Full Transcript Introduction to Functional Medicine Testing 0:01 [music] Welcome to the trip lab kitchen table 0:05 conversations about integrative medicine and psychedelics. [music] 0:08 I'm your host and attending physician Dr. Mariela Wood. 0:14 Welcome back to another episode of the trip lab. Today we're going to be 0:18 talking about functional medicine testing. So what it is, when it can be 0:22 genuinely helpful, and where the limitations lie. So, I see all sides of 0:28 this topic every single day. Patients who come in with stacks of expensive 0:32 testing that were ordered after a single visit with a functional medicine 0:35 practitioner. Sometimes a doctor, sometimes not, and we'll talk more about 0:39 that later. And then I also see my more traditional western medicine colleagues 0:43 dismiss any functional medicine testing outright because it's quote unquote not 0:47 validated. And I also see plenty of patients asking for these tests without 0:52 actually knowing what they measure or what questions they're trying to answer 0:56 with the test. So, let's dive into all of this. And I will say right off the 1:00 bat that I actually do use functional medicine testing in my practice, but 1:04 almost never as the first part of my workup. I always start with a thorough 1:09 history, a careful clinical assessment, and when appropriate, basic testing that 1:14 can be done through traditional laboratories. 1:16 Functional medicine testing usually enters the picture only when those 1:20 standard approaches fall short and we don't have a clear understanding of 1:23 what's driving someone's symptoms. So at the end I'll also walk through the 1:27 specific functional medicine tests that I do find helpful and use regularly. 1:32 We'll also talk about the limitations of those tests and also a few categories of 1:36 tests that I don't usually recommend. So let's start at the beginning. What do we 1:41 actually mean when we say functional medicine testing? So these are generally 1:45 advanced laboratory tests designed to look at physiology, metabolism, and 1:50 biological patterns rather than diagnosing a specific disease. Some 1:55 examples of these include the Dutch hormone tests, comprehensive stool
What Functional Medicine Testing Is 1:59 testing, food sensitivity testing, which is different than allergy testing, and 2:04 functional nutrition testing. So all of these tests are not run through 2:08 traditional hospital-based laboratories. They're usually offered through 2:12 specialty labs, most often paid for out of pocket and not covered by insurance. 2:18 So that alone, I think, tends to raise concerns for both patients and 2:21 clinicians and understandably so. Traditional medical testing is largely 2:26 built to answer a very specific question. Does this patient meet 2:30 criteria for a diagnosible disease? Functional medicine testing is usually 2:35 asking a different question. How is this system functioning? where might it be 2:41 under strain or compensating? So instead of focusing on whether a value crosses a 2:46 diagnostic threshold, many of these tests look at patterns, ratios, 2:51 metabolites, or dynamic changes over time. And they're meant to inform 2:55 hypotheses rather than give definitive answers, which I think is the key. And I 3:00 think that intent is where a lot of the confusion and controversy comes from. 3:04 These tests are not designed to replace standard labs. They are not diagnostic 3:08 tests in a traditional sense and they're not meant to be ordered in isolation 3:12 without clinical context. When functional medicine testing is used 3:17 well, it's layered on top of a thoughtful history, a physical exam, and 3:21 conventional testing. It's not a shortcut. And I think another important 3:25 and sometimes uncomfortable part of this conversation is who is ordering these 3:30 tests. Many functional medicine labs allow a wide range of practitioners to 3:34 order testing, which includes physicians and nurse practitioners and PAs, but 3:39 also chiropractors, nutritionists, and sometimes even health coaches depending 3:44 on the state. I've also seen many patients who were able to just order the 3:48 labs themselves. But I do want to be very clear here. This is not about 3:52 saying that non-healthcare professionals like doctors, PAs, nurse practitioners, 3:56 even naturopathic doctors shouldn't order the functional medicine tests. I 4:01 do think that many non-clinian providers like nutritionists and health coaches do 4:05 do excellent work and do have a deep expertise in specific areas, but we do 4:10 have to recognize the difference in training. physicians and I'm going to 4:13 include naturopathic physicians here. NPs and PAs are trained extensively in 4:19 differential diagnosis, pathophysiology, disease progression, and most 4:24 importantly, what not to attribute to a test result. We're trained to recognize 4:29 when a lab abnormality is clinically meaningful, when it's incidental, and 4:33 when it actually may be a red herring. When functional medicine testing is 4:37 ordered without that broader medical framework, there's a higher risk of over 4:41 interterpretation, misdiagnosis, unnecessary supplements, that's a big
Validation, Interpretation, and Overtesting Risks 4:46 one, or attributing symptoms to lab findings that may not actually be the 4:51 cause of the problem. And I think from a patient perspective, this can be 4:54 incredibly confusing. When results come back flagged as abnormal and sometimes 4:59 very dramatically so with how these tests come up, it doesn't give a clear 5:02 explanation of what's clinically relevant and what isn't. And that is how 5:07 people end up with a long list of supplements, oftentimes also anxiety and 5:12 actually very little symptom improvement. 5:15 So again, this isn't functional medicine testing is good or bad. I think the key 5:20 here is how it's used and interpreted and whether it's being integrated into 5:24 real clinical reasoning. So testing should support clinical 5:28 judgment, not replace it. Next, let's jump into the biggest controversy with 5:33 these functional medicine tests and that is testing validation. 5:38 So many providers will dismiss these tests and use a blanket statement saying 5:42 that quote unquote these tests are not validated. So what does that actually 5:46 mean? How do we validate tests and our functional medicine tests actually not 5:51 validated? In medicine, when we talk about validation, we're usually talking 5:55 about a very specific process. So, traditional laboratory tests are 5:59 validated by being studied in large populations and tied to clear clinical 6:04 endpoints. So, we ask questions like, does this test reliably detect a known 6:09 disease? Does it predict outcomes that we care about like morbidity or 6:13 mortality? Does acting on this result change what happens to the patient in a 6:17 measurable way? And asking those questions is how we end 6:21 up with reference ranges, diagnostic cuto offs, and clinical guidelines. So 6:26 tests like fasting glucose or an A1C or a TSH has been studied in tens or 6:32 actually probably even hundreds of thousands of people. And we know what 6:36 values correlate with disease, what values predict risk, and what 6:40 interventions improve outcomes when those values are abnormal. Functional 6:44 medicine testing is not built that way. Many of these tests were not designed to 6:49 diagnose disease or predict hard outcomes like hospitalization or death. 6:54 They were designed to measure biological processes, metabolic intermediates, or 6:59 physiologic patterns. And because of that, they usually haven't gone through 7:04 the same large-scale validation studies that traditional diagnostic tests have. 7:07 So when someone says a functional medicine test is invalidated, what they 7:11 usually mean is that it hasn't been linked to a specific disease diagnosis 7:15 or clinical endpoint in a large population trial. So that part 7:19 definitely is true. But I will say that lack of traditional validation does not 7:24 automatically mean that a test is meaningless or unscientific. But it does 7:28 mean that we need to be much more thoughtful about how we interpret it and 7:32 what we use it for. And in fact, what I think a lot of people don't realize is 7:36 that medicine uses plenty of tests and measurements that aren't perfectly 7:39 validated in the way we like to imagine. For example, we routinely use surrogate 7:44 markers. LDL cholesterol is actually an example of one. [snorts] We extrapolate 7:48 the number from what we know about physiology. Then we make clinical 7:52 decisions based on patterns, trends, and imperfect data. The difference is that 7:57 we usually do this within a framework that acknowledges that uncertainty. So, 8:01 some functional medicine tests do in fact have components that are 8:04 analytically validated. They often go through a certification process, meaning 8:08 that the assays themselves can reliably measure what they claim to measure. So, 8:12 this is great. Another thing to note, too, though, is that these tests do 8:15 generate a lot of data and sometimes with values flagged as abnormal, even 8:20 when there's no clear evidence that changing that value will improve 8:23 symptoms or outcomes. So, this should make us pause. We do need to interpret 8:28 these results cautiously in context and in combination with the whole picture of 8:32 the patient. I think a key way of looking at this is that functional 8:36 medicine testing is rarely definitive. It gives you a snapshot in time. It does 8:41 not give you answers in the same way that a biopsy or tropponin level does. 8:45 It gives you clues. And I think another problem arises when functional medicine 8:49 testing is presented as more precise, more advanced or more definitive than 8:54 our traditional medicine. On that same note, I do want to briefly talk about 8:58 when overesting actually can be dangerous and why I almost never start 9:02 with functional medicine testing. So, when you start with really broad 9:06 unargeted functional medicine testing, especially early in a workup, you 9:10 dramatically increase the chance of finding abnormalities that may not be 9:13 clinically meaningful. Inevitably, these tests, they're like 20 pages long, will 9:18 produce something flagged as out of range. And without context, those flags 9:22 can quickly turn into a quote unquote diagnosis where supplement regimens or 9:26 protocols are given and it might not actually be what the patient needs. So I 9:30 usually begin when appropriate with conventional laboratory testing, not 9:34 because it's quote unquote more sophisticated, but because it is better 9:38 validated, easier to interpret, and often enough to identify or at least 9:42 rule out something serious or common. If we skip that step and jump straight into 9:46 functional medicine testing, we may miss something basic or attribute symptoms to 9:51 a functional abnormality when there might be something more straightforward 9:54 going on. I think another real risk of overesting too is what it does to 9:58 patients psychologically. When someone is handed a report with all these red 10:02 flags, arrows, and complex charts, it can reinforce the belief that their body 10:07 is broken. That mindset alone can drive anxiety, 10:11 hypervigilance, and a constant sense of needing to fix something, sometimes 10:15 indefinitely. So, bottom line with all of this, I use functional medicine 10:19 testing when it's intentional and targeted, and usually only after a 10:24 simpler explanation has been ruled out. So, with that long explanation and 10:29 preface, let's talk about which tests I actually do use in my practice. 10:33 First, we'll start with the Dutch hormone tests. So Dutch stands for dried 10:37 urine test for comprehensive hormones. It's a urine based test that looks at 10:41 sex hormones and their metabolites along with cortisol patterns across the day. 10:46 At least the Dutch complete does. There are a few variations of the Dutch test. 10:50 So unlike a single blood draw, it gives a more integrated picture of hormone 10:54 production, metabolism, and clearance over time. What I think it does 10:58 particularly well is assess hormone metabolites. 11:02 So rather than just telling you how much estrogen or progesterone is circulating 11:05 at one snapshot in time, it shows how estrogen is being broken down into 11:10 different pathways, how progesterone metabolites look across the ludal phase,
Dutch Hormone Testing 11:15 and how cortisol is rising and falling throughout a day. That information is 11:18 something that we don't get from a standard blood test. And this is why I 11:22 find the Dutch test most helpful in situations where symptoms don't match 11:26 what we're seeing on those tests. For example, someone may have a normal serum 11:31 estrogen and progesterone level but still be experiencing significant PMS, 11:36 PMDD, pmenopause symptoms or even stress related hormone disruption. And in those 11:42 cases, understanding hormone metabolism, the cortisol rhythm, and the 11:47 relationship between stress hormones and sex hormones can be very clinically 11:51 useful. That said though, this test is not diagnostic. It does not diagnose 11:56 hormone disorders, adrenal disease, or endocrine pathology, and it should never 12:02 replace basic labs to rule out those conditions. I also want to be clear that 12:06 the Dutch test is not something that I use as a screening tool on people 12:09 without symptoms. It's a targeted test that I use when there's a specific 12:13 clinical question I'm trying to answer, particularly around cycle symptoms, mood 12:17 changes tied to the menstrual cycle, or stress hormone interactions that aren't 12:21 explained by conventional testing. There's also a few variations of the 12:24 Dutch test that I think are worth mentioning briefly. We have the Dutch 12:28 cycle mapping version which is designed to collect samples across an entire 12:31 menstrual cycle. This can be helpful in more complex cases where symptoms may 12:36 vary from phase to phase or where ovulation timing is unclear. It's 12:41 definitely more intensive. You have to collect your urine at on different days 12:44 throughout the entire month. So, it's not something that I use routinely, but 12:48 in select cases, it can provide a valuable insight. We also have the Dutch 12:52 adrenal test which is more focused and narrowly on cortisol and cortisone 12:55 patterns throughout the day. So this can be useful with patients with significant 13:00 fatigue, sleep disruption or stress related symptoms when we're trying to 13:04 understand that cortisol rhythm. So overall, I think the Dutch test is a 13:08 good example of how functional medicine testing can be helpful when it's used 13:12 thoughtfully. Next, let's talk about the GI MAP test, which I think is one of the 13:17 more commonly used comprehensive stool tests out there. So, this is a stool 13:20 test that uses PCR based DNA analysis to look at the gut microbiome. 13:26 It assesses bacterial, parasite, viral, and fungal DNA along with markers of 13:31 digestion, inflammation, and immune activity in the gut. I think this test 13:35 can be helpful for patients with persistent GI symptoms like bloating, 13:39 abdominal pain, diarrhea, constipation, or post-infectious IBS, especially when 13:45 our standard GI workup has been unrevealing. 13:48 In those situations, it can help generate hypotheses around microbial 13:52 imbalance, inflammation, or altered gut immune signaling. However, I think it's 13:58 important to know that the GI map test detects the presence of DNA, [snorts] 14:02 not necessarily active infection or clinical pathology. 14:07 So, just because an organism is detected does not mean that that's what's causing
GI-MAP Stool Testing 14:11 symptoms. Many bacteria show up as quote unquote 14:15 abnormal on these reports in healthy and asymptomatic people. Another major 14:20 misconception that I want to really address here is the idea that knowing 14:24 your specific microbiome makeup tells us which probiotics you should take right 14:29 now. This is just simply not how it works. 14:32 Even though the GI map can give us a snapshot of your microbiome, we do not 14:36 have evidence yet that choosing a specific probiotic strain based on the 14:41 microbiome leads to better clinical outcomes. 14:45 Maybe in the future we'll get there, but at this point, seeing low levels of a 14:49 particular organism does not mean that you need to replace it with a probiotic. 14:54 And seeing high levels also does not automatically mean that you need to 14:57 eradicate it. The GI map test is helpful for looking at broader patterns. And 15:02 those patterns allow us to act more like detectives. They can help us point 15:06 toward potential root causes like chronic stress, prior infections, 15:11 medication effects, diet patterns, motility issues, or immune dysfunction 15:16 that may be shaping the gut environment in the first place. 15:20 So, we're not trying to micromanage the microbiome. We just want to understand 15:24 it a little bit better. So, I use it selectively when there's a clear 15:28 clinical question and when the results will meaningfully influence management. 15:32 In many cases though, I'll actually start with mindbody approaches for gut 15:36 dysfunction like gut- directed hypnotherapy before jumping straight 15:40 into a stool test. We'll do a whole episode on this later, but even modern 15:44 medicine now classifies IBS as a functional gastrointestinal disorder, 15:49 meaning there's a strong mindbody connection. And treatments like therapy 15:54 and gut-directed hypnotherapy are now actually included in clinical 15:58 guidelines, which I think is a big shift from how IBS was approached even a 16:02 decade ago. Next, let's talk about organic acids testing, often abbreviated 16:07 as oats. So, the organic acid test is a urine based test that looks at a wide 16:11 range of metabolic byproducts, which are small molecules produced as the body 16:16 breaks down nutrients, neurotransmitters, and energy 16:19 substrates. These markers give us indirect 16:22 information about things like mitochondrial function, nutrient status, 16:27 oxidative stress, neurotransmitter metabolism, and overall metabolic 16:32 efficiency. This test is very different from traditional labs. It's not 16:36 diagnosing disease and it's not telling us that someone definitely has a 16:41 deficiency or disorder. Instead, it offers a functional snapshot of 16:46 metabolism. So, how efficiently certain biochemical 16:49 pathways may be working and where there may be increased demand or stress. One 16:55 way I often explain this to my physician colleagues is by comparing it to how we 16:58 use homocyine. So, homoyine is not a direct measurement 17:02 of B12 or folate levels. So in a sense it actually is a functional marker. When
Organic Acids Testing 17:08 homoyine is elevated it suggests impaired methylation or increased demand 17:12 for the B vitamins even when serum or blood B12 levels appear normal. So the 17:18 organic acid testing works on a very similar principle but much broader gives 17:23 you a lot of numbers. Instead of looking at one functional marker tied to one 17:26 pathway, the OAT test looks at many functional markers across multiple 17:30 metabolic pathways at once. So that makes it really comprehensive but also 17:35 pretty complex to interpret. I find this test most helpful in patients with 17:39 chronic and non-specific symptoms that we haven't been able to figure out 17:42 what's going on. So things like chronic fatigue, brain fog, low energy, exercise 17:48 intolerance, or even neurocognitive symptoms when basic labs, imaging, and 17:53 standard workups are all normal. So this test can sometimes highlight patterns 17:56 that suggest mitochondrial stress, increased oxidative burden, or higher 18:01 demand for certain micronutrients involved in energy metabolism. 18:06 So that information can help us guide more targeted lifestyle interventions 18:10 like nutrition. We always start with nutrition and supplementation, but I 18:15 always try to optimize those lifestyle interventions before recommending a 18:18 specific tester or supplement. Moreover, because the markers on the organic acid 18:22 tests are indirect, they are influenced by diet, recent activity, gut function, 18:28 medications, and actually timing of the sample as well. So, we really need to 18:32 keep all that in mind when we interpret. So, those are just a few functional 18:36 medicine tests that I do use in my practice. Last, I do want to talk about 18:40 two categories of functional medicine tests that I usually don't recommend, 18:45 and those are mold testing, such as urine microtoxin panels, and broader 18:49 environmental toxin testing like microplastics or chemical exposure 18:53 panels. Now, this is not because I don't think 18:57 that mold or environmental toxins impact people. I actually do think that they 19:01 do. There is nuance which we can definitely dive into a separate podcast 19:05 about particularly with mold toxicity or candidada where I see people claiming it 19:10 as the root cause of a lot of things. Um but we'll get back to that another 19:15 episode. But with these tests, it's not that I don't think that mold or 19:20 environmental toxins are real. It's because the results of these particular 19:24 tests don't change how I treat patients. So let me explain a little bit further. 19:31 When we expect a mold or environmental toxin exposure is suspected and we 19:36 suspect that it's causing dysfunction or symptoms, the core interventions are 19:41 largely the same regardless of which specific mold or toxin shows up on the 19:46 test. So, it's going to be first and foremost 19:49 removing the source of exposure. After that, treatment typically focuses on 19:54 supporting the body's natural detox systems like sweating with saunas,
Mold and Environmental Toxin Testing 19:59 optimizing hydration, sleep support, nutrition, and sometimes targeted 20:05 supplements, but again, there's not one specific supplement for one specific 20:09 mold or toxin. So, my recommendations don't change dramatically based off 20:14 whether a specific micotoxin or chemical shows up. So because of that, I find 20:19 that this test often just adds cost and complexity without adding actionable 20:24 value. In my practice, I usually start by asking detailed questions about 20:28 exposures. So things like water damage or visible mold in the home, 20:33 occupational exposures, building environments, chemical sensitivities, 20:38 and symptom patterns that correlate with these certain spaces. But I will say 20:43 these tests aren't entirely useless. I think there are situations where mold or 20:48 environmental toxin testing can be helpful. 20:51 For some patients, having objective data can validate their experience and 20:55 confirm that exposure may be contributing to their symptoms. And in 20:59 rare cases, identifying a specific toxin can help patients be more precise about 21:04 where they need to focus eliminating. for example, identifying a particular 21:09 building that's contributing to ongoing exposures or removing specific 21:13 microplastics from the home. But I will admit getting to that point is pretty 21:17 rare. More often I see patients undergo extensive and expensive testing only to 21:23 end up with a result that confirms what we already suspected and without 21:27 offering a clearer or more effective treatment path. I do have many patients 21:31 that have undergone this testing and then were recommended extensive 21:35 supplement protocols to get rid of those specific toxins, but the truth is that 21:39 they don't end up feeling better and there's not a lot of evidence for these 21:43 protocols. But again, we won't get into that now. We can do a separate episode 21:47 all about that. So, in summary, I'm not denying the impact of mold or 21:51 environmental toxins. I'm just being honest about what these tests can and 21:54 cannot do, at least in my practice. When my treatment approach is largely the 21:59 same regardless of the results, I'm much more likely to focus on exposure 22:03 history, prevention, and foundational support rather than expensive testing. 22:07 So, with all that, to close out this episode, I want to bring it back to the 22:11 bigger picture. Functional medicine testing isn't inherently good or bad. 22:16 It's merely just another tool in the toolbox. And like any tool in medicine, 22:21 its value really depends on when it's used, why it's used, and how it's 22:26 interpreted. So more testing doesn't automatically lead to better care. And 22:31 fewer tests doesn't automatically mean that something is being missed. 22:35 Integrative medicine is about using the right tools with intention and restraint 22:40 and always guided by clinical reasoning and the whole person in front of us. 22:46 Thanks for listening to the trip lab. If you liked this episode, please subscribe
Closing Thoughts 22:50 and share so we can get the conversation started about integrative medicine and 22:55 psychedelics to destigmatize it and fully explore what this could mean in 22:59 the world. [music]
Comments