Full Transcript Introduction to Abuse and Coercive Control 0:00 We all grew up with stranger danger, right? 0:02 Right. 0:03 93% of offenders are known to the child. 0:04 Someone they love, someone they trust, Someone their family member loves or trusts. 0:08 Less than 3% are ever arrested, convicted, and imprisoned. 0:12 Wow. 0:13 Did you experience any abuse whatsoever at all? 0:15 No. 0:16 I mean, unless you include that I met my future husband when I was 16 years old. 0:20 And that began a pattern of abuse, which we probably could talk about. 0:24 Our expert, Dr. 0:25 Christine Pochiola. 0:27 Hey! 0:27 How are you? 0:31 Today, we're exposing the hidden layers of abuse, narcissism, and control with guest Dr. 0:36 Christine Kosciola. 0:37 As the founder and CEO of the Coercive Control Consulting Institute, she is a world-renowned expert on psychological manipulation. 0:44 Let's dive in. 0:45 You know, it's interesting talking about these things right now with this huge release of Epstein files. 0:50 Sometimes I look at it, I'm like, this can't be believable. 0:52 and we are just hearing about it now. 0:54 What is that about? 0:55 That's about people in positions of power holding that power over others. 1:00 It's quite remarkable, I think, like to think about the amount of the power perpetrators often have. 1:06 The neighbor next door who says, hey, let me watch your kids on Saturday because you have work. 1:10 Oh my gosh, that's wonderful. 1:11 He's such a great guy. 1:13 Come to find out he's an abuser. 1:14 what are some of things that people can do to try to identify these things early rather than later on in life? 1:21 Yeah, so those are. 1:29 Welcome to another episode of a healthy point of view podcast. 1:33 I'm your host, Sam Tahata, and as usual, we're bringing experts from all over the world to talk about health, wellness, beauty and mindset. 1:41 Today's guest flies all the way from that cold weather all away from etiquette. 1:48 You know what sucks? 1:48 It's cold here in Florida right now, so she's not even able to enjoy the weather the way she should. 1:54 So today's episode, we've heard a lot about abuse, narcissism, control. 2:01 Are you in one of these relationships? 2:03 You might not know. 2:05 We bring today our expert, Dr. 2:08 Christine Cochchiola. 2:10 Hey, how are you? 2:14 Doc. 2:16 Welcome to a healthy point of view podcast. 2:19 Thank you very much for having me. 2:21 And I wish you had sent the warm weather along. 2:24 It's somewhere. 2:26 Everyone here in the nation is trying to find that warm water. 2:29 Actually, I think it's in Alaska. 2:34 Alaska officially is warmer than Florida. 2:40 So awesome. 2:41 Listen, this is a topic that we haven't covered here on a healthy point of view podcast. 2:47 Your story, not just your education, but your story is very interesting because you didn't learn just from formal education going through school. 2:56 You learned from your own experience of being in an abusive relationship, et cetera, which I'll let you get into that in a minute. 3:03 But before we start any of that, we want to get to know who Dr. 3:06 Christine truly is. 3:07 And I want go way back from when you were a kid, your upbringing. 3:11 So the viewers and listeners can really understand who you are. 3:14 Absolutely, I would say what's kind of interesting is a lot of people who end up in abusive relationships, perhaps a lotta them come from abusive homes. 3:24 I had the most remarkable loving family system. 3:28 Not perfect, let's be clear, but my mom and dad celebrated their 64th wedding anniversary in October. 3:36 They had four of us. 3:37 We are all still very close and connected. 3:41 And I would say that, you know, grew up in a large city and went to Catholic school. 3:47 My parents sent us all to catholic schooling, old school traditional values. 3:53 And, it just was a small neighborhood, played kickball in the middle of the street on the weekends and whiffle ball in backyard. 4:04 We had a pool, all the neighborhood kids come over to our pool. 4:08 It was pretty amazing and beautiful. 4:11 Yeah, that's amazing. 4:12 That's almost like my family. 4:14 I'm the youngest out of four. 4:15 You know, mom and dad are still together, you know.
Dr. Christineu2019s Background and Early Advocacy 4:17 Grew up in the Catholic Church Midwest. 4:21 Same thing. 4:21 Nice, beautiful neighborhood. 4:23 So I get it. 4:24 And I understand that. 4:27 Let's talk a bit about how your work began in this industry that you're in right now, because you actually initially started as a social worker, 4:37 correct? 4:38 Yes, I am a social worker still, but I became an advocate at the age of 19 for a local umbrella agency, a domestic abuse sexual assault agency. 4:49 What made you do that at that age? 4:50 I mean, that's young. 4:51 It's a great question. 4:52 So actually at age 11 I found out that my mother had been abused as a child and I was so angry. 5:02 I Was so floored that the world actually we lived in a world where adults could get away with harming children would not be arrested would Not actually 5:15 have consequences And I just, I think my mom and dad expected me to say, okay, thank you for letting me know. 5:23 What they didn't expect is that it literally lit a fire in me that I was going to spend my life. 5:28 And, and I knew that at age 11, that this was something really important to me, That I couldn't believe children could suffer abuse in a family system. 5:38 Yeah. 5:40 That's something Now did you experience any abuse whatsoever at all in high school or any of the teenage years outside of home? 5:48 No, I mean unless you include that I met my future husband when I was 16 years old and that began a pattern of abuse which we probably could talk about 5:59 but yeah, no overall I I Thought I was living a, you know, a pretty good life. 6:04 My parents were super strict and I hated that they were superstrict and, but yeah, no, at 19 I said, I want to be a volunteer for this agency and actually 6:17 spoke out against child pornography on the steps of Waterbury, Connecticut City Hall before the internet had opened up this world. 6:25 It was called the White Ribbon Campaign, and there I was at 19 or 20 standing on the steps talking about how child pornography, 6:33 which we now call child sexual abuse images, was so horrifying. 6:38 And little did I know what the internet would unfold, as you know, Sam. 6:43 Yeah. 6:44 So, you know, it's interesting talking about these things right now, especially, with this huge release of the Epstein files. 6:51 You see all of this of what's really being unpackaged. 6:56 And it sometimes I look at it and say, this can't be believable. 7:01 Yeah. 7:04 I would say that it relates back to why you brought me on to the podcast. 7:10 it's this concept of coercion and control. 7:14 It's the concept that when I have power, when i have fame, or when have fortune, that I can coerce people into doing things that they really don't want 7:27 to do. 7:28 And of course, power being the primary source of that. 7:32 And then I think of these these young girls who were so harmed and were hearing more and more. 7:39 I mean, it's like literally it was a whole sex trafficking ring and so many powerful people. 7:47 were included in this sex trafficking ring and we are just hearing about it now and when we're just learning about what is that about? 7:54 That's about people in positions of power holding that power over others. 8:02 It's quite remarkable, I think, to think about the amount of the power perpetrators often have. 8:10 Right, and that's a level of power that is being utilized in a very abusive manner. 8:15 I mean, in an abusive matter that it's just not right at any type of level. 8:21 So now you as a professional, specializing in this type particular issues and topics, What are you feeling? 8:34 What're you seeing? 8:36 How are handling it? 8:37 Because your mind works completely different than everybody else who's on the news, talking about it, everyone who is complaining, 8:42 people that are protesting. 8:43 Your mind goes in different places and you're looking at certain behaviors and everything else. 8:48 So I wanna tap into that. 8:49 What is going on in your with this whole thing? 8:52 Yeah, so that's a great question. 8:55 I think that we're missing a very important part of the puzzle. 9:01 We do this thing in society where we wait for someone to perpetrate, and then perhaps we hold them accountable. 9:09 93% of offenders, child sexual abuse offenders are known to children. 9:12 They're not a stranger.
Recognizing Grooming, Red Flags, and Control 9:19 And we all grew up, I know you're probably younger than me, but we grew with stranger danger, right? 9:24 93% of offenders are known to the child, someone they love, they trust, their family member loves or trusts. 9:30 Less than 3% are ever arrested, convicted, and imprisoned. 9:35 Wow. 9:37 Because we live in a world where we have always assumed that children lie about abuse, right? 9:43 They're making up a story. 9:44 And what do perpetrators do? 9:46 We call it DARVO. 9:49 They typically deny, attack, and reverse the victim and the offender. 9:56 We see this all the time. 9:58 Rape is a really great example, right? 9:59 Like a woman is like what she was wearing, where she, was what, she drinking versus what did he do? 10:06 Right. 10:06 Right? 10:07 And so, and so one of the things about Epstein that a lot of people aren't familiar with, there was a case that his case was getting like exposed in Arizona 10:16 and he knew the governor of Arizona. 10:18 And they were able to protract the case long enough so that the victims that were going to be on that trial would be older. 10:26 So this is like the power, right, that ends up happening. 10:30 And so when I think about coercive control, I thing about it as the underpinning of all abuse. 10:38 We have this really faulty ideology, this archaic way of looking at abuse and we assume that there's going to be evidence of the abuse, 10:49 physical evidence. 10:51 Even when children used to disclose 20, 30 years ago, even maybe 10 years, ago they would go to the doctor and the Doctor would look for physical evidence. 11:00 But the bruises and something right, something along that line. 11:04 And when we think about the parts of the body that are impacted by abuse, in particular, let's say child sexual abuse. 11:12 It's like the inside of your mouth. 11:15 It heals within 24 hours. 11:18 So if I disclose to you on Thursday and this happened to me on Sunday, there's not going to be evidence. 11:25 And so we used to think children lied about this and abusers had power to control the narrative. 11:32 And then, of course, if anyone believed the child, the abuser would point the finger at the children and say they were a liar. 11:39 They were making it up. 11:41 And this goes back to your original question. 11:43 When I'm looking at this Epstein case, all of the cases, it's a grooming process. 11:51 abusers do not show up, I have a TEDx, it's gotten lots of views on Course of Control, and I say abusors don't show with signs saying I'm an abuser. 12:03 The problem we have in society is that we are looking for a sign that someone is an abuser instead of looking at the grooming tactics they are using to abuse. 12:16 So I wanna dive deeper into that because I think that's what a lot of the listeners and viewers are gonna wanna really hear because that like the meat 12:22 and potatoes here. 12:23 Now, I want you, before we get into the define what course of control truly is, right? 12:31 Because when people hear, Anything about abuse, right? 12:36 They always how you say that you just said that the physical signs, someone grabbing you hurting you, smacking you doing something physically, 12:45 but there's a mental portion to it. 12:47 There's an emotional component to. 12:49 It there are other things that. 12:50 You don't see. 12:51 So can you give us what that definition is of that course of control? 12:56 Sure, Dr. 12:57 Evan Stark, he advanced the term. 13:00 But to give a little clarity around it, I would just let your listeners know that Albert Biderman started researching coercion in the Korean War. 13:08 And he was looking at men who were imprisoned with prison guards and how they could slowly lose their autonomy, their agency, 13:20 and actually admit to crimes they had never committed. 13:23 We're talking about grown military men, right? 13:26 And so what we know that course of control is an eroding away, a stripping away of my agency, my autonomy, and my ability to really know what I should know. 13:39 And so I see, I take it a step further. 13:42 I think coercive control is the underpinning of all abuse. 13:47 You think about child abuse, you think of racism, sexism. 13:52 It's all about one person or one group of people exerting power and control over another person, or another group people. 14:03 And we can look at, a Catholic priest scandal, It's about a person or groups of people exerting their position in society to harm and to silence others, 14:18 right? 14:19 And so the interesting part about it is that you often, Dr. 14:23 Stark used to say, it's like carpenter ants devouring the foundation of a house. 14:28 You don't even know what's happening until it' too late. 14:32 It's like it happens around you. 14:35 And you live in a world where you are gaslit, you're manipulated, You are intimidated. 14:45 You're isolated. 14:47 It also includes financial abuse. 14:50 Usually victims and survivors might be on a budget or they might get a reward for doing the act, whatever the acts are, right? 14:58 Or they might lose their housing, or they may get housing if they do the thing that they're supposed to do. 15:05 So it's like a bribe in some ways, right? 15:08 And that's the manipulation. 15:10 Oftentimes when victims leave, in particular with intimate relationships, when a victim decides that she can see the abuser for who they are, 15:19 as soon as the abuse knows that the've been exposed in the course of control often intensifies. 15:26 This is why we know victims and survivors suffer more abuse once they leave. 15:33 Oh, wow. 15:34 So we say leave, we tell, you know, will believe you. 15:38 We say, why did you stay so long? 15:41 Me, right? 15:41 Why did we stay? 15:42 So long because I knew there would be retaliation so intense when I left. 15:48 that the fear of leaving, and Dr. 15:50 Stark talked about that, he opened one of the first shelters in the country, in New Haven, Connecticut. 15:57 And he and his wife, Annie, opened it. 15:59 They said that victims would come with bruises or whatever, they would say the worst part was the fears of what would next. 16:11 And that, when you think about that. 16:12 Think about a child who's abused. 16:15 Isn't the fear about what's gonna happen next, if they tell, isn't that fear that they're not gonna be believed or how the abuser is going to be so angry 16:25 with them or maybe take away their mother's housing. 16:29 You know, the threats are always there. 16:33 In the case of the clients, I work with a variety of clients but many of my clients are protective parents. 16:41 They are people who have tried to escape an abusive relationship and that's when abusers will weaponize the children. 16:49 And they will use the legal system to keep someone engaged in the process so that they can actually retain the control So I mean, 17:00 to finish up, I would just say the thing that people don't realize is that abuse starts off feeling good. 17:10 Abuse is certainly an experience of feeling like someone's your soulmate, feeling they're doing wonderful things for you. 17:19 The neighbor next door who says, hey, let me watch your kids on Saturday because you have work. 17:24 Oh my gosh. 17:25 Like, that's wonderful. 17:25 Thank you so much. 17:26 He's such a great guy. 17:27 Come to find out he's an abuser. 17:29 So abusers don't show up with signs telling us. 17:34 Right. 17:35 Number one, it's a very scary thing, right? 17:39 Because you kind of go into an abusive relationship regardless if it is an intimate relationship or that neighbor without knowing, 17:47 you go into it blindly. 17:49 So what are some of the things that people can do to try to identify these things early rather than later on in life? 17:57 Yeah, so those are red flags. 18:00 And in a perfect world, we would be teaching every single child from early on what are boundaries? 18:09 What are things that adults shouldn't ask of you, right? 18:14 Like an adult should never ask you to keep a secret. 18:17 An adult never should say to you oh, just try it. 18:21 That's not appropriate. 18:23 And an adults should not ask for your help. 18:25 A adult doesn't a child for help, and so giving children agency like a toolbox where they know what to say and do in these circumstances And as they develop,
Weaponizing Children and Family Court Abuse 18:38 giving young people an understanding that when someone falls madly in love with you and then starts saying things even like, 18:48 you sure you want to go out with your girlfriends on Friday? 18:51 Don't you miss me? 18:53 Or wouldn't you rather just stay home and snuggle with me? 18:57 And so when someone starts to take away the things in your life that matter to you or that mattered to before, that's a red flag. 19:09 When someone, maybe you look at their phone and you have a question about something that's on their, phone, and instead of them answering you what's in 19:18 their phones, why that purchase or why the other person's phone number is in there phone. 19:23 Instead of answering, you they say, what are you doing looking at my phone? 19:28 They say oh you're looking my my just like I looked at your phone you trying to get back at me. 19:34 They gaslight, they change the reality. 19:37 They don't take responsibility. 19:40 Yeah. 19:41 Now, that's one of the things that you mentioned that, you know, I've seen a lot of recent content about like what guys should be doing, 19:49 what girls should we do and how, women shouldn't really have guy friends because guys have a certain type of intention. 19:57 And one things you brought up is like the female, a guy telling the females like don' hang out with your girlfriend. 20:04 And what I want to do is provide certain type of clarity. 20:07 Be some of the content that I've seen recently is like should should a married woman or someone in a serious relationship be going out with their girlfriends 20:16 to a nightclub, staying out until three o'clock in the morning, partying, drinking and being in this environment that makes the other guy uncomfortable, 20:24 you know, because that that could be a situation similar to that. 20:27 What would be your opinion on that? 20:29 Yeah, I mean, here's the key. 20:35 Is there reciprocity in our relationship where if I'm doing it, you can do it and it's fine. 20:41 If we have decided mutually that we're both gonna do these types of things and neither one of us is gonna have a problem with it. 20:49 And it is our choice, no one's forcing me to do. 20:52 Right. 20:54 then that's fine. 20:55 I mean, that is the difference. 20:57 What happens in these relationships is one person can do it and the other person cannot. 21:02 Right? 21:02 That makes sense. 21:03 Yeah. 21:04 And so that hugely problematic and that always, like I say to people, is your relationship equal? 21:11 Yeah Are you contributing just as much money financially as they are? 21:15 Maybe you don't make as money. 21:16 Are contributing the percentage that you can in relationship to their percentage? 21:24 Are each on the same budget? 21:26 Each of you has X amount of dollars a week. 21:29 You each have the amount. 21:31 Is someone dictating to you what you cannot and cannot purchase? 21:37 You know, it's about reciprocity and mutuality and equality. 21:43 Yeah. 21:43 I think that's the missing part with a lot of the stuff that I've been watching, is that equality, you know? 21:48 Making sure. 21:49 It's something that you both have to agree on. 21:51 Like if you agree, hey, we both shouldn't be in that environment, then you should both respect that. 21:56 That's right. 21:57 So I that is very important. 21:59 You know you're talking about how the children and a lot of these type of relationships. 22:05 They get weaponized against the other partner. 22:09 And I'll tell you, working at the fire department for 12 years I've been retired for almost seven or eight years now. 22:15 But firemen and police officers, for some reason here in Florida, teachers have the highest divorce rates. 22:21 Right. 22:21 So I saw a lot of these guys go through, I mean, some serious, a, lot, of trauma, right. 22:29 In these different divorces that they were going through. 22:32 Not just guys, but even some of the women that were working with me. 22:35 And one of the things that bothered me the most is when the other parent would weaponize these children against them because I feel like the kids really 22:43 got to stay. 22:45 You got keep the kid out of it. 22:46 Like they shouldn't be exposed to all of this trauma. 22:49 I mean, this really can really hurt a child. 22:52 Long term, I mean the childhood trauma will stick with you for years after years, and you have to then you'd have the work on it have breakthroughs and, 23:00 you know, really work in the Childhood Trauma in your 40s, 50s sometimes, so I want to dabble into that because. 23:08 You've experienced this, right? 23:10 You actually were in one of these relationships for 27 years and 11 months. 23:16 And then you had X amount of years before that because you were with them since you're 16. So I want to talk about your story and about how that was when 23:26 your own children were being weaponized against you. 23:28 Yeah. 23:29 I have to say, I don't think there's anything more heartbreaking than losing a child when you never actually did anything to lose the child, 23:40 right? 23:40 Losing a relationship. 23:42 But the other side to that, and I'm a clinical social worker and studied this in my doctoral degree, is the others side of that is that secure attachment 23:54 is vital to healthy development. 23:57 And when a child is made to hate one parent over another, it is a significant psychological trauma. 24:06 It changes their life, as you just mentioned, forever. 24:11 When a parent is an abuser and there's evidence of an abuse, and this is where it gets a little dicey, right? 24:19 Let's just say that you're divorcing and you don't get along and kind of hate each other because maybe one person had an affair and whatever, 24:29 but no one is an abuser, right? 24:32 No one purposefully gaslighting, manipulating, intimidating, taking you to court 500 times. 24:40 We have Jennifer Dulos in our state, that infamous case where he was taking her back to So, the court system itself, by the way, 24:51 is unfortunately often colluding, because there's money to be made in these divorces. 24:56 There's so much money. 24:57 The attorneys, all of them. 24:59 Yes, we call it the divorce industrial complex, actually. 25:04 Come on, winning. 25:05 They win. 25:06 If you stay in court, then they win, right? 25:09 And so what happens in these situations, again, if we don't get along, than at least we want the children to have a healthy, 25:17 secure attachment to each of us. 25:20 Unless one person is an abuser. 25:22 Then game over, in my opinion. 25:24 And that's when it's a little bit tricky, because it is hard for the childen to actually recognize that one parent might be an abusive, 25:31 So in my particular case, I thought I was married to a great dad and relatively decent husband, wasn't perfect. 25:39 But then when I began to recognize what was going on and the multiple affairs, et cetera, and I started to pull away, that's when the coercive control 25:51 of the children intensified. 25:53 So abusers will actually coerce the child into a false narrative about the safe parent So, you know, I was framed and that's one of my books is called 26:05 framed woman in the family court underworld I Was framed as unstable that I? 26:11 Was off my meds the one the there was one incident where I caught him having an affair I took the kids to my parents for the weekend and he knew where 26:20 was I picked up the kid I said we're going to mom my mom and dad's and then he started calling and saying he's gonna call the police for me kidnapping 26:28 my children and He got on the phone with my father and started screaming at my dad. 26:32 This is someone he had known our entire life. 26:35 He couldn't control me, you understand, right? 26:37 And so then eventually he figured out that if he played nice, which is what abusers do, it's called, I think you had Dr. 26:44 Nadine Macaluso on your show. 26:45 It's trauma bonding, he threw in some intermittent reinforcement. 26:49 And this is happened with Albert Biderman in the coercion chart he created in 1957. The prisoners of war would be given, 26:57 after starving for five days, a piece of bread. 27:00 Well, now the prison guard's your friend. 27:03 Instead of the enemy, they become your friends, right? 27:06 Or you're cold on a concrete floor and they throw you a pillow. 27:10 All of a sudden, you make nice with the person who actually has been harming you over and over again. 27:17 You know, we call it entrapment. 27:19 Feminist psychologists in the early 1970s called it psychological warfare because it literally, like, F's with your brain. 27:27 Like, you can't figure out what's real and what not real anymore. 27:30 And my abuser started saying, just come home. 27:34 We'll go to therapy. 27:35 we'll get better, et cetera. 27:36 Now, he was the one who had the affair with a good friend of ours. 27:40 So I go home and when I teach college full-time, when i went to teach my course that afternoon, I brought them home, brought the children home. 27:49 Went off to teacher my courses. 27:50 He's going to call a therapist. 27:52 We're going get better. 27:52 Fast forward eight years when there was an incident between him and my daughter and I said to her, it was a very toxic incident, 28:04 and i said, When did this start? 28:07 And she said when she was nine. 28:10 She remembers the day and the hour, and it was that day where he started saying, your mother's the cheater, she's off her meds, 28:18 you can't trust her, come to me for everything. 28:22 Yeah, so imagine telling a nine year old who had a really secure attachment. 28:28 An attachment is really hard to break, but it can be fractured. 28:33 And so you take a 9 and a 10 year-old, my son was 10, over and over again for eight or nine years, those children start to have contempt. 28:43 They don't trust you. 28:44 We call it betrayal trauma. 28:46 The are betrayed by the abuser because they know the abuse has so much power. 28:51 And if they go against the abusers, they're afraid. 28:55 So they don. 28:57 Then they are told that you're a betrayer. 29:00 You can't be trusted. 29:01 Your off your meds. 29:03 you yell all the time. 29:04 Like they create a false narrative. 29:07 I mean it sounds like that psychological warfare. 29:11 I'm just sitting here listening to you and I feel like I am going crazy thinking about it. 29:16 It's really incredible and it's happening a lot. 29:20 And I think, you know I will go back to an earlier question you have, who are these people? 29:25 Like who these abusers? 29:26 And the problem is, is that if I show up in a suit and tie, If I'm the guy down the road, I don't know, the fireman, plumber, 29:36 school counselor, and everybody thinks I am a decent person. 29:40 No one would believe that I covertly trying to take away the attachment, malicious fracturing of attachment. 29:50 Take away attachment my child has with their safe parent. 29:53 And you know what that's a remedy for. 29:56 It's a remedy to either be involved in an abusive relationship, it's recipe for a recipe to be in abusive relationships or to sadly be on the trajectory 30:07 towards becoming a narcissistic abuser. 30:10 Becoming a coercive controller, becoming someone who needs to control their environment so much that they will do it covertly in a way that no one in the 30:22 world would ever suspect. 30:24 Let me ask you this, those abusers, do you think they know that they're an abuser? 30:31 You know, this is a great question. 30:33 I think that initially my perspective is that what I have seen is if I'm a child who has lived in a family system, probably born with the traits, 30:45 let's be honest, people are born a little bit more, lets say, fragile. 30:50 and more susceptible to behaving this way. 30:54 But then you put them in a family system where they don't actually securely attach. 31:01 And secure attachment is based on one major thing. 31:05 What's that? 31:05 The ability to authentically be myself. 31:10 Mm. 31:12 That comes with unconditional love. 31:15 So it's like authenticity can only occur if I'm loved without conditions. 31:19 You can do whatever you want, I still love you. 31:22 I may be upset that you broke the glass or the vase, but I love no matter what. 31:28 Yeah, that's amazing. 31:31 Yes, exactly. 31:32 And so when I grow up in a home where I can't be myself, I have to be careful of what I say to dad or mom. 31:44 Maybe I'm shamed if I cry. 31:46 I am a little boy and I was shaming if cried. 31:49 A boy who is not allowed to have emotion. 31:52 Or I a girl who's not to allowed be angry. 31:55 And so all of those things are occurring to me in childhood and then the behaviors that are concerning become fortified because I learned I had to hide myself. 32:06 I can't be me. 32:08 And the more I hide myself, I call it the fortress of shame.
Dark Tetrad Traits and Why Abuse Escalates 32:13 I'm ashamed of who I am. 32:15 My parents don't like me, they don' love me unconditionally. 32:19 So I have to hide. 32:20 The older I get, the better I'll get at hiding myself. 32:24 As I age, I no longer actually see it as hiding myself, I'm no long in a position of I am doing something wrong to answer your question. 32:40 I kind of in delusional state where I not doing anything wrong. 32:44 This is me and if you don't like it, too bad. 32:49 And so that fortress of shame becomes so thick and then you marry that person. 32:56 and they're the lawyer in town that everybody loves. 33:00 They're even a prosecuting attorney. 33:03 And they are doing really great work. 33:05 Then you try to divorce them. 33:09 You're trying to penetrate that fortress of shame. 33:11 How dare you? 33:12 Oh, don't you dare. 33:13 I am gonna now retaliate. 33:16 And we're seeing this more and more. 33:18 That's why I'm good friends. 33:20 One of my dear friends and colleagues is Dr. 33:22 Ramani Diversola. 33:22 She's a narcissistic abuse expert in the world. 33:25 We talk about how there's trajectory of these problem behaviors. 33:31 The person who actually has these traits of coercive control is not only narcissists, but Machiavellian. 33:41 What does that mean? 33:43 Yeah. 33:44 Highly manipulative. 33:46 Manipulative of systems. 33:49 It's go to court and performative. 33:54 The judge loves you, right? 33:56 The police come and you're like, yeah, she was really angry and, you know, She just lost her mind. 34:00 So that's what happened here. 34:01 Oh, wow. 34:02 Right. 34:03 And so it's that Darvo. 34:04 it is the deny, attack, reverse, victim and offender. 34:08 Poor me. 34:09 I'm the victim, that's the perpetrator when actually that person is the perpeter and they're so good at it because they are not losing their mind because 34:20 their children aren't talking to them. 34:22 They're not loosing their minds because of losing the house. 34:25 they actually are retaining the control. 34:27 Victims are losing there mind, because there losing house, there children, all their friends, the false narrative is going on. 34:34 And so it's narcissism, Machiavellianism. 34:38 The fourth is psychopathy. 34:40 It's a dark tetrad. 34:42 We haven't connected it to abuse in this way, but all of us working in the field see this with all the worst abusers. 34:52 Its psychophathy, I'm willing to break the law. 34:55 I am willing. 34:57 And this is the thing that victims don't realize is that if they think they're being stalked, they are being You know, it's not hard, 35:04 as you know to, right? 35:06 I mean, in this world, you can tag somebody's phone easily. 35:09 You can take someone's car easily, no one would ever know. 35:13 So stalking is illegal in all 50 states, but if it your intimate partner, the police don't respond. 35:18 Why is that? 35:19 because it's a civil issue. 35:25 It's the civil, you guys just aren't getting along. 35:28 And so the third one is psychopathy where I'm willing to break the law or probably already am breaking the laws. 35:34 The fourth one, and I see this with all of my clients, is sadism. 35:40 I actually like to see you suffer. 35:43 I want you to suffer. 35:45 You're gonna suffer because you exposed me. 35:48 And I'm not gonna be exposed. 35:50 I am gonna do whatever I can to turn this around. 35:53 So many victims of abuse are suffering these types of harm. 36:01 This is very prevalent. 36:03 Yeah, and we're seeing a lot more of that. 36:05 And I think because of the digital world that we live in, a lots more exposure is coming out. 36:10 You know, you're seen a lotta celebrities, lot of politicians, lotta people in these powerful positions, as you mentioned earlier. 36:17 But everything that you just mentioned, those four things, You're seein' it in this individuals. 36:24 Connecting the dots with it. 36:26 Yeah. 36:26 Absolutely. 36:27 If you don't pull back on this charge you're trying to charge me with, then I'm going to do this to you. 36:33 I mean, there's always this imminent threat and it might be a quiet threat. 36:38 It doesn't have to be an aggressive threat, right? 36:40 It can be very covert, but there is always knowing. 36:46 We hear stories, right? 36:47 Like the mafia or whatever. 36:49 I mean, this is the kind of behavior that is going on, sadly, in these circumstances where victims know they will suffer considerably. 36:59 My ex used to say to me, the kids will never love you. 37:03 You'll never have custody. 37:05 Go ahead and leave. 37:06 It doesn't matter. 37:08 Would you label that as a neurological and psychological impact when you lose that autonomy? 37:17 You lose an autonomy very gradually, right? 37:19 It's not something that's like overnight. 37:21 It is a slow erosion. 37:24 We call it a multifaceted strategic intentional plan. 37:29 I will slowly erode your autonomy. 37:31 If I took it away right away, you'd be like, what are you doing? 37:34 If I take it away slowly and I make you think there's something wrong with you It's like that movie Gaslight from the 1938 film where he Ingrid Bergman's 37:44 in it and and the abuser starts turning down the lights in the house and tells her she's crazy when she sees the Lights getting turned down and it's all 37:53 because he's trying to get her jewelry Yeah, so so You know, one thing that I've heard you talk about is that family courts are becoming dangerous, 38:05 you know? 38:07 And that it's really changed in the past 20 years that you've been seeing this stuff with your profession. 38:15 Can we talk that? 38:16 What is it that's happening in this family court system? 38:20 So we used to have something called the tender years doctrine, which back in a day when men worked full time and women were stay at home, 38:30 they would divorce, and the expectation was that the mother would stay with the children, right? 38:34 I mean, we didn't have a lot of divorces, but when we did, it was up to the woman to take care of the kids, all right. 38:40 But then with women's lib and women working more, there was an understanding that if I divorce someone, I'm going to have to pay child support and or alimony, 38:52 so I want 50-50. 38:54 Now, many dads deserve 50-50, right? 38:57 Many deaths are good deaths, no question about it. 39:00 But the problem is that now that initiative has taken over when safety is a concern. 39:08 That's the problems. 39:10 I always use the example of, let's just say that I worked, and this is like something that we're so far away from, but in a perfect world for me, 39:18 from a psychological perspective relating to children, if I work 80% of the time, in the city and my partner was home 80% of the time and we divorced. 39:30 My partner should get 80 percent of custody because the attachment is with my partners. 39:37 But what we do is we just assume it's 50-50. 39:41 So we take children who were spending most of their time maybe with mom or dad and just take it all away And we go week on week off. 39:50 Could you imagine going a week not seeing your mother when you were five years old or eight years? 39:53 That would be crazy. 39:54 Right. 39:54 Yeah. 39:55 But we're doing it because family court does not understand the developing brain. 40:00 All right. 40:00 And they don't take into consideration the trauma of pulling a child away from something that is a secure attachment, whether it's the father or the mother. 40:10 Yes. 40:11 Listen, I've even seen some fathers that end up getting that 50 50. and they don't know what to do with themselves because they've never actually spent 50% 40:18 of the time with the kids. 40:19 Their whole life has to get adjusted. 40:21 And I've seen fathers where they really don' even want it 50-50, but they get stuck with it. 40:26 So I hear with what you're saying. 40:28 Sometimes taking the 50 50 means that I don have to pay child support, so there's a monetary gain, right? 40:35 And that's problematic because kids are not objects to be exchanged like an exchange, So what can you tell me about high spectrum abusers? 40:46 What is that? 40:48 High spectrum of users. 40:50 So I'm thinking, um, that you're talking about, are you talking to autism spectrum? 40:56 Like, yeah, something of that nature, you know, Yeah, okay. 41:02 Well, I think that, well, let's start with this. 41:06 One of the things that happens a lot is that abusers will get misdiagnosed or self-diagnoes. 41:16 They will say, Well the reason why I told you that happened when this happened or the reasons why didn't come home on time and I thought I'd told but I 41:26 actually didn' tell you was because I have ADHD. 41:29 or I'm a high functioning person on the spectrum and therefore I get a little obsessed about things and that's why I keep asking you where you're going 41:38 and who you are going out with. 41:39 This is what the pattern of behavior is. 41:42 A lot of abusers will get diagnosed with bipolar, which is like highs and lows. 41:50 What I would just say is that There is no excuse for abuse. 41:57 There's no diagnosis that should supersede a person's behavior when they're being abusive. 42:05 And a lot of times what victims do is they stay and they want to help the person. 42:13 She's on the spectrum so I'm going to stay and help her or she's got ADD and that's why she does these things instead of actually looking at the pattern 42:24 of behavior that is diminishing you in this relationship. 42:28 Right. 42:29 Yeah. 42:30 Doc, let me ask you, when it comes to male and female, what's the percentage look like with female abusers versus male abusors in these relationships? 42:40 That's a great question. 42:42 So I just did a training last week in Arizona to court professionals, and there's always this conversation about there is a lot of female abuser, 42:52 my clientele they'll say is males and females. 42:56 And I run a men's support group. 43:01 There are men who suffer abuse, there's no doubt about it. 43:04 But 35% of women suffer violence in their lifetime. 43:09 Those are the physically, the sexually or physically violent cases. 43:14 My question is, how many of them are suffering non-physical forms of abuse? 43:19 It's all coercive control, and we don't even know it, probably 70%. and how many children are growing up in these homes. 43:27 I'll give you another stat. 43:28 90% of violent crimes occur by men, okay? 43:32 So we are not saying that men... 43:34 I don't say that man are victims, but I just think that the scale is a little bit this way. 43:40 And I would say going back to your family core in the systems, when we think about all of the system in world, you know, 43:46 we just had Roe v. 43:47 Wade overturned, right? 43:49 We live in a society that is based on norms created by white men. 43:56 Right. 43:57 The courts are set up by White men, the criminal justice system is set by a White man, right? 44:01 I mean, churches set-up by the White Men. 44:03 We can go on and on, and so those patriarchal systems are in place and are oppressive to everyone else, including women. 44:13 And so men are victims. 44:15 However, I will also say that, you know, my ex is an abuser, but one time when the police came and I had called them, he told them I was an abused. 44:27 And I hadn't abused him. 44:28 Thank God there were cameras. 44:30 But the point is, is that lots of times abusers will claim victimhood even when they're not. 44:38 So it's, I think just in general, there has to be an understanding that the systems are not set up equitably, going back to equity. 44:48 They're not setup equitebly. 44:49 Women are treated differently than men, and boys are treat differently then girls. 44:55 That's good and bad, meaning little boys aren't treated with the dignity that they deserve in our society. 45:02 Their actually groomed to behave a certain way that society expects of them, and little girls are too. 45:11 It's problematic. 45:13 Why are we creating a space where children can't be their authentic selves? 45:20 Whatever that is, cry when they want to, get angry when the want too, why are not allowing for that? 45:28 And so the problems start very early on that creates the misogyny that we continue to see. 45:37 So if someone catches themselves in one of these relationships, can that relationship be fixed with therapy?
Leaving Safely and Beginning Recovery 45:49 I say no. 45:51 No? 45:51 No. 45:52 No, it's really problematic. 45:55 A lot of couples will go to therapy and try to work on the relationship when someone has, I call it their character logically disordered, 46:03 right? 46:03 I think Dr. 46:03 Nate calls it the pathological lover. 46:06 I called these people once they're in the family system, predatory parents. 46:11 And so that person needs to retain control. 46:15 They might show up to the therapy acting like they want to get healthy. 46:20 But I'm going to return to, is the relationship equal? 46:24 I am going return, to has there been a pattern of behavior to diminish you? 46:28 A pattern is one more than one. 46:31 If you sit there and we're having an argument one day and you call me a stupid whatever, and I say, please don't call that anymore. 46:37 I don' appreciate it. 46:38 And you continue to call to me that. 46:40 That's a patterns of verbal assaults. 46:42 Right, right. 46:44 What happens is people hold on to the good. 46:48 The dinners out a family vacation. 46:50 I don't know the bills getting paid you know food on the table, I mean some of I used to work for child welfare some victims are just desperate to be able 46:59 to keep their lights on and they stay in abusive relationships so. 47:06 For me, there are very few, and we know this from research, plenty of research. 47:12 Abusers are drawn towards conflict. 47:15 So when a victim tries to leave, it's going to get worse. 47:18 Yet we tell them to live all the time. 47:20 But also, that there're very situations, its called situational violence, where someone has one episode of being bad. 47:29 Whether its physical, sexual violence or its verbal assaults, whatever it is, the gamut. 47:37 They have one incident and then they're really sorry. 47:39 And they go and get help and they actually get better. 47:44 Those cases are literally less than 1%, if at all. 47:50 Wow. 47:51 Every time we say to a victim, maybe he'll get The reality is we're giving a victim hope when there is no hope. 47:59 And that intensifies the trauma bond. 48:02 When the world says, oh, come on, she's a great provider or he's great. 48:06 Provider. 48:07 Oh, Come on. 48:07 He's. 48:08 A great dad. 48:09 Why would you leave him? 48:10 You're going to lose everything if you. 48:12 Leave him. 48:13 Society supports the negative narrative. 48:18 How does the. 48:21 Your spiritual belief get into this. 48:24 Not you in particular, but other people, right? 48:26 Because I'm a believer, I am a Christian, and the Bible says differently, all right. 48:31 So my mom used to say, God doesn't make junk. 48:35 She used say that, then she realized who I was married to. 48:39 And she realize that after multiple times of trying to forgive and going back, that actually she was the one who said to me, 48:47 i'm disappointed in you that you haven't left him yet. 48:49 Oh wow. 48:50 And so she was a church going woman, Christian, she died several last month with her rosary beads on her chest. 48:59 She was the person who was God loving and I believe that evil exists. 49:08 And the evil exists in people that are walking around us every day and we don't even know that they are bad people. 49:16 And so there's some people who will never heal. 49:20 It's because of the traits that were born with. 49:24 Like I said, they were a little more fragile. 49:26 Then they were born into a family system where they couldn't actually receive all of this unconditional love and the ability to be authentically themselves. 49:36 They create this wall around themselves and they have to protect that wall. 49:42 And so, sadly, when children grow up in abusive homes, they're growing up and that same inability to This is an intergenerational trauma that is could 49:55 be cured if we kept children safe. 50:00 So what's the solution for someone who catches himself in that relationship? 50:05 What do they do? 50:08 Yeah, well, first of all, you don't tell the abuser you're leaving. 50:10 Never. 50:11 You get everything in place first. 50:14 You plan on losing a lot financially. 50:17 you just plan. 50:18 On it, you plan, on giving up some of what you really hoped to have, whether it's the house. 50:26 I mean, most of my clients, none of them ever keep the. 50:29 Because the abuser often has, um, cameras in the House anyway. 50:33 Like there's just so many hidden ways to stalk someone nowadays. 50:36 The house isn't safe anymore. 50:38 Right. 50:38 So you plan on what you're going to give up, and then you consider what your going gain. 50:45 And frankly, Dr. 50:47 Stark, he passed away last year, but he called course of control a liberty crime. 50:53 and you don't even know that your liberty is being taken away. 50:56 And so one of the things you gain when you leave, when your escape, because escape is elusive, you're never done because post-separation abuse is the intensifying 51:07 of coercion and control post separation. 51:10 But one the thing you gained is your freedom in some capacity, not entirely because the abuser won't allow that, but in capacity. 51:20 The second thing that you've gained if you have children is you gain giving them the gift of perspective. 51:31 The gift they get to know you for the first time in their life, who you really are, because as a victim, you were walking on eggshells all the time, 51:40 in that home. 51:42 They were working on egg shells. 51:44 So all of a sudden, they got to be who they truly are. 51:49 with you. 51:50 And sometimes that doesn't feel good, by the way, these kids are angry. 51:53 I wrote a children's book every moment of every day to help protective parents when their children are coming home from an abuser's house or are needing 52:00 to go and they don't want to. 52:02 These kids. 52:03 Are so dysregulated. 52:05 Anxiety is the number one factor that's going on in their life because because they haven't been able to relax. 52:11 Right. 52:11 They haven.t been. 52:12 Able to be themselves. 52:15 Wow. 52:16 And so the gift of perspective is an amazing thing. 52:20 It's not easy, it takes time, but it is a gift. 52:29 With all of your experience, obviously having your doctorates in this course of field here, when someone gets out of that abusive relationship, 52:39 that controlling relationship there's a healing process that they have to go through. 52:44 This is a healthy point of view. 52:48 Give me the top three things that people should focus on to be able to heal within and get their parasympathetic system back to where it needs to, 52:56 right? 52:57 Where they're not so anxious and have the anxiety and now they are free. 53:01 What are some of the things maybe you did, to able heal yourself and be to live that healthy, very fruitful life full of vigor? 53:11 Yeah. 53:11 And we have so much research now that's showing that this complex trauma that occurs lives in the body, and it causes long-term autoimmune illnesses for people. 53:23 Sadly, the research is just starting to come out and we're starting recognize it, but I think the more and more that we realize that, 53:31 then we are going to be able to say, wait a minute, this is also impacting people physically, right? 53:37 And so some people decide that the most important thing for them to do to get healthy is to advocate, is become a social justice warrior. 53:48 And I was doing that before. 53:50 I teach on this subject every semester, did not know I'm a victim of abuse. 53:55 So I was doing this work already, but obviously I propelled it a little bit more, right? 54:00 And that became to be able to help other people heal, to to change legislation. 54:06 We've codified course of control now in nine or 10 states now, in the United States. 54:10 It's now a form of domestic abuse. 54:12 I don't have to have a bruise to get a restraining order. 54:15 Right. 54:15 Right? 54:16 So these are huge movements. 54:18 Some people, it's knowing that we have to, like we know yoga works, right? 54:24 We know that tapping works. 54:26 We that meditation works mindfulness, mindfulness. 54:29 Removing ourselves from the abusive situation as much as possible is really very healing. 54:37 I would say for me the most healing thing was when my children were turned against me as a therapist, I realized that I had to parent them differently. 54:49 And that meant looking through the lens of their own aversion and control. 54:55 And my healing came when I began to see my children heal. 54:58 When I begin to actually fortify and reignite the attachment they had with me all along, that there's nothing, as you could imagine, 55:07 better than seeing your child doing better and healing. 55:11 And it's my particular niche is to help protective parents learn the skill set to parent these children differently, even if they're going to the abuser's home. 55:22 Even if they love the abuser, how do you parent differently so your child can heal? 55:29 And in that, of course, we heal. 55:31 Right, right. 55:33 Amazing. 55:34 Doug, I'm gonna have a little fun here to get to know you even a bit better. 55:38 So one of my favorite podcasters out there is Steven Barlett with The Diary of a CEO. 55:43 He came out with these conversation cards. 55:45 I wanna have you grab that. 55:47 And you'll pull that sleeve up, and then you're gonna randomly pick a card from the middle somewhere. 55:53 You'll read the question and answer. 55:58 What would you do if you absolutely weren't afraid? 56:02 Um, what would I do? 56:10 If I absolutely wasn't. 56:14 I'd say write a book, but. 56:15 You've written a few of those. 56:17 Yes. 56:18 That would probably would have been the first thing that I would say. 56:21 Probably the, I think probably also add health to my work, physical health and wellbeing, expand my business to help people get physically healthy as they're
Healing, Parenting, and Final Takeaways 56:38 dealing with the CPTSD. 56:39 I love that. 56:40 It's so important. 56:42 Pick another one. 56:49 What have you done recently for someone else? 56:54 I just sent out my Valentine's Day cards to all of my loved ones. 56:58 Oh wow, early. 56:59 Yeah, yeah. 57:01 All right, I love that, amazing. 57:06 I like to do that for Valentine day, bake some cookies and heart shapes. 57:11 Want me to another one? 57:12 Yeah one more, one I'll say one. 57:14 One more. 57:19 Do uncomfortable situations bring the best or worst out of you? 57:23 Hmm. 57:24 Oh, that's a good one. 57:25 It is. 57:26 I'm trying to think of a really uncomfortable situation I had recently. 57:30 And I would say that it probably, um, yeah, I. 57:35 Would say. 57:36 That I think I handled it good. 57:46 I think this is an interesting conversation, and I won't go too much on the tangent here, but I would say that what happens when you've been, 57:53 one of the reasons, I have a podcast called Perfect Prey, because I thing abusers choose their victims. 58:00 And what we know about victims' character traits is that they're typically highly agreeable, people pleasing, kind-hearted, 58:08 loyal to a fault, conscientious. 58:11 They like to fix things, they like things to work. 58:15 But what that also is related to from a clinical perspective is this idea of subjugation, where in society, in general, women are subjugated at a high rate. 58:26 Like you're supposed to be a good girl. 58:28 The Catholic church religion makes you follow the rules, right? 58:33 Sometimes your family system. 58:35 And in, general women, are born to caretakers. 58:37 It's just biologically innate, So, and then what happens is when you give so much in life over and over again, you gave to your partner who's taking instead 58:49 of giving back, right? 58:50 You give to children, your family, et cetera, that there's a space between giving and resentment. 59:00 And that resentment can percolate. 59:02 And we see this with a lot of victims where they don't behave well under duress because they are so tired of being subjugated. 59:11 They're so of taking advantage of, that it's like a little perculating coffee pot and they explode. 59:18 Wow. 59:19 That's when people say, aha, look at you. 59:23 You are the problem. 59:25 when actually you weren't the problem, you just, after a period of time, were so worn down that you behaved in an uncharacteristic way. 59:36 Victims will always say to me, how do I know I'm not the abuser? 59:39 And I say, who would you be if you were in a relationship with yourself outside of this relationship? 59:44 Who would you be? 59:46 Typically they're like, I'd be happy, be good, it'd compromise, collaboration, we'd work together. 59:51 I wouldn't be angry all the time. 59:53 It wouldn' be frustrated. 59:55 And so oftentimes victims will behave pretty poorly in situations that are challenging. 1:00:03 That's the true definition of how they say, Not everyone's made to be with each other. 1:00:09 Yeah. 1:00:11 Sure. 1:00:11 And no one's been made with an abuser. 1:00:13 Absolutely not. 1:00:14 You know, and that's something that people really have to open up their eyes, their ears, all of their senses and realize when it's going that direction. 1:00:25 So Dr. 1:00:26 Christine, as we wrap up here, if one person is listening or viewing this podcast and really resonates with today's message, 1:00:36 what is that one last thing you can leave them open? 1:00:39 that if you are a person living in this situation and you're a parent, I promise you, you have so much influence. 1:00:49 Your attachment to your child can never be entirely broken. 1:00:54 And do what you can to fortify it and to reignite it. 1:00:58 That's so imperative to healthy child development, secure attachment, to you. 1:01:03 Amazing. 1:01:04 If people want to find you where can they find? 1:01:07 Coercive control consulting. 1:01:08 I'm on Instagram. 1:01:09 Dr. 1:01:09 Coach Yola course of control typically if you put in course Of control you'll find me. 1:01:13 So yeah, amazing. 1:01:16 That's a Christine. 1:01:17 Oh, she Allah. 1:01:18 It was a pleasure having you on a healthy point of view podcast I think this was extremely informative and if we can just change one person and make your 1:01:26 life better That' what it's all about. 1:01:28 Thank you. 1:01:29 You thank you so much for having me Sam Guys, you heard the doc speak You gotta be aware of these red flags. 1:01:37 Especially if you have kids, we gotta put our kids first. 1:01:42 We gotta make sure that they don't grow up in this type of trauma. 1:01:45 we have to protect them. 1:01:47 Guys, make that you take this podcast, you share it with friends and family, because it just takes one person to watch this Podcast where we could truly 1:01:58 change the trajectory of their overall life. 1:02:02 Make sure you like, share, comment, do all that fun stuff, and we'll see you for the next one.
Comments