with autism have obvious gut symptoms, it's so important to test the rest. 14:09 Because some of these gut bacteria and yeast seem to only affect brain function or mostly affect brain function and not gut symptoms. 14:17 So these hidden infections are so important. 14:20 Yeah, and it's fascinating. 14:22 I mean, when I'm talking to parents and a parent's asking, well, how do I know if they have yeast? 14:26 You know, I often say, well, think about a drunk. 14:28 And that's the alcohol comparison. 14:30 You know, you can have a belligerent, angry drunk. 14:32 That can be a yeast symptom. 14:34 You can have a silly, inappropriate drunk. 14:36 That's a yeast symptom. 14:37 You can have a clumsy, klutzy, you know, gait, you know, unstable. 14:43 That can be a yeast symptom. 14:44 And it's not just children with autism. 14:47 We see that in many children with PANS pandas. 14:50 And I think in children with PANS, yeast is one of those infections or flora that often get missed and may well be causing the symptoms that the children 15:02 are having. 15:03 And if all we're doing is putting antibiotics on to treat the pandas, we may be missing another germ that is even more relevant in that particular child. 15:15 Yeah, absolutely. 15:16 I think that's so important. 15:18 And one of the key things we found in our latest paper on yeast is that not only were Candida elevated, but there was an anti-correlation where they had 15:28 lower levels of cerevisiae.
Gut issues, yeast overgrowth, and hidden symptoms 15:30 And so similar to S. 15:32 bilardi, Saccharomyces bilardi. 15:35 So it's a problem in yeast of not just high levels of harmful yeast, but too few of the normal commensal yeast. 15:43 I won't necessarily say beneficial, but the ones that are normally there. 15:47 So I think that's, again, an important message to get across. 15:51 It's not necessarily all bad and some are helpful. 15:54 As many physicians have said, aspilarity seems helpful in many cases. 15:59 Yeah, and it's also an idea that, you know, I often wrap my head around, you know, there's not necessarily just good, bad, 16:07 and ugly within the floor of the gut. 16:09 It's how they interact. 16:11 It's what proportions they're in with others. 16:14 So there are so many nuances to this that I think are so important for people to understand and that you've done such a great job in helping many of us 16:23 to understand. 16:24 Yeah, that balance is just so key. 16:26 I mean, a little bit of E. 16:28 coli is good, too much can be fatal. 16:30 So depending on the species. 16:32 So, you know, we use the analogy of a village. 16:35 You don't want to have a village that's all policemen or all farmers or all doctors. 16:39 You need all of them working together. 16:41 And that's really what we try to focus on is balance. 16:45 And that's one of the surprising things to us is that the latest meta-analyses of over 10 studies of probiotics for autism show, 16:54 on average, no effect. 16:56 That it's surprising, but on average, there is no effect of them on gut symptoms, maybe a small benefit for autism symptoms. 17:05 Highly variable from one child to another. 17:07 That was one of the surprises when we did a study, published a study on a customized probiotic. 17:13 measure the microbiome for every child, use a tailored approach to choose specific probiotics, species for that person, and yet we found it just so incredibly 17:24 varied from one child to another. 17:26 And the probiotics are, you know, one to ten species, but if you're missing a hundred, it's just a very small amount of what's really needed. 17:33 Yeah. 17:34 I often refer to it as peeing in the ocean. 17:36 Yeah. 17:38 And also that idea of the grass and the weeds, that's always a great analogy. 17:45 If you're just putting one weed killer in one spot, you may well miss it. 17:51 It's all about letting all the grass grow, which has as much to do, I know this is important to you too, with diet as it does with the supplements or medications 18:02 that we put in, correct? 18:03 Yeah. 18:04 Yeah, I think diet is so important in trying to prevent these issues. 18:08 In our studies, we've seen the biggest challenge is low fiber consumption. 18:12 And fiber, as you know, is converted by the gut bacteria into butyrate, the main food for the cells that line our gut, providing about 60 to 70% of their energy. 18:22 So most Americans just not getting nearly enough fiber from their vegetables and fruits. 18:28 But sadly, we haven't seen much. 18:31 I haven't heard much anecdotally. 18:32 There hasn't been a formal research study. 18:34 But when people go to a higher fiber diet, it doesn't seem to help. 18:39 It's not enough to fight off these infections in our experience. 18:43 You may have different experience. 18:45 But although we highly recommend a healthy diet, it doesn't seem to be able to eliminate these embedded infections that seem to last for many years or 18:54 decades if we can't find a powerful intervention for them. 18:57 Yeah, yeah, absolutely. 18:59 And what treatment options are available? 19:03 From your perspective. 19:04 Yeah, so there are, of course, many treatments for the symptoms, for the GI symptoms. 19:09 So treating constipation, I think, is very important. 19:12 People don't often recognize this. 19:14 We've had families come into our study say, yeah, my child poops once every 10 days. 19:19 Sure, they swell up like a balloon, but they don't seem to be bothered by it. 19:23 In the same way for a bottle of wine, the longer you let it ferment, the more alcohol is produced. 19:31 The longer that stool sits in the gut, the more toxins are being produced. 19:35 So we recommend trying to have a bowel movement at least once a day, if not once for each meal. 19:41 So exercise is great for that, enough water, having the right foods that you eat, a healthy diet. 19:48 If necessary, laxatives, suppositories, enemas as a last resort. 19:53 I'm not keen on those. 19:54 Diarrhea is a separate issue. 19:56 Diarrhea is the body's defense against something harmful. 20:00 So generally, I'm not too thrilled with treatments like Imodium that try to stop diarrhea. 20:06 I'd rather figure out what is the cause of the diarrhea? 20:08 Why is the body rejecting the food that you're giving it or whatever it's exposed to? 20:14 So food allergies could be a big issue, so changing diet. 20:17 to avoid those. 20:19 But then the more advanced things that we really focus on, we have our vitamin mineral micronutrient supplement that we think is very important. 20:28 So getting a powerful vitamin mineral micronutrient supplement helps somewhat with gut issues. 20:35 And then for yeast, the data out of ARI is incredibly strong, survey of 23,000 families. 20:42 The top two treatments of any type higher rated than any psych med are Nystatin and Diflucan. 20:50 So, and very safe to give. 20:53 So again, really, really great to say. 20:55 I mean, with Diflucan, you do have to check occasionally for liver and kidney toxicity, but it seems to be extremely rare. 21:02 Yeah, 30 years, seen it once, I say three times, but the two others with the liver function were fine and checking it every two to three months, 21:12 absolutely safe. 21:14 I'm reassured to hear that. 21:16 We've tried several times to get federal funding for study of antifungals. 21:21 But so far, the federal government has said no, they just haven't been interested. 21:26 The challenges of those antifungals we think are not enough, then you need to couple them with a modified diet, low sugar, 21:33 low starch diet. 21:34 So those, I think, are very powerful. 21:36 The real challenge is treating the bacterial infections that we find. 21:41 Again, we can treat the symptoms, but these infections seem to have been very embedded in the microbiome, very resistant to treatment through forming biofilms. 21:52 Obviously, we've had some very good success with microbiota transplant, and I can talk about that. 21:59 We strongly oppose use of antibiotics.
Diet, constipation, and first-line treatments 22:02 The studies out of ARI show it's much more likely to worsen problems than to improve them. 22:08 In fact, it's one of the most common features we see in medical histories of kids with autism is overuse of antibiotics during infancy. 22:16 So if there's been an overuse of them, then I think that's a major clue. 22:21 You probably are at much higher risk of a gut infection or a yeast infection. 22:27 So you can try probiotics, you can try prebiotics. 22:31 Again, with prebiotics, generally the research is mixed on using prebiotics because of the problem you're often giving just one strain like inulin, 22:44 and that can actually worsen problems in some people. 22:47 So you want to give a balance of fiber because that's what the gut is used to. 22:52 Having a wide variety of fiber sources, wide variety of fruits and vegetables, supplementing with some inulin is probably okay. 23:00 I wouldn't overdo it. 23:01 I would use a variety of prebiotics. 23:03 And then, but the real issue, the real treatment I think that we've had great success with and others have is our microbiota transplant. 23:11 And I can talk about that more if you want. 23:13 Yeah, I do want to go into that. 23:14 I want to talk a little bit, though, about a couple of things as related to pans and pandas, because I absolutely agree with you that the overuse and plethora 23:23 of antibiotics, especially in the first few years of life, can be very detrimental to most kids. 23:30 not just those with autism. 23:32 However, in our Pans Pandas group, when the antibiotic is targeted to a strep infection or to a tick-borne disease in combination with herbals, 23:43 in my opinion, and I'm a big believer in herbals for all of these, I think, you know, sometimes in those cases it is necessary. 23:52 So, but I think it's the use of them and to a great degree, the overuse in the very early parts of life that become much more problematic. 24:04 Yeah, I think the key issue with antibiotics is that they're very different one from another. 24:09 Some are very broad. 24:10 Some are very target, more targeted. 24:13 None are as targeted as we'd like. 24:15 There's a company we're working with that has a really wonderful antibiotic. 24:19 We'd really love to get approved, but we were trying to raise millions of dollars to do the studies that we need to get it approved. 24:26 It's great because it really targets only the harmful ones, but it's not available yet. 24:32 Yeah, I know, I know. 24:34 And you know, Jim, you do such a great job with all of the research that you do. 24:38 I mean, hundreds and hundreds of published research articles. 24:42 I've read a lot of them, not all of them. 24:45 And you have mentioned, and I have not read, the paper you recently published on Pan's Pandas. 24:51 Could you talk about that one just a little bit? 24:54 Yeah, so I had a relatively smaller role in that, that the PANS-PANDAS group came to me and said they wanted to develop a questionnaire because there wasn't 25:03 one that we can use for treatment study. 25:06 So if you want to get treatments approved for a condition, you need to be able to evaluate the severity of the symptoms beforehand and after treatment. 25:14 And so we've developed questionnaires for a very rare condition, pit Hopkins. 25:19 We've also developed questionnaires for autism. 25:23 And so the key factor here is to first survey a group of families, find out what symptoms they feel their child has, and then work with them on developing 25:33 a questionnaire that matches their symptoms. 25:36 It's understandable to families. 25:38 And then after you've developed that and checked it with one group of families, then the next step is to validate it. 25:45 Give it to another group of families and have them take the questionnaire. 25:50 And then a couple of weeks later, have them take it again when there have been no changes and make sure that you're getting the same answers. 25:57 And in general, we found good reliability in this questionnaire. 26:00 So it's now published. 26:01 It's out there. 26:02 Encourage people to use it. 26:04 Even if they're doing treatments at home, it's really nice to be able to have a standardized questionnaire that you can use. 26:11 Yeah, absolutely. 26:13 And, and we recommend that use on questionnaires quite readily. 26:17 I mean, Richard Horowitz's questionnaire on Lyme disease, Jill Christa's on mold, the ones that Tonya Murphy and Sue Suito have been part of in Pans Pandas. 26:27 The use of validated questionnaires can save families lots of money in specialty testing and can also help all of us clinicians and researchers to better 26:41 understand what's next to be done to treat the child or what's next to be done to research what's going on in this particular issue. 26:48 Absolutely. 26:49 Absolutely. 26:51 So, and one other thing I wanted to touch on before we get to the microbiota transplant therapy, was just the whole idea of constipation and treating it. 27:01 And I totally agree with what you said. 27:04 And there's another area where a lot of things nutraceuticaly may be very helpful. 27:09 aloe, magnesium, sometimes vitamin C, good fluids, all of that. 27:15 And where research has shown us again, not just in autism, but in kids with Pans Pandas, that that's stooling once a day at least. 27:24 And I always say, don't go do it right now during this listening to this podcast, but if you haven't done it today, you should be doing it. 27:29 You know, how that pooping is, is so important. 27:33 And I, I love that I've listened to a couple of the other webinars and podcasts that you've done, and you're always talking about looking at poop and smelling poop. 27:42 And I love that. 27:43 We don't talk enough about poop or farting for that matter. 27:47 And I think it's really important. 27:49 Yeah, I mean, roughly a third of the stool is gut bacteria. 27:53 And one of the most common comments we have from families is their child's stool has a strange color, and more importantly, 28:00 can have a very foul odor. 28:02 In some extreme cases, the family says when the child has a bowel movement, they go outside the house. 28:07 That's just so bad. 28:09 usually not that bad, but usually quite noticeable. 28:12 And after microbiota transplant, we see it back to normal. 28:15 So it really matters. 28:17 So there's a Bristol stool scale that has been used for many studies, you know, to tell you is the stool unusually hard? 28:24 Is it unusually soft or liquid? 28:27 Or is it forming like a sausage? 28:29 And that's really the ideal So many families, when we ask them to then go do a 14-day stool analysis, look at their child's stool in the toilet,
Antifungals, antibiotics, and microbiota transplant 28:39 they come back and say, I had no idea how bad my child's stool was until I started looking at it. 28:45 Because after age five or so, depending on the child, you never see your child's poop anymore. 28:50 And so they have no idea how bad it is. 28:53 They may hear them grunt occasionally in the bathroom. 28:56 Some kids cry out, but often they have no idea. 29:00 One of the most important recommendations we have for families is look at your child's poop. 29:06 Yeah, I love that. 29:07 And, you know, like you were talking earlier about encaprecis, you know, those children that have constipation may really have liquid poop around it. 29:16 But if they're examining the stool, they may have diarrhea or this liquid poop first and then this rabbit pellets. 29:24 Again, you're going to be able to understand what's going on if you're really looking at it, smelling it. 29:30 I wouldn't go as far as tasting it, but that then brings us to the microbiota transplant. 29:36 And you know, Jim, I've often laughed that after some of your studies years ago, I'd never drink chocolate milk again. 29:44 Tell us more about that, why you started studying that, all about, all you've learned, anything you want to talk about. 29:51 Yeah, so as I mentioned, the vancomycin study inspired me many years ago that we knew that a powerful antibiotic like vancomycin could kill off bacteria, 30:01 leading to big improvements in gut symptoms and autism symptoms temporarily. 30:06 But within a few weeks, the benefits were lost. 30:09 So it told us that it's like having a garden filled with weeds. 30:13 You can pluck all the weeds, but when you stop those weeds, you're just going to grow right back. 30:19 So our idea is to pluck and replant. 30:23 So what the technique we've developed and this follows work by Tom Brody who's really the pioneer, one of the leading pioneers in the field. 30:32 He advised us on this was first we do two weeks of vancomycin, a very safe antibiotic when taken orally because almost zero absorption into the gut. 30:43 And again, the classic study 25 years ago showing it helped. 30:46 And then that study, they treated for eight weeks, where two weeks is enough to kill it off, whatever it's going to. 30:53 And then we do a bowel cleanse, just like you'd have for a colonoscopy prep. 30:57 And that's really the only hard part of the study. 31:00 taking a strong laxative like Miralax or magnesium citrate, and then for several hours having diarrhea. 31:09 Our goal is to have just to be very blunt, clear liquid, no solids coming out still. 31:15 We really want to flush the gut as much as possible. 31:18 There'll still be a biofilm there. 31:20 but remove as much of the competition, go garden as carefully as we can and then replant. 31:26 So we replant with high dose microbiota and then use a maintenance dose on later days. 31:32 And so the high dose microbiota or all microbiota comes from the University of Minnesota now. 31:38 They have an incredible facility there. 31:40 They're the leader in the United States in producing microbiota for academic research studies. 31:45 They've treated over 8,000 people, over a dozen different health disorders, zero serious adverse effects. 31:53 It is extremely safe because they spend a lot of money. 31:58 of order five to $10,000 to make enough product for a person, because donors are not just healthy, they are exceptionally healthy people. 32:08 People who are not on any medications, people who have ideal body weight, not underweight, not overweight. 32:15 no history of GI problems in themselves, no GI cancers in their family, just very, very extensive testing. 32:23 And so our donors are really the top few percent healthiest Americans in the United States. 32:28 And wouldn't you want to have gut bacteria like that? 32:32 And so what we've done is use that product and currently we have both the capsule version that we use. 32:38 So you can just swallow the capsule. 32:40 It passes through the stomach acid, which would otherwise kill off most of what you take. 32:46 And then it gets into the gut and releases there. 32:49 We also now have a powder version because some kids can't swallow capsules. 32:54 So the powder version, we just mix a little bit of milk or yogurt. 32:57 We do use chocolate milk to hide the color a little bit. 33:00 That's okay. 33:01 But again, the product is so incredibly pure. 33:04 It's just 99% bacteria. 33:06 It just looks like a probiotic. 33:11 and you just mix it with a little bit of milk or yogurt it's tasteless odorless and then we also have to give an antacid at the same time or a stomach 33:20 acid suppressant and that works well so we've used both forms we have done a little bit of work with enemas but we find that that didn't was not as effective 33:31 as the oral route and the reason as you know is that the gut is very long you know of order 28 feet long and You giving an enema only goes a very short distance. 33:41 And although most of your gut bacteria is in the colon, you still have some good guys in your small intestine as well. 33:47 So you get your bacteria from the food you eat, the water you drink, and oral we think is the right way to go. 33:54 Yeah. 33:55 Well, I mean, the study of those donors is so important. 33:58 Often, you know, with Brody's Protocol, many of my families were trying to do it on their own and finding a donor within their family which has its own 34:08 genetic and other problems or another donor that's really clean is so hard to do because you don't want somebody that's had multiple antibiotics or infections 34:20 or So many other things. 34:22 So knowing that is so key, I think, for this work. 34:28 Absolutely. 34:29 That's so very key. 34:31 For a C. 34:31 diff infection, it's common to use a spouse or someone else. 34:35 Almost anyone can be a donor for a C. 34:38 diff infection. 34:39 where you have life-threatening diarrhea, you get one to two doses, in two to three days you're cured 90% of the time and symptom-free the rest of your 34:49 life in almost all cases. 34:51 But with autism, it's a much harder infection to fight. 34:55 That's why we have to treat for months this major pretreatment, but in most cases it works. 35:01 But the exciting news that we've begun to realize now is that we do see decreases in the amounts of these microbiota metabolites as we treat, 35:11 but not as much as we would like. 35:13 So we think we have been underdosing. 35:16 So in the same way that half an aspirin is good for a headache, But a whole aspirin would be better, and you might need two aspirin for a severe headache. 35:24 We're now doing a dosing study to go to higher dose, and we hope to see even more improvement than we've seen so far. 35:31 So that's our goal. 35:32 And as per your previous research, you've not just seen improvement in those metabolites, you're also seeing improvement in symptoms, 35:40 more importantly. 35:41 That's right. 35:42 And not just gut symptoms, certainly neuropsychiatric and neurologic symptoms. 35:46 Yeah, what's so exciting is, again, we see the improvements in the gut symptoms first. 35:51 A little bit later, we begin seeing improvements, especially in the mood-related symptoms, because by affecting dopamine and serotonin, 35:59 and by normalizing those, getting rid of the harmful metabolites and the melatonin affecting sleep, We often see kids begin to sleep better, 36:09 they're happier. 36:10 The most common comment we get is just their child's happier. 36:13 Again, that's, you know, serotonin and dopamine have big effects on your happiness. 36:17 But we see improvements in anxiety. 36:19 We had one young man, an adult, who was on five different antidepressants. 36:24 And after treatment, he said, wow, I haven't felt this good in years. 36:29 So, anxiety, depression, hyperactivity, aggression, self-injury, these are the sort of mood-related disorders that we think are really driven by these issues. 36:41 We also had one person with Tourette's who, eight weeks into the treatment, they were cured of Tourette's. 36:47 It just disappeared. 36:48 I don't use the word cure lightly. 36:50 So we are anxious to try the treatment on people with seizures. 36:54 We are now starting to treat some children who have stable seizures. 36:59 Again, we're very cautious, but we do know that people with seizures, people with epilepsy, not autistic, but just straight epilepsy, 37:08 have higher levels of P. 37:09 creosal even than the autism kids do. 37:11 So we think many, and we know P. 37:13 creosal causes seizures in animals. 37:16 So it's not too surprising. 37:17 It's causing it in humans as well. 37:21 Now, those with ticks or Tourette's like that one, have you studied that anymore? 37:26 Do you think that's a similar mechanism of action or not sure yet? 37:30 We can't say for sure, we think it's similar, but we've had only one case of Tourette's in our study because we're studying children with autism and one 37:40 of them also had Tourette's, so we'll see. 37:43 But certainly many children improve on their repetitive stims, on their repetitive vocalizations, and that has some relationship. 37:52 But we really need to do a study with more children who have Tourette's to see if there's additional hope for them as well. 37:59 And correct me if I'm wrong, but the microbiotic transplant is only available through research studies from your perspective now,
PANS/PANDAS research, questionnaires, and future studies 38:08 correct? 38:09 That's right. 38:09 That's right. 38:10 So that's why we've done phase one studies. 38:12 We've done several phase two studies. 38:15 We're now gearing up to do what we hope will be a final phase three study. 38:19 There's just one little detail we need to raise about $20 million to be able to do that last big study. 38:26 But we're partway there. 38:29 We formed a company to be able to fund our final studies. 38:32 And the amazing thing is we've had 120 autism families invest a total of 10 million so far in our company. 38:40 So our company is very unusual. 38:43 We're funded by autism families to help autism families. 38:47 But now we need to raise 20 million for a final phase three study. 38:51 And so we are talking with some venture capital firms too. 38:54 But honestly, we'd much rather have investors from the autism community because let me just say there's the potential to be wildly profitable and we'd 39:03 like to see those profits go to autism families. 39:06 And we'd like them to share a motivation. 39:08 In speaking with many companies, they say, we'd like to You know, we think you have a great plan, but we think your plan pricing is too low, 39:15 and we want to keep our prices low. 39:17 Our goal is to get it approved by the FDA, then it will be covered by Medicaid, likely to be covered by insurance. 39:24 We want to make it free or as close to free as possible for every family. 39:30 Yeah, yeah, you know, not just great research, great goals, and great ethics. 39:35 So that is always something that I and many of the people listening so appreciate because this is a very expensive road to hoe, 39:45 whether your child has autism or pans pandas. 39:48 And expensive for many, you know, not just the financial end, but the effort end and the emotional, psychological end for all the families, 39:56 as you know. 39:57 Yeah. 39:57 Then we've spoken with a couple of PANs organizations and they'd say, yeah, we'd love to do a study of MTT. 40:02 They've come to us about it, but they just don't have the money to do it. 40:06 These studies are unfortunately very expensive. 40:09 We'd need about a million dollars to do a study for say 20 kids with Pitt-Hopkin, with PANDIS. 40:15 But I think it'd be fascinating to do even a small pilot. 40:19 I think that, again, the fluctuations in Pans-Pandas, if we could identify that with fluctuations in the gut microbiome, 40:27 and we can do it with just our simple urine tests, get a urine when they are flaring and when they aren't, I think that would be really fascinating to see. 40:35 I do too. 40:36 I think that would be fabulous and I'm going to work on that. 40:39 I'm going to work on some Pan's Pandas donations for you because I think we need to understand certainly with Pan's Pandas there can be a flare because 40:47 they have a virus. 40:48 There could be a flare because they were exposed to mold or you know a plethora of things but what is really going on when they have that flare and if 40:57 we can find some of these metabolites in an easy urine test rather than having to go for a blood test or more invasive studies and interventions. 41:08 That would be remarkable. 41:11 And I think one important thing too is that with autism, in general, you inherit most of your gut microbiome from your mother. 41:17 So assuming, especially if they're born by a vaginal normal birth as opposed to a C-section. 41:23 And so for children with autism, where the symptoms begin very early in life, we think that's a major driving force. 41:30 So if a mother has one child with autism, we'd urge them to again check their gut microbiome early on before having another child if possible. 41:40 With Pans Pandas, if it's occurring later in life, as you say, there are a variety of other things that could be leading to those disruptions. 41:47 Maybe that's why most of them don't have autism but have other symptoms because it struck later in life. 41:52 They had enough time for the child to develop partway. 41:57 Yeah, but I have to say clinically, I find a lot of these children that later develop pans pandas also have a very disrupted gut milieu. 42:07 You know, a mom that had multiple antibiotics or born by C-section or, you know, all of the classic things that we think about with autism. 42:16 And I think there's a spectrum to all of this. 42:19 And, you know, those children may have been lucky enough to be neurotypical in the first several years of life, but unlucky enough that some environmental trigger, 42:30 infectious trigger came in on a somewhat compromised gut that they were getting by on. 42:36 But now that trigger, you know, as we always say, genetics loads the gun and environment pulls the trigger. 42:43 That trigger may just be much later. 42:45 But there's differences early on that I think would be fascinating to research more. 42:52 Absolutely. 42:53 So there's so many, so many places where I know many of my listeners want to go. 42:58 So first of all, you've published so much, where could the listeners, and there are so practitioners listening, where can they find your published research? 43:06 Sure. 43:07 So one place to go is to our ASU website, autism.asu.edu. 43:14 They can also go to our gut brain access website for more in the business side and specific to microbiota. 43:21 So that's just GBAT, gut brain access therapeutics, gbat.com. 43:27 If they want to learn more about our nutritional supplement side of things, then it's autism and for nutrition, R for research, 43:35 C for centered.org. 43:36 That's our nonprofit that distributes our vitamin mineral supplement and gives general recommendations. 43:42 That's great. 43:42 And then if somebody wants to order the microbial-derived metabolite gut health test, how do they do that? 43:49 How can they order that? 43:50 Yeah, so the name of the company is Analudos. 43:53 It was originally written to say analite, but the first four letters, A-N-A-L, so anal, A-N-A-L-U-T-O-S. 44:04 Okay, Analudos. 44:06 Okay. 44:10 Okay. 44:10 And they can order it right there. 44:12 Okay. 44:13 And then if they're interested in the clinical trials you're doing and the microbiota transplant, is that a separate website or where would they go? 44:21 Just go to my ASU website and they can get on our email list and we'll let people know whenever we have a new study coming out. 44:28 Again, the challenge is when we have an opening for 50 people, we have, you know, a thousand applications in a week. 44:34 We just get inundated. 44:36 I get emails every day. 44:39 from a family wanting to be in our study. 44:41 Again, we'd love to have them, but we're limited by finances, how many we can admit. 44:46 Yeah. 44:47 Yeah. 44:47 Well, the research is unending, Jen, and I hope you never stop because I think we've learned so much through what you've done, 44:56 not just in the autism world, but as applies to so many of our other children. 45:02 And any last words of wisdom or experience or hope you want to leave any of the families with? 45:10 I think the main thing I'd say is just we've seen so many of children improve, not everyone. 45:16 Right now, microbiota transplant therapy is a treatment. 45:19 It leads to substantial benefits, but it's not a cure. 45:23 But it is a substantial benefit for many people. 45:26 Again, most families just say their child's happier. 45:29 But as we do more research, we think we're going to be able to improve on the treatment to help more people. 45:34 And again, probably the most important message I'd give is, sure, about 40% of kids with autism have obvious gut symptoms, 45:41 but most of the rest have a hidden gut symptom and the only symptom is worse autism. 45:47 So we encourage people to go get it tested somehow. 45:51 If you don't use our tests or others, but ours is, we think especially good. 45:56 Well, if you had a hand in it, I would have to agree. 45:59 So Jim, thank you so much for joining us today. 46:02 Thanks for talking about all this really incredible research and hope for all of our families. 46:09 So thanks everybody for being here and we'll see you next time on Demystifying Pan's Pandas. 46:17 Thanks, Jim. 46:18 Thank you. 46:19 That's it for today's episode of Demystifying Pan's Pandas. 46:24 I hope you're walking away with insights, tools, and hope to help you and your child on this journey. 46:30 If you found today's conversation valuable, be sure to subscribe so you never miss an episode. 46:36 Share this podcast with anyone who might need it. 46:39 It could be the lifeline they're searching for. 46:41 And if you have a moment, leaving a review helps us reach even more families who deserve answers. 46:48 Also, for more information, training, and community, check out our website, drohara.com, and join our annual membership. 46:59 And remember, every step forward, no matter how small, brings us closer to healing and understanding. 47:07 Until next time, be present, be hopeful, and we look forward to seeing you next time on Demystifying Pan's Pandas.
Comments