Full Transcript Introduction to Longevity and Healthspan 0:05 Hey everybody, Dr. 0:06 Rob Silverman here. 0:07 I'm with my good friend, my really good friends, Doctor Christopher Karowak. 0:11 He's been kind enough to take some time out of the day. 0:14 We're going to talk about longevity. 0:15 we're actually going talk the longevity connection. 0:19 he's going really differentiate the difference between life span and health span. 0:23 Dr Karrowak, Chris, it's my pleasure to have you. 0:26 What is going on? 0:27 Dr Rob, so it is always a pleasure just to connect with you, talk life and limb and longevity honestly we're in it together and uh you've been a great 0:38 influence on my life in my career and i'm always happy to get connected with you and just talk science and health and wellbeing to just help the general 0:47 public live longer and feel better. 0:48 I'm excited. 0:50 As they like to say, so let's go. 0:52 Let's hit it. 0:53 let start the conversation off. 0:55 See that you've written that medicine has evolved from postponing death. 0:59 Good idea to preserving vitality. 1:02 How do you define health span versus lifespan? 1:05 And why is that distinction so central to you and the population? 1:09 Well, realistically, and I've seen this a lot mostly in the ICU, we in Western medicine have done a great job in extending the years of somebody's life. 1:18 So we think about sort of the quantity adding years to someone's like. 1:24 But I think what's happening now is there's a lotta Gen Xers who have seen their baby boomer parents die slowly and poorly and yet still have many years 1:36 in their lives. 1:38 dying sick alone or in a hospital or a nursing home. 1:43 And when patients come to me, they don't always ask to live longer. 1:47 They ask the live better. 1:49 Right. 1:50 So this distinction between lifespan and healthspan is not my term. 1:54 It's a common term in the longevity medicine is the idea of The difference between the 80 year old who is with bilateral hip replacements and struggling 2:04 to walk to get the mail and the eight year-old who's skiing with his or her partner and vacationing in Italy and having world tasting components and really 2:16 having the zeal and vitality for life because they have a quality of life, not just a quantity of Quality versus quantity.
Hallmarks of Aging and Epigenetics 2:25 I mean, the hope is to get both realistically so you can have an incredibly powerful quality life and die young and or you could have a very extended sick life. 2:37 and die poorly. 2:38 The hope is to really have many aspects of youth and vitality going on into old age. 2:45 I really think that it's foolish to imagine immortality. 2:50 Um, I know that there are some genetic components that are coming out. 2:53 Had a conversation with a young man who was studying these components about the goal for immortally. 2:58 Don't really that's a practical goal. 3:01 Integrity is really the practical There are a couple of individuals who think they're going to live anywhere between 120 and 150. They'll remain nameless, 3:09 David Asprey and Dr. 3:10 Brian Johnson. 3:12 And they look great and all that, but is that pushing the envelope? 3:17 Is that breaking the envelop? 3:18 For me, it's kind of a, let's see what happens. 3:21 I remember even in medical school, we were theorizing that if we could eliminate childhood diseases, It's highly likely that people could live to be 120 3:28 to 130 and live healthily. 3:32 The individuals who are hoping to live to be 120 to 130 have already experienced their childhood diseases. 3:38 So again, at least the old history may have gone by. 3:42 If you want to have a really interesting experience, check out Demi Moore and Dennis Quaid's new movie, The Substance, in terms of trading old and new. 3:52 And sometimes This concept of youth and immortality may not be what it's cracked up to be, but I'm kind of getting off course. 3:59 It's sort of the idea of of making sure that your mobility is powerful and that you're lung capacity is. 4:07 Powerful and your brain is, powerful that all these aspects of human existence still are present. 4:13 I mean, I don't want to being great physical health with no cognition. 4:16 Equally, don' want have cognition with the physical help. 4:20 there are ways of navigating this so that way you can have better control of your outcomes. 4:29 I mean, when we look at the legends of aging from ancient cultures, there was a thread that would be cut or there a candle that go out. 4:40 And I really think that we have much more control our outcomes provided we do some simple lifestyle pillars. 4:49 I love that. 4:49 Lifestyle pillars, lifestyle hacks, if you will. 4:52 So lifespan versus healthspan, lifespan how long you live, health span how you long live without chronic disease. 4:58 And I noticed you incorporated the idea of vitality. 5:02 Vitality is can we go for a run? 5:05 Can we for go a hike? 5:07 that really intersects with the idea of the quality of life. 5:12 So when you talk about pillars of lifespan and lifestyle and longevity, I think you're talking more about the biology beneath the years. 5:24 So are you ready? 5:26 We're not just aging. 5:27 It's not a mystery, but there are 12 more hallmarks of aging, correct? 5:31 Yeah, I think there was originally like eight or nine and they've expanded this to 12. And what's interesting is you dive deep into them, 5:38 you find that there's an intersection in regards to these 12 I've worked diligently to learn most of them. 5:46 I never can keep all 12 straight. 5:49 But they are kind of interestingly enough that the hours on the clock So it's interesting that this time element that we have, 5:56 there's the 12 hours on the clock and each one plays a role in terms of how much time you have. 6:00 Interesting. 6:01 So let's go through a few of them. 6:02 I mean, there are 12. The first time I saw the Hallmarks of Aging was a 2013 article. 6:09 They had an addendum in 2023. Hit us with a couple of the hallmarks in aging. 6:15 Oh, I hit you in the rabbit hole right away. 6:18 Sorry about that, bud. 6:20 Well, so this is a really fascinating component. 6:25 Can we influence our genes or are we stuck with the parents that we have? 6:30 And so thinking about these methylation components on DNA, these epigenetic clocks, and what can we turn on and can turn off, 6:39 I loved Jeffrey Bland's component about dog ears and bookmarks in terms of our genes and the methylated pathways that would basically flag certain genes, 6:51 turn them on. 6:52 and it's interesting because you know in our field everybody's interested in these methylation pathways and the mthfr genes and methylated vitamins and 7:01 yet nobody was interested In this in the 18th century and as I dive into it most of the methyulation that we get in Our day-to-day life just comes from 7:09 plants plants already have the methylated vitamins in them and so again simple lifestyle pillars if I stay in this plant-rich philosophy, 7:18 eating all my colors by the end of the day, I may cover my methylation better than individuals who are going to be eating processed foods. 7:25 I think methyilation is an incredibly interesting thing that you can control and help your healthier genes turn on and maybe map your genes. 7:35 Well, let's talk about some that I like to discuss, some of the new ones. 7:38 Let's about dysbiosis, the unleveling of good and bad bacteria, and the intersection or the interconnection between dysbiosis and microbiome. 7:47 So the way I talked about this, I stole an ecosystem disruption from Yosemite National Park to explain the aspect of microbiomes. 7:58 And so there was a time frame when the wolves of Yosemite were attacking the livestock of the farmers and the National Forestry Agencies decided that it 8:09 would be better to relocate the wolfs. 8:12 and the entire ecosystem of Yosemite got disrupted by one species. 8:17 And I think the microbiome is very similar to that. 8:19 If you over-populate or under- populate, or bring in a foreign species, you can really disrupt the whole ecosystem, of your gastrointestinal tract, 8:28 not unlike disrupting the ecosystem YOSEMITE.
Gut Health, Dysbiosis, and Antibiotics 8:33 as you eat poorly and bring more stress into your life and have greater sleep deprivation and then get exposed to antibiotics, 8:44 your ecosystem is going to be disrupted and that's going affect your immune system and your neurotransmitters and you're inflammatory pathways. 8:53 And so these concepts of inflammation we talk about, I think they're somewhat rooted in the health of your gastrointestinal tract. 9:02 I mean, we'd say it all the time, but Hippocrates even said that death starts in the colon. 9:07 And so really, this is not a new concept. 9:11 It is just a reawakening of an old concept that a healthy gut may lead to a health life. 9:16 Hippocrates also said all disease begins in a gut. 9:18 Alessio Fasano said, all diseases begins with a leaky gut, and I'll give you one more. 9:22 Paracelsus said the dose determines the poison. 9:27 And so along those lines, that's where we come in and we sort of think about like, well, other ways to basically create a hostile environment, 9:34 but not a deadly environment. 9:35 So when we have somebody with a disruption in their gastrointestinal tract, you know, an overgrowth of their bacteria, we certainly can throw in FDA-approved 9:44 antibiotics and wipe everything out. 9:47 Or we can create a slightly hostile environment. 9:49 Again, bringing the wolves back into Yosemite to basically control the deer population and therefore change the course of the foraging and, 9:57 therefore, the other wildlife and then even the courses of rivers. 10:00 And so when you wind up basically creating balance within the system by creating somewhat a eustress or hormesis type environment, 10:09 a stressful environment that will kill off the foreign and the weak and old so that way the strong survive. 10:16 Again, not that I'm always pro natural selection, but maybe in the microbiome that's a good idea. 10:21 Bringing these hospital environments in so your gastrointestinal tract can be robust and vital leads to a robust vital life. 10:28 Now you're a medical doctor, so you can prescribe antibiotics. 10:32 I am not the chiropractor who is anti-antibiotics. 10:34 Hope that is not a misnomer. 10:38 Where do you stand on antibiotics for longevity, health span and vitality? 10:44 I know that's loaded. 10:45 I apologize, but you're my buddy. 10:47 No, I think it's relatively reasonable because when we look at the critical factors in terms of longevity from a public health perspective, 10:55 like when did the human population start living longer? 11:00 The two factors that come in are public Meaning that when doctors washed their hands, that affected outcomes in their patients. 11:09 And then another factor was penicillin, which was really realistically the first antibiotic. 11:14 So, you know, if we could go back into the 18th century and maybe the early 19th Century, there were a lot of individuals dying of infection. 11:22 So, antibiotics played a huge role in regards to that. 11:25 However, I would say the overuse of antibiotics at this point in time has led to a strange chronic disorder of inflammatory diseases like cardiovascular 11:35 disease and cancer and the increase in uptick of autoimmune diseases. 11:40 So around about way, the role of the antibiotics has to be seen as a risk benefit. 11:46 I think about, you know, when I had come back from our Florida trip and something was wrong, little did I know I, uh, I'd had a ruptured appendix. 11:55 I really don't want to go through a naturopathic functional medicine way of managing my rupture, the appendics I have, entering into sepsis and my life 12:05 expectancy is shorter than it would have been. 12:08 And I have this component without antibiotics. 12:12 So I think it becomes a risk benefit component. 12:15 I Think you try to do everything you can with the least amount of intervention. 12:19 But at the same time, if death is on the line, then you need to choose the weaponry necessary to combat that. 12:29 So in a nutshell, everything's on a table like me and you got to pick and choose, the risk, reward and balance. 12:35 And that's great. 12:36 That's eclectic. 12:37 I think that would help towards the extension of longevity and healthspan. 12:42 Now, interesting, I've heard you say, or it's been said quite commonly, that genes load the gun, environment fires the guns, 12:51 and you like to talk about the conversation going on, the interconnection of the body is really the conversion. 12:57 So I kind of like wanted to tee that up for you. 13:00 Well, I mean, realistically, so for, you know, genetics loads the gut. 13:04 You and I are both over six feet tall. 13:06 I think we have a much better chance of playing basketball than some of our colleagues that are going to be five foot nine. 13:16 And so our genes are our gene. 13:19 I have certain genes that put me at risk for certain disease states. 13:24 And that does not create predestination. 13:28 It may have a preclusion, but it doesn't create pre-destination We know from twin studies that especially twins from the Scandinavian countries who were 13:42 separated because they have the largest population of twin studies available that, you know, if you take one, two twins that both have a risk for cancer 13:49 and one smokes and ones eat, one eats vegetables, the environmental cues can, again, going back to the methylation pathways, 13:56 turn genes on and turn jeans off. 13:59 And what's interesting to me is that And I think this is true. 14:04 I remember this when I was going through residency. 14:06 In the 50s, we believed that disease was 50% genetics. 14:10 in the 60s we believe it was 60%. And literally, up until the 90s. 14:15 We found out that that diseases were 90% related to environment. 14:20 So let me go back with 50 percent genetics, and then In the 60s, it was 60% environment, in the 70s it's 70% environmental. 14:30 I mean, I think back to the women who followed the idea about voluntary bilateral mastectomies because of their diagnosis of the BRCA gene. 14:42 and I was destined to have breast cancer and so let me take a proactive approach to this and have the bilateral mastectomy only to find out that you could 14:50 actually turn these genes on and off based on lifestyle pillars and behaviors and maybe you didn't need to had this radical mastctomy to protect you from 14:58 the cancer. 14:59 I think there is a beautiful interplay and conversation. 15:02 You should know your genes and that can be related to family history or the extreme case of genetic testing. 15:09 But your genes are not predestination. 15:11 Well, you brought up the article. 15:12 I shouldn't say brought the the concept of the HRT. 15:18 I know it was hovering behind you. 15:20 So let's do this kind of like rapid fire. 15:23 Sure enough. 15:24 Is there any starch in the shirt for HR T? 15:27 Yes or no? 15:28 In other words, is there a role for H R T for both men and women?
Hormones, Muscle, and Movement 15:30 Absolutely. 15:31 And honestly, the most recent component from the healthcare system is the black box warning has been taken away. 15:39 Right. 15:42 The components of what we learned in the 40s is now going to be playing a role in now the 2020s. 15:52 I recently just did a lecture on bioidentical hormone replacement therapy and I was kind of the I was kind of the cleanup guy. 16:01 So it was interesting. 16:02 I decided I wanted to do, well, what was it like for our moms? 16:05 What was like the 40s and the 60s? 16:07 And honestly, Western medicine gave out unopposed estrogen to everybody with no screening at all. 16:16 And I don't think that was a great idea. 16:18 But then in the late 90s, and early 2000s we put this warning component on hormones and remove them altogether, that equally was not a good idea. 16:29 Again, going back to this idea about risk and benefit, there are components where certain individuals should not be exposed to hormones. 16:38 But I'm starting to learn that this is very few and far between. 16:42 That mimicking the aspects of youthful chemistry in an older body can lead to better outcomes most of the time if you time it correctly. 16:54 The UK study, the elite study I think is what it was called. 16:57 The elite studies showed that if you can start hormone replacement therapy on a woman between the ages of 45 and 55 and she has symptoms associated with 17:06 a hormone withdrawal, you could extend her life by five to 10 years. 17:09 Wow. 17:10 And so it's just like, wow. 17:11 It's like again, breast cancer is terrible. 17:14 Heart disease is just terrible, but you may die of something else if don't choose the timing of the hormone replacements therapy. 17:21 Muscle mass. 17:22 is the longevity organ. 17:24 Gabriella Lyon say it almost every week. 17:26 Rob Silverman says muscle mass is a currency of longevity. 17:30 But that's just the baseline. 17:31 You know, let's talk about body composition. 17:34 Let's about FFMI because you told me about that. 17:38 Then let go to VO2 max. 17:40 Go to grip strength. 17:42 And then I'll bring in the secret weapon. 17:43 So to use your financial terminology, I always say that muscle tissue is the 401k of longevity. 17:50 This determines a lot of components. 17:52 So like we are in the financial component of it. 17:55 I don't want to take anything away from Peter Rettia and the idea that the VO2 max really is number one. 18:02 So I think your lung capacity plays a very large role that I learned that in our trip to the parks in Utah, where as much as I had muscle mass, 18:13 my lung, capacity was not what it should have been. 18:16 And I said, I really need to start paying attention to this if I'm going to believe in these world views of longevity. 18:22 However, there is something to be said from both an anti-inflammatory and a practical point of view in regards to muscle tissue. 18:30 From an, from an antianflammatory point-of-view, we know that fat tissue acts as its own organ system, especially as America got fatter. 18:38 We started noticing high inflammatory secretions of hormones from the endocrine organs that was adipose tissue, But that led to another interesting discovery, 18:47 finding out that muscle tissue releases an enormous amount of anti-inflammatory chemicals and cytokines. 18:54 So now we have a organ system that can combat inflammation pathways. 19:02 And from a practical point of view, the things that often will put people in the nursing home is an inability to care for themselves. 19:11 And the hip hinge, specifically the squat, is a critical component for an elderly man or elderly woman to get up off the toilet. 19:19 And if they don't have the core strength or the leg strength to, get off of the toilets, they will then spend their life in the nursing home. 19:27 So I think there's both an inflammatory chemical component as well as a practical physical component to muscle tissue. 19:32 Well, you really stole a little bit of the thunder with the secret weapon. 19:36 Movement and movement dysfunction and movements patterns are the number one source of aging. 19:41 I'd only like to use a lot of political examples, but I remember in 2012 when Mitt Romney was running against President Obama, 19:50 they turned to shake hands before the debate. 19:52 Same height, virtually the same weight. 19:55 You know, they both looked like the president, if you will. 19:58 The next day I saw President Obama at 51 years old come down the stairs of Air Force One and he didn't need to hold on to the banister, 20:07 the guardrail. 20:08 He just came down and was moving quite briskly. 20:12 Mitt Romney at 65, though he did not look 65. How to Hold On? 20:18 So that's where the age was quite discernible. 20:21 So let me have some fun with you now. 20:23 Let's talk about some biomarkers for longevity. 20:26 You give me one, I'll give you one. 20:27 We'll do this rapid-fire. 20:28 we'll Do it New York style. 20:29 you're a Northeast guy. 20:30 let's go. 20:31 Give me a biomaker for Longevity. 20:33 For me, the biomakers of longevity will be CRP. 20:36 so your chronic inflammation state in the background. 20:40 So I would pick, my first one will be CRP in terms of a blood marker. 20:44 And you're going for CRPs, so CRPS is for inflammation, tissue inflammation high, and you also going to throw in HRCRP or are you going separate the two? 20:53 So we can say HRCRP is going be much more targeted for heart disease, CRPC is gonna be more common, but if someone is in a chronic inflammatory state, 21:03 they're gonna be running slightly hot, their needle RPMs are going to be slightly in the red, they are gonna have an overheated engine. 21:12 And it doesn't take a big jump to think that if I have a classic Corvette that's overheating, it's not going basically have the beautiful aspects of its 21:23 lifestyle so that way I can drive it up the Pacific Coast the way that I want to. 21:27 So CRP, HR, CRR, or HSCRP. 21:30 HSCRP more arteries, CRP, more tissue inflammation. 21:34 I'm gonna go with an easy one, not in any order. 21:36 i'm just gonna say vitamin D level. 21:38 So I'll say- Oh, brilliant. 21:41 Low vitamin d has been associated with low muscle mass. 21:44 Vitamin D is critical for our overall immune health. 21:47 As a chiropractor, vitamin E is great for musculoskeletal. 21:50 And I believe that vitamin B provides a swath of health promoting properties. 21:55 Dr. 21:55 Kerouac, give another biomarker for longevity. 21:58 I think I would pick fasting insulin levels. 22:01 Again, I don't want to steal components, although I feel you're going to be in the New Yorker. 22:09 You're finally going win final jeopardy in this kind of debate, but I'll give you my best shot. 22:16 For those who are a little bit more frightened of fasting, you could do hemoglobin A1C. 22:20 So if individuals are going to be slightly in the metabolic dysfunction, they're gonna have a couple of markers that are gonna make them sticky sweet. 22:30 And instead of having that beautiful, smooth pathway, their gonna be somewhat caramelized and that's going lead to premature aging. 22:39 I set you up for a tremendous blast off. 22:42 Ready? 22:43 Blood pressure, number one reason for heart disease, cardiovascular. 22:47 Tell me what's going on and tell me, what is the right blood pressure to have when someone walks into your doctor's office? 22:52 Oh my gosh. 22:53 All right. 22:53 So this is going to be interesting. 22:55 And so what I will tell you, this is discouraging for me, 90% of blood pressure problems are what we call idiopathic hypertension. 23:02 And so that means 90 percent of the time, we as Western medicine physicians have no idea what's going on, which is relatively scary. 23:08 If this going to be related to one of number one killers, then 90 % of time we don't know what is going. 23:14 So I would tell because you know me and part of it is just because we would tour together and talk a lot. 23:20 Again, you opened up my world in terms of thinking at root causes and really looking beneath the surface. 23:25 I'm always fascinated to sort of what makes blood pressure tick. 23:29 In other words, if 90% of the time we don't know what it is, what exactly is causing blood-pressure problems?
Biomarkers, Blood Pressure, and Cardiometabolic Risk 23:35 So for me, the tightness of musculoskeletal component in the arteries is a key. 23:40 And so how do we make muscles relax? 23:43 And part of that is the nervous system, part is use of magnesium, and part that nitrates. 23:47 So all this component is trying to create more vasodilatory components. 23:51 Secondary from a physics point of view, The larger the radius, so basically the more capillary depths we can get. 24:02 And realistically, the biggest development of capillary depth is going to be muscle tissue. 24:07 So as we build more muscle tissues, we get more capital areas. 24:09 We can bring our blood pressure down. 24:11 And then ultimately I think your centralized pump, your heart really dictates a lot of that. 24:16 So if your hear becomes stiff and old and archaic as compared to soft and pliable and strong, which I thinks goes to the original aspect of the VO2 max 24:25 where you keep cardiovascular fitness. 24:27 Muscular skeletal components of blood vessels, capillary density and the strength and vitality and resiliency of your heart, 24:37 I think dictate a lot of the idiopathic blood pressure problems. 24:42 There's some other, the other 10% we know everything about. 24:45 They're very interesting components that may be related to salt, kidney disease, diabetes, so on and so forth. 24:51 But 90% of time, you need to go to the root causes and basically say, your lifestyle is probably affecting your blood pleasure. 24:56 So for longevity, which one's more important? 24:59 A, PO, B, whichever everybody should take. 25:02 Okay. 25:02 Okay, I'll put it out there or LP little a Oh my gosh. 25:07 Okay. 25:07 So this is what this Is what I discovered based on the a discussion between primary care physician or cardiologist. 25:17 They say that if you can't make a diagnosis, you should at least make the decision. 25:22 So I'm going to make that decision that APO-B is more indicative and let's talk about why. 25:28 The theory behind the heart attack that's bound to happen is related to the plaque that has yet to rupture. 25:36 And the plaques is made out of cholesterol that gets calcified and then it reaches a certain size where the current or the the hydrodynamics of your blood 25:50 tears the clot off and creates an inflammatory cascade. 25:52 So you wanna keep this clot small and uncalcified. 25:56 80 to 90% of the cholesterol circulating in your is LDL, and 10% if it is LiPoA. 26:04 And so LDl is much larger inside the clock than the LPA, but the LP little a is the sticky dangerous one, perspective. 26:15 And so what usually happens with these, with the poor LP little A individuals is they have a high LDL and that the lipo little a increases their risk for 26:27 heart attack because their LDl is elevated. 26:30 So if you can keep an LP, little as LD L down, they don't get the heart. 26:36 If we argue that circulating cholesterol affects heart attacks. 26:41 And we can have a huge debate about whether we should be checking cholesterol and weather cholesterol. 26:46 I always tell people, like, if you have dirty water, but your pipes aren't clogged, realistically, the dirty, water can flow through the pipes and you 26:54 don't get the clot. 26:55 That's where the calcium score comes in. 26:56 So like basically, maybe we shouldn't look before we start you on statin. 26:59 Maybe we could see what your types look like before. 27:02 We say, well, you're going to be at risk because your water's dirty. 27:04 Right. 27:05 And then there's the age old question of statins, which we're gonna put a pin in and not talk about because we want to talk. 27:09 About longevity a little bit more. 27:12 You call the mitochondria the power plants of youth, not the Powerhouse, so yourself. 27:18 How do these little tiny engines determine whether we age with vitality or fatigue? 27:24 So I have to admit, this is the one that has been the most fascinating for me professionally and personally. 27:30 I was not really, when I first started in functional medicine, I awestruck by the world of mitochondria. 27:38 At this point in time, as an aging athlete, I am much more interested in mitochondrion than I ever have been. 27:45 So realistically, how we move energy around in our body dictates an enormous amount of our outcomes. 27:53 I think muscle tissue plays a role with that, blood pressure plays the role, VO2 max plays role. 27:59 But from a microscopic and cellular level, how our mitochondria turn food into energy and move energy around, I think is much more critical. 28:10 You were the one who really taught me that the highest concentration of mitochondrion is going to be in your brain, your heart, 28:15 and your muscle tissue in that order. 28:17 And I feel realistically, you, as we see it, comes from brain heart and muscle. 28:23 So I these are real keystones in regards to youth and vitality. 28:28 you need to have a brain. 28:32 And also from a personal perspective, I've been dipping into some of the carrier molecules. 28:38 and finding that it has been radically different. 28:41 I mean, literally from day one, thinking about some of the CoQ10 and the NAD type supplementations, and it's been probably the biggest impact for me personally. 28:53 And so I'm becoming much more interested in the world of mitochondrial dysfunction and mitochondria rejuvenation. 28:59 N.A.D., coenzyme Q10, L-glutathione, magnesium. 29:03 Lucy now is the new signaller heartthrob. 29:06 from Mitochondria. 29:07 Really? 29:08 Yeah, there's a new article on that. 29:10 Leucine right here, by presenting with leucin proteins, it ultimately boosts the cell energy production, acetyl-L-carnitine, 29:18 and where would we be without the discussion of creatine? 29:21 Oh my goodness. 29:22 So leuccine realistically of the three branched-chain amino acids, that's the critical one that is going to lead to the greatest amount of muscle tissue component. 29:28 I wonder if there is a connection between muscle building and mitochondria in the leucine world. 29:34 But yes, let's talk about this creatine component. 29:39 To me, it is a no brainer from ages two to 102, you should be taking five grams a day. 29:45 It is no-brainer. 29:47 I had a discussion with my 16-year-old daughter because my two sons were taking creatinine and my daughter at 16 who runs the 400 hurdles and she's a high jumper. 29:59 So she positioning yourself to be a haptathlete. 30:03 And she said, dad, what do you think about women taking creatine? 30:06 And I said you know, I never really looked into that. 30:09 Let me do a little bit of a deep dive component. 30:12 What I found out is that women have a bigger impact on creatinine than men do, even though they have less muscle tissue than them. 30:19 So realistically, her morning smoothie is gonna have the five grams of creatines every day. 30:26 We battle in the household who's gonna basically get the creatins first. 30:31 It's for brain health, for heart health as well as muscle health. 30:33 Big antioxidant.
Mitochondria, Creatine, and Dosing 30:35 I personally think it is the smartest and safest supplement on the marketplace. 30:39 I think it really should be in the New York water supply. 30:42 There you go. 30:43 I love it. 30:43 Five grams, and I agree. 30:45 And women who have less muscle mass require creatine. 30:48 You can take it before, during, after a workout. 30:50 The only thing that I'll say, I've said it a couple of times, is creatinine can't be a hot aqueous solution. 30:55 It breaks apart the particles. 30:57 This dissolves it, And it can go in with caffeine. 31:00 So a lot of these pre-workouts have creatines with Caffeine, so that's a persona non grata for me. 31:07 But creatine adds that phosphate to mitochondria, which is where we were going to revert back to anyway because I could feel it coming. 31:14 The hard thing for me because the new research is now coming out where if 5 is good, 10 must be better, and 20 is the best. 31:21 And so we go back to the Mark McGuire days of the Andrewstein Dion and these young baseball players who were souping up on this and getting kidney failure 31:29 because they were dehydrated and taking creatine. 31:31 But there is some newer studies to show that 30 instead of five might be the better dosing. 31:37 I'm not there yet because of kidney function and hydration, but it'll be interesting to see if more necessarily is better in the world of creatines. 31:46 You know, it's interesting, you bring up the idea of dosing, and the reason we're talking about all these supplements, muscle, 31:52 performance, they're longevity oriented. 31:54 Dosing. 31:55 So you wear two hats. 31:57 You're a medical doctor, but you're also an integrative doc who adheres to certain tenets of functional medicine. 32:02 So the people in functional medicine, i.e. 32:04 many chiropractors, naturopaths, we underdose. 32:08 We don't put our Superman cape on. 32:09 You guys are willing to dose appropriately from the medical side. 32:13 So if you could take that left and right brain, put it together, tell me what's right and wrong. 32:17 I would greatly appreciate it. 32:20 The two things that come to mind. 32:21 One, I think that we have built in insurance to protect us more from dosing world. 32:26 First and foremost, do no harm. 32:32 But we also have learned there's effective dose and there is lethal dose. 32:37 And realistically, if you give a sub-effective dose, you can sometimes, at least looking at the world of antibiotics, sometimes cause more problems than good. 32:48 I also remember working with the supplement companies that we've been working, that most supplement company will put on their package labeling for safety 32:57 purposes half of the effective does as the standard dose to be taken. 33:02 And so I think the real key, if I can encourage the chiropractors, the naturopaths, acupuncturists, other individuals in our field of functional medicine, 33:11 I want you to really think mechanism of action. 33:15 I thing that if you go back to mechanism, how does this work? 33:19 And what will be the consequences based on mechanism? 33:21 I actually think that you'll develop a certain amount of courageousness in regards to your dosing. 33:28 Like all things, if you get to root causes and you understand how something works, you can have a lot more courage in using it. 33:33 I concur. 33:35 The body has a way of cleaning itself. 33:37 We're able to vacuum up certain things. 33:40 Intermittent fasting has come to mind, but intermittent fasting really pertains to the idea of synolytics. 33:48 Yes. 33:49 We haven't talked about synolytics. 33:50 How close are we to clinically clearing what we like to refer to as zombie cells? 33:56 Zombie cells. 33:58 And realistically, you know, in the night of the living dead, realistically zombie cell are neither dead nor alive. 34:07 What's interesting is it seems as though what I've read is that these kind of synesthetes cells may play a role in our youth. 34:16 in terms of protecting us from cancer. 34:19 At least that's what I've been reading about that sometimes there's actually a good role for zombie cells, but mostly in our youth because it doesn't happen 34:27 that often. 34:27 But as we age, it happens more frequently. 34:29 And now there is this chronic release of inflammatory products that come from these zombie cell or senescent cells. 34:40 So how do we wind up targeting zombies without getting too science fiction? 34:47 Realistically, the newer treatment plans look like it's a combination of a cancer drug known as Dysantinib mixed with a naturopathic drug, 34:58 Forcetin. 34:59 It seems as though that combination has been studied to create a synergistic response to actually knock things out. 35:08 There's some plant-derived flavonoids. 35:11 I may be saying this wrong. 35:16 Is that right? 35:17 Ficetin seems to be doing that. 35:18 And then, and then it's sort of in this, you know, this Foxy world, the Fox04 type pathways, which to me are a little bit beyond my MD. 35:30 and I need to go back and get my PhD to understand it. 35:33 But some of these redundant pathways that have been preserved from molds and worms all the way up into humans, if we can sort jiggle some airplane dashboard, 35:44 there may be some components to shut some of these pathways off. 35:48 But what I found realistically is, again, going back to the simplistic aspects of calorie restriction, intermittent fasting, 35:58 full-fledged deep sleep movement pathways, these pillars seem to play a role in regulating autophagy and senescent cells as well. 36:09 So I love the space age component of these wonderful combinations of peptides and medicines and supplements. 36:18 At the same time, it does seem as though the simple things that are the lifestyle pillars still play a large role in terms of the outcomes. 36:27 Interesting. 36:28 So the supplements you're talking about are quercetin, ficetin as you said, resveratrol, which I happen to think is a little overrated, 36:35 green tea and curcumin. 36:37 Zombie cells are those cells that dead, but they didn't know to go away and they're spilling inflammatory markers. 36:44 And zombie cells can be cleared through the body's natural process, promoted by intermittent fasting and exercise. 36:50 and they're aided by the compounds that we said. 36:52 Now, here's the question. 36:54 If they are aiding by exercise, do myokines come into the fray to help with synolytic cells? 37:02 I think that's not a definitive, that is a thought-provoking question, and my group here who listens does know what a myocine is now. 37:10 Based on the terminology, I suspect that they were more band-aids than silver bullets. 37:18 So if myokines create anti-inflammatory products, I think they combat the inflammatory products that the senescent cells produce. 37:27 But I don't suspect that they actually target them. 37:31 They probably help. 37:33 Again, you can overpower a system. 37:35 You can power evil with good, for lack of a better term. 37:40 create more of a band-aid healing symptomatic component than actual targeting. 37:45 But we'll see. 37:47 Right. 37:47 I would agree with you. 37:56 Hence, that helps with synolytics and synolithic cells, but the actual removal of the cells eating and fasting, which is really interesting. 38:03 That idea of autophagy, the breakdown of old cells take the debris and make new cells.
Senolytics, Autophagy, and Lifestyle Pillars 38:08 Same idea in mitophage. 38:10 I mean, their body is tremendous. 38:12 So you think about the change that goes on in body composition. 38:14 So now we're going to put somebody on a, you know, a program where we change their sleep and their food and they're movement and there's stress and social connectivity. 38:23 And they wind up building muscle and losing fat. 38:25 I don't think you can do that without altering insulin resistance, without altering mTOR, Without alterating AMPK, with alterning NAD pathways and sirtuins, 38:36 all of which play a role in the world of senescence. 38:40 So I have a suspicion that there's a secondary gain. 38:43 I think building muscle, in order to build muscle there has to be sleep, food, resistance training, and hormones. 38:49 And I thinks sleep food resistance, training and, hormones lead to the treatment of the synolytics. 38:54 So that's what I, think is probably the connection. 38:56 The behaviors get rid of zombie cells and the muscles help alleviate the symptoms. 39:01 But you can't build the muscle without doing the pillars and then the pillar gets rid the zombie cell. 39:06 You talked about hacks before, or if you will, lifestyle tenants that you would want to do. 39:13 So let's go through a list. 39:15 Give me your three favorite supplements for longevity. 39:18 Oh, my three favorites supplements. 39:19 I think that for, can I expand it to medicines? 39:24 Why don't you do both? 39:26 I mean, you're here. 39:28 If I were going to pick the world of supplements, I would probably pick berberine. 39:33 But I think I'd lean more toward metformin, which is a prescription medicine for diabetes. 39:38 So metormin has a little bit more traction than the berberein does, but if I have to stay in the word of supplement, then I'll pick Berberin for my favorite longevity. 39:45 This is great. 39:46 Metformins has traction, so I probably would pick that. 39:50 I think choosing either the NAD supplementation precursor, either NR or NMN. 39:58 I've not personally used the NR, I have used NNM, and I remember one is more easily absorbed and one more readily converted. 40:08 The NR is easier to absorb and the MN is easily converted, don't quote me on it. 40:14 So I like the MMN a little bit more. 40:17 got berberine, I got NMN, and what's my other one that's going to be my favorite? 40:23 I guess creatine would probably be it because that way we can basically increase muscle tissue. 40:28 That's the one, that is going be the safest and the most practical in terms of muscle tissues. 40:31 Creatine? 40:32 TRT? 40:33 Well, but that not a supplement. 40:35 We can talk about TRTs, so if you want to stay in the world of supplements, you got to think thinking pathways, I got to think about a metabolic supplement 40:45 to change insulin resistance. 40:46 I gotta think of a muscle building supplement, and I've got think a mitochondrial supplement. 40:51 So those are the three that I would pick. 40:53 If we want to go into the world of medicine, my metabolic one is going to be Metformin. 40:57 My muscle-building one, probably between the word of testosterone or potentially a fertility drug called Enclomaphene, which kind of sort of helps reset 41:08 your own natural production of So we got metabolic testosterone. 41:14 From a world of mitochondria, I don't think medicine has really entered into the world, of medically treating mitochondrion yet. 41:22 So I think there is going to be a medicine that helps with mitochondry. 41:25 I would say if I were going be really kind of outside of the box, exercise is gonna be that component in terms of Western medicine world for the mitochondrial. 41:36 And then realistically muscle and metabolic too for that. 41:38 and their exercise would probably be some form of weight resistance, even body weight. 41:42 You know, so if you talk to me 18 months ago, you know I would have actually died on the hill of resistance training. 41:50 I think now that I have just entered into, I had my 58th birthday, and I am now starting to believe that VO2 max and lung capacity is probably just as 42:02 important as resistance trainings. 42:04 So I there has to be something of a mix So now, despite the dark weather, Beth and I are walking our dog at the end of the day as much as the time I was 42:14 spending in the gym. 42:15 Let's talk about a hot supplement. 42:17 I guess you could call it a supplement, peptides. 42:20 They're seen as cellular language. 42:22 So I'll ask you, how do you see peptide therapy fitting into the future of a personalized longevity care program? 42:29 So what I find fascinating about peptids is they most often they are naturally occurring substance that are already in our own cellular mechanisms. 42:38 They've just been isolated by scientists. 42:40 So we can be clear about the definition. 42:43 Peptides are basically small proteins that act as signaling agents. 42:48 It's funny because I think sometimes they'll get a bit of a bad rap because of some of the legal ramifications that have occurred as of 2023. However, 42:58 Insulin, which was a life-saving medicine for diabetics, especially type 1 diabeics is a peptide. 43:06 And so insulin was the first peptides. 43:08 So we don't think of that as sort of having a bad rap. 43:10 We think that is being an essential component for type one diabetics. 43:14 Then the peptids that are taking the world by storm, the GLP1s. 43:20 You know, so GLPs1 equally are peptized and yet they're really mainstream. 43:28 I think, again, I find that peptides become cellular signaling agents to tell your internal mechanisms what to do when they have lost their way. 43:38 To go back to our analogy, these really start the conversation. 43:43 They're biomimimatic. 43:45 Correct. 43:46 And there's some that are really wonderful for the immune system. 43:49 There's ones for cellular repair and inflammation. 43:56 I mean, there's some of the ones that I'm not sure what role they really play in longevity. 44:00 They don't necessarily need to be tan and grow hair to live longer. 44:03 And so some them do that. 44:05 It's part of their life. 44:07 What's wrong with you? 44:08 Come on. 44:08 I means, it's not us living longer, looking good. 44:12 Who doesn't want to as a male be Brad Pitt? 44:15 You know, Nando, nando. 44:16 Don't be a schnook. 44:16 That's how you feel. 44:18 You look, you know. 44:20 Part of it. 44:22 Reality, we're not supposed to talk about that, but You and I both practice and we're dealing with people and patients and they not only want to be healthy, 44:32 at least I hope they want be to healthy but they wanna look good and be health. 44:35 They wanna be good. 44:36 And I think there is some advantage to being aesthetically healthy. 44:41 as well as practically healthy. 44:43 The other thing to think about is, you know, the aspect of social connection and intimacy. 44:47 Peptides also help the aging individual sort of rekindle passion. 44:51 And so there's some really, really fascinating components in the world of mitochondria, inflammation, neuroprotection, so that way your brain stays strong, 45:00 tissue regeneration, immunology components, metabolic balance.
Supplements, Peptides, and Delivery Methods 45:06 It remains to be seen. 45:08 The world of oral peptides are a little bit easier, and there are some companies that have found a way to create a lipo-lipolysized or a lipophilic component 45:20 to get better delivery. 45:23 I get some access to injectable components, so they have a bit more potency and a However, a good majority of peptides now are off the market and have 45:36 to be bought in secondary marketing places while checking the box that says not for human consumption. 45:44 This has been slightly tragic for me because now I get into legal problems if I want to help people use peptide because I'm going to advise them about 45:54 these components and then when they order them, they have the check off a box saying, I am not going use this for the human And if it's contaminated or 46:03 poorly made, they can get into a lot of problems. 46:05 So the regulation, I think, has now entered into the common marketplace instead of the high standards of pharmaceuticals. 46:11 I kind of hope it returns to that higher standard, but I'm not sure what's going to happen. 46:16 A lot people always ask me about the injectable peptides because they feel that they're more effective. 46:22 Can you differentiate the injection from oral as a delivery system and effectiveness? 46:29 I think that the easiest way to think about this is the same way that injectable medication versus oral medications. 46:35 So what happens is that when you take something orally, it goes through your intestine and gets absorbed through you villi and then it go into the portal 46:43 vein and goes to what's called first pass through the liver. 46:46 And your liver is this beautiful filtering system for toxins and exposures and foods for that matter. 46:53 So if I take a medication and I put it through an oral system, it has to pass through my liver. 46:57 My liver, is highly likely to change it, through the cytochrome P450 system. 47:02 It's, you know, so there's less potency. 47:06 in an oral drug or an oil peptide. 47:09 And science being what it is, you wind up putting different chemicals on it to try and beat the liver's ability to break it down. 47:19 Now, if you take an injection, your bypass the component of the living, and you get it directly into the system. 47:24 Probably the best way to think about it is that there have been several companies that have working on oral GLP-1s. 47:31 And they do not work as well as the injectable GLPs. 47:35 Now, what's interesting is the oral, the modern oral glp-ones work better than the older GLp ones, but the new oral ones do work not as good as new injectible ones. 47:49 I think that's the same way you should look at it for the peptides. 47:52 Again, bypassing the system by absorbing it into the oral mucosa, maybe. 47:58 There certainly is some technology, but there's very few companies that have patented this component. 48:04 So, you know, there is good research. 48:06 But again, if you're the only one in the industry, sometimes it's tough to be believable in early stages. 48:12 Oral, in general, is going to wind up being less potent than injectable for both drugs and peptides because it first passed through the liver. 48:20 BPC-157. 48:20 I think it is a miracle. 48:24 And I have big debates even within my staff about how to use it. 48:28 So oral components from BTC- 157, hands down, for dysbiosis and leaky gut. 48:35 Because realistically, you get it into the system, and you have the BPC right there to help the leakey gut become unleaky. 48:43 It then gets absorbed into system. 48:45 And then it goes throughout the systems to take care of ligaments, tendons. 48:49 You know, it works on a couple of different pathways. 48:52 That helps repair collagen through stimulating chondrocytes. 48:56 it increases capillary density and it releases nitric oxide. 48:59 But it has to go into entire system If you take it orally, if you have an injectable component, you can put it directly into your shoulder, 49:06 your knee, uh, ankle, wrist, neck, and you basically have hyperconcentration in that particular area of injury. 49:14 So for me, the BPC 157 is for injections is better used for tendon, ligament, muscle injuries. 49:22 And the oral is probably best used for the world of leaky gut, or maybe some systemic aspects of inflammatory processes. 49:29 So we like to talk about the Wolverine stack when it comes to peptides. 49:32 BPC-157, KPV, which is not as popular, but really quite medicinal in the fact that it does help with the gut. 49:41 And TB4 frag, you and I were talking about before, is great for immunity. 49:46 You mix that with a PEAA or a pro-resolving mediators, and you've got a potent formula. 49:52 Staying with me. 49:53 because we're both aging athletes. 49:55 I mean, I jokingly say, you know, when my children were 16 and they twisted their ankle, You know I'd give them a Popsicle and a nap and maybe it's fine. 50:06 And I twist my ankle now I've got six weeks of rehab. 50:09 So realistically, these oral concoctions are miraculous. 50:15 They take advantage of thymus peptides that affect immunity and inflammation and the stimulate cells to repair damage. 50:23 I think that the real key to the aging athletes is that, the problem is, that as an aging athlete, our muscles are still really strong. 50:31 Our central nervous system and our joints are not. 50:34 And so injury is a real risk and recovery from injury, is much more difficult after age 35 than before age, 35. So if you have these abilities to mimic 50:47 a younger healing system, as in older individual, I think that you take advantage of that. 50:56 You set yourself up for the next inquiry in that, you've written here about treating age while living it. 51:03 So you alluded to that just before. 51:07 How has your personal journey helped shape how you practice medicine? 51:12 As I've suggested, I just turned 58, so I'm coming much closer to my sixth decade of life. 51:19 I had some Yeah, I got you. 51:24 I know you do. 51:24 And so you're the preview to my movie, for lack of a better term. 51:28 As long as I'm not the conclusion to it. 51:33 So, you know, sometimes I'll take my supplements and have a really good cup of coffee and I just feel somewhat spirited in the gym and try to do a personal record. 51:46 only to have my pec minor snap on me and be like, oh my gosh, you know, again, not that I'm going to need some surgical intervention, 51:53 but it's like that's going set me back for a couple of months. 51:57 And this aspect of learning how to I hate to say it this way, learning how to enjoy the journey and redefine what we call success,
Aging, Recovery, and Final Longevity Advice 52:09 I think is critical in the aspects of aging. 52:11 That's why I this viewpoint of immortality is absolutely foolish. 52:16 I that integrity is really what should be the goal. 52:20 Because you're up against this idea about wanting to do these components of our youth, but the system has accumulated damage. 52:32 You know, The Body Keeps Score is the real title of the book. 52:36 And you have to sort of realize that your emotional traumas, your physical traumAs, um, you're, mental traumAS are going to play a role. 52:45 Again, I wouldn't trade it to lose my wisdom. 52:47 At the same time, if I act foolishly, like a 20 year old, will create a shorter lifespan. 52:55 This is why we have be somewhat careful in the world of hormone replacement therapy, because we You know, 50 and 60 year old women, 53:02 when we put them back on a hormone regimen, they feel 20 and sometimes they act 20, and it doesn't go well. 53:09 I hear you, man. 53:11 So as we wrap up, I always ask the same question to all my guests. 53:21 And he always says, Rob, give me one solid thing. 53:24 If I can do one thing, if I could make one change every week that I hear your podcast, I'm on the road to recovery. 53:30 I am on a road of health and performance. 53:32 What would you suggest for him to do for more longevity? 53:36 For me, i really believe that time and consistency is the key to quality and quantity. 53:44 And to not underplay the aspects of deep sleep movement pathways, excellent nutrition, stress management, and social connection. 53:59 These are the five pillars that really are map to the road to longevity. 54:05 I do think that science will always come up with newer and greater things, but if you really want to live a healthy and happy life, 54:17 these five that have been talked about from the dawn of mankind are really the key. 54:25 And then again, time and consistency within these five pillars leads to both lifespan and health span. 54:33 Outstanding. 54:34 This has been a pleasure. 54:35 My pleasure, please. 54:38 We've got to do this again. 54:39 2.0 is always better than 1.00. The sequel with us is better always than the original. 54:45 Isn't it wonderful? 54:46 And let's just have multiple sequels in terms of helping America get healthy again. 54:53 I love it. 54:54 Everybody, Dr. 54:54 Christopher Carwack, Rob Silverman, Proven Health Alternates, we'll see you soon.
Comments