Full Transcript Introduction to Gut Immune Tolerance 0:00 What our next discussion we're going to be talking about all things. 0:03 Gut immune tolerance. 0:06 How to build a resilient gut. 0:08 And you help me do that is my good friend Kiran Krishnan. 0:11 Kiran is a research microbiologist and a health and wellness expert 0:13 who aims to make complex information understandable to all. 0:17 He has founded a number of successful health and supplement companies 0:20 over the last 20 years, 0:21 including co-founding and leading Microbiome Labs, the preeminent 0:24 microbiome therapeutics focused brand among health care professionals. 0:28 He's currently a co-founder and partner in three other companies 0:31 that aim to revolutionize wellness care. 0:33 He has conducted and published several research studies in scientific journals. 0:37 He has published chapters in scientific textbooks, reference books, has global 0:41 patents, and is a sought after speaker on human health and the microbiome. 0:45 And he's kind of my go to when it comes to gut health. 0:47 So, Kiran, welcome. 0:49 Thank you Jason, it's great to be here with you. 0:51 So we were just kind of chatting a little bit beforehand about some of the 0:54 things that we're finding in the health and wellness, in the food spaces 0:58 and kind of this crazy place we're in where 1:02 we have various perspectives on food. 1:04 And there's just seemed to be this mass confusion 1:08 about aspects of food, components of food, what's good, what's bad. 1:13 And I really feel for our audience out there because the messaging 1:16 is just all over the place. 1:17 And and one of the things that you, you kind of brought up 1:20 was this idea of fiber and how this is being attacked now. 1:23 And generally what I see when it comes to something, 1:27 whether it's, you know, Fitbits and lectins and fiber 1:31 and sugars and what had there's a grain of truth, forgive the pun. 1:35 I guess there's an element of truth in there, 1:37 but it gets mixed up in this just sweet of misinformation, ignorance, 1:44 and just like a lack of real understanding of the mechanisms and how 1:47 the body works. And so 1:49 maybe just 1:50 give me your perspective on just kind of what I just said, just generally speaking,
Food Confusion and the Fiber Debate 1:54 how are you seeing all these things that that we're attacking saturated fats 1:57 and then we're attacking seed oils and there's like all this stuff out there. 2:00 What's your take and how do you process all that? 2:03 Yeah, it's it's it's a really, really difficult area 2:06 to navigate for consumers just because they don't have 2:09 the background in these things and they hear people that they 2:12 that they respect and believe having one extreme view of the other. 2:16 And I think part of the problem 2:17 is that the pendulum just kind of swings too far on both ends. 2:21 Right? And it's over corrections of things. 2:25 Saturated fat has probably been unjustly demonized to a certain degree. 2:29 There are still some actual problems with saturated fat for certain people, 2:33 but then the then the the pendulum swings all the other way 2:36 where it's like plants have anti nutrients and this, that and the other. 2:40 And so plants will kill you. Right. 2:42 And so people go nuts and they lose their mind. 2:44 So if we take something like fight tapes 2:46 for example like phytic acid which you hear a lot about like 2:49 oh this phytic acid and it and it chelating minerals. 2:52 And so if you eat plants that are phytic acid in it, 2:55 it's going to pull minerals off your bone. 2:57 Well that that does not happen in humans, right. 3:01 There's no connection at all. 3:03 Like maybe you can take in a petri dish. 3:06 You can put a bunch of calcium or something in the petri dish and throw 3:09 some phytic acid in there and then see it coagulating or chelating, if you will. 3:14 But that doesn't happen in the human body, right? 3:17 The phytic acid has no chance 3:18 of pulling minerals off your bone, because bone resorption, 3:21 which is the process of releasing minerals in the bone, is a very 3:25 controlled process and there are lots of different cells involved in it. 3:29 So it makes sense, right? 3:30 Like that's a pretty important thing. 3:32 It's a pretty important. 3:33 Like how vulnerable would we be as a species 3:36 if our ancestors are walking around and they're just eating whatever 3:39 they could and some things are eating are just sucking minerals 3:42 through bone, right? 3:44 And then they're just like falling apart and dying, and they just keep eating them 3:47 and keep eating them for thousands of years, you know, exactly. 3:50 Without learning a thing. 3:51 Right. 3:51 And so, 3:52 so yeah, I think people just have to use a little bit of logic in some of this 3:56 and go, wait, some of these things have been around for thousands of years. 3:59 We've been consuming it were omnivorous. 4:02 We eat lots of different things, and that's the basis of our diet. 4:06 Then you look at literature and you look at the studies. 4:09 And the studies that are important are outcome studies, right? 4:11 Mechanistic studies and all that are interesting 4:14 to look at to understand how some cellular processes work. 4:18 But when you think about diet, 4:19 you really have to look at longitudinal and outcome studies. 4:23 The diet that is that is the most well studied with, 4:27 with some of the best outcomes is the Mediterranean style diet, 4:31 you know, and that's a very balanced, you know, quite diverse diet. 4:34 It's got good fats. 4:36 It's got fruits and vegetables and lots of polyphenols 4:39 and all of the things nuts and seeds and so on. Right. 4:42 And that's the ideal situation. 4:44 So if you are extreme then you are off the charts on on 4:48 what is what is determined by the research to be normal. 4:52 Let's tackle fiber for a moment. 4:54 I mean, I see too many carnivore people, you know, on this saying, not only do 4:58 you not need fiber, but meat can increase diversity of the microbiome, 5:04 and that fiber is unnecessary and can be harmful and so on. It. 5:08 I've seen it with a lot of people claiming that that it irritates this, 5:12 this irritable bowel. Right. 5:13 Like it creates inflammation. 5:15 And again, I think, okay, 5:16 maybe a grain of truth in that for some people in certain circumstances. 5:20 But we can't just blanket statement say okay, because that might 5:22 cause irritation in some people with certain conditions. 5:26 Right. You already a dysfunction going on. 5:29 Then we can just apply that to to the ballot. 5:32 Totally. 5:32 It's it's no different than like, hey, weightlifting is great right? 5:36 Like go and do deadlifts and squats. 5:39 That's fantastic for you. 5:40 But if you're if you have two slipped discs, 5:45 including so for that person. 5:47 So it's a deadlift is not a good idea right. 5:50 So then you can't go well for that person it's not a good idea. 5:53 So squats and deadlifts are bad overall right. 5:55 That's and I'll be I'll even get more nuance with that too. 5:58 Like there's a genetic component where some people's, you know, certain 6:01 parts of their legs are longer. 6:02 They they break, etc.. 6:04 And so for some people, actually squat may not be the ideal lift 6:09 because of the way their body is structured in shape. 6:11 And so this is likened to food where it's like 6:14 we have genetic differences, we have uniqueness, 6:17 we have a constitution kind of going back to Ayurveda and Chinese medicine. 6:21 And so and we're now doing this with, you know, the DNA company 6:24 and various other, 6:26 you know, genetic testing out there that we can start to tell, okay,
Why Fiber Matters for Longevity 6:29 this person doesn't digest saturated fats is what this person does better. 6:32 Right. 6:33 There's all these little nuances where genetics come into play. 6:36 Totally. Yeah, absolutely. 6:37 And and just addressing the fiber issue. Right. 6:39 So fiber is probably the most well-studied 6:43 macronutrient there is as a as a great example of that. 6:47 Right. So it's also quite sad because it's easy to study. 6:49 Or why do you think that is. 6:52 I think that is because you can 6:56 you can quantify fiber 6:59 intake easier than you can quantify protein. 7:02 And fat intake. 7:03 I think people because fiber sources are somewhat limited 7:07 and, and different cultures consume them at different, at different levels. 7:12 And also when, when you have certain studies that show real great promise, 7:19 in terms of the effect of a nutrient, whatever it may be. 7:22 Then it's easier to get grants to study that and then further. 7:27 Right. 7:27 That's probably the biggest reason for it. 7:30 It's no different than why we have, you know, 8000 studies, vitamin D, 7:34 because as early studies started coming out, that vitamin D intake is beneficial 7:40 when when researchers are starting right, grants grant offices are much more likely 7:44 to give them money because they're like, yes, 7:46 this is a really interesting scaling topic. 7:50 We want to learn more about it. 7:51 And so it's easier to get grant money to do that. 7:54 And so, you know, so so here's the latest meta analysis on it. 7:58 Right. 7:58 So we're talking about a 2019 published meta analysis 8:01 that looked at roughly 180, 8:05 almost 200 published studies on fiber intake. 8:09 And this had a wide variety of the types of studies 8:12 interventional studies, longitudinal studies, and so on. 8:16 And is this soluble and insoluble fiber? 8:19 It is. Yeah. So it's a total intake of fiber. 8:21 I think the typical average intake of fiber 8:25 is around 70% time, about 30% insoluble. 8:28 But if it's 5050, it doesn't really make a huge difference. 8:32 But but predominantly soluble fiber. 8:34 And that's the fiber that most people inadvertently even consume anyway. 8:39 And so what they found and the total number of person visits. 8:43 Right. 8:43 This is an important number, because when you look at how strong is 8:48 the cohort of data in any given meta analysis, you want to look at either 8:52 number of person years, which makes up the data or person visits. 8:56 Right. 8:56 So among all of the studies, how many visits were there 9:00 to the lab getting the bloodwork and looking at all different things? 9:03 In this case, it was 153 million person visit. 9:08 Wow. Right. 9:09 So same massive cohort mass report right. 9:12 So here's what they showed. 9:13 They showed that for every ten grams of fiber that you add to your daily diet, 9:19 you reduce your all cause mortality that's dying from any disease by 10%. 9:24 And that was up to almost 45g. 9:28 So you could go from the standard American diet of inadvertent eight grams 9:32 ish of fiber and take down your your risk of all cause mortality 9:37 to 45% less by just getting yourself to 45g of fiber. 9:43 Right. 9:43 If that was a if that was a compound, you know, if 9:46 I discovered a compound and I came out and said, hey, I got a compound 9:50 that can cut your risk of dying from anything by 45%, right? 9:55 Number one, the first question people would ask is, well, that's a huge claim. 9:59 So you must have huge data to support that. 10:01 And I go, yeah, I am doing 200 studies, you know, 153 million person visits. 10:06 Oh, okay. Great. 10:07 What is this miracle compound and why isn't it $1 trillion product? 10:11 Well, it's fiber, you know, and it's it's just so fascinating to me 10:16 that that kind of level of data is ignored. 10:20 And then people pick on small things like phytic acid and, 10:24 you know, these little compounds that from some mechanistic 10:27 study might show something is so it's it's mind boggling. 10:31 It's I think it's disingenuous. 10:33 And it does a disservice to people in general. 10:36 Yeah. No, even the funny. 10:38 Right. 10:38 Like we are really, really funny creatures. 10:40 Like, I've really discovered this 10:41 in the sort of the health field, right, between the integrative practitioners. 10:45 I know between the clients and patients that I've seen. 10:47 It's like we're just really funny. 10:49 You know, it kind of reminds me, you know, what you're saying 10:51 from like of walking, right? 10:53 Walking is like the most boring thing to study. 10:55 It's the most rewarding thing to think about for many people, 10:58 there's no way to debate, like the form of a walk and how you do it. 11:02 Right. It's just it's just a walk. 11:04 And yeah, this is the thing that leads that same thing 11:07 all cause mortality, longevity, health and well-being, walking. 11:11 And it's just so simple. 11:12 And and we know the data 7000 to 10,000, 7000 like the 11:16 the nice sort of like sweet spot that is. 11:18 And if you get more than 7000 steps in the day, 11:21 it's like all these benefit to it. 11:22 I know we we debate those high intensity interval 11:25 training or is it a Tabata workout or is it like this in UK? 11:29 Yeah, those are good to you know, they have their place
Soluble vs Insoluble Fiber and Practical Intake 11:32 and like stick to the basics and it seems like. 11:35 Well and people will spend, 11:37 you know ungodly amounts of money on getting themselves a cold plunge system 11:41 and the sauna and that red light and all that, and that's great. 11:44 You know, by all means, do those things, but don't do them in 11:48 lieu of the basics of just walking, you know, and it's so simple. 11:53 And the data on walking is way stronger than any of those other things 11:57 and those the historical context of it. 11:59 Right? Yeah. 12:00 And that's the easy part to for people to kind of wrap the head around. 12:03 Right. 12:04 Like, what have we been doing historically and thereby what has our system adapted 12:09 to requiring or working with in some way. 12:13 Right. 12:13 So so again, you know, not like all the biohacking in the world. 12:17 You want to do perfectly fine. 12:18 I have no issue with that. 12:19 And I love saunas and I do some, some of the same fights. 12:22 Oh right. Yeah. Totally. 12:24 But but anytime someone is knocking some of the basics, 12:29 I think you have to be really suspicious of what they, what they have to say. 12:33 So let's get into some of the nuance with fiber. 12:35 Right. Because again we mentioned insoluble. Insoluble. 12:37 Maybe we can talk about the differences there. 12:39 You know we have something like Metamucil right. 12:42 So if I hear oh fiber, I'm 12:43 just gonna take Metamucil or I'm gonna take psyllium husk or, or 12:46 I just stick to this sort of one strategy or philosophy when it comes to fiber, 12:51 you know, is that going to be different than, you know, eating leek and, you know, 12:55 green beans and you know, of wide variety of plant sources of fiber. 13:01 How should I think about that? 13:02 And then maybe you can work in and we'll kind of 13:04 maybe after that we'll wander into the territory of, of loss of immune tolerance 13:08 because I can maybe hear somebody, some people listening to this already and 13:12 saying, well, I try to eat this one food that has tons of fiber. 13:15 It's a healthy food, you know? 13:16 I mean, not many people complain about the cucumbers, isn't it? 13:19 Like they're not saying it's a it's an unhealthy food. 13:21 And yet there are I've met people 13:23 that they cannot eat a cucumber without, you know, having dramatic symptoms. 13:26 And so this is the case actually with a lot of plants in the vegetable 13:30 family, is that people will eat them and they say it just absolutely wrecks me. 13:34 Like there's just no way I can eat that. 13:36 So how can I argue and benefit? 13:37 You know, why is something so healthy that contains so much fiber 13:41 just absolutely wrecking me? 13:42 So we'll get maybe we even get to that toward the end. 13:44 But what's the difference in soluble soluble. 13:46 Now how do we think about these things. 13:48 Where are where do we run into some some danger or threat. 13:51 Right. Potentially. Where do they have it. Right. 13:53 When they say fiber you got to be careful with it. 13:55 Yeah. 13:56 Well yeah that's that's a really important thing to address. 13:58 So I think a couple areas. 14:00 Number one so with with fiber as important as it is I think you want to 14:05 you want to be measured in in ensuring you're getting adequate amounts. 14:10 Right. 14:10 And what are adequate amounts. 14:12 While I go to 40 to 50g a day. 14:15 Because I know up to that point it's a linear, a reduction in all cause mortality 14:20 after the 40, 40, 45 to 50g, it the line starts 14:24 to flatten out in terms of its impact on all cause mortality, 14:28 meaning that there's probably some degree of diminishing return. 14:32 So I don't see the need to go beyond 50g. 14:34 There are days where I eat more than that, 14:36 but that's my goal is to get to that point now. 14:39 And one piece of advice here about just people think, oh, 50g, 14:43 how do I measure that? Right. 14:44 And what I've learned with this is like whenever it comes to protein 14:47 or fats or sugars or whatever, I'm trying to like gauge 14:50 is that there's like general like a what I take is like a week and it's okay. 14:53 I look at the content of a potato and whatever. 14:56 I'm like, okay, so I get a rough estimate. 14:58 I don't know either. 14:58 Like, you know, so so you just kind of take 15:00 that little study period and you go, okay, this is what I'm getting. 15:03 And then you just have a loose feel, right? 15:05 Like, I'm sure you're not every day counting and measuring and track 15:08 and spreadsheet thing and. Right. 15:10 So you just get it. 15:11 You wait for for most people, it just takes up a little bit of like what 15:15 these foods contain. 15:15 And then getting a sort of sense. 15:18 Yeah. 15:18 And I mean, you can use ChatGPT and I, I totally so it's oh easy these days. 15:23 So the way I do it is and you shouldn't go from your normal 15:27 standard American diet of eight grams per day to 40g. 15:30 The next day. Right. You want to taper it up? 15:32 My my recommendation is usually adding somewhere around 15:36 4 to 5g for each day for a week. 15:39 So meaning that if I'm getting ten grams this a day 15:43 regularly, then for the next week I'm doing 15g. 15:46 You know, seven days. 15:47 Let my body get used to managing the fiber and utilizing it properly. 15:51 Then the next week I'm getting 20g a day, then 25, and so on. 15:54 The way I do it, because I want to ensure that I'm reaching my goals, is 16:00 I did exactly what you suggested, which is I took about a week's worth of eating 16:04 and looked at some of the common things I eat. 16:06 The tend to have fiber in it, so I eat a good amount of nuts and seeds. 16:10 I eat a lot of like broccoli, you know, beans. 16:13 So I just looked at a few things that I eat 16:15 and I, and I gauged with the help of ChatGPT 16:19 approximately how much fiber is 16:22 in my standard bowl like that I have at home, like, 16:25 you know, and you can actually just scan or take a picture of it 16:28 and then upload it to chat and ask it to, assume how much fibers in it. Wow. 16:33 It can absolutely do that. 16:35 And it's and it's in your ballpark. 16:36 Right. Like that's the main ballpark. Yeah. 16:38 And keep in mind that the studies when you look at those studies and that 16:41 many, you know, that many person visits and that large scale of a cohort, 16:45 they're not measuring this stuff like precisely. 16:48 It's all rough, right? 16:49 It's possible -15, 20% here and there. 16:52 It's about the consistency and the cumulative effect of doing it over time. 16:57 That's really where the big benefit comes from. 16:59 So if you're like 28g one day 17:02 and 40g the next day and 30g, it doesn't matter. 17:06 You're getting it in and you're accumulating the benefit. 17:09 There. 17:09 So so I averaged out and to me it was about 17:14 I'm getting about 20, 25g a day from just the regular stuff. 17:18 I eat. 17:19 And so what I decided is that, okay, I'm going to then supplement 20g a day 17:25 so that between what I normally eat and the supplementing, I know I'm
Understanding Immune Tolerance in the Gut 17:28 getting around 4045 some days a tire, some days it's a lot less. 17:32 And the way I supplement 17:33 and this has another benefit is even just basic psyllium husk. 17:37 And I look for fiber products that may have a small variety of fiber. 17:42 Maybe it has some acacia fiber in it, some inulin, some psyllium husk. 17:46 Right. But the easiest thing is psyllium husk. 17:48 And I use the organic India version of it because it's just super clean. 17:52 It's there's nothing else in it but psyllium husk. Right. 17:55 And I do about ten grams of it in water before meal. 17:58 Drink it down. 17:59 It's not a great experience because there's no flavor 18:01 or anything to it, but you just drink it down 18:04 and you do that about 10 to 15 minutes before you eat, and then you eat. 18:07 Now the other side benefit of that is it acts like a GLP one agonist, right? 18:12 It slows down gastric emptying and made to eat less food. 18:16 It slows down and blunts the glucose response, 18:18 which I actually tested on myself for a three week 18:21 period that I had a CGM, a continuous glucose monitor. 18:25 I looked at all these foods and I looked at like taking fiber before the food, 18:30 taking fiber after the food. 18:31 And I would do like, you know, even something as is insulin 18:34 genic as like for me, bananas actually very insulin genic. 18:37 Even more so than like a donut can be. 18:40 And so I started using bananas and I would take like ten grams of fiber 18:45 before the banana or, and then another time do it without the fiber. 18:49 And you'd see like I would want the glucose. 18:52 The glucose response is like 40, 50%, right 18:55 dramatically just from taking the ten grams of fiber. 18:58 So I know that I'm fighting against insulin resistance. 19:01 I'm improving my metabolic health. 19:03 So it has all of those benefits, along with the fiber going down 19:07 and then feeding the microbes in the in the large bowel 19:10 and then them converting it to really important compounds 19:14 that my body needs to fix and repair things, you know, and maintain structures, 19:19 especially the barrier system and also immune cells needing it. 19:24 Right. And and fiber. 19:27 We'll talk about why. 19:28 But fiber plays a very important role in the next thing we want to talk about 19:32 which is immune tolerance. Right. 19:34 And the loss of immune tolerance. 19:36 And I actually just just produced a white paper on this because 19:39 we're developing some products to really look at, 19:43 revamping immune tolerance, because it's becoming clear that 19:48 loss of immune tolerance is at the root 19:51 of so many chronic conditions. 19:54 Right. 19:55 And not only because your immune system is now inadvertently attacking things 19:59 it shouldn't attack. 20:00 Yeah. 20:00 And also, maybe you can just define immune tolerance 20:03 for for the issue, which maybe aren't quite familiar with what that is. 20:06 Sure. Yeah. 20:07 And just the, the way to really understand immune tolerance. 20:09 Is this your immune system is of course, 20:11 the only system in your body designed to defend you. 20:15 Right? That's a defensive system. 20:18 Your immune cells are born out of your bone marrow or your thymus. 20:22 Those are the two parts of your body that produce immune cells. 20:24 Now, when immune cells are born, 20:26 they're born with capabilities but not with any knowledge. 20:30 Right. 20:30 Your immune system is a very important system 20:33 that needs to learn how to adapt to your environment, 20:36 because everyone has different things that their immune system 20:40 needs to defend them against. Right? 20:41 You are all the way in the West Coast. I'm in the Midwest. 20:44 We actually have different antigens. 20:46 We have different viruses. 20:47 We have different things that could harm us 20:49 even in the same country, just being a couple thousand miles apart. 20:53 And so your immune system has to adapt to your environment. 20:55 My moon system has adapt to my environment. 20:58 That's why biologically, the immune system is designed to not have 21:02 any sort of ingrained or inbred memory as to what's bad and good. 21:08 It's supposed to learn on the fly, right? 21:11 If I get up right now and I moved to India, it's going 21:14 to have to adapt to that crazy environment compared to this crazy environment. 21:18 Right. 21:19 And so how does it do that? 21:20 So it's born with capabilities. 21:22 The analogy I give is like imagine your immune system is an army 21:26 that has all the tanks, 21:27 all the missiles, all the guns, all the helicopters, everything it needs. 21:30 But it has no general and has no plans. 21:33 It doesn't know who the enemy is. 21:35 What's a no strategy at all, right? 21:37 It doesn't know where the borders are. 21:38 It doesn't know what's good and bad. 21:40 It just is ready to go. 21:41 It needs instructions the way we've developed is the immune 21:46 system gets its instructions largely from the microbiome. 21:50 The microbiome is the outward facing component of the immune system, right. 21:55 So the microbiome is sitting in the mucosal tissue 21:58 most of the inside part of your body, most of your orifices are all lined 22:03 with the mucosa in that this would be like military intelligence, right. 22:06 It's like the first people to get information 22:09 and then relay that down to the ones that are actually going to take action. 22:12 Yeah, exactly. 22:13 It's it's 22:14 the it's you're like first line of defense are some of them can fight for you. 22:19 Many of them don't. 22:20 Some of them are just like like you said like informants if you. 22:23 Well. Right. 22:24 So imagine you had a neighborhood watch. 22:26 That's that's often the analogy I use. 22:28 Like your, your, 22:29 your microbiome is the neighborhood watch, meaning they're all 22:32 watching out the windows and keep an eye on what's happening in the neighborhood. 22:36 And then they will signal to the cops 22:38 or the military when something bad is going on. 22:41 And in fact, the, the, the immune system 22:44 understand what to attack and what not to attack, right? 22:48 So a loss of immune tolerance means 22:51 that that relationship and the tutoring and the communication 22:55 between the immune system and the microbiome is disrupted. 22:59 And as a result, the immune system goes a little bit haywire and it attacks 23:03 all the things it shouldn't attack. 23:04 And that would be food particles, environmental antigens, 23:08 of course, your own tissue in the case of autoimmune conditions. 23:11 So it's going haywire. 23:13 And and it tends to upregulate inflammatory mechanisms. 23:18 Right. And I can explain that for a little bit. 23:20 Now let's maybe let's get into how your immune system samples the environment 23:26 and how it does so in the context of the microbiome. 23:29 Right. 23:30 So you've got let's and let's take the gut because that's the largest site 23:33 of sampling in your body. 23:34 And I think most people listening have heard this term like 23:38 most of your immune system is in your gut. Right. 23:40 But what does that actually mean. 23:42 Well, that means that about 70, 80% of your immune sampling 23:47 tissue is in your gut. 23:49 That and there's a good reason for that, because most things you encounter 23:53 in your environment are going to end up in your gut in one way or the other. 23:56 But if I'm walking around and I breathe in a virus, a cold virus that's out 24:01 there, right, the virus is going to go into my upper respiratory tract. 24:04 It's going to get trapped in the mucus in my upper respiratory tract, 24:08 and then that mucus is 24:09 going to get sloughed off by something called a mucus elevator. 24:13 And then it's going to push it down to the back of my throat. 24:15 And I'm going to swallow it. 24:17 So that virus with the mucus is going to end up in my gut. 24:19 If things going through your eyes, your ears, all of that drains 24:23 to the back of your throat, through your Eustachian tube, right? 24:26 So everything virtually, unless it's trauma and penetrates 24:29 through your skin, is essentially going into your gut. 24:32 Of course, the biggest introduction of foreign materials into your body 24:36 comes from food and drink. 24:37 And so all of that, of course, is going to your gut. 24:40 So your body's designed to have the largest immune sampling site in your gut. 24:45 So the way that structure is, is set up is you've got this mucus layer 24:50 in the mucus layer, you've got all the microbes living. 24:53 And then that mucus layer has a certain thickness to it. 24:56 And the bottom part in the mucus layer has very few microbes in it. 25:00 Right. 25:00 Most of the microbes live in the top part of the mucus layer. 25:03 That mucus layer in the small intestine sits on top of what we call 25:07 the intestinal epithelial cells. 25:09 These are the single cell layer cells kind of sitting shoulder to shoulder that 25:13 that form the final barrier before things enter your actual circulation. 25:18 Right in the first part of the circulation is what we call the interior 25:21 circulation, where things, most of the things 25:24 actually go to the liver, but from there they're going to go throughout the body. 25:27 So so you have to imagine this is our barrier. 25:29 This is our gate system. Right? 25:31 So if the body is a fort, this is the walls of the fort. 25:35 And sitting on top of the walls of the fort, which is the top of the mucus 25:39 layer, are the are the informants are the neighborhood watch. 25:43 Right. They're sitting then watching what's coming in. 25:45 So they're sitting up there now the the first and the most active 25:50 immune cells that are constantly sampling things are cells called dendritic cells. 25:55 Now, the reason they're called dendritic cells is because they have these dendrites 25:59 which look like little tentacles that can extend. 26:01 Right. So you've got the the cells the Intel. 26:04 So until your cells sitting shoulder to shoulder on top of 26:08 that is a mucus layer in the mucus layer of the microbes. 26:11 And everything that comes into your body 26:13 comes into that mucus layer with the microbes there. 26:16 The dendritic cells are actually on the other side of the intestinal epithelium, 26:20 but they're a little dendrites can sneak in between your intestinal 26:23 epithelial cells and go into the mucus and start sampling things. 26:27 Right. 26:28 So it's sampling like, oh, what is that? 26:30 That's a food antigen. 26:31 No, that's an environmental particle. That's a bacteria. 26:34 That's a virus. 26:35 Right now while it's sampling things the commensal around it 26:40 are activating certain receptors called toll like receptors. 26:45 When they activate toll like receptors 26:48 and kind of present antigens to the dendritic cells, 26:52 the dendritic cells know that those antigens are pollen antigens. 26:57 We don't need to attack it. Right. 26:58 So they're getting that signal from the microbiome. 27:02 The microbiome is sitting next to let's say a peanut protein that comes in right. 27:06 And the dendritic cell is sampling the peanut protein. 27:09 The microbiome is essentially going, hey, you don't have to attack that, right. 27:13 So we need to build tolerance against that. 27:15 So the dendritic cell learns that. 27:17 It then goes and activates T cells. 27:21 And then it activates 27:22 T cells to say hey T cells we need to tolerate this peanut protein. 27:26 So the immune system needs to learn about this. 27:29 Well how does it teach the rest of the immune system anyway? 27:32 You see peanut protein don't attack it is that T cell then goes and activates 27:36 a B cell that makes an antibody against that. 27:40 That protein and that antibody typically is called IGA, right. 27:45 It's not an IGA or IgG E, which is a hypersensitivity response. 27:50 It's a IGA antibody. 27:52 Then that antibody secreted into the mucosa. 27:55 And then anywhere that that peanut protein is seen, 27:58 it might bind to it and kind of neutralize it. 28:00 But the peanut protein bound with an antibody indicates 28:04 the immune system that, hey, this thing is tolerant. 28:07 We don't need to attack it, right? 28:09 But that's that whole process basically happens with food borne 28:12 antigens, with environmental articles, with bacteria, viruses and all of that 28:17 that the microbiome struck at the microbiome teaches the immune system 28:21 not to attack. Right. 28:23 So then you look at what happens when you lose immune tolerance. 28:26 So so here's what happens. 28:27 And that's also how you produce lots of secretory IGA. 28:30 Right. 28:31 Which is really important because secretory IGA 28:33 acts as like the first line of defense in all your secretory fluid. 28:37 So anything that's coming in, it's just binding and neutralizing
How Loss of Tolerance Drives Inflammation 28:40 and teaching the immune system up. This stuff is neutralized. 28:43 Don't worry about it. You don't have to attack it. 28:45 And when IGA binds to something, it doesn't elicit inflammatory response. 28:50 It elicits a tolerance response. 28:52 Now. And that's one of the things that we can test too. 28:54 It's it's often a really good test and a good test 28:56 because if it's if it's low, will we get a problem? 28:58 Like that's not good. 28:59 We need the body to be using, you know, stigma or secretory IGA 29:03 if it's really high. 29:05 That also indicates that that's a good sign. 29:07 The body's producing it, but it indicates dysfunction. 29:09 There's something going on. 29:10 There's an alarm bells going off that we're producing a lot of this stuff. 29:13 So something something's happening that we need to be aware of. Right. 29:16 So yeah, it's 29:17 really like those, those two extremes that indicate something's actually off. 29:22 Totally. Yeah. 29:23 And it's a great marker because it's a marker of like your body's 29:26 immune system functioning the way it should. 29:28 And there is another player in that whole game, 29:31 which I didn't mention is something called a regulatory T cells. 29:35 The regulatory T cells are the T cells that monitor this whole interaction. 29:39 And and as long as this tolerant response is happening, it's happy. 29:43 And it's just sitting there monitoring it right now, let's say, 29:47 you know one of your dendritic cells kind of goes haywire. 29:50 Doesn't get the right communication from the from the microbiome 29:54 and takes that peanut protein and goes, oh, this is an enemy 29:57 and presents it to the T cell, the the helper T cell as an enemy 30:01 to get the helper T cell to elicit an immune response against, then 30:05 that regulatory T cell comes along and goes, 30:07 no, no, no, no, no, you messed up right. 30:09 That's not a enemy. 30:11 You need to dampen that down. 30:12 Now, that whole process is so important 30:16 that that was the Nobel Prize in medicine in 2025. 30:21 The discovery of the regulatory T cell and its mechanisms 30:26 was awarded to three individuals who played a significant role 30:29 in discovering that over the last ten years. 30:32 And that was the Nobel Prize in Medicine this year, which is fascinating. 30:36 That's how important it is. Right. 30:37 And so and the microbiome is at the core of that whole mechanism. 30:43 So let's say you've got a dysfunctional microbiome. 30:45 You've had poor lifestyle choices, antibiotics, whatever it may be. 30:48 Your dendritic cells are still 30:49 they're sampling right with their little dendrites everywhere. 30:52 But it's sampling things without the microbiome 30:56 effectively sitting next to it and saying, hey, don't this is fine. 31:00 This is tolerant, intolerant. 31:01 So it starts this sample things as if those things are problematic. 31:06 And so then it pulls those antigens in to process called phagocytosis. 31:11 It eats the antigens of you well, takes it to T helper cells and presents it 31:15 to T helper cells in a different way 31:17 than it would have if it saw that antigen in the context of the microbiome. 31:21 And then as a result of that presentation, the T helper cells 31:25 activate a whole bunch of other immune responses, 31:27 like your killer T cells and natural killer T cells and so on. 31:31 And then those cells come in to that area, go, oh shit, we got to attack this thing 31:35 and it starts attacking at the same time, because it's not a tolerance response, 31:41 because it's not seeing the antigen in the context of the microbiome, 31:44 you're not getting IGA being produced against it. 31:48 Then there's 31:48 another part of the immune system that senses that, hey, you are low IGA. 31:52 What does it do in response to that? 31:54 It upregulate IGI, right? 31:57 So people with histamine intolerance, mast cell activation, 32:01 you know, allergies, asthma, all of this overreactive 32:05 inflammatory hyperactive immune responses tend to have more IgG 32:10 in their secretory fluids in IGA because your body's going 32:13 we need some antibodies in this in this in secretory fluid 32:17 which is our first line of defense. 32:18 We're not getting the signals to make IGA because the microbiome is not providing 32:23 those signals. 32:23 So we're going to make IgG instead. 32:26 The problem with it is when IG binds an antigen 32:30 it recruits cells call it Sana fills in basophils which then release 32:34 histamine and all kinds of stuff to create this hypersensitivity response. 32:38 Right. 32:39 So then what is effectively happening 32:42 is because the microbiome is not present in the right way 32:46 to facilitate the tolerance response to all of the common things 32:50 that your immune system shouldn't be attacking. 32:53 Your immune system 32:53 then starts to perceive those things as things that should attack. 32:57 And on top of that, it's creating a blanket inflammatory response 33:03 by up regulating IgG response everywhere else. 33:07 Then you have this other danger of call. 33:10 It's called a bystander effect, right? 33:13 The bystander effect is where any time you've got inflammatory responses 33:17 against things and inflammatory responses are facilitated 33:21 by the early part of the immune system, called the innate immune system. 33:25 The innate immune system is kind of the analogy I was used is like, imagine 33:29 you had a window open and then you had a bunch of you had a bunch of mosquitoes 33:33 coming into the window and you're like, oh God, I got to kill the mosquitoes. 33:36 You run into the room and you start bloating the whole room, right? 33:40 And you're going to kill the mosquitoes. Absolutely. 33:43 But you're 33:43 you're going to burn the wall a little bit 33:45 and you're going to burn to break the windows, probably. Right. 33:48 So that's what the innate immune system does. 33:50 It goes, oh shit, something's there. 33:52 We don't know what it is. 33:53 They're just going to come to that area and bombard everything, right? 33:56 And then they're supposed to 33:57 then hand off the process to the adaptive immune system. 34:02 And they in my analogy, the adaptive immune system 34:04 would be the more reasonable. 34:05 But slower individual 34:07 that comes into the room and goes, okay, let's turn off the blowtorch. 34:10 Let's use like a little flyswatter and let's close the window properly. 34:13 Right. 34:14 So that's a more adaptive gentle response. 34:18 But the innate system gets there faster. 34:20 The blood guy gets there faster. 34:21 So he's going to blow some stuff up. 34:23 And so during the innate immune response your own cells are going to get damaged. 34:28 Right. 34:29 So debris from your own cells are in that area. 34:32 Macrophages and dendritic cells which are called antigen presenting cells 34:36 come to that area and start eating up everything that's in that area 34:39 for two reasons. 34:40 One is to start cleaning things up. 34:42 Number two is to start presenting potential antigens 34:45 to the next part of your immune system, which is your adaptive immune system, 34:49 to try to tell the immune system what was the culprit. 34:52 Ultimately, right. 34:53 It's kind of the idea is like something bad happens, something caused a issue. 34:58 We're going to come and bomb 34:59 this area, 35:00 and then we're going to look through the debris and go, what was that thing? 35:03 And that's the job of the dendritic cells and macrophages in that role. 35:06 They come in, eat up 35:07 everything, start presenting antigens to the T cells and B cells. 35:11 Now the regulatory part of the of the immune system, 35:14 the T right part observes that whole presentation. 35:18 And when it sees things that you shouldn't be presenting like your own 35:21 tissue accidentally, it stops it. 35:25 But if you don't have a healthy microbiome and you're not up regulating the T rag, 35:29 and the T rex system is very dependent on your microbiome, 35:32 then you're going to get an accidental presentation of your own proteins. 35:36 Then your immune system goes on. 35:38 That's one of the culprits, and develops this whole 35:41 antibody response against your own protein. 35:44 That is an autoimmune process which is autoimmune, right. 35:46 So this is how you can go from intolerance being kind of an annoying thing. 35:53 Like, oh, there's certain foods I can eat 35:55 I want to stay away from that is my ever yeah, just stay away. 35:59 Just avoid them. 36:00 Just, you know, because I don't tolerate them. 36:02 If that keeps continuing in your body, you'll become less 36:05 and less tolerant of more and more things, including your own body. 36:09 At some point. Right. 36:11 So so it is it. 36:13 This goes back to an early part of our discussion where it's like, 36:16 oh, there's all these plans and things that I can't eat. 36:19 And I, it doesn't agree with me. 36:21 Well, it doesn't mean you just avoid all of that 36:23 because it's a strong indication that your system 36:27 is moving in the wrong direction, and it's only going to get worse. 36:30 Right? Absolutely. Yeah. 36:32 And so we have a few more minutes here. 36:33 Caron, I want to be mindful of your time, you know, 36:35 and what I want to kind of remind people of is you mentioned the microbiome 36:40 being a central, playing a central role 36:42 in sort of regulation of the immune system there. 36:45 You know, what comes to mind for me is poor digestion, lack 36:48 of hydrochloric acid production, poor vagal tone, inability 36:52 to move the food through the GI tract, 36:56 sets up purification, sets up fermentation starts to throw off 37:00 the microbiome can't break down a proteins and other peptides. 37:03 Now those are being sampled and peptides or long chain 37:07 proteins are viewed as as a foreign body instead of amino acids. 37:10 So you know, we're not 37:11 we're not breaking down the amino acids in our brain is not working as well. 37:15 We're not producing dopamine, serotonin, acetylcholine, etc., etc.. 37:19 So it's to me, I think about the dysfunctions that happen, right? 37:22 Head injuries, lack of sleep, poor food 37:25 choices, antibiotics, birth control pills, 37:28 you know, not chewing our food thoroughly, 37:30 eating at the wrong time of day, eating too much. 37:33 Right? 37:33 Like there's there's all these things that probably many of us have partaken, 37:37 in, in our, in our life, especially in childhood, when we just don't know better. 37:41 Right. Or for me, it was pre-internet, like I didn't know anything. Right. 37:44 And so there's a lot that can go on there. 37:46 So maybe you can kind of just give me in the last few minutes here, 37:49 what are some things that people can focus on? 37:51 What can they do to kind of rebuild this system and gain that tolerance? 37:56 Yeah, really, really easy. 37:58 And, really quite important. 37:59 And I want to make one quick connection because we, I know the program overall 38:03 is about toxic brain with the toxic 38:05 gut and everything we talked about with loss of tolerance. 38:09 Right. 38:10 What that ends up doing is constantly activating 38:13 the innate immune system, causing inflammatory responses 38:16 to things that shouldn't be creating inflammatory responses. 38:20 Now, those inflammatory responses that start in the gut 38:23 end up going throughout the periphery, including the central nervous system. 38:27 This is big. Like right? Like that has been active.
Five Pillars to Rebuild Gut Resilience 38:30 It's massive. 38:30 This is like the foundation of the vast majority of chronic illnesses, which is 38:35 why they were given the Nobel Prize for discovering this tolerance issue. 38:38 Right. 38:39 And when you have this constant inflammatory activation 38:43 because of loss of tolerance, 38:45 you also get the same inflammatory activation in the central nervous system 38:50 through something called micro glial cells. 38:52 These are like the macrophages and dendritic cells 38:54 of the central nervous system. 38:56 So now stuff you eat and things in your environment that shouldn't be causing 39:01 inflammatory responses, are causing inflammatory responses in your gut. 39:05 And then moving up your central nervous system. 39:07 Now your brain is inflamed and your brain is getting damage. 39:10 Your body's always as microglia like when those get activated neuron fire, 39:15 they're combined to turn off. It's actually really hard. 39:17 I remember learning this from a function and they're all just like, you know, once 39:20 those are on and they're going crazy, that's difficult. 39:23 It's very hard to regulate them because the Treg cells that we talked 39:26 about in other parts of the body, they don't work as well 39:29 or as efficiently in the brain. Right now. 39:31 The brain has like its own immune type of system. 39:35 And so, so yes, that is where this loss of tolerance 39:39 and toxicity in the gut directly impacts the brain. 39:43 And and that is one the microglial activation 39:47 and inflammation in the central nervous system is central to anxiety, depression 39:53 and neurodegenerative conditions and all that. 39:55 One quick example of that is take tryptophan for example. 39:58 Right. 39:59 Or tryptophan is the precursor to serotonin and melatonin. 40:03 You need that and you need to make your sleep hormone 40:06 and your happy hormone in your central nervous system. 40:08 But when you have microglial activation and inflammation in the central nervous 40:13 system, tryptophan is not converted to melatonin and serotonin. 40:17 It's converted to something called new renin and colonic acid, 40:21 which are both neurotoxic and and enhances anxiety and depression. 40:26 Right. 40:26 So so the precursor to your happy hormone is now being converted 40:29 to something that makes you depressed and toxic to your brain. 40:33 So that's just how impactful inflammation is. 40:36 So let's break down quickly what people can do. 40:39 I actually break it down to five pillars, 40:41 and you have to do at least one thing that each of these five pillars. 40:45 And if you 40:46 if you skip 2 or 3 of the pillars, 40:47 you're really not going to get the same response. 40:49 So you want to become conscious of being of having this cumulative effect. 40:53 Pillar number one is food, right. 40:55 Like we talked about earlier, you want to try to increase the diversity 40:59 of your diet. 41:00 You want to get enough fiber, enough polyphenols in enough lean meats, enough 41:05 good healthy fats, you know, olive oils and all the good stuff that no fresh food. 41:09 Like they have enzymes in them, like real live foods. 41:12 Yeah, exactly. Bitters. 41:14 You want to get your digestive bitters in to help with the digestive process. 41:17 And so food is one of the most impactful things on your microbiome. 41:21 And I mentioned earlier 41:22 that your microbiome is required for all this tolerance effect. 41:25 Not only is it the presence of the microbiome, 41:27 but a byproduct that they produce from digesting fiber called short chain 41:31 fatty acids, acetate and butyrate are two short chain 41:35 fatty acids made from fiber digestion that are critical 41:39 for this whole immune process to occur, to build tolerance and make IGA right. 41:45 So so a diet is number one. 41:48 And number two is stress management. 41:50 So stress is one of the biggest drivers of dysbiosis. 41:53 Every bout of stress you have is like taking a small dose of antibiotics. 41:57 Stress creates dysfunction in the gut microbiome. 42:01 Makes the gut more leaky. 42:02 And of course put your brain 42:04 in an inflamed state as well because it activates the HPA axis, 42:08 the hypothalamic pituitary adrenal axis, and puts you in fight or flight. 42:12 So stress can be very profoundly effective against your gut and your brain. 42:17 Number three is lifestyle factors. 42:19 And the most important lifestyle factors to me are adequate movement. 42:23 So the simple walking we talked about right. 42:26 And resistance training if you can do it which is would be fantastic 42:29 because when you lift weights against a resistance and your muscles 42:33 contract against the resistance, they release compounds called myo kinds. 42:37 And myo kinds have a profound effect on sealing up the lining 42:40 of your gut and improving the balance within your microbiome. 42:44 So myocarditis can act as like a 42:46 your endogenous, your endogenous, you know, prebiotics if you will. 42:50 Almost. 42:51 And then the other thing is the major kinds also reduce cortisol and stress. 42:55 Right. 42:55 So so pillar number three which is weight lifting and movement actually helps. 43:00 Pillar number two which is stress. Right. 43:03 The other thing, and pillar number three in the lifestyle is sleep. 43:06 Make your gut microbiome is a diurnal system. 43:09 It needs that rest period because that's where it does 43:12 all of the housekeeping stuff and repairs the lining and all of that stuff. 43:16 You need 6 or 7 hours of sleep and varies from person to person. 43:20 If you're using, 43:21 you know, 43:22 things like the aura, it can tell you what you see, proficiency is and all that. 43:25 And I think people really need to get much more focus on their ability to sleep. 43:30 Number four, pillar number four is exposure. 43:33 And what I mean by that is exposure to good stuff like in the outside 43:37 environment, getting out, moving, going through hikes 43:40 and all that touching dirt and rocks and all that, 43:42 and then also reducing your exposure to things that kill your microbes. 43:45 So, you know, really strong household cleaners, personal care products 43:49 that are loaded with antimicrobials and all that. 43:52 And then the last one and it's deliberately last is supplementation. 43:55 Because if you don't do anything in these four, 43:57 you can't out supplement all of those other bad habits. 44:00 Right. 44:00 So and with supplementation probiotics like the spore based probiotics prebiotics 44:06 good fish oils polyphenols in a basic things
Where to Find Kiran Krishnan 44:09 you don't have to get super exotic with your supplementation. 44:13 If you're doing all four of those things and add some basic supplements to it, that 44:17 cumulative effect will have a profound outcome for you over time. 44:21 This is great promises. It's always amazing. 44:23 I love talking to you. 44:24 I feel like we could geek out on on the microbiome 44:27 and and the immune system and all things health for a long time. 44:30 You're a wealth of information, 44:31 so tell people where they can find more of the work that you're doing today. 44:35 Yeah. 44:35 You know, I post a lot on my Instagram, which is the handle is at Huron Biome. 44:40 Kiren bio on me. 44:43 And one of the things people will see out there is I also offer a microbiome course 44:47 called Build Your Resilient Gut a. 44:49 People want to take a course and understand 44:51 it deeper and understand more action items and things they can do for themselves. 44:55 And then if you put my name in YouTube, you'll find lots of interviews 44:58 that people have done that have, 44:59 and they've kindly uploaded them to YouTube as well. 45:02 So lots of information in all these places. 45:05 Amazing. Karen, good to see you as always. 45:07 Thank you so much for coming on. My pleasure. Thank you. Jason.
Comments