Full Transcript Introduction to NAD and Longevity Medicine 0:01 [music] Welcome to the Trip Lab, kitchen table 0:05 conversations about integrative medicine and psychedelics. [music] 0:08 I'm your host and attending physician, Dr. Mariela Wood. 0:14 Hi everyone, welcome back. Today we're going to talk about a topic that has 0:18 become almost unavoidable in wellness, longevity clinics, and supplement 0:23 conversations right now, and that is NAD and longevity medicine. If you've spent 0:28 any time in this space, whether on social media or outside, you've probably 0:32 heard NAD described as a kind of master molecule for aging. Something that 0:37 declines as we get older and if restored might improve energy, slow aging, or 0:43 even extend lifespan. And it shows up in supplements, IV clinics, lab testing, 0:48 and a lot of very confident claims. And like many things in medicine that sound 0:53 compelling, there is real biology underneath it. But there's also a lot of 0:57 oversimplification layered on top. So in this episode, we're going to break all 1:01 of that down. We're going to talk about what NAD actually is and why it's 1:06 getting so much attention. Then I want to zoom out a bit and use 1:10 NAD as an entry point into the broader field of longevity medicine and what 1:14 it's trying to do, why it's very exciting, why it's also prone to hype, 1:19 especially when human outcome data is still emerging. From there, we'll go 1:23 even deeper. We'll look at what NAD does in the body, why levels may decline with 1:28 age, inflammation, and lifestyle factors, and what that decline actually 1:33 represents. We'll also talk about testing, whether or not NAD can be 1:37 measured, whether those tests are validated, and what they do and don't 1:41 tell us clinically. And finally, of course, we'll talk about 1:45 supplementation, what the data supports, what actually is still theoretical, 1:50 what's definitely overhyped, and why NAD supplementation might still be 1:54 reasonable in certain contexts, even though we don't yet have the kind of 1:58 outcome data that would justify universal recommendations. 2:02 So, spoiler alert, this episode is not about declaring NAD a miracle or
What Longevity Medicine Is Trying to Solve 2:07 dismissing it. It's about drawing a line between promise and proof and using NAD 2:12 as a case study for how longevity medicine is evolving in real time. So 2:17 let's just get into it. To really understand NAD, we first have to talk 2:21 about longevity medicine and how aging is being studied. 2:26 So big picture, longevity medicine shifts the focus of healthcare earlier. 2:31 So away from reacting to disease once it's established and toward 2:35 understanding the biological processes that drive aging and age related decline 2:40 in the first place. So the goal isn't simply to live longer lifespan but to 2:46 extend health span the number of years we spend functioning well with 2:50 resilience mobility cognitive clarity and metabolic flexibility. So this is 2:56 part of what makes the field so compelling. Longevity medicine draws 3:00 from systems biology, metabolism, immunology, neuroscience and a whole lot 3:06 more to ask a different set of questions than our traditional medicine has 3:10 historically asked. So instead of waiting for diabetes or cardiovascular 3:15 disease or neurodeeneration to happen, it asks what is happening now at the 3:20 cellular level and molecular level that could lead to disease or signs of aging 3:26 and whether or not those processes are actually modifiable. One of the most 3:31 influential frameworks to come out of this research is the concept of the 3:34 hallmarks of aging. So these are shared biological processes that tend to change 3:40 as we age and are thought to contribute to both the visible features of aging 3:44 and to many chronic diseases. So some notable examples include mitochondrial 3:49 dysfunction, deregulated nutrient sensing, impaired autoagi, epigenetic 3:56 alterations, tieumir attrition, chronic inflammation, and stem cell exhaustion. 4:02 We could easily do an entire episode breaking those down in more detail, and 4:06 maybe we will. But the brief point here is that aging isn't viewed as one single 4:11 process. It's understood now as a network of interconnected biological 4:16 changes. And this actually is where NAD enters the conversation. NAD plays a 4:22 role in several of these hallmarks of aging. Mitochondrial energy production, 4:27 DNA repair pathways, and cellular stress responses. So because of this, it has 4:33 become a very attractive target within longevity medicine. So at high level, it 4:38 certainly does sound pretty straightforward. NAD declines with age. 4:42 NAD is involved in many of the hallmarks of aging. So supplementing NAD should 4:47 improve aging outcomes. And that might be true, but this is also 4:52 where longevity medicine becomes vulnerable to oversimplification. 4:56 Many of these hallmarks are supported by strong mechanistic and animal data. But 5:01 translating that biology into meaningful human interventions is far more complex. 5:07 Aging happens over decades, which means outcomes take years, decades to measure. 5:14 So, this doesn't mean that our theoretical lab studies are wrong. It 5:17 just means that we don't have long-term data in humans yet, and it's pretty hard 5:22 to assess, which we'll get into later. But with all that being said, one nuance 5:26 that I often emphasize when discussing integrative or longevity focused 5:30 therapies is this. The decision to use a treatment doesn't necessarily need to be 5:35 based solely on whether or not we have definitive proof that it works. 5:39 Sometimes the data suggests something might help. And in those cases, the 5:43 decision also hinges on other questions. Does it cause harm? Is the cost 5:49 reasonable? How strong is the biological rationale? and how uncertain is the 5:54 evidence? And truthfully, most of these longevity medicine treatments live right 5:59 at the intersection of those questions. The field is quite scientifically
How NAD Works in Cells 6:03 sophisticated and genuinely promising, but it also is incomplete at this stage. 6:09 But we could also argue that all of medicine is incomplete. But I will say 6:13 longevity medicine is still relatively new and how it's being applied 6:16 clinically, which makes careful interpretation especially important. 6:22 So with all that in mind, let's dive deeper. What do we actually know about 6:26 NAD? To start, NAD stands for nicotenomide adinine ducleotide and it's 6:32 a molecule that exists in every living cell. At its most fundamental level, NAD 6:38 is essential for energy metabolism. It carries electrons during metabolic 6:43 reactions, which essentially means that it helps convert the food we eat into 6:47 usable cellular energy or ATP. Without adequate NAD, these pathways, 6:54 particularly in the mitochondria, just simply don't function efficiently. So, 6:58 this alone makes NAD very important. But that's actually not all that it does. It 7:04 also functions as a signaling molecule and fuel when our cells are under 7:08 stress, either from inflammation, oxidative damage, environmental 7:13 exposures, or just wear and tear, aka aging. So for example, our DNA is 7:19 constantly being damaged. This happens every day from metabolic processes, 7:24 exposure to UV light, environmental toxins, oxidative stress, inflammation, 7:29 or even just plain old normal cell division. And when that damage occurs, 7:34 the cell activates repair pathways to fix it. The enzymes involved in those 7:39 repair pathways require NAD to function. They literally use NAD as fuel to do 7:45 their work. This is a key idea because it helps explain why NAD levels tend to 7:51 be lower with age and in chronic disease. So over time, cells are 7:55 naturally exposed to more cumulative stress and damage and they burn through 8:00 more NAD trying to keep things functioning and stable. This is also why 8:04 NAD levels are often lower, not just with aging, but in states of chronic 8:08 inflammation, insulin resistance, mitochondrial dysfunction, and prolonged 8:13 physiological stress. Lifestyle factors of course play a role here as well. Poor 8:18 sleep, sedendary behavior, excess caloric intake, and ongoing 8:22 psychological stresses appear to increase the metabolic and inflammatory 8:26 burden on cells, which of course increases NAD demand. With this, I do 8:32 want to note an important conceptual shift here. Declining NAD over time may 8:37 not be the cause of aging so much as a marker of cumulative cellular stress and 8:42 damage. As cells are forced to respond to more injury over time, they consume 8:47 more NAD, and the systems responsible for regenerating can't keep up with the 8:52 less NAD available. So, we get it. Yes, NAD important. But where does it 8:57 actually come from? Well, our bodies make it primarily from B vitamins like 9:03 B3 or niacin, which are found in foods like meats, fish, dairy, legumes, nuts, 9:09 and whole grains. All of those contain different forms of B3 that our body can 9:14 use as building blocks for NAD. Our bodies also have what's called a salvage 9:19 pathway, which is the primary way we maintain NAD levels dayto-day. So 9:24 instead of constantly building NAD from scratch, cells actually recycle the 9:28 breakdown products, especially nicotinomide back into NAD. 9:33 This recycling process is efficient, but it's also where problems can arise as we 9:39 age or experience chronic inflammation and stress. The demand for NAD increases 9:44 as we talked about and also the salvage pathways may not keep up with how much 9:48 NAD is being consumed. So even though we can make NAD, our levels do depend on a 9:54 balance between production, recycling, and consumption. If consumption goes up 10:00 because of ongoing inflammation, oxidative stress, repeated DNA repair, 10:05 NAD levels fall unless our production and recycling keep up the pace. This is 10:10 also why lifestyle factors matter. Adequate nutrition can provide the raw
Measuring NAD and B Vitamins 10:14 materials. Sleep, exercise, and metabolic health 10:17 influence how efficiently NAD is recycled. On the other hand, chronic 10:22 stress and inflammation increases demand. So, when we talk about quote 10:26 unquote low NAD, what we're often really describing is an imbalance in this 10:30 system rather than a simple lack of intake. I think understanding this is 10:35 very important because it helps us reframe how we actually think about 10:38 supplementation. Taking an NAD supplement, which is 10:42 actually an NAD precursor, which we'll get to, isn't introducing something 10:45 foreign into the body. It is providing additional raw materials for a system 10:49 that already exists. But the question is, which we will get into right now, is 10:54 whether adding more raw materials meaningfully changes outcomes in humans. 10:59 So to understand whether supplements work, we have to first talk about can we 11:03 actually measure NAD and its building blocks like B vitamins. 11:07 Technically, yes, NAD can be measured. There are blood tests that look at NAD 11:12 levels and/or its related metabolites. And there are actually now commercial 11:16 tests, including fingerstick options that claim to assess NAD status. In 11:22 research settings, these measurements are done using very precise laboratory 11:25 techniques. But in clinical practice, right now, the picture is a little bit 11:29 more complicated. The first challenge is what are we actually measuring? Most 11:34 available tests do measure NAD, but they measure NAD in the blood. What we need 11:40 to remember is that NAD is used inside the cells, muscle, liver, brain, and all 11:47 of those tissues have very different NAD dynamics. So, a blood value doesn't 11:52 necessarily tell us what's going on inside the tissues that we actually most 11:56 care about for aging, performance, and cognition. 12:00 So right away there is one limitation on how directly actionable these numbers 12:03 are. The second is interpretation. Right now we don't have wellestablished 12:09 clinical reference ranges for NAD that are clearly tied to outcomes like 12:13 improve function, reduce cardiovascular risk, or longer health span. All of what 12:19 our goal of supplementation, which we will get to later, would address. In 12:23 many cases, testing can tell us whether NAD levels change after an intervention, 12:28 but not whether the change actually translates into a meaningful benefit. 12:33 However, this doesn't mean that it's not helpful. It can serve as a biioarker 12:37 that gives us just one piece of the puzzle. A related question that often 12:41 comes up now that we know that NAD is made from B vitamins is whether testing 12:45 B vitamins, particularly B3, is useful. This is where nuance really matters. 12:52 While B vitamin deficiencies certainly exist and can be clinically important, 12:56 blood testing for B vitamins is surprisingly imperfect. Again, blood 13:01 levels don't reflect the intracellular status, functional adequacy, or how 13:06 efficiently those vitamins are being used inside the cells. So, what that 13:10 means, someone can have a quote unquote normal B vitamin level in blood work and 13:15 still have impaired utilization due to inflammation, metabolic dysfunction, or
NAD Supplements: NR and NMN 13:19 genetic variation. Conversely, elevated levels can sometimes reflect recent 13:24 supplementation rather than true tissue sufficiency. 13:28 So, while B vitamin testing can be helpful in specific clinical scenarios, 13:33 it doesn't reliably tell us whether the body is effectively producing or 13:37 maintaining NAD. This also highlights a broader theme in longevity medicine. 13:42 Just because we can measure something doesn't mean it's necessarily useful and 13:47 certainly does not give us the whole picture. Okay, so testing may be helpful 13:51 if we look at it just one piece of the puzzle. But what about supplements? 13:55 Well, to start, the first thing to know is that most NAD supplements are not 13:59 actually NAD. Instead, they are blends of NAD precursors, which are molecules 14:04 that the body can then convert into NAD. And the two most common ones we see are 14:10 nicotenomide riocide, NR, and nicotenomide monucleotide, NMN. So, 14:17 here's what we do know with fairly good confidence. In many studies, NR does 14:22 increase blood NAD levels. A well-sighted trial in healthy 14:27 middle-aged and older adults showed that NR was well tolerated, which is 14:30 important, and also increased NAD over 6 weeks. In another study looking at obese 14:36 men, NR was also safe, also important. It raised NAD like the other one, but it 14:42 did not improve insulin sensitivity over the study period. Follow-up studies also 14:46 found that NR did not improve skeletal muscle mitochondrial respiration or 14:51 content which is an important note because mitochondria are one of the 14:55 major reasons people take these products. So essentially NR does 14:59 increase NAD levels but the actual functional impact of that is pretty 15:04 inconsistent so far. For NMN, a randomized multic-center placeboc 15:09 controlled dose ranging trial in healthy middle-aged adults found that NMN did 15:14 increase blood NAD concentrations and was well tolerated. More recent NMN work 15:19 in older adults also suggest potential improvements in areas like sleep quality 15:24 and walking speed, but these are still early and not definitive yet. 15:29 Additionally, further systematic reviews and meta analysis are basically telling 15:33 the same thing. NMN reliably increases NAD levels, but most clinically relevant 15:39 metabolic outcomes are either small, inconsistent, or not statistically 15:43 significant across trials. And they did show a big risk of bias common in 15:48 several of the big studies. There also are disease specific studies worth 15:52 mentioning as well. So in one randomized trial in peripheral arterial disease, NR 15:58 meaningfully improved 6-minute walk distance compared with placebo over 6 16:01 months for mild cognitive impairment. A small randomized pilot study showed NR 16:07 increased blood NAD, which we know happens, and was generally well 16:11 tolerated, also important, but did not show clear cognitive improvement over 16:15 the short duration, which is what they were looking at. Ultimately, the data 16:19 isn't quite there for the clinical outcomes, but the theory behind 16:23 supplementation is interesting. And again, we're thinking of this more 16:26 long-term longevity, and these studies were done over pretty short terms. But 16:30 what we do know is that most supplementation was pretty safe in all 16:34 the clinical trials so far. Next, let's talk about the different delivery types 16:38 with all of these highly marketed supplements. We have those regular 16:42 capsules or tablets. We have sublingual or dissolving products. and we have IVs 16:48 which are very hyped. So let's talk about each of them and look at what the 16:51 data shows. To start the oral capsules actually have the most data to support 16:56 it primarily because these are what are being used in the clinical trials. 17:02 Next when we look at the liposal or sublingual the dissolving under the 17:05 tongue ones the thought is that supplements are better absorbed or 17:09 delivered into the tissues this way. So liposal meaning better absorbed in the 17:14 gut, sublingual dissolves directly into the bloodstream. And that does sound 17:18 plausible, but we actually don't have robust evidence or clinical trials that 17:22 show superior outcomes with these formulations over our regular capsules. 17:27 Last, the most highly marketed route, IVs.
IV NAD, Delivery Methods, and Lifestyle Strategies 17:31 But before we ask whether it helps, there's another basic question we need 17:36 to answer first. What happens to NAD when you infuse it? A human study done 17:41 to document plasma and urine NAD metabolites during and after a six-hour 17:45 NAD infusion highlights that directly infusing NAD has a pretty complex 17:51 metabolism and excretion dynamics, meaning it's not just as simple as IV 17:56 NAD go straight into the cells. Separately, there's ongoing debate in 18:01 the scientific community about whether intact NAD can cross cell membranes in 18:06 meaningful amounts. More practically, the larger problem is that IVNAD is 18:11 being sold from everything from detox or anti-aging in ways that really really 18:16 exceed the quality of evidence and often at a very high cost. So ultimately, we 18:22 just don't know how helpful NAD supplementation is. Theoretically, it 18:26 should be very helpful and so far it hasn't shown to be harmful, but we just 18:31 don't know yet. We do know NAD is essential for longevity and quote 18:35 unquote anti-aging and supplementing may be helpful, but so might many other 18:41 lifestyle strategies that actually have more evidence than NAD does right now. I 18:46 will add though right now I would definitely say IV NAD is probably not 18:50 worth the cost. So I mentioned these lifestyle longevity strategies. 18:55 These are essential because they can improve NAD levels and actually work 18:59 more broadly for longevity. And it truly is back to lifestyle basics like 19:04 exercise, metabolic health, sleep, and inflammation reduction. But of course, 19:10 let's look at the data. Strength training appears to upregulate 19:14 NAD salvage capacity in human skeletal muscle, which is one of the more 19:18 compelling non-supplement strategies that we have. 19:22 There are also reviews and newer work supporting the idea that exercise 19:26 acutely and chronically influences NAD metabolism and NAD biosynthesis 19:31 pathways. Add in other fundamentals like 19:34 maintaining adequate dietary B3 intake, improving insulin sensitivity, treating 19:40 sleep disruption, and reducing chronic inflammation burden. And you're often 19:44 addressing the real upstream reasons NAD gets stressed in the first place. So to 19:50 conclude, NAD is very important and it clearly plays a role in energy repair 19:55 and aging related pathways. We know that we can raise NAD levels 20:00 with supplementation, but we don't have strong evidence that doing so reliably 20:04 improves long-term health outcomes. The promise is very real, but the proof 20:09 is still emerging. And I think that is the larger point of 20:13 longevity medicine right now. The field is so exciting because it is asking the 20:18 better questions earlier, but it also sits in a space where mechanisms often 20:23 get mistaken for answers and molecules get more attention than systems do. In 20:29 my opinion, longevity is probably less about finding the right supplement and 20:33 more about understanding why the body is under so much stress in the first place. 20:38 Aging isn't just something to quote unquote fix. It's something to 20:42 understand. And the most powerful longevity interventions are still 20:46 lifestyle, diet, nutrition, sleep, stress reduction, and social connection. 20:53 Thanks for listening to the Trip Lab. If you liked this episode, please subscribe 20:57 and share so we can get the conversation started about integrative medicine and 21:01 psychedelics to destigmatize it and fully explore what this could mean in 21:06 the world. [music]
Comments