Full Transcript Butter, Oils, and the Big Question 0:01 For 40 years we've 0:01 For 40 years we've been told that 0:02 been told that 0:02 been told that butter will kill you. Then 0:03 butter will kill you. Then 0:03 butter will kill you. Then the internet declared 0:05 the internet declared 0:05 the internet declared butter a superfood and 0:06 butter a superfood and 0:06 butter a superfood and oils a poison. So what is 0:07 oils a poison. So what is 0:07 oils a poison. So what is true about this? 0:08 true about this? 0:08 true about this? Today I'm cooking eggs 0:10 Today I'm cooking eggs 0:10 Today I'm cooking eggs three ways: in 0:11 three ways: in 0:11 three ways: in butter, in 0:12 butter, in 0:12 butter, in olive oil, and using the 0:14 olive oil, and using the 0:14 olive oil, and using the famous cooking 0:15 famous cooking 0:15 famous cooking trick—oil plus 0:16 trick—oil plus 0:16 trick—oil plus butter. And I'll tell you 0:17 butter. And I'll tell you 0:17 butter. And I'll tell you which fat actually 0:19 which fat actually 0:19 which fat actually wins. Not because the 0:21 wins. Not because the 0:23 guidelines say so, but because of 0:23 guidelines say so, but because of chemistry and data. I am
Introducing the Egg Cooking Test 0:25 chemistry and data. I am 0:25 chemistry and data. I am Dr. Ahmet Ergin. I am an 0:26 Dr. Ahmet Ergin. I am an 0:26 Dr. Ahmet Ergin. I am an endocrinologist. 0:28 endocrinologist. 0:29 endocrinologist. As you know, we have a 0:30 As you know, we have a 0:30 As you know, we have a website called sugarmds.com, and 0:31 website called sugarmds.com, and 0:31 website called sugarmds.com, and today I will give you 0:32 today I will give you 0:32 today I will give you honest and truthful 0:34 honest and truthful 0:34 honest and truthful information. Some 0:35 information. Some 0:35 information. Some commonly accepted 0:36 commonly accepted 0:38 nutritional advice was 0:38 nutritional advice was wrong. The era of 0:39 wrong. The era of 0:39 wrong. The era of low-fat foods 0:40 low-fat foods 0:40 low-fat foods pushed people towards 0:41 pushed people towards 0:41 pushed people towards sugary foods, and 0:42 sugary foods, and 0:42 sugary foods, and many of my 0:43 many of my 0:43 many of my diabetic patients 0:44 diabetic patients 0:44 diabetic patients paid the price. It's 0:45 paid the price. It's 0:48 fair to be skeptical, but 0:48 fair to be skeptical, but skepticism means 0:49 skepticism means 0:49 skepticism means following the evidence, 0:50 following the evidence, 0:50 following the evidence, even when it 0:51 even when it 0:51 even when it surprises you. So, 0:52 surprises you. So, 0:52 surprises you. So, let's protest. I'll call
Why Butter Burns Faster 0:53 let's protest. I'll call 0:53 let's protest. I'll call this pan the first—just 0:54 this pan the first—just 0:56 butter. It tastes 0:56 butter. It tastes great, there's no 0:57 great, there's no 0:57 great, there's no arguing that. But 0:58 arguing that. But 0:58 arguing that. But look at the 0:59 look at the 0:59 look at the frying pan. Butter is 1:00 frying pan. Butter is 1:00 frying pan. Butter is approximately 80% fat, 1:01 approximately 80% fat, 1:01 approximately 80% fat, water, and milk 1:03 water, and milk 1:03 water, and milk residues: proteins and 1:04 residues: proteins and 1:04 residues: proteins and milk sugar. These 1:05 milk sugar. These 1:05 milk sugar. These milky residues 1:06 milky residues 1:06 milky residues start to 1:07 start to 1:07 start to brown and 1:08 brown and 1:08 brown and burn at a fairly 1:09 burn at a fairly 1:09 burn at a fairly low temperature. 1:10 low temperature. 1:11 low temperature. This is why oil smokes 1:12 This is why oil smokes 1:12 This is why oil smokes and turns black over 1:13 and turns black over 1:13 and turns black over medium to 1:14 medium to 1:14 medium to high heat. 1:14 high heat. 1:15 high heat. Burnt butter is 1:16 Burnt butter is 1:16 Burnt butter is not just bitterness. 1:17 not just bitterness. 1:18 not just bitterness. Overheated fats 1:19 Overheated fats 1:19 Overheated fats form 1:20 form 1:20 form oxidation products, which you wouldn't 1:21 oxidation products, which you wouldn't 1:21 oxidation products, which you wouldn't want to eat every morning. 1:23 want to eat every morning. 1:23 want to eat every morning. Now let's talk about the 1:24 Now let's talk about the 1:24 Now let's talk about the second pan—oil
The Olive Oil Myth 1:26 second pan—oil 1:26 second pan—oil and butter. Chefs 1:27 and butter. Chefs 1:27 and butter. Chefs say that adding 1:28 say that adding 1:28 say that adding oil raises the 1:29 oil raises the 1:32 oil's smoke point. And here's the truth: 1:32 oil's smoke point. And here's the truth: that's not entirely true. 1:33 that's not entirely true. 1:33 that's not entirely true. Milk residue will still 1:34 Milk residue will still 1:34 Milk residue will still burn at the 1:35 burn at the 1:35 burn at the same 1:35 same 1:36 same temperature. There are 1:37 temperature. There are 1:37 temperature. There are just fewer of them per spoon 1:38 just fewer of them per spoon , so they burn 1:39 , so they burn 1:39 , so they burn a little slower and 1:40 a little slower and 1:40 a little slower and you notice it less 1:41 you notice it less 1:41 you notice it less . So this 1:43 . So this 1:43 . So this method is a flavor 1:44 method is a flavor 1:44 method is a flavor trick, not a 1:45 trick, not a 1:45 trick, not a health benefit. Not bad, 1:46 health benefit. Not bad, 1:46 health benefit. Not bad, but overrated. 1:47 but overrated. 1:47 but overrated. Now let's talk about the 1:49 Now let's talk about the 1:49 Now let's talk about the third pan— 1:50 third pan— extra virgin olive oil. 1:51 extra virgin olive oil. 1:51 extra virgin olive oil. People will say, "Doctor, 1:52 People will say, "Doctor, 1:52 People will say, "Doctor, what are you talking about? You 1:53 what are you talking about? You 1:53 what are you talking about? You can't cook with olive oil 1:54 can't cook with olive oil 1:54 can't cook with olive oil . It has a 1:55 . It has a 1:55 . It has a low 1:56 low 1:56 low smoke point." Well, this is 1:57 smoke point." Well, this is 1:57 smoke point." Well, this is one of the biggest 1:59 one of the biggest 1:59 one of the biggest kitchen myths. In a 2:00 kitchen myths. In a 2:00 kitchen myths. In a laboratory 2:01 laboratory 2:01 laboratory study, scientists 2:02 study, scientists 2:02 study, scientists heated 2:03 heated 2:03 heated olive oil and other 2:04 olive oil and other 2:05 olive oil and other popular oils to 2:06 popular oils to 2:06 popular oils to high temperatures for hours. 2:07 high temperatures for hours. 2:07 high temperatures for hours. Extra virgin olive oil 2:09 Extra virgin olive oil 2:09 Extra virgin olive oil was found to be 2:10 was found to be 2:10 was found to be the most stable. 2:11 the most stable. 2:11 the most stable. It produced fewer
Olive Oil Stability and Health Data 2:12 It produced fewer 2:13 It produced fewer harmful compounds than 2:14 harmful compounds than 2:14 harmful compounds than oils with a higher 2:15 oils with a higher 2:15 oils with a higher 2:17 smoke point. Why? 2:18 smoke point. Why? Thanks to natural 2:19 Thanks to natural 2:19 Thanks to natural antioxidants, 2:20 antioxidants, 2:20 antioxidants, polyphenols and 2:21 polyphenols and 2:21 polyphenols and vitamin E. 2:21 vitamin E. 2:21 vitamin E. Smoking temperature is 2:23 Smoking temperature is not everything. 2:23 not everything. 2:24 not everything. The main thing is 2:24 The main thing is stability. Eggs 2:25 stability. Eggs 2:27 are cooked over 2:27 are cooked over low heat in any case. 2:28 low heat in any case. 2:28 low heat in any case. Egg or chatter—you're 2:29 Egg or chatter—you're 2:29 Egg or chatter—you're not even 2:30 not even 2:30 not even close to the 2:31 close to the 2:31 close to the danger zone. 2:31 danger zone. 2:32 danger zone. Now here is the medical 2:33 Now here is the medical 2:33 Now here is the medical data. This is not just a 2:34 data. This is not just a 2:34 data. This is not just a kitchen experiment 2:35 kitchen experiment . A large-scale 2:35 . A large-scale 2:36 . A large-scale Harvard 2:36 Harvard 2:36 Harvard study 2:37 study 2:37 study tracked more than 2:38 tracked more than 2:38 tracked more than 90,000 people for 2:39 90,000 people for 2:39 90,000 people for nearly 30 years. People 2:41 nearly 30 years. People who consumed more than 2:42 who consumed more than 2:42 who consumed more than half a tablespoon of 2:43 half a tablespoon of 2:43 half a tablespoon of olive oil per 2:44 olive oil per 2:44 olive oil per day had a lower 2:45 day had a lower 2:45 day had a lower risk of death from 2:46 risk of death from 2:46 risk of death from heart disease, cancer, and 2:47 heart disease, cancer, and 2:47 heart disease, cancer, and neurodegenerative 2:49 neurodegenerative 2:49 neurodegenerative diseases. Replacing 2:50 diseases. Replacing 2:50 diseases. Replacing about 10g of 2:51 about 10g of 2:51 about 10g of butter, 2:52 butter, 2:52 butter, margarine or 2:53 margarine or 2:53 margarine or mayonnaise per day with 2:55 mayonnaise per day with 2:55 mayonnaise per day with olive oil was 2:56 olive oil was 2:56 olive oil was associated with an 2:57 associated with an 3:00 8–34% reduction in the risk of death. This is 3:00 8–34% reduction in the risk of death. This is observational data, 3:01 observational data, 3:01 observational data, so it shows 3:02 so it shows 3:02 so it shows a correlation, not 3:03 a correlation, not 3:03 a correlation, not necessarily 3:03 necessarily 3:03 necessarily perfect proof, but 3:05 perfect proof, but 3:05 perfect proof, but it is consistent with 3:06 it is consistent with 3:06 it is consistent with randomized 3:07 randomized 3:07 randomized trials of the 3:07 trials of the 3:07 trials of the Mediterranean 3:09 Mediterranean 3:09 Mediterranean diet, like Predimed. What
Eggs, Cholesterol, and Blood Sugar 3:10 diet, like Predimed. What 3:10 diet, like Predimed. What about eggs? The good 3:11 about eggs? The good 3:11 about eggs? The good news: 3:12 news: 3:13 news: eggs are good for most people. 3:14 eggs are good for most people. 3:14 eggs are good for most people. Dietary cholesterol 3:15 Dietary cholesterol 3:15 Dietary cholesterol affects 3:16 affects 3:16 affects blood cholesterol levels 3:17 blood cholesterol levels 3:17 blood cholesterol levels less than we 3:18 less than we 3:18 less than we previously thought. However, some 3:19 previously thought. However, some 3:19 previously thought. However, some people are 3:19 people are 3:19 people are hyperreactive, and 3:21 hyperreactive, and 3:21 hyperreactive, and people with diabetes 3:22 people with diabetes 3:22 people with diabetes should monitor their 3:23 should monitor their 3:23 should monitor their egg consumption. So 3:24 egg consumption. So 3:24 egg consumption. So know your 3:25 know your 3:25 know your metrics. Get a 3:26 metrics. Get a 3:26 metrics. Get a lipid profile and, 3:27 lipid profile and, 3:27 lipid profile and, if possible, 3:28 if possible, 3:28 if possible, include an 3:29 include an 3:29 include an apoB test. Your 3:30 apoB test. Your 3:30 apoB test. Your analyses are more useful than 3:31 analyses are more useful than 3:31 analyses are more useful than anyone else's opinion, including 3:32 anyone else's opinion, including 3:32 anyone else's opinion, including mine. In addition, fats 3:33 mine. In addition, fats 3:33 mine. In addition, fats do not cause 3:34 do not cause 3:36 blood sugar spikes. Eggs fried 3:36 blood sugar spikes. Eggs fried in olive oil are a 3:37 in olive oil are a great breakfast with a 3:38 great breakfast with a 3:38 great breakfast with a low glycemic 3:39 low glycemic 3:39 low glycemic index. It's what 3:40 index. It's what 3:41 index. It's what you eat them with—white 3:42 you eat them with—white 3:42 you eat them with—white bread, juice, crackers—that 3:43 bread, juice, crackers—that actually causes the 3:45 actually causes the 3:45 actually causes the sugar spike. So, 3:46 sugar spike. So, 3:46 sugar spike. So, who is the winner? 3:47 who is the winner? 3:47 who is the winner? Of course, 3:49 Of course, 3:49 Of course, extra-virgin olive oil. It is 3:50 extra-virgin olive oil. It is 3:50 extra-virgin olive oil. It is stable, contains 3:51 stable, contains 3:51 stable, contains protective compounds, and 3:52 protective compounds, and 3:52 protective compounds, and has the most 3:52 has the most 3:52 has the most convincing 3:53 convincing 3:53 convincing long-term data. 3:54 long-term data. 3:54 long-term data. Do you like 3:55 Do you like 3:55 Do you like butter? Don't panic. A
The Winner: Extra Virgin Olive Oil 3:57 butter? Don't panic. A 3:57 butter? Don't panic. A small piece 3:58 small piece 3:58 small piece at the end for taste 3:59 at the end for taste is normal for 4:00 is normal for 4:00 is normal for most people. 4:01 most people. 4:02 most people. The main thing is not to burn 4:03 The main thing is not to burn 4:03 The main thing is not to burn oil and not make 4:04 oil and not make 4:04 oil and not make it your main 4:05 it your main 4:05 it your main source of fat. 4:06 source of fat. 4:06 source of fat. Write 4:06 Write 4:06 Write your 4:07 your 4:07 your favorite way 4:08 favorite way 4:08 favorite way to cook eggs in the comments, and 4:09 to cook eggs in the comments, and 4:09 to cook eggs in the comments, and we'll see you in the 4:09 we'll see you in the 4:09 we'll see you in the next video. 4:10 next video. 4:10 next video. Of course, like the 4:11 Of course, like the 4:11 Of course, like the video. Share 4:13 video. Share 4:13 video. Share it and write what you 4:14 it and write what you 4:14 it and write what you think.
Comments