Full Transcript Diet debate introduction 0:02 In my last 0:02 In my last video, we talked about a 0:04 video, we talked about a 0:04 video, we talked about a fascinating clinical 0:05 fascinating clinical 0:05 fascinating clinical study where a 0:06 study where a 0:06 study where a ketogenic diet 0:07 ketogenic diet 0:07 ketogenic diet reduced 0:08 reduced 0:08 reduced liver fat by 67%, and I 0:09 liver fat by 67%, and I 0:09 liver fat by 67%, and I immediately understood what had 0:11 immediately understood what had 0:11 immediately understood what had happened. Some people heard 0:13 happened. Some people heard 0:13 happened. Some people heard this and said, "See, 0:15 this and said, "See, 0:15 this and said, "See, keto wins." And 0:16 keto wins." And 0:16 keto wins." And others said, "No 0:17 others said, "No 0:17 others said, "No way, the 0:18 way, the 0:18 way, the Mediterranean 0:19 Mediterranean 0:19 Mediterranean diet is the healthiest 0:20 diet is the healthiest 0:20 diet is the healthiest diet in the world." And somewhere in 0:23 diet in the world." And somewhere in 0:23 diet in the world." And somewhere in the middle, someone 0:24 the middle, someone 0:24 the middle, someone is eating an avocado and 0:25 is eating an avocado and 0:25 is eating an avocado and wondering which 0:26 wondering which 0:26 wondering which team to 0:27 team to 0:27 team to join. Isn't that right 0:30 join. Isn't that right 0:30 join. Isn't that right ? So today I 0:32 ? So today I 0:32 ? So today I want to resolve this 0:33 want to resolve this 0:33 want to resolve this dispute. But 0:35 dispute. But 0:35 dispute. But I'm not going to 0:36 I'm not going to 0:36 I'm not going to announce the 0:37 announce the 0:37 announce the winner. Because that would be a 0:40 winner. Because that would be a 0:40 winner. Because that would be a great 0:41 great 0:41 great title for a video, 0:42 title for a video, 0:42 title for a video, I know, but it's bad 0:43 I know, but it's bad 0:43 I know, but it's bad medicine. I am Dr. 0:45 medicine. I am Dr. 0:45 medicine. I am Dr. Ahmet Ergin. I'm 0:47 Ahmet Ergin. I'm 0:47 Ahmet Ergin. I'm an endocrinologist, a 0:48 an endocrinologist, a 0:48 an endocrinologist, a specialist in diabetes 0:49 specialist in diabetes 0:49 specialist in diabetes and metabolism, and 0:50 and metabolism, and 0:50 and metabolism, and today we're going to 0:51 today we're going to 0:51 today we're going to compare a healthy 0:52 compare a healthy 0:52 compare a healthy ketogenic diet to a 0:53 ketogenic diet to a 0:53 ketogenic diet to a Mediterranean diet. 0:55 Mediterranean diet. 0:58 Not internet keto. Not 0:58 Not internet keto. Not the diet where you 0:59 the diet where you 0:59 the diet where you add butter to your coffee, 1:01 add butter to your coffee, 1:01 add butter to your coffee, bacon on top of 1:02 bacon on top of 1:02 bacon on top of bacon, and all that other stuff 1:03 bacon, and all that other stuff 1:03 bacon, and all that other stuff . Where for some reason you 1:06 . Where for some reason you 1:06 . Where for some reason you convince yourself that 1:07 convince yourself that 1:07 convince yourself that vegetables are dangerous. 1:09 vegetables are dangerous. 1:09 vegetables are dangerous. I mean a 1:10 I mean a 1:10 I mean a properly designed 1:11 properly designed , nutrient-rich 1:13 , nutrient-rich 1:13 , nutrient-rich ketogenic diet when 1:14 ketogenic diet when 1:14 ketogenic diet when I talk about a ketogenic 1:15 I talk about a ketogenic 1:15 I talk about a ketogenic diet. And we're 1:17 diet. And we're 1:17 diet. And we're going to compare 1:18 going to compare 1:18 going to compare these diets where it 1:19 these diets where it 1:19 these diets where it really matters. 1:20 really matters. 1:24 Blood sugar levels, insulin 1:24 Blood sugar levels, insulin resistance 1:25 resistance , weight loss, 1:26 , weight loss, 1:26 , weight loss, triglycerides, 1:27 triglycerides, 1:27 triglycerides, LDL cholesterol, 1:28 LDL cholesterol, 1:28 LDL cholesterol, fiber, 1:30 fiber, 1:30 fiber, heart health, and perhaps the 1:31 heart health, and perhaps the 1:31 heart health, and perhaps the most underrated 1:32 most underrated 1:32 most underrated category of all. 1:35 category of all. 1:35 category of all. Can you really 1:36 Can you really 1:36 Can you really eat like this for the 1:37 eat like this for the 1:37 eat like this for the next 5 years without going 1:39 next 5 years without going 1:39 next 5 years without going crazy? So, 1:40 crazy? So, 1:40 crazy? So, let's begin. 1:41 let's begin.
Defining healthy keto 1:44 First, what does 1:48 healthy keto actually mean? Keto 1:48 healthy keto actually mean? Keto is defined 1:49 is defined 1:49 is defined primarily by 1:49 primarily by 1:49 primarily by 1:52 carbohydrate restriction. But 1:52 carbohydrate restriction. But restricting carbohydrates 1:53 restricting carbohydrates 1:53 restricting carbohydrates tells me almost nothing 1:54 tells me almost nothing 1:54 tells me almost nothing about the quality of the diet 1:56 about the quality of the diet . Think about it. 1:58 . Think about it. 1:59 . Think about it. Two people can 2:00 Two people can 2:00 Two people can consume 30 g of 2:01 consume 30 g of 2:01 consume 30 g of carbohydrates per day. The 2:02 carbohydrates per day. The 2:08 first person eats 2:08 first person eats salmon, extra virgin olive oil 2:10 salmon, extra virgin olive oil 2:10 salmon, extra virgin olive oil , 2:11 , 2:11 , avocado, 2:12 avocado, 2:12 avocado, walnuts, eggs, chicken, spinach, broccoli, cauliflower, zucchini, mushrooms 2:14 walnuts, eggs, chicken, spinach, broccoli, cauliflower, zucchini, mushrooms 2:17 , 2:17 , olives, chia seeds, 2:19 olives, chia seeds, 2:19 olives, chia seeds, flax seeds, and 2:20 flax seeds, and 2:20 flax seeds, and some berries. The second 2:28 some berries. The second 2:28 some berries. The second person eats bacon, 2:29 person eats bacon, 2:29 person eats bacon, sausage, butter, cheese, 2:31 sausage, butter, cheese, 2:31 sausage, butter, cheese, processed meats, 2:32 processed meats, 2:32 processed meats, more butter, and coffee with 2:33 more butter, and coffee with 2:33 more butter, and coffee with so much 2:35 so much 2:35 so much heavy cream that it 2:36 heavy cream that it 2:36 heavy cream that it could be called soup. 2:37 could be called soup. 2:41 Technically, both 2:41 Technically, both people can 2:41 people can 2:42 people can be in a state of 2:43 be in a state of 2:43 be in a state of ketosis. Metabolically, 2:44 ketosis. Metabolically, 2:44 ketosis. Metabolically, it's not the same 2:45 it's not the same 2:45 it's not the same diet. This distinction is 2:47 diet. This distinction is 2:47 diet. This distinction is extremely important. A 2:48 extremely important. A 2:49 extremely important. A healthy ketogenic 2:50 healthy ketogenic 2:50 healthy ketogenic diet, in my opinion, 2:51 diet, in my opinion, 2:51 diet, in my opinion, should borrow some of the 2:53 should borrow some of the 2:53 should borrow some of the best features of the 2:53 best features of the 2:54 best features of the Mediterranean 2:55 Mediterranean 2:55 Mediterranean diet. The 2:56 diet. The 2:56 diet. The carbohydrate levels vary, 2:57 carbohydrate levels vary, 2:58 carbohydrate levels vary, but the emphasis on 2:59 but the emphasis on 2:59 but the emphasis on food quality should be similar. 3:00 food quality should be similar. 3:04 Your essential fats 3:04 Your essential fats should 3:05 should 3:05 should come primarily from 3:06 come primarily from 3:06 come primarily from foods like 3:07 foods like 3:09 extra virgin olive oil, 3:09 extra virgin olive oil, avocados, nuts, 3:10 avocados, nuts, 3:10 avocados, nuts, seeds, olives, and 3:12 seeds, olives, and 3:12 seeds, olives, and fatty fish. Your protein 3:16 fatty fish. Your protein 3:16 fatty fish. Your protein should come from a 3:17 should come from a 3:17 should come from a mix of fish, 3:18 mix of fish, 3:18 mix of fish, seafood, eggs, 3:19 seafood, eggs, 3:19 seafood, eggs, poultry, lean 3:20 poultry, lean 3:20 poultry, lean meats, and other 3:21 meats, and other 3:21 meats, and other minimally 3:22 minimally 3:22 minimally processed sources 3:23 processed sources 3:23 processed sources that meet 3:24 that meet 3:24 that meet your 3:25 your 3:25 your carbohydrate allowance. And vegetables 3:28 carbohydrate allowance. And vegetables 3:28 carbohydrate allowance. And vegetables should not disappear. 3:29 should not disappear. 3:29 should not disappear. Even the opposite. A 3:30 Even the opposite. A 3:31 Even the opposite. A healthy ketogenic 3:32 healthy ketogenic 3:32 healthy ketogenic diet should 3:33 diet should 3:33 diet should contain plenty of 3:33 contain plenty of 3:33 contain plenty of non-starchy 3:34 non-starchy 3:34 non-starchy vegetables. Leafy 3:38 vegetables. Leafy 3:38 vegetables. Leafy greens, broccoli, 3:40 greens, broccoli, 3:40 greens, broccoli, cauliflower, 3:41 cauliflower, 3:41 cauliflower, cabbage, 3:42 cabbage, 3:42 cabbage, peppers, mushrooms, asparagus, 3:44 peppers, mushrooms, asparagus, 3:44 peppers, mushrooms, asparagus, zucchini, cucumbers, 3:45 zucchini, cucumbers, 3:45 zucchini, cucumbers, eggplant. People sometimes 3:50 eggplant. People sometimes 3:50 eggplant. People sometimes say to me, "Doctor, 3:52 say to me, "Doctor, 3:52 say to me, "Doctor, vegetables contain 3:52 vegetables contain 3:52 vegetables contain carbohydrates." Yes, and 3:55 carbohydrates." Yes, and 3:55 carbohydrates." Yes, and water contains oxygen. 3:56 water contains oxygen. 3:58 Context matters 3:58 Context matters . You don't have to 4:00 . You don't have to 4:00 . You don't have to worry about the 3 grams of 4:01 worry about the 3 grams of 4:01 worry about the 3 grams of carbs in 4:02 carbs in 4:02 carbs in broccoli when you drink it with a 4:03 broccoli when you drink it with a 4:05 carb-free beverage alongside a 4:05 carb-free beverage alongside a plate of processed 4:07 plate of processed 4:07 plate of processed meat. This means not 4:08 meat. This means not 4:08 meat. This means not seeing the forest for the trees 4:09 seeing the forest for the trees 4:09 seeing the forest for the trees . Keto doesn't mean 4:12 . Keto doesn't mean 4:12 . Keto doesn't mean eating as much 4:14 eating as much 4:14 eating as much fat as possible. This is probably the 4:17 fat as possible. This is probably the 4:17 fat as possible. This is probably the biggest 4:17 biggest 4:17 biggest misunderstanding about 4:18 misunderstanding about 4:18 misunderstanding about ketogenic diets. Keto 4:20 ketogenic diets. Keto 4:20 ketogenic diets. Keto means that your 4:21 means that your 4:21 means that your 4:23 carbohydrate intake is so 4:23 carbohydrate intake is so low that your 4:24 low that your 4:24 low that your metabolism 4:24 metabolism 4:24 metabolism switches to more 4:25 switches to more 4:25 switches to more active 4:26 active 4:26 active fat oxidation and 4:27 fat oxidation and 4:28 fat oxidation and ketone production. This does not 4:29 ketone production. This does not 4:29 ketone production. This does not mean that your 4:30 mean that your 4:30 mean that your mission is to consume the 4:31 mission is to consume the 4:31 mission is to consume the maximum 4:32 maximum 4:32 maximum amount of dietary 4:33 amount of dietary 4:33 amount of dietary fat. You have your own 4:35 fat. You have your own 4:35 fat. You have your own fat stores. If you're 4:36 fat stores. If you're 4:36 fat stores. If you're trying to lose weight 4:37 trying to lose weight , we'd like your 4:38 , we'd like your 4:38 , we'd like your body to 4:39 body to 4:39 body to use 4:40 use 4:40 use some of them. You won't 4:41 some of them. You won't 4:41 some of them. You won't get a medal for 4:42 get a medal for 4:42 get a medal for your coffee 4:43 your coffee 4:43 your coffee containing 500 calories from 4:45 containing 500 calories from 4:45 containing 500 calories from butter. In fact, it 4:46 butter. In fact, it 4:46 butter. In fact, it can be detrimental to 4:47 can be detrimental to 4:47 can be detrimental to achieving the goal. Fat is 4:48 achieving the goal. Fat is 4:48 achieving the goal. Fat is extremely 4:49 extremely 4:49 extremely energy-intensive. So if 4:52 energy-intensive. So if 4:52 energy-intensive. So if someone puts butter in their 4:53 someone puts butter in their 4:53 someone puts butter in their coffee, pours cream on everything 4:55 coffee, pours cream on everything 4:55 coffee, pours cream on everything , eats handfuls of 4:56 , eats handfuls of 4:56 , eats handfuls of cheese, snacks on nuts all day, 4:57 cheese, snacks on nuts all day, 4:57 cheese, snacks on nuts all day, and 4:58 and 4:58 and drizzles oil on every 5:00 drizzles oil on every 5:00 drizzles oil on every meal because fat doesn't 5:01 meal because fat doesn't 5:01 meal because fat doesn't raise insulin, they 5:02 raise insulin, they 5:02 raise insulin, they can still consume a 5:04 can still consume a 5:04 can still consume a huge amount of 5:05 huge amount of 5:05 huge amount of energy. Insulin 5:08 energy. Insulin 5:08 energy. Insulin matters, but calories 5:09 matters, but calories 5:09 matters, but calories didn't disappear from human 5:11 didn't disappear from human 5:11 didn't disappear from human physiology when keto 5:12 physiology when keto 5:12 physiology when keto became popular. Both are 5:13 became popular. Both are 5:13 became popular. Both are important. 5:15 important.
Comparing diet philosophies 5:17 Now let's look at the 5:17 Now let's look at the Mediterranean 5:18 Mediterranean 5:18 Mediterranean diet. The 5:18 diet. The 5:19 diet. The Mediterranean 5:20 Mediterranean 5:20 Mediterranean diet is very 5:21 diet is very 5:21 diet is very different from 5:22 different from 5:22 different from strict keto, but they 5:23 strict keto, but they 5:23 strict keto, but they also have a lot 5:24 also have a lot 5:24 also have a lot more in common than 5:25 more in common than 5:25 more in common than people think. The 5:26 people think. The 5:34 Mediterranean 5:34 Mediterranean diet 5:35 diet 5:35 diet emphasizes 5:37 emphasizes 5:37 emphasizes foods such as vegetables, 5:38 foods such as vegetables, 5:40 extra virgin olive oil, 5:40 extra virgin olive oil, nuts, seeds, fish, 5:41 nuts, seeds, fish, 5:41 nuts, seeds, fish, seafood, legumes, whole 5:43 seafood, legumes, whole 5:43 seafood, legumes, whole fruits, whole 5:44 fruits, whole 5:44 fruits, whole grains, and relatively 5:45 grains, and relatively 5:45 grains, and relatively moderate amounts of 5:46 moderate amounts of 5:46 moderate amounts of highly processed 5:47 highly processed 5:48 highly processed foods, 5:48 foods, 5:48 foods, refined 5:49 refined 5:49 refined carbohydrates, 5:50 carbohydrates, 5:50 carbohydrates, sweets, 5:50 sweets, 5:50 sweets, processed meats, and 5:52 processed meats, and 5:52 processed meats, and excess saturated 5:53 excess saturated 5:53 excess saturated fats. So, you 6:02 fats. So, you 6:02 fats. So, you may notice something 6:03 may notice something 6:03 may notice something interesting right away. A healthy keto diet 6:04 interesting right away. A healthy keto diet 6:04 interesting right away. A healthy keto diet and a Mediterranean 6:05 and a Mediterranean 6:06 and a Mediterranean diet 6:06 diet 6:06 diet differ greatly in 6:07 differ greatly in 6:07 differ greatly in how many carbohydrates 6:08 how many carbohydrates 6:08 how many carbohydrates you should consume. 6:10 you should consume. 6:10 you should consume. But they 6:10 But they 6:10 But they agree on 6:11 agree on 6:11 agree on many other things. 6:12 many other things. 6:12 many other things. Both can 6:13 Both can 6:13 Both can emphasize 6:14 emphasize 6:14 emphasize natural foods. 6:15 natural foods. 6:15 natural foods. Both can 6:16 Both can 6:16 Both can emphasize 6:17 emphasize 6:17 emphasize vegetables. Both can 6:18 vegetables. Both can 6:18 vegetables. Both can emphasize fish. 6:20 emphasize fish. 6:20 emphasize fish. Both can 6:21 Both can 6:21 Both can emphasize 6:22 emphasize 6:22 emphasize olive oil. 6:22 olive oil. 6:23 olive oil. Both may 6:24 Both may 6:24 Both may include nuts and 6:25 include nuts and 6:25 include nuts and seeds. Both 6:26 seeds. Both 6:26 seeds. Both can eliminate 6:27 can eliminate 6:27 can eliminate sugary drinks. Both 6:29 sugary drinks. Both 6:29 sugary drinks. Both can significantly 6:30 can significantly 6:30 can significantly limit refined 6:31 limit refined 6:31 limit refined carbohydrates. And both 6:33 carbohydrates. And both 6:33 carbohydrates. And both can minimize 6:34 can minimize 6:34 can minimize ultra-processed 6:35 ultra-processed 6:35 ultra-processed foods. The main 6:36 foods. The main 6:36 foods. The main disagreement is what 6:37 disagreement is what 6:37 disagreement is what happens next. The 6:38 happens next. The 6:39 happens next. The Mediterranean 6:40 Mediterranean 6:40 Mediterranean diet says: “ 6:41 diet says: “ Legumes are good.” 6:42 Legumes are good.” 6:43 Legumes are good.” Lentils are good. 6:44 Lentils are good. 6:45 Lentils are good. Fruit is good. " 6:46 Fruit is good. " 6:47 Fruit is good. " Whole grains can 6:48 Whole grains can 6:48 Whole grains can be beneficial." 6:49 be beneficial." 6:51 Healthy Keto says: “ These foods may 6:52 These foods may 6:52 These foods may be nutritious, but 6:53 be nutritious, but 6:53 be nutritious, but many of them 6:54 many of them 6:54 many of them contain enough 6:55 contain enough 6:55 contain enough carbohydrates to 6:56 carbohydrates to 6:56 carbohydrates to interfere with nutritional 6:57 interfere with nutritional 6:57 interfere with nutritional ketosis. And this is where the 6:59 ketosis. And this is where the 6:59 ketosis. And this is where the real 7:00 real 7:00 real discussion begins. Let's talk
Blood sugar and metabolism 7:03 discussion begins. Let's talk 7:03 discussion begins. Let's talk about blood sugar. 7:04 about blood sugar. 7:05 about blood sugar. If you have 7:05 If you have 7:05 If you have insulin resistance 7:07 insulin resistance , prediabetes, or 7:08 , prediabetes, or 7:08 , prediabetes, or type 2 diabetes, 7:09 type 2 diabetes, 7:09 type 2 diabetes, carbohydrates 7:10 carbohydrates 7:10 carbohydrates matter. This does not 7:12 matter. This does not 7:12 matter. This does not mean that carbohydrates 7:13 mean that carbohydrates are poison. This 7:14 are poison. This 7:14 are poison. This means that carbohydrates 7:16 means that carbohydrates are the macronutrient 7:17 are the macronutrient 7:17 are the macronutrient that has the most 7:18 that has the most 7:18 that has the most direct impact on 7:19 direct impact on 7:19 direct impact on glucose levels after a 7:20 glucose levels after a 7:20 glucose levels after a meal. So, reducing 7:21 meal. So, reducing 7:21 meal. So, reducing carbohydrates 7:22 carbohydrates 7:22 carbohydrates can be a very 7:23 can be a very 7:23 can be a very powerful 7:23 powerful 7:23 powerful tool. This is one 7:25 tool. This is one 7:25 tool. This is one reason why some 7:26 reason why some 7:26 reason why some patients 7:26 patients 7:26 patients use 7:27 use 7:27 use continuous 7:28 continuous 7:28 continuous glucose monitoring 7:29 glucose monitoring 7:29 glucose monitoring and are surprised when they 7:30 and are surprised when they 7:30 and are surprised when they start eating on a 7:31 start eating on a 7:31 start eating on a keto diet. Their 7:32 keto diet. Their 7:32 keto diet. Their glucose graph 7:33 glucose graph 7:33 glucose graph suddenly becomes boring. 7:34 suddenly becomes boring. 7:35 suddenly becomes boring. And with diabetes, a boring 7:36 And with diabetes, a boring 7:36 And with diabetes, a boring glucose graph is 7:37 glucose graph is 7:37 glucose graph is often a good thing. Fewer 7:40 often a good thing. Fewer 7:40 often a good thing. Fewer spikes, lower 7:41 spikes, lower 7:43 post-meal glucose readings, sometimes 7:43 post-meal glucose readings, sometimes lower 7:44 lower 7:44 lower fasting glucose, often 7:45 fasting glucose, often 7:45 fasting glucose, often less 7:46 less 7:46 less insulin requirement in those who 7:48 insulin requirement in those who 7:48 insulin requirement in those who use it. This is 7:52 use it. This is 7:52 use it. This is especially noticeable in 7:53 especially noticeable in 7:53 especially noticeable in people who previously 7:54 people who previously 7:54 people who previously consumed large 7:56 consumed large 7:56 consumed large amounts of bread, rice 7:57 amounts of bread, rice , pasta, potatoes, 7:58 , pasta, potatoes, 7:58 , pasta, potatoes, sweets, juices, and 8:00 sweets, juices, and 8:00 sweets, juices, and processed 8:00 processed 8:01 processed carbohydrates. But here's an 8:04 carbohydrates. But here's an 8:04 carbohydrates. But here's an important comparison. The 8:06 important comparison. The 8:06 important comparison. The Mediterranean 8:07 Mediterranean 8:07 Mediterranean diet doesn't 8:08 diet doesn't 8:08 diet doesn't require you 8:09 require you 8:09 require you to eat a huge 8:10 to eat a huge 8:10 to eat a huge bowl of pasta and 8:11 bowl of pasta and 8:11 bowl of pasta and then baklava. A 8:12 then baklava. A 8:12 then baklava. A properly designed 8:13 properly designed 8:13 properly designed Mediterranean 8:14 Mediterranean 8:14 Mediterranean diet also limits 8:15 diet also limits 8:16 diet also limits refined carbohydrates 8:17 refined carbohydrates 8:17 refined carbohydrates and added sugar. The 8:18 and added sugar. The 8:20 remaining carbohydrates 8:22 usually come 8:22 usually come from foods such 8:23 from foods such 8:23 from foods such as legumes, whole 8:24 as legumes, whole 8:24 as legumes, whole fruits, vegetables, and 8:25 fruits, vegetables, and 8:25 fruits, vegetables, and whole grains. These 8:27 whole grains. These 8:27 whole grains. These foods behave 8:28 foods behave 8:28 foods behave very differently than 8:29 very differently than 8:29 very differently than soda and 8:30 soda and 8:30 soda and white bread. So it's 8:32 white bread. So it's 8:32 white bread. So it's not so much carbs 8:33 not so much carbs 8:33 not so much carbs vs. no 8:34 vs. no 8:34 vs. no carbs. It's a 8:37 carbs. It's a 8:37 carbs. It's a question of how many 8:38 question of how many 8:38 question of how many carbohydrates, which ones 8:39 carbohydrates, which ones , for which patient, 8:40 , for which patient, 8:40 , for which patient, and what happens to the 8:42 and what happens to the 8:42 and what happens to the rest of the metabolic 8:43 rest of the metabolic 8:43 rest of the metabolic picture.
Evidence from the KetoMed trial 8:47 picture. 8:47 picture. Keto-Med research. Fortunately, 8:49 Keto-Med research. Fortunately, 8:49 Keto-Med research. Fortunately, researchers have actually 8:50 researchers have actually 8:50 researchers have actually compared these approaches. 8:51 compared these approaches. 8:54 One extremely 8:54 One extremely interesting study 8:55 interesting study 8:55 interesting study was the 8:56 was the 8:56 was the 8:58 Keto-Med randomized crossover study from 8:58 Keto-Med randomized crossover study from Stanford. People with 9:00 Stanford. People with 9:00 Stanford. People with prediabetes or 9:01 prediabetes or 9:01 prediabetes or type 2 diabetes 9:02 type 2 diabetes 9:02 type 2 diabetes followed two 9:03 followed two 9:03 followed two diets. A well- 9:04 diets. A well- 9:04 diets. A well- balanced 9:05 balanced 9:05 balanced ketogenic diet and a 9:06 ketogenic diet and a 9:08 Mediterranean 9:08 Mediterranean Plus diet. This is an interesting 9:10 Plus diet. This is an interesting 9:10 Plus diet. This is an interesting comparison because 9:11 comparison because 9:11 comparison because both diets were 9:12 both diets were 9:12 both diets were designed to be 9:13 designed to be 9:13 designed to be relatively healthy. 9:14 relatively healthy. 9:14 relatively healthy. Both emphasized 9:15 Both emphasized 9:15 Both emphasized non-starchy 9:17 non-starchy 9:17 non-starchy vegetables. Both 9:18 vegetables. Both 9:18 vegetables. Both eliminated added 9:19 eliminated added 9:19 eliminated added sugars. Both 9:20 sugars. Both 9:20 sugars. Both limited 9:21 limited 9:21 limited refined grains. The 9:22 refined grains. The 9:22 refined grains. The main difference 9:24 main difference 9:24 main difference was that the 9:25 was that the 9:25 was that the Mediterranean 9:26 Mediterranean 9:26 Mediterranean diet included 9:27 diet included 9:27 diet included foods such as 9:28 foods such as 9:28 foods such as legumes, fruits, and 9:29 legumes, fruits, and 9:29 legumes, fruits, and whole grains. The 9:30 whole grains. The 9:30 whole grains. The ketogenic diet 9:31 ketogenic diet 9:31 ketogenic diet restricted them. So what 9:33 restricted them. So what 9:33 restricted them. So what happened? After 12 9:35 happened? After 12 9:35 happened? After 12 weeks, HbA1c levels were 9:37 weeks, HbA1c levels were 9:37 weeks, HbA1c levels were not significantly 9:38 not significantly 9:38 not significantly different between the 9:39 different between the 9:39 different between the two diets. Both 9:40 two diets. Both 9:40 two diets. Both indicators 9:41 indicators 9:41 indicators improved 9:41 improved 9:42 improved compared to 9:43 compared to 9:43 compared to baseline. This is interesting. 9:44 baseline. This is interesting. 9:44 baseline. This is interesting. Keto didn't kill the 9:45 Keto didn't kill the 9:45 Keto didn't kill the Mediterranean 9:46 Mediterranean 9:46 Mediterranean diet. The 9:47 diet. The 9:47 diet. The Mediterranean 9:48 Mediterranean 9:48 Mediterranean diet didn't kill keto 9:49 diet didn't kill keto . But when the researchers 9:51 . But when the researchers 9:51 . But when the researchers looked deeper, the 9:52 looked deeper, the 9:52 looked deeper, the differences became 9:53 differences became 9:53 differences became more interesting. 9:54 more interesting. 9:54 more interesting. Triglycerides 9:55 Triglycerides 9:55 Triglycerides decreased more 9:56 decreased more 9:56 decreased more during the ketogenic phase. 9:57 during the ketogenic phase. 9:58 during the ketogenic phase. This is physiologically 9:59 This is physiologically 9:59 This is physiologically logical. Reducing 10:00 logical. Reducing 10:00 logical. Reducing carbohydrates can 10:01 carbohydrates can 10:01 carbohydrates can significantly improve 10:02 significantly improve 10:02 significantly improve triglyceride levels 10:03 triglyceride levels 10:03 triglyceride levels in many patients 10:05 in many patients 10:05 in many patients with 10:05 with 10:05 with insulin resistance 10:06 insulin resistance . But LDL cholesterol 10:08 . But LDL cholesterol 10:08 . But LDL cholesterol changed in the 10:08 changed in the 10:08 changed in the opposite 10:09 opposite 10:09 opposite direction. LDL 10:11 direction. LDL 10:11 direction. LDL increased during the 10:12 increased during the 10:12 increased during the ketogenic phase and 10:13 ketogenic phase and 10:13 ketogenic phase and decreased during the 10:14 decreased during the 10:14 decreased during the Mediterranean 10:15 Mediterranean 10:16 Mediterranean phase. So, keto 10:17 phase. So, keto 10:17 phase. So, keto got the point. Then the 10:18 got the point. Then the 10:18 got the point. Then the Mediterranean 10:19 Mediterranean 10:19 Mediterranean diet got a point. 10:20 diet got a point. 10:20 diet got a point. Welcome to the 10:21 Welcome to the 10:22 Welcome to the science of nutrition. 10:23 science of nutrition. 10:23 science of nutrition. That's why anyone who 10:24 That's why anyone who 10:24 That's why anyone who tells you that one 10:25 tells you that one 10:25 tells you that one diet improves every 10:27 diet improves every 10:27 diet improves every biomarker in every 10:28 biomarker in every 10:28 biomarker in every person is probably 10:29 person is probably 10:29 person is probably selling something. How about
Weight loss and appetite 10:31 selling something. How about 10:31 selling something. How about losing weight? Both 10:34 losing weight? Both 10:34 losing weight? Both diets can 10:34 diets can 10:34 diets can work. The 10:35 work. The 10:35 work. The Stanford 10:36 Stanford 10:36 Stanford Keto-Med study 10:37 Keto-Med study 10:37 Keto-Med study found weight loss 10:38 found weight loss 10:38 found weight loss during both 10:39 during both 10:39 during both diet phases. And this is 10:40 diet phases. And this is 10:40 diet phases. And this is consistent with a 10:41 consistent with a 10:41 consistent with a much larger 10:42 much larger 10:42 much larger body of research in the 10:43 body of research in the 10:43 body of research in the field of nutrition. 10:44 field of nutrition. 10:47 People can 10:48 People can lose significant weight through 10:49 lose significant weight through 10:49 lose significant weight through low-carb, 10:50 low-carb, 10:50 low-carb, Mediterranean, 10:51 Mediterranean, 10:51 Mediterranean, low-fat, 10:52 low-fat, 10:52 low-fat, high-protein 10:52 high-protein 10:52 high-protein diets, 10:53 diets, 10:53 diets, intermittent 10:54 intermittent 10:54 intermittent fasting, and other 10:55 fasting, and other 10:55 fasting, and other approaches. Why? Because 11:00 approaches. Why? Because 11:00 approaches. Why? Because successful weight loss 11:01 successful weight loss 11:01 successful weight loss requires creating an 11:03 requires creating an 11:03 requires creating an energy deficit and 11:04 energy deficit and 11:04 energy deficit and maintaining it. Diet 11:06 maintaining it. Diet is a remedy. 11:07 is a remedy. 11:07 is a remedy. Compliance is the 11:08 Compliance is the 11:08 Compliance is the driving force. The keto 11:10 driving force. The keto diet may give 11:11 diet may give 11:11 diet may give certain people an 11:12 certain people an 11:12 certain people an advantage. Some 11:13 advantage. Some 11:13 advantage. Some patients tell me 11:14 patients tell me 11:14 patients tell me something very specific. 11:15 something very specific. 11:16 something very specific. Doctor, I just 11:16 Doctor, I just 11:16 Doctor, I just don't feel 11:18 don't feel 11:18 don't feel hungry anymore. This is important. 11:19 hungry anymore. This is important. 11:22 Protein gives a feeling of 11:22 Protein gives a feeling of satiety. Fats 11:23 satiety. Fats 11:23 satiety. Fats can also be satiating. 11:24 can also be satiating. 11:25 can also be satiating. Ketosis can change 11:26 Ketosis can change 11:26 Ketosis can change appetite in some people 11:27 appetite in some people . Eliminating combinations of 11:29 . Eliminating combinations of 11:29 . Eliminating combinations of sugar, starch, and 11:30 sugar, starch, and 11:30 sugar, starch, and fat removes a 11:31 fat removes a 11:31 fat removes a huge number of 11:33 huge number of 11:33 huge number of foods that people 11:34 foods that people 11:34 foods that people often overeat. 11:35 often overeat. 11:37 Cookies disappear. 11:38 Cookies disappear. Cakes are disappearing. 11:39 Cakes are disappearing. 11:39 Cakes are disappearing. Pizza is disappearing. 11:41 Pizza is disappearing. 11:41 Pizza is disappearing. Ice cream is disappearing. 11:43 Ice cream is disappearing. 11:43 Ice cream is disappearing. French fries are disappearing. 11:45 French fries are disappearing. 11:45 French fries are disappearing. Most fast food is disappearing. 11:46 Most fast food is disappearing. 11:47 Most fast food is disappearing. Suddenly you're eating salmon 11:48 Suddenly you're eating salmon 11:48 Suddenly you're eating salmon and broccoli. And people 11:50 and broccoli. And people 11:50 and broccoli. And people say, "Keto magically 11:52 say, "Keto magically 11:52 say, "Keto magically cut my 11:53 cut my 11:53 cut my calories." Well, sometimes 11:55 calories." Well, sometimes 11:55 calories." Well, sometimes the magic is that you 11:56 the magic is that you 11:57 the magic is that you stopped eating chips 11:58 stopped eating chips 11:58 stopped eating chips at 10:30 p.m. It still 12:00 at 10:30 p.m. It still 12:00 at 10:30 p.m. It still counts. But the
Flexibility and sustainability 12:01 counts. But the 12:01 counts. But the Mediterranean 12:02 Mediterranean 12:02 Mediterranean diet has another 12:03 diet has another 12:03 diet has another advantage—flexibility. This is where the 12:05 advantage—flexibility. This is where the 12:07 Mediterranean 12:07 Mediterranean approach becomes 12:07 approach becomes 12:07 approach becomes extremely 12:08 extremely 12:08 extremely attractive. Are you going 12:10 attractive. Are you going 12:10 attractive. Are you going to dinner? Perfectly. 12:11 to dinner? Perfectly. 12:12 to dinner? Perfectly. Fish, vegetables, olive 12:13 Fish, vegetables, olive 12:14 Fish, vegetables, olive oil, maybe legumes, 12:15 oil, maybe legumes, 12:15 oil, maybe legumes, some whole grains, 12:16 some whole grains, 12:17 some whole grains, fruit for dessert. Are you 12:19 fruit for dessert. Are you 12:19 fruit for dessert. Are you traveling? This is still 12:20 traveling? This is still 12:20 traveling? This is still acceptable. Family 12:22 acceptable. Family 12:22 acceptable. Family holiday? Usually 12:23 holiday? Usually 12:23 holiday? Usually acceptable too. Vacation 12:25 acceptable too. Vacation 12:25 acceptable too. Vacation in Italy? Very convenient. A 12:27 in Italy? Very convenient. A 12:27 in Italy? Very convenient. A strict keto 12:28 strict keto diet may 12:28 diet may 12:28 diet may require more 12:30 require more 12:30 require more planning. And this is 12:31 planning. And this is 12:31 planning. And this is important, because 12:31 important, because 12:31 important, because theoretically, a perfect 12:33 theoretically, a perfect 12:33 theoretically, a perfect diet that you 12:34 diet that you 12:34 diet that you follow for 19 days is less 12:35 follow for 19 days is less 12:35 follow for 19 days is less beneficial than a very 12:36 beneficial than a very 12:36 beneficial than a very good diet that you 12:38 good diet that you 12:38 good diet that you follow for 10 years. 12:39 follow for 10 years. 12:39 follow for 10 years. In the KetoMed study, 12:40 In the KetoMed study, 12:40 In the KetoMed study, observations 12:41 observations 12:41 observations showed that 12:42 showed that 12:42 showed that participants found it easier 12:43 participants found it easier 12:43 participants found it easier to stick to the 12:44 to stick to the 12:44 to stick to the Mediterranean 12:45 Mediterranean 12:45 Mediterranean approach. This does not 12:46 approach. This does not 12:46 approach. This does not mean that everyone. I 12:48 mean that everyone. I 12:48 mean that everyone. I have met patients 12:50 have met patients 12:50 have met patients who love keto. 12:51 who love keto. 12:51 who love keto. They say, "Doctor, 12:52 They say, "Doctor, 12:52 They say, "Doctor, this is the easiest diet 12:53 this is the easiest diet 12:53 this is the easiest diet I've ever 12:55 I've ever 12:55 I've ever tried." They don't 12:56 tried." They don't 12:56 tried." They don't miss bread. They don't care 12:57 miss bread. They don't care 12:57 miss bread. They don't care about pasta. 12:58 about pasta. 12:59 about pasta. They love eggs, 13:00 They love eggs, 13:01 They love eggs, fish, meat, vegetables, 13:02 fish, meat, vegetables, 13:02 fish, meat, vegetables, olive oil, and 13:03 olive oil, and 13:03 olive oil, and avocados. Fantastically. 13:06 avocados. Fantastically. 13:06 avocados. Fantastically. And I've also met 13:07 And I've also met 13:07 And I've also met patients who 13:08 patients who 13:08 patients who look at me as if 13:09 look at me as if I've ruined 13:10 I've ruined 13:10 I've ruined their childhood when I 13:11 their childhood when I 13:11 their childhood when I tell them they can't have 13:12 tell them they can't have 13:12 tell them they can't have fruit. Such a person 13:13 fruit. Such a person 13:13 fruit. Such a person may not be a 13:14 may not be a 13:14 may not be a suitable 13:14 suitable 13:14 suitable candidate for 13:15 candidate for 13:15 candidate for long-term keto 13:16 long-term keto . 13:16 . 13:17 . This brings us back to the 13:18 This brings us back to the 13:18 This brings us back to the previous video. 13:19 previous video. 13:20 previous video. The study we 13:21 The study we 13:21 The study we discussed 13:22 discussed 13:22 discussed showed a dramatic 13:23 showed a dramatic 13:23 showed a dramatic reduction in 13:24 reduction in 13:24 reduction in liver fat on the keto 13:25 liver fat on the keto diet, and 13:26 diet, and 13:26 diet, and mechanistically, this 13:27 mechanistically, this 13:27 mechanistically, this makes sense. Fatty 13:29 makes sense. Fatty 13:29 makes sense. Fatty liver disease is 13:30 liver disease is 13:30 liver disease is closely linked to 13:31 closely linked to 13:31 closely linked to insulin resistance 13:33 insulin resistance . When 13:35 . When 13:35 . When insulin levels are chronically 13:36 insulin levels are chronically 13:36 insulin levels are chronically elevated, 13:37 elevated, 13:37 elevated, adipose 13:38 adipose 13:38 adipose tissue metabolism becomes 13:39 tissue metabolism becomes 13:39 tissue metabolism becomes abnormal. Free 13:42 abnormal. Free 13:42 abnormal. Free fatty acids 13:43 fatty acids 13:43 fatty acids fill the liver. 13:45 fill the liver. 13:47 Thank you for watching. 13:47 Thank you for watching. See you in the 13:48 See you in the 13:48 See you in the next video.
Comments