Full Transcript Introduction to SPARC and Healthcare Conflict 0:02 [music] If you work in healthcare, you already know this. Conflict [music] is 0:07 everywhere. In the O, in labor and delivery, in committee meetings, between 0:14 physicians, nurses, administrators, and teams that are all trying to do the 0:21 right thing. But here's [music] the problem. Most of us were never trained 0:26 to handle conflict well. We learned procedures. We learned diagnostics. 0:32 [music] But we didn't learn how to navigate the 0:35 moments when Q professionals strongly disagree. 0:40 That's why I developed the [music] SPARC framework. 0:44 Spark stands for stop, pause, ask, don't assume, 0:51 reflect, and respond, and create a path forward. It's a 0:57 practical system designed specifically [music] for high stakes healthc care 1:01 environments through keynote talks, residency 1:05 workshops, and spark master classes. [music] 1:09 I teach physicians, nurses, and healthcare teams how to [music] turn 1:13 destructive conflict into productive conversations that strengthen teams and 1:19 improve care. If your hospital, residency program, or medical conference 1:25 is looking for a speaker on conflict, communication, [music] 1:28 and leadership in healthcare, I'd love to work with you. You can [music] learn 1:33 more in the show notes because in medicine, conflict is inevitable, 1:40 but handled well, it can [music] make teams stronger. 1:50 >> [music] 1:57 >> In every operating room, in every ward, in every clinic and every team meeting,
Podcast Opening and Guest Introduction 2:03 a silent battle bruise, conflict, negotiation, 2:08 identity. [music] Welcome to the Scalpel and Sword podcast 2:12 where I, Dr. Lee Chararma, physician and conflict analyst, [music] explore the 2:16 hidden negotiations beyond modern medicine. Let's trade burnout for 2:20 boundaries [music] and learn the art of healing with precision and power. 2:28 Hello my peaceful warriors and welcome to the scalpel and sword podcast. I am 2:33 your host Dr. Lee Chararma, physician and conflict analyst. I want to ask you 2:39 a question. What if the biggest threat to physician well-being isn't burnout, 2:45 but the way we've been taught to communicate, lead, and adapt under 2:50 pressure? What if resilience isn't something we 2:54 build alone, but it's something that organizations grow together and 2:59 intentionally before things start to break, before conflict becomes 3:04 disruptive instead of having a chance to be transformative. 3:09 I am so excited today to have on the podcast someone who I think is really 3:13 going to help to illuminate this for us. This is Dr. Lillian Emlet. She's an 3:18 associate program director of the internal medicine critical care medicine 3:22 fellowship of the multidisciplinary critical care training program. She 3:27 teaches by assimulation skills and rapid response team leadership paliotative 3:32 endof life communication and difficult airway management. She is a vital talk 3:37 trained faculty member and teaches communication skills to healthcare 3:41 providers in intensive care and emergency medicine. She is also a 3:46 certified professional coach and the founder of transforming healthc care 3:50 coaching which provides coaching services to health care professionals. 3:55 Lillian, I'm so glad you're here today. Thank you so much. I'm so excited to be 4:00 here. So, at what point did you really start to see this intersection between 4:07 physician well-being and communication and want to start exploring that? You 4:12 know, I would say probably for the greater part of all of our careers, we 4:17 accidentally cause trauma in the workplace, right? A lot of times we're 4:22 not kind to each other and we're certainly not kind to ourselves and we 4:26 do a lot of accidental communication things that we don't even realize we're 4:31 doing uh in the time. Fortunately, I think with practice and skills practice 4:35 in the simulation lab, most from undergraduate medical education all the 4:39 way through becoming a faculty, there are more increased intentional places 4:43 for communicating, doing more patient centered interviews, motivational 4:47 interviewing, end of life communication, empathic skill training. The good thing 4:51 is there is some threat of that. Maybe not enough or maybe we just need more 4:56 doses of it. But for me, I think the reality realizing that a lot of times we 5:01 are unintentionally unkind to each other and ourselves throughout the day. 5:06 >> And what led you from that realization to want to become a coach? 5:11 >> You know, so I think for me what I discovered when I had a coach, this 5:16 person helped me level up my communication skills. So, believe it or 5:19 not, I actually was going through a divorce in the middle of the pandemic, 5:22 and I myself had a mediator trying to help this conversation along. And I 5:28 realized at some point all of my empathy skills to communicate with families and 5:33 surrogates and other colleagues with greater skill in the clinical realm 5:38 really wasn't serving me. And the mediator, it wasn't working. I got a 5:42 divorce coach. And the coach helped me understand how to be more centered, to 5:48 be able to see another person's perspective, to probably do the things 5:52 that you as a mediator do in terms of trying to see that there are more facts, 5:56 feelings, emotions, perspectives, to be a little more curious. And so she helped 6:01 me through that process. And I realized this is just a whole new level of more
Discovering Coaching Through Personal Crisis 6:05 amazing skills even beyond what I already was doing with teaching 6:08 communication skills for clinicians dealing with family surrogates and 6:12 patients. So I decided to go back in the pandemic to go get additional training 6:17 and understand how to make curiositybased questions that really 6:21 expand an open diversity of thinking. Right? Because that's really what 6:25 coaches do. Aside from holding you accountable, they also begin to question 6:29 in a safe way the things we've always created as assumptions. There are a lot 6:33 of assumptions that we hold as individuals and they come as a natural 6:36 process of our development and they're okay. It's okay to have your lived 6:40 experience, your traumas, your culture, your gender, all of your identities are 6:45 great. You're a unique human and we also accept a lot of society's things. And so 6:51 through coaching, we often question, explore, own 6:56 discard and take on new versions. Right? So, we often use coaching whenever we 7:01 are in a place where I can't get any further with what I've already learned. 7:05 And that's why people always get a little confused, right? Like, well, what 7:07 do teachers do? What do mentors do? What do sponsors do? Coaches move whenever 7:12 you need to push against just yourself where you are the only other thing left. 7:17 There isn't probably no other no mentor could tell me how to get through a 7:21 divorce mediation in the pandemic when I was opening the co ICU and dealing with 7:26 all the things right no mentor can mentor that it's a unprecedented time 7:30 and so it was the coach who actually helped me through that process and 7:34 that's how I discovered coaching wow there's so much in your journey 7:39 that's just incredible I love that you were in an incredibly stressful 7:46 situation going through divorce in the unit during 7:49 the pandemic and I think there are a lot of people who would have that experience 7:55 and rather than taking this path of becoming curious about this journey 7:59 being curious about developing this skill set a lot of times people would 8:03 have said you know what it is what it is I'm going to survive the process but I'm 8:07 not going to grow through it and so the fact that you were able to take this 8:10 experience and not only use it as an ability to improve your own 8:14 communication You also made it a way to become curious about where other people 8:20 were in this journey. And I think this is one of the cornerstones to conflict 8:24 is this idea that my perspective is mine. It is the product of my lived 8:30 experience. It is my worldview. It is the lens through which I appreciate the 8:34 world around me. And I love how you say that. That's part of who we are. It is 8:38 part of our identity. But to be able to have the metacognition to question that, 8:44 >> to say that I'm actually going to sit here and I understand that my lens might 8:48 need some polishing and I'm going to get someone to help me to do it. 8:52 >> I think that is one of the absolute keys to developing conflict skills and 8:56 management. So, I love that you unfortunately had to go through all of 9:00 that, but you built this really amazing skill set. When did you discover vital 9:04 talk and when did that become something that you became interested in and 9:07 trained with? >> Yes. So, Vital Talk actually has been 9:11 instrumental really the cornerstone majority of my entire academic career. I 9:15 discovered it back when I was junior faculty. I think back then we were just 9:19 revising the curriculum. So really pretty much that first year as faculty I 9:24 began my mentor was Bob Barnold and he is one of the founders of the nonprofit 9:29 Vital Talk. And so back then, you know, the evidence already was quite large for 9:34 training oncologist and pal of care physicians on how to teach communication 9:38 skills and how do you pay it forward so you create an army of teachers of 9:41 communication skills. And so there are hundreds now of all specialties and 9:45 disciplines with vital talk who do teach communication skills in different ways, 9:49 right? So they actually have a DEI module, they actually have a pediatrics, 9:53 neonatal, nephrology, critical care. There's so many different specialties 9:57 now represented. Nursing and other, you know, chaplain and social workers. 10:01 Everyone is welcome at Vital Talk because everybody communicates in some 10:05 way in the healthcare sector. So really, it really was the foundation for much of 10:09 my simulation communication skills training to do the Vital Talk faculty 10:13 development program. They have a robust faculty development program. It is not 10:16 for the faint of heart. And at the same time, if you really want to be well, as 10:21 you and I both know, it is worth that investment in time and practice and 10:26 mentoring and observation and feedback and recording yourself and listening to 10:31 yourself and wondering. This is no different for people who get voice 10:34 coaches and speaking coaches. It is that entire process of trying, learning, 10:40 doing, and then seeing what other people think and then also just hearing 10:44 yourself and then asking for that deliberate feedback. actually that needs 10:48 to happen to I'm working on this and can we just get that part good first and 10:52 then move on to the next problem. So you've not only developed the ability to 10:57 communicate, you've developed the ability to grow in your own method of 11:00 communication, be able to critique yourself and actually see where you can 11:03 improve in your communication. I love that this is an ongoing process. I feel 11:07 like all of us need to be reminded that as we're developing these skills, they 11:12 don't just pop out fully formed. that we're constantly improving, refining, 11:16 and the more experience we have, the better we get at those things. You 11:20 mentioned mentoring, and I know that as an instructor, you're teaching
VitalTalk Training and Communication Skills Development 11:24 residents, faculty, you're teaching junior faculty as well. What are some 11:29 things with communication that you really find maybe they didn't get 11:33 earlier in their training or you find you really have to focus on as you work 11:36 with them? You know, I think what's really 11:39 interesting, there are some people who see really great role models and they 11:42 know it when they see it, right? So during the interviews for people coming 11:45 into fellowship, they're like, I really want to do critical care because I had a 11:48 really great intensivist who showed me how important it is that communicating 11:53 at the end of life with families. I mean, that's what they're going to 11:56 remember. Or they themselves were critically ill because right because 11:59 many of us got sick with COVID. So they themselves actually had their own 12:02 critical illness story and now are want to go into the field and a lot of the 12:07 memories are actually related to communication and whether that's medical 12:10 errors whether that's things done well whether that's disclosures and so that's 12:16 what the good stories and I think the other opposite lens is when they don't 12:20 see things go well and they can begin to compare and contrast and they realize 12:24 there are a range for how I want to be or how I don't want to be as clinician 12:29 and so I think what's hard is not everyone is comfortable just like not 12:32 everyone's comfortable with a particular procedure in certain fields or not 12:36 everyone loves to teach about I don't know fill in your blank sort of 12:40 physiology you have to find the right people who that's the thing they like to 12:43 talk about how they can deconstruct it and just like most teaching it's 12:46 deconstructing noticing making it a micro actionable thing you can do 12:53 whether it be pausing more using different words finding different words 12:58 sentence structure rehearsing it outside the room, having a strategy, having a 13:03 pneummonic for how you might communicate. It's just these funny 13:06 little muscle things. And we talk about the fact that this toolkit of your words 13:10 and your verbals and your non-verbals. You do need someone to observe you to 13:14 tell you that you're really good at this. Keep doing that. I don't know if 13:17 you knew that, right? I know that you make great eye contact, for example, or 13:21 you lean forward right when you're supposed to. Keep doing that. Or you 13:25 really use silence or pausing just at the right moments. Keep doing that. And 13:29 then also sometimes, you know, noticing that if it's not received well, right, 13:34 the data is always with the other person. Sometimes it's really nice when 13:38 you're in the heat of the moment, you can't actually notice what's happening 13:41 because you're just so engrossed in the conversation. It's nice to have the 13:44 other friend along with you just to notice, hey, I noticed that the other 13:48 person leaned back, you know, like there was a facial expression. And when we're 13:52 talking, it often just goes right past us. It's nice to have that friend in the 13:56 room whenever you're talking with another person just to be able to say, 13:59 "Hey, just want to let you know what I noticed because it's data that we 14:02 missed." >> And I love that you're encouraging them 14:05 to collect that data. And you have different perspectives. You may be the 14:08 person talking. You may be the person observing. And the person who's talking 14:12 when they have that feedback from the observer, it's like, "Okay, these are 14:15 things that I can work on. These are things I did well. These are things that 14:18 I can improve." But I'm also willing to bet as the observer, you're learning 14:22 from the person talking. And you're also, okay, I love how this person did 14:27 this. I love how she leaned forward. I loved how she made this eye contact. 14:31 Those are things I'm going to emulate the next time I have this conversation 14:34 with a patient. I think the experience of being the observer also becomes very, 14:39 very educational. One of the things that I love that you 14:42 talk about especially with your coaching and I think this goes handinhand with 14:47 your training young people. A big thing right now for all of us right now in 14:51 medicine especially if we have medical students or residents is helping them 14:54 develop a team mentality. We grow up in a silo in medical education. You know 15:00 our braids are our own, our residency is our own. We're competing for positions 15:04 in the match. So all of a sudden we get into clinical training and we're 15:08 expected to learn how to work in teams. And this is something that I think is a 15:13 little foreign to my generation. It wasn't something that was encouraged, 15:17 but I think now the younger people that are coming up, we all recognize how 15:20 important it is to work as a team. And one of the things that I think you do so 15:24 beautifully as a coach is you look at coaching as a system. You're looking at 15:28 the entire ecosystem that you're coaching. What do you look at if you're 15:33 coming into an organization and you're the coach and you're helping to build 15:37 resiliency and communication within this organization? What are some things that 15:41 you look at initially going into this process? 15:45 >> Yeah. So, with our systemic team coaching that we do at transforming, the 15:49 reality is we're trying to help people understand where they are in the entire 15:54 ecosystem. We hear a lot of these narratives right on you know TV public 15:59 media where there's always like from a particular perspective it's the system's 16:04 fault and there's only one way to do things and we often see this right even 16:07 within our own groups right as we work with another specialty well they want 16:11 that and we want this and there's a lot of us them feeling and yet at the same 16:17 time we have four specialties consulted on one patient and it gets very 16:21 complicated very quickly whenever we have all four teams trying to make a 16:25 cure plan together because we often are only seeing things from just one view. 16:30 And this happens on a daily basis in terms of we think this, they think that, 16:33 it's always very antagonistic. And so when we think about how that 16:39 translates even to them, policies, how things are organized, supply chains, 16:43 collaborative projects, throughputs, ways that we can work quicker together, 16:49 especially for ICU, surgery, emergency medicine, right? So that's one whole 16:53 throughput line that to in order to cure for a trauma patient from injury entry 16:58 into the doorway all the way home. There's a lot of people who get 17:01 involved. There's a lot of different teams that get involved. And so with our 17:04 systemic team coaching, we're really helping the leaders of those teams in 17:08 different areas of the entire organization begin to think more willing 17:13 to collaborate with each other and understand from another perspective so 17:17 they can actually leverage become more efficient together. We often work with 17:20 leaders first because they need to be aligned with their own internal team and 17:24 also once they're in internally aligned and can begin to imagine because one
Teaching Communication Through Observation and Feedback 17:28 exercise we do which is the 13th chair meaning there's an extra person in this 17:33 room as we make a policy decision as we make a clinical service line decision 17:38 who else's perspective have we not considered right we often never think 17:43 about that there are unintended consequences because we never actively 17:46 go looking for our blind spots we just I think we got the right stakeholders and 17:50 so I have the chief nurse, I have the chief physician, I have the chief a you 17:54 know I have one, you know, someone you one person and then when we go system 17:58 testing right because in simulation we often system stress test a new system 18:02 build get readiness for stroke activation like things like that and 18:06 then we're like oh we really need to involve public affairs and the police 18:10 because apparently this elevator is locked and the only people who can 18:14 unlock this elevator would be public safety right like someone else in the 18:18 building, right? There's all kinds of things that we often don't use this 18:22 systemic model to think about even the ecosystem of one building, but that even 18:26 that one building, I argue, you're part of a larger healthcare system. And the 18:30 healthcare system now is often multi-state, multi-outpatient and 18:34 impatient. There's so many ways within an organization that the systemic model, 18:38 the systemic team coaching really needs to be evolved because you can find 18:42 places where you can become more aligned so that people can work better and 18:48 faster and have greater places of communication and feel more empowered. 18:52 You're doing things together. Oh my gosh, I love that so much. So, 18:58 there so many things about that that I love. The first one is this idea that 19:02 you're using simulations to actually get this very big picture on all of the 19:07 stakeholders because so often I think in developing 19:12 system resiliency but also kind of helping organizations learn about 19:16 conflict as they start working on conflict or they have a conflict that's 19:20 already existing they may see two or three individuals they see as 19:24 stakeholders. They don't understand that the nurses also suffer, the patients 19:29 also suffer, the physical therapist coming through is going to suffer, that 19:32 there are so many people who are impacted by this one conflict that they 19:35 thought they might only be two or three people. 19:37 >> It very often to me makes people more invested in the process of seeing the 19:43 system become stronger because the majority of people when they realize 19:46 their conflict has affected somebody else in that way, I didn't mean for this 19:51 person to feel this way. I didn't mean for my thing to overflow onto this other 19:55 person and then when you broaden their big gaze and they realize I think it 20:00 invests them in the process. So I love that you create that through simulation 20:03 you're showing them there are all these other stakeholders that you didn't even 20:06 think about that are invested in what you're doing right now. But the other 20:10 thing that I love that you said is that you're using your processes to build 20:14 more alignment within these structures that as people see where they're 20:19 aligned, not where they're opposed, where they're aligned, that they see how 20:24 much stronger this communication becomes and they actually start to function more 20:28 effectively as a system. >> I love how you're using a simulation and 20:33 you're using your systems to do that. One of the systems that you use in your 20:38 coaching has an acronym which is a ND and tell us about that. 20:45 >> Yeah. So when we think as coaches, you know, how do people get through that arc 20:48 of transformation? We start with awareness. And it's really interesting 20:51 to me because some people don't actually want to be aware. Some people are not so 20:55 happy when I say we're going to start with like a online assessment of your 20:59 energy levels. And so we have a proprietary assessment called the energy 21:02 leadership index. Many coaches use different types of assessments. Some 21:06 people use personality based assessments. We have two different ones. 21:09 One's a personality based, one's an energy leadership based one. But there's 21:13 all kinds of assessments that people do just to either figure out what's going 21:17 on your organization. We some of them use 360s to figure out how everybody is 21:21 perceiving everything. There are also team based systemic team based 21:24 assessments on whether this is a high value team in terms of how they're 21:28 functioning. So, you got to know where you are first before you can begin to 21:32 imagine where you're going to go. Because sure, everyone can have the same 21:35 goal of being a highly loving, caring organization with billiondoll impact and 21:41 revenue that serves the community and gives back, you know, half of it with 21:45 charitable impact with some other kind of philanthropic arm that everyone can 21:49 have the same goal. But when you assess where you are, not every organization 21:53 can get there as fast, right? And your strategy is going to be different 21:56 depending on what your capacity is, personalities and talents that are 22:00 actually on the team in terms of what's working, what's not. And so assessments 22:03 is key first, whether you're working with a team or with an individual. Once
Systemic Team Coaching and Organizational Alignment 22:08 you know where you are and can reflect how it shows up in the daily actions, 22:12 behaviors, and thoughts either as an individual or how does it exhibit as a 22:16 team? Because the team can probably pretty agree that when we're behaving 22:20 like this, this is what it looks like. When we're behaving like this, this is 22:22 what it looks like. Because when you look at your scores, our usual question 22:26 next is and how can anyone give us an example of what that might look like or 22:31 how do you feel it? You know, how do you think it? How do you act on it? And 22:34 people use and give some kind of example. And then once you know where 22:37 you are now, then we think about, well, what do you want to switch? So, okay, 22:40 these are your scores. You understand your scores. Different people respond 22:44 differently, but like, well, this really bothers me right now. And so, I really 22:47 don't like that score, and I want to change that. that I need to fix that 22:50 because this is what's actually messing everything up this one particular thing 22:54 and so okay great so how are we going to get there and then we explore and we 22:58 unpack and imagine new ways whether it's data action sometime it is just a 23:03 thought often times it's just people's mindsets and like they actually begin to 23:07 say all the negative mindset and then we have to challenge them on it and how 23:11 true is this and they're like no I am not a failure or an imposttor or not 23:15 qualified I'm like great so how can we interrupt a cycle and so we have to 23:20 think about new actions all the time and they could be small little new actions 23:23 or they can be big new actions right for some of our clients it's actually I'm 23:26 going to go get an MBA I'm going to go you know two years just like you know 23:30 yourself I'm going to go off and do the thing for a while and I'll be back 23:34 whenever that's the time so the new action can vary person to person and 23:38 then once that new action is taken oftentimes just like sustained weight 23:42 loss just like managing through a big health concern a big financial concern 23:48 It's going to take deliberate attention to it, right? Because habits take a 23:51 little while to form and we often fall off into our bad habits again that we 23:55 had before because somehow that habit loop trigger served us in some way 23:58 before we can easily fall back into old patterns. We just have to it's hard to 24:03 make a new one. So just to think that two or three coaching sessions are going 24:06 to somehow miraculously everything will be better is sort of hilarious, right? 24:10 Because any of us who've done major transformational change, it does take 24:13 sustained attention, accountability, strategy, and then it is a habit, right? 24:18 So then what's interesting for me is even just watching as people change, 24:22 some things we don't talk about anymore because it is now newly ingrained upon 24:25 them, but then we all move on to a new thing, right? Because once you've 24:29 discovered something great and you've changed it for yourself, it's kind of 24:32 addictive. People come back and they're like, "Let's move on to the next thing." 24:36 things and then they take on another thing off that assessment like let's 24:39 move on to this. I'm like okay let's move on to that. So obviously that 24:43 varies per person, right? For some people they're like great, six months I 24:46 made my whole career pivot, I'm good, we'll just keep in touch and then 24:51 they're great and then it might just be the thing they need, right? So career 24:54 transition doesn't go on and on, right? But big system level changes especially 24:58 at the team level easily need six months to a year depending how dysfunctional a 25:03 team is and the quicker they are willing to accept the assessment the quicker 25:06 they're able to move on. I mean, I think that's the hardest thing that I think 25:09 for most people to really stomach. How stubborn are you? Because if you're 25:14 willing to even be willing to open the mind a little bit and like begin to see 25:18 could there be a different way then you actually are going to be faster for 25:22 transformation. It's the people who are very recal and I think some people have 25:26 labeled or have they called sometimes just not willing to change maybe just 25:30 isn't bad enough. I think everyone's willing to change if it gets bad enough 25:34 for themselves. It's just that's the question. I love that. I love your 25:38 process beginning with awareness that you have to know who you are. You have 25:42 to be able to confront those things. I think when I first got coaching and I a 25:47 360 assessment, I remember crying the first time I sat down with that because 25:51 there were a lot of things that I was looking at on the 360 and it's like, 25:54 wow. Okay. But then you take a deep breath. It's like, okay, well, this is 25:59 where I'm starting from. And as you start to realize, I can only get better 26:03 if I open my awareness. I can only improve. this is only up and the hardest 26:08 part of course is that first step of actually being willing to be assessed 26:11 and actually look behind the curtain which I think like you said it's really 26:15 hard to be open to that but once you do I think you start to see all of the 26:19 benefit there that can come. I think one of the things that's also so 26:24 awesome about what you do in terms of helping organizations become more 26:28 resilient and become more aware is in my world sometimes I don't see people 26:34 looking for this kind of help and all the wonderful things you're offering 26:38 until something catastrophic has happened. Right? There's been a horrible 26:41 outcome and generally with the horrible outcome has been this how did we get 26:46 here and then as we're going back through all the conflicts that led us to 26:50 this horrible outcome. You see the breakdowns in communication that have 26:53 been there for years. You see the people that have been so entrenched in their 26:57 silos that they haven't understood how to function as a team. Part of what you 27:01 do that I love is that you help people begin to work on these processes before 27:06 they become catastrophes. But occasionally, I would bet that 27:11 sometimes you don't get those calls until something really catastrophic or 27:15 something really bad has happened. But then all of a sudden, when that happens, 27:19 that's when people are sometimes more open. I hate to say that, but sometimes 27:22 that's when people become more open to embracing this process. 27:26 >> One of the things that you also talk about, and I love how you address this, 27:31 is this concept of cognitive flexibility. 27:35 What is cognitive flexibility and why is it important to this process of 27:39 coaching? So I think the part of cognitive flexibility really is about 27:44 being able to task switch and set switch. And so the two definitions 27:50 relates to you know when we think about learning especially in the ICU there is 27:54 some thought about the fact that we're working in pretty highly complicated 27:58 environments. And so it's a lot of overload and whether that's going to be 28:02 to how can you process from a sensory perspective and when you get overloaded 28:07 you have to be able to recognize is how to slow down so that you can catch back 28:11 up and speed up again. And so if you don't have that degree of awareness for 28:15 your own cognition that's when people make mistakes. And so we think about 28:20 this in the competencies when we're teaching and we're learning. What that 28:23 looks like from an educator perspective is that you know do they learn right 28:27 from self mistakes and do they have a process to reflect and talk with others 28:31 and learn from the process. But that's a really global sort of fuzzy holistic 28:35 from down all the way more from the thinking perspective. It's whether you
Coaching Framework: Awareness, Assessment, and Change 28:38 can focus and then switch and be willing to just let go of a prior preconceived 28:45 notion, right? a prior bias, a prior willingness to actually just like you 28:49 said in the beginning, change the color of your sunglasses. And that's actually 28:52 how I talk about the different levels of energy. It's like these are all 28:55 different ways you can respond when presented with a reality. We all have 29:00 choice and agency for how we want to show up that day in that situation. If 29:04 you're hungry and hurt and traumatized, you probably are going to choose what we 29:08 call level one, which is just hide, don't say anything, don't speak up, and 29:11 just keep your mouth shut. Then you also might be level two, which is angry, 29:15 defensive, and just will lash out at somebody. You also could just be like, 29:19 I'm just sort of neutral. I'm going to survive this just by being sort of like 29:23 non-confrontational, but I also am saying yes to the not right situation we 29:27 have right in front of us. Then there's people who are going to get up and care 29:30 about the situation, which is going to be to nurse and figure out how to be 29:33 compassionate to the people and actually give to the situation. Then there's 29:37 people like, well, yeah, this is a huge problem. We had a horrible error and 29:41 this is an opportunity for us to finally do the right thing, make the policy 29:45 change, do the education and bake into the system so it doesn't happen again. 29:49 Right? So people as you hear this story, you can sort of see, oh yeah, I've seen 29:52 this in my organization before and we just show up. We can choose how we want 29:57 to do it. And I want to say that also none of these are wrong or right. 30:00 Doesn't mean the person who wants to hide and keep their mouth is any more 30:03 right or wrong than the person who sees the opportunity. They're just in the 30:07 moment different ways to hear, feel, and see with the situation. At the end of 30:13 the day though, at some point, you have to be flexible enough to rise up, right? 30:17 So, and part of the reason why you said you're amazed by how I was able to kind 30:20 of get through all such stressors in 2020, but it's also because I teach the 30:24 well-being curriculum and I know a lot of the trauma-informed literature is 30:28 that trauma can be a permanent scar or it can be the greatest thing that ever 30:33 happened to you. And you have a choice on how you have your trauma become the 30:39 best thing that ever happened to you because then you have those skills of 30:42 whatever it is. And people don't really realize how to turn their trauma into 30:46 superpowers. One of the biggest things is having this 30:49 flexibility to say, "Okay, that's what happened. It's okay that it happened. 30:54 And then what am I going to do differently? And can I just try on other 30:58 people's way of being?" I often tell like even in our communication skills, 31:02 you're just trying on out other people's words. And so in our learning labs, you 31:06 know, people will say the same sentence over and over again because they're just 31:09 trying the sentence on for the first time because they really like their 31:12 friend's sentence. I'm like, great, try it on. And they're like, "Okay." And 31:16 they do and then it comes out weird the first time. That's okay, too, because 31:20 eventually you do your own intonation. You do your own cadence. You add on a 31:24 different jargon so that it becomes more relaxed how you want to vibe. Oh, I love 31:28 that so much. I love how you're encouraging the concept of agency as I 31:34 have the ability to choose how I respond and show up in this moment. And part of 31:39 that choice is acknowledging what's going on inside of me. Do I need a 31:42 Snickers bar? Have I had no sleep? Did I have a fight with my spouse? Did my kid 31:47 do something that really bugged me today? Which of these things is in me 31:51 right now? and being able to acknowledge that in some way, but also able to 31:55 choose my agency in terms of how I show up in the midst of all of that. But the 32:00 other thing that I love that you do, especially as you're talking about doing 32:02 these simulations, is as people are trying on these different phrases. And 32:06 this something we definitely do working with conflict too, is this idea of doing 32:10 role plays and actually scripting and practicing. When I'm in a fast-paced 32:14 situation and I have a conflict brewing, you have a patient that's crashing, you 32:17 know, they're in the ER or they need to go for a stat laby and everybody's going 32:21 crazy and I see people start to escalate. What can I do to actually stop 32:26 this process from escalating so we can get the patient taken care of? And I 32:28 have stock phrases that I have. It's like, can we just take a sec? I mean, 32:32 this will roll off me because I use it to get everybody to bring the room down 32:37 and then we can actually pause and we can assess what's going on and give them 32:41 a safe space to do it. You're actually creating this environment where they can 32:45 try it out. It may not feel good to you right now, but say it a few times and 32:50 then as you say it a few times, if it starts to feel good to you, try it out 32:53 in real time. And I think the fact that you give them the space to do that is so 32:57 powerful for them. Yeah, I do think the use of the improv actor really across 33:02 medical schools. I think what's really to me the saddest thing is I think once 33:06 we're in practice all of the luxury I mean it costs money to run all of these 33:10 training programs medical schools using improv and actors to be able to help 33:14 with the communication because it's so critical in those early years right but 33:18 then once we're in practice for some reason they think we never need a dose 33:22 of training again and yet I think we all need that right because if anything we 33:26 need the stakes are higher and we need to continue to role model what it needs 33:30 to be and it's really sad when you go back and teach first year medical 33:33 students, they have so much empathy. All of their sentences are so amazing. You 33:39 realize what has happened to me in the last 10, 15 years that it doesn't just 33:44 come off so easily, right, with the non-verbals because they're closer to 33:48 having the hidden curriculum of healthc care make it evaporate. And so hopefully 33:53 we can all be champions of pointing out when it's gone because I think we often 34:00 also don't reinforce what's going right. My mentor, Dr. Arnold, we know he talks 34:04 about the fact that in some ways education is somewhat like dog training. 34:08 How do we get the dog to sit? We actually praise them, right? We praise 34:12 them and give them a treat to be able to say, "You did the right thing. Good 34:15 job." If fact, everything often our workplace is the opposite. No news until 34:20 something goes wrong. And so all we're reinforcing is sort of like a negative 34:24 culture rather than thanks for doing the right thing or thanks for speaking up or 34:29 thanks for apologizing when you were rude. like I'm glad you recognize it and 34:34 no harm done. Thanks for just apologizing to each other. It actually 34:37 just happened to me the other night when I was on call and I'm like yeah no big 34:41 deal like I didn't feel anything from it and thanks for apologizing because we 34:45 all I mean you've been in the operating room for 12 hours like I would be tired
Cognitive Flexibility, Agency, and Role-Playing Practice 34:48 too so it's okay. >> So 34:50 >> yeah. >> Oh I love that so much and I to 100% 34:54 agree with you. One of the great things to me about teaching medical students is 34:59 getting that kind of being able to see that in them, seeing the empathy, 35:04 seeing, you know, that they genuinely want to be physicians and they want to 35:07 be a part of our system. And I think that's always inspiring. And every time 35:10 every time around medical students, I come out of that interaction feel like, 35:13 okay, dang, yes, this is the reason why I'm doing this job. I want to be that 35:17 kind of energy. But there was something else that you said that I really want to 35:21 come back to, especially as an educator and working with students, residents, 35:25 even junior faculty and even our colleagues. I teach martial arts and one 35:30 of the things that I always used to do when I taught martial arts classes, even 35:32 because I've done this for a while, is every single student in that class that 35:37 day, I would say one positive thing to them before they left. At some point 35:41 during the class, I would say, "I love how you're holding your hands. I love 35:45 how you're doing that kick." That was a great sparring round that you had and 35:49 every single person during that day got one positive comment. Now sometimes you 35:53 got to look if someone's really struggling on a certain day. You got to 35:56 really find something. It's like but you find one thing and even if you give them 36:01 four or five things they have to work on they've left that day with one thing 36:06 that's positive. And what will they say when they leave that class? That was a 36:10 good class. They will leave that class feeling good. And even when you're 36:15 seeing patients in the office, I will try to find one thing. Your nails look 36:20 really cute. I love your nails. I love your shoes. I'm really proud of the fact 36:24 that you took your medicines on schedule. I'm really proud of the fact 36:27 that you actually kept this followup and we got this checked out for you. But you 36:31 find one thing and it helps people buy into whatever it is you're doing with 36:36 them, whatever process you are working on. When you give people that little bit 36:42 of positivity, they will come back and they will also have the sense that 36:47 whatever it is that you're working on for them or with them, it is to their 36:50 benefit and they will buy in so much faster. So, I love the fact that you 36:54 emphasize that. >> That's 36:56 >> Yeah, that's really a teaching point in general. Just can you notice what's gone 37:00 well? One thing for every student. That's actually not so easy. And I just 37:04 think now again of all the elementary school teachers, right? because you do 37:07 need to do that because otherwise you get demoralized like why do I even come 37:10 here I get nothing right zero out of zero it's horrible and so just noticing 37:15 that we all have to be just be better observers really teaching in many ways 37:19 is just noticing what's gone right so that we can keep doing it because 37:23 otherwise it might just go away absolutely no I agree with you 100% so 37:30 you are working with a group of physicians and you're working on their 37:34 communication skills What's one skill that maybe every 37:38 physician should try to master or maybe work on as part of their skill set? One 37:45 communication skill. So I think for some people they also call the buckiveness 37:50 into like the active listening sort of process, right? Which is just not 37:55 responding in the way that you think you're supposed to respond, which is I 37:59 need to give you my perspective or give you another fact. It's really just 38:03 recapitulating. Did I understand you correctly? Right? So, it's a oftentimes 38:08 either the summary or it's like I heard you say or what I'm noticing and trying 38:12 to be a more active listener in just summarizing what you've just heard 38:18 because that helps you get into alignment very quickly, you know, in 38:22 terms of whatever it is that you're given from a patient's perspective or 38:26 surrogate's perspective. And then being explicit about transitioning, right? Is 38:30 like would it be okay? Always asking permission. Is it okay if I talk about 38:33 this? Is it okay if I give you the serious news? Is it okay if we now talk 38:38 about what I'm worried about? Is it okay? We give control back to the other 38:42 person actually in that sentence because we often don't. Okay, nobody likes to be 38:48 bulldozed in a conversation, right? This is also why mansplaining is also very 38:52 uncomfortable for many people in a room because it's like I didn't ask for you 38:56 to repeat and reexlain everything I just said. I needed you to acknowledge and 39:00 hold and verbally restate what I just said so that I know that you heard me. 39:06 And so I think that will go a long way in general, the active listening 39:10 techniques that lots of different communication teachers talk about. I 39:15 love that and you're absolutely agree with you that is one of those things in 39:18 terms of building alignment. The idea of being a good listener, being a 39:22 reflective listener, and actually participating, listening as a 39:25 participatory activity and not a passive one, I think is tremendous. I love that 39:30 so much. And what you just said, I love this. And I'm going to start applying 39:36 this Monday that is it okay if I cuz that's one of those things that honest 39:43 to goodness, Lillian, today that's something I would have used today with a 39:47 patient. I actually would have used that today and that's something I'm gonna 39:52 start incorporating. So, thank you for sharing that because I love that so 39:56 much. So, before we close, what's one thing right now as you're doing your 40:03 work, not just as a clinician, but as a coach, what's one thing you're seeing 40:07 right now in healthcare that gives you hope for our health care system and our 40:12 physicians? I would say probably is just like you 40:15 said with the medical student is really just the people right the people really 40:19 are there for all the right reasons you know no matter what role you are or 40:23 whether you're in leadership or not in leadership people are there for the 40:27 right reasons at the end of the day which is to make people better to make 40:31 the system better to be able to advance science technology delivery I mean no 40:36 matter where you are what you're doing you're there for the right reasons and I
Active Listening, Hope in Healthcare, and Closing Remarks 40:40 think the heart right the heart of healthcare really is still the backbone 40:44 of what it is and then there's always like funny incentives and structures and 40:48 errors that can happen along the way but if we focus on the people and this is 40:52 why I think the reality is probably for the I've always been a people focused 40:55 person right obviously as an educator but even this next phase of my career in 40:59 the coaching is really about developing the people because without that I mean 41:04 yes AI is going to take over some of the tasks yes we become more productive in 41:08 some ways we may become more accurate in some way may even be smarter in some 41:11 ways because we'll have the additional brain of an AI bot with us. But at the 41:15 end of the day, it's still going to be people on people, right? No matter how 41:18 you look at it. So, I think this is the people in healthcare. 41:21 >> I love that. Lillian, thank you so much for being here. This has been amazing. 41:27 If people want to reach out to you, if they want to know more about your 41:30 healthcare coaching, if they want to know more about what you do, how best 41:34 would they reach out to you? Yes, you can email me at 41:37 hello@transforminghealthcarecoaching.com, 41:41 which I know is a little long. Or you can find me on LinkedIn. LinkedIn is my 41:44 favorite social media location. I post every single day. It's my favorite place 41:48 to be. There's lots of really great humans out there on LinkedIn. But if 41:51 you're not, we're also on YouTube. We have a podcast, Transforming Healthcare 41:54 Coaching Podcast on Apple, Spotify, YouTube. And honestly, if you want to 41:58 get closer and just kind of hang out with whatever we're up to, we actually 42:01 have a small little community called Med Thrive Connect. And I'll provide the 42:06 link for the show notes where you just sign up. You'll get free information 42:10 just on our podcasts, our live LinkedIn webinars, and just get close so you know 42:15 what cool interesting things people are doing in healthcare to help healthcare 42:18 professionals be better humans. >> That sounds incredible. And we will put 42:23 the links to all those in the show notes. Lillian, thank you so much for 42:26 being here. This has been incredible. >> Thank you so much for having me. the 42:30 work you're doing is really amazing and important because I think people don't 42:35 really realize how much communication really is what empowers majority of what 42:40 we do. Yes, we went to and studied for a long time but how I guess actualize is 42:46 the precision by which you communicate and that's why your podcast is really 42:50 amazing. I appreciate you and I appreciate the fact that we've had so 42:54 many generous people who have given their time and their talent and their 42:57 energy to helping people see into how these processes make us better doctors. 43:02 So, I appreciate you so much. Thank you. >> Thank you. 43:06 >> And for all of our peaceful warriors who joined us today on the scalpel and 43:10 sword, until next time, be at peace. >> [music] 43:16 >> Every episode is an invitation to speak, to negotiate, to choose. I'm Dr. [music] 43:23 Lee Chararma. Join the dialogue by subscribing to Scalpel and Sword. Until 43:29 next time, peaceful warriors. May your choices [music] be sharp and your voice 43:34 be even sharper. 43:39 This podcast is a reflection of lived experience and [music] research in 43:43 conflict resolution. The scalpel and sword is not intended as medical or 43:48 legal [music] guidance. For personal matters, please consult a qualified 43:52 professional.
Comments