Full Transcript Beyond Meat and the health debate 0:00 It's all new trans fats, no hormones. Makers of Beyond Meat say that they that 0:04 the product is healthier than >> Hey, well, Beyond Meat will likely price 0:07 beyond the company's initial expectations. 0:10 >> Yeah, that's >> Impressive. 0:14 >> It was billed as one of the most successful IPOs at [music] the time. 0:18 >> Beyond Meat, the best performing IPO so far this year, up 163% on day one. 0:26 >> We've never eaten soy leg hemoglobin before, and scientists just don't know 0:30 enough about it yet. >> Is it safe? 0:32 >> In health news, a number of new meatless alternatives to traditional burgers have 0:37 made headlines in recent months, but some consumers have raised questions 0:41 about what these products are made from and how nutritious they really are. 0:45 >> If you're going to say that [music] there's less risk of disease, then let's 0:49 see the clinical research. 0:55 >> Dr. Garth Davis, uh he when he's on a rant, this guy's 0:59 epic. Let's hear what he has to say. >> So, I just went to this uh restaurant uh 1:05 burger place that I go to from time to time occasionally. 1:09 You just want a burger, and uh they made Beyond Meat burgers, and I went in this 1:12 time and there's like, "Sorry, we don't carry Beyond Meat anymore. We do 1:16 mushroom burgers." Fine, thank you for giving a plant-based option. 1:20 But, of course, I had to ask, "Well, why did you get rid of the Beyond burger?" 1:24 And so, the guy was like, "Because it's not healthy." 1:28 And I said, "Hm." You're selling regular burgers, like 1:32 regular burgers. Yeah, but those are real meat. 1:35 Okay, but why is that healthier?" And he said, "Well, they're not processed." I'm 1:40 like, "Actually, they are processed, um but I get what you're saying, but it's a 1:43 burger." And um 1:46 I said, "Do you know about the Swap Meat Trial?" 1:49 Of course he hasn't. Um the Swap Meat Trial, they took um 1:53 I believe it was 30 people, but they uh put them on eight weeks of two 1:56 servings a day of either regular meat burgers or plant-based alternative, 2:00 which was Beyond Meat. And they looked at several different 2:03 cardiac factors. Now look, in 2 weeks you're not going to see a lot of changes 2:06 either way, but they actually found that there was a a big difference in a 2:09 chemical called TMAO, especially if you'd started on the meat 2:12 and then went to the plant-based burger. Um TMAO um 2:17 is a it's basically 2:20 a byproduct of a breakdown of certain things inside meat, but it has been 2:25 highly associated with heart disease. Um there was also a rise in the LDL. 2:30 This was a crossover trial, so it was the same people. For 8 weeks they ate 2:33 the regular burger, 8 weeks of Beyond Burger. Either they started with Beyond 2:36 or they started with the meat. Uh during eating meat they had substantially 2:40 higher cholesterol levels. Um and they also, believe it or not, 2:45 lost weight when they were doing the plant-based burger. Now, the burgers, 2:48 there's 280 calories in a regular burger and there's 2:51 I believe 230 calories in a Beyond Burger. Beyond Burger has a little bit 2:55 of fiber, not a lot, but 3 g. Basically, the claim that
What makes a burger healthy? 3:01 a burger is healthier than a Beyond Burger is absolutely unfounded. I mean, 3:05 completely unfounded. It's ridiculous. Now, do I think a Beyond Burger is 3:08 necessarily healthy? No, I mean, there's a lot of salt in Beyond Burgers. Um 3:12 there's not as much fiber. Um like if you're trying to get the same amount of 3:15 calories in just black beans, it'd be a cup and a half of black beans and 3:19 there'd be a lot less salt and there'd be a lot less fat. It'd be a lot more 3:22 fiber. It'd be a lot more filling. Obviously, whole foods are always going 3:24 to be healthier. But once in a while you want a maybe more 3:29 healthy, than a regular burger, or probably more healthy than a regular 3:33 burger. And uh yeah. So, I gave them a friendly 3:38 earful to my local burger place, but I don't think they bought it. 3:41 >> People don't eat burgers to be healthy. People eat burgers for delicious 3:48 indulgence fattiness 3:52 taste texture memories of childhood or experiences where you've eaten that food 3:59 and it transcends you to a time and a memory. 4:03 That's what food does. That's what burgers do, right? They They 4:09 give an ownness of indulgence. And I think that's a very important 4:15 marker to make here, right? Like nothing about a burger is healthy. Let's not 4:19 quote that. And even I mean, your black bean burger 4:24 alternative, potentially, yes. But if it's laden with vegan mayo and other 4:31 heavy saturated fats like avocado and on a burger, that can also not be the 4:36 healthiest type of burger as well, right? 4:40 But I think the biggest thing here, it kind of just it it almost gets me off 4:44 onto like what Jeffrey was talking about before. Like 4:49 has the plant-based movement lost its way and I'm like, "No, Jeffrey. This is 4:53 kind of where the plant-based movement is going, right?" What we're seeing here 4:56 is we're building indulgent-style foods like burgers and trying to invite 5:02 people in to give them a comparative value of you can still get 5:07 what you like, what you, you know, your beefy-style texture without all of the 5:12 saturated fat. Without all that extra caloric intake. 5:16 And by the way, the sodium is comparable when we take a look at what the studies 5:20 are saying, right? Because oftentimes when people are eating beef, they're 5:24 adding more salt to their home-cooked burgers, right? 5:28 So, burgers have never been about health. 5:32 >> But here's the thing, and this is something Rich Roll said in a recent 5:36 podcast episode with Simon Hill, and it's really taking off. This video is 5:40 doing really, really well. He acknowledged that these plant-based 5:45 burgers are healthier than their animal-based counterparts. But he said 5:50 one of the reasons the vegan movement suffered a few years ago is cuz these 5:53 companies were making out like they were miles ahead of the pack. They were so 5:58 much healthier. And actually, you know, these beyond I'm not talking 6:03 about, you know, the I still say the Engine 2 Diet burgers with like one 6:05 ingredient. I'm talking about, you know, Beyond Burger, Impossible Burger. Yeah, 6:09 okay, they might be a little bit healthier, but in the grand scheme of 6:12 things, they're still very, very processed. I think part of the problem 6:16 here is a messaging problem from the companies. And people just felt uh like 6:20 it was kind of disingenuous. They felt like they were being lied to. 6:22 >> When you look at Beyond Meat or Impossible Foods or Oatly, like the 6:27 stock prices of these companies are in the tank. And grocery stores that used 6:30 to have gigantic sections devoted to plant-based milks or meat and dairy 6:34 alternatives have shrunk. The appetite for these products has been reduced. And 6:39 it does have a lot to do with the way that the health benefits or health 6:43 implications of these products were communicated publicly. I think that when 6:46 you look at them, you can make the argument that they are healthier in the 6:51 wash in comparison to their animal versions of them. The communication was 6:56 presenting them as health foods, when in fact, most of them are pretty highly
Processed food, trust, and plant-based messaging 7:00 processed foods. And I think people felt gaslit a little bit, like they're being 7:04 fed a lie that was pretty transparent. And that led to a breach of trust. And I 7:10 think that contributed to people breaking up with whatever short-term 7:14 affair they had eating a more plant-predominant diet. 7:17 >> That is very interesting cuz yeah, I do remember there was a time where 7:21 everybody was eating these vegan burgers and absolutely loving life. And then the 7:25 whole ultra-processed argument came in. So, like you said, maybe it was more 7:29 just about the disparity between how much healthier they healthy are 7:34 healthier they actually are versus trying to market it, like Shabnam 7:39 said, it's just like an enjoyable thing to eat once in a while. Like I think 7:45 >> [sighs and gasps] >> Yeah, it's frustrating to me because 7:47 like I want to go to a barbecue and have a Beyond Meat burger, but even amongst 7:51 like, you know, people I know that eat meat, they'll be like, "Ooh, that's very 7:55 unhealthy." And I'm like, "You're eating a burger!" Do you know 7:59 what I mean? We're all here to eat burgers, or they're having sausages on 8:02 the barbecue, or, you know, any other amount of processed things, but for some 8:07 reason the plant-based burger is just seen as like, you know, really, really 8:12 bad. >> True, but I think that opens up a 8:14 conversation of like, how do we define healthy? What are What are the metrics 8:18 and standards of that? Are we looking at saturated fat? Are we looking at TMAO? 8:22 Are we looking at um LDL cholesterol after the consumption of 8:27 a beef-based burger versus a plant-based burger? Like, these are all 8:32 evidence and factors that we now have in our studies that can showcase that, 8:36 technically speaking, eating a plant-based burger 8:40 can be healthier than eating a meat-based counterpart, but it's not 8:44 considered a health food. So, we we can't conflate the two. Just because it 8:49 has healthier in its in its comparative value doesn't make it a health food. 8:54 Um and and that's very important to note. 8:56 >> Yeah, but that's why I find it weird when people are like, "Oh, yeah, but 8:59 it's unhealthy." whilst they're simultaneously eating a burger made of 9:02 animals. Like, we aren't talking about health foods. Anyway, I'm just like, 9:06 "Ugh." >> That was um this comment on and I know 9:10 um Sari, you're going to be talking about the comments on the Dr. Garth 9:12 Davis video, which are fascinating, but on the Rich Roll video that I mentioned, 9:17 um which was titled The Lies That Killed the Vegan Movement, one of the comments 9:21 was, "The problem was that the movement became plant-based rather than vegan. 9:26 Health trends come and go, but veganism is an ethical commitment to reducing 9:31 animal exploitation and suffering wherever practical and possible. For 9:34 many of us, it's also a spiritual practice, living in compassion, 9:38 non-violence, ahimsa, and respect for the interconnectedness of all life. 9:42 Trends fade, compassion doesn't. >> True, but that's an identity that a 9:47 majority of people in this world don't share. And so when you live on the 9:51 fringes of that bell curve, of the 1 to 2%, um 9:57 it's ideal. We'd love everybody to be there, but not everybody falls there. 10:01 Most people fall in the middle of the bell curve. And so we need to be 10:04 communicating in ways that bring them into our particular lifestyle patterns. 10:10 And to be honest, talking about animal welfare 10:15 is not a way that turns people to eating less meat sometimes. That's what we're 10:22 just finding in our research. So it's it's how do we start enticing people to 10:26 eat foods to showcase that they are comparable in taste parity 10:32 and satiety. Right? You're not sacrificing something by You're not 10:37 giving up your burger. You still get to eat that. And it's a transitional food. 10:41 It's a transitional way of thinking, and I feel like that that's 10:44 that's where the movement is going. How do we tap into not the vegans, but the 10:49 flexitarians? And so I can see how the vegans 10:54 who have fought for this movement for 11:00 eons feel a bit slighted. >> There is one comment here from a guy 11:05 Well, I actually don't know if it is a guy, from a person, um who says, "Even 11:09 the lack of heme iron should be a plus for the Beyond Burgers." But then goes 11:13 on to say, "Yet the coconut oil, the canola oil, the potassium chloride, the 11:17 methylcellulose are off-putting. For the record, I do not eat flesh and do not 11:22 miss it, but if I did, the list of highly processed ingredients would 11:25 probably make me postpone the change to a vegan diet indefinitely." 11:29 >> And again, I think this is what we were talking about earlier, like the 11:32 scientific verbage 11:36 that language doesn't fit the anecdotal story. 11:40 But if I start like giving a nursery rhyme of like what methylcellulose is 11:48 comparative to its everyday usage 11:52 people will listen. And so I I I I hear people loud and clear, but it's 11:57 frustrating. >> Hey, the other thing on this you know
Swap Meat trial results and cholesterol 12:00 this processed argument where people are saying like you know the vegan burgers 12:03 are more processed. The meat industry call their factories meat processing 12:08 plants. So even if a meat burger has one ingredient, I mean most have more, 12:13 right? Let's be honest, most meat consumed is a class one carcinogen which 12:16 causes cancer by the World Health Organization. But even if you're going 12:20 to take um 12:23 many many forms of animal products, they are reared in meat they're killed in 12:28 meat processing plants. So they are processed. Certainly way more than just 12:33 putting a few ingredient vegan ingredients together. 12:35 >> Exactly. And it has to be in some way preserved, right? Which is also a form 12:39 of processing. I mean farmers or slaughterhouse people will literally 12:43 call it processing an animal. But nobody wants to think about that because they 12:48 like their foods and they like the way things have been, you know? And we have 12:52 another comment here which is kind of casting aspersions on the conversation 12:56 about plant-based meat versus animal meat which says, "I wonder how much you 13:00 get paid to promote this. I would love to see a study comparing the fake meat 13:04 with a true carnivore or ketovore diet." >> And I'll even go back to when I sort of 13:08 got the idea. I was opening the New York Times three different times and there's 13:11 this full page ad like slamming all the new plant-based meats, saying these 13:15 things are dog food, these things are crap, these things I can't believe 13:18 people are eating them. Um maybe they're good for the 13:20 environment, but they're full of uh coconut oil for the saturated fat, 13:24 they're high in sodium, and they're ultra-processed. So your cholesterol's 13:28 going up, your blood pressure's going up, and your weight's going up. And I 13:31 thought, that's my superpower. I I do that kind of study. 13:36 That wouldn't really be that hard. I could give people a couple servings a 13:38 day of plant meat and a couple servings a day of red meat. 13:42 In fact, I bet we could deliver that. I'm not This is 8 weeks each. It's a 13:45 crossover, so everybody did both things. So, I think we enrolled 40 and 36 13:50 finished, so we have good retention. And LDL cholesterol went down, not up. 13:56 And that was pretty easy to predict, cuz yes, coconut uh fat is saturated, but 14:02 there was less saturated fat in the plant-based alternative. We said, you 14:06 know, you're on your own for the rest. We're not buying you the rest of the 14:08 food. But, we do want to say that if it's the burger and you're having a 14:12 white bun, and we don't want you to have a white bun, but if you have a white bun 14:14 in one phase, you need to have it in both phases. 14:17 And if you put on uh 14:20 uh iceberg lettuce on one, you got to put iceberg lettuce on both. But, if you 14:23 put the whole grain organic foofy bun on one, you got to put it on both. And if 14:29 you have the farmers market lettuce and tomato on one burger, you got to have it 14:34 on both. LDL cholesterol went down, not up. 14:37 Blood pressure didn't change. So, let's just do the sodium really quickly. So, 14:41 yes, the um Beyond Meat burgers have more sodium than ground beef. But, guess 14:46 what? When people get ground beef, they salt it. 14:49 And so, by the time you looked at it at the end, the sodium intake was identical 14:53 in the two groups. And the blood pressure 14:55 didn't change. We also looked at TMAO, trimethylamine oxide, which is 14:59 uh if you're on Twitter, you'll see it's a little controversial. Some people 15:02 think it's a very cool emerging new risk factor that Stan Hazen from the 15:05 Cleveland Clinic identified about a decade ago. That was our primary 15:10 outcome, and it went down in the um Beyond Meat eaters. So, 15:15 anyway, basically, that was swap meat. The things that they got trashed for in 15:18 the newspaper of getting worse didn't. They even lost weight. Not much 15:22 weight, but they lost pretty much on average they lost a pound 15:26 or two. Clinically, a pound or two is not very 15:28 relevant, but it was fascinating. Almost everyone 15:31 lost a pound or two. And so it's if it's very consistent, it 15:35 can still be statistically significant even though it's not clinically 15:38 relevant. But I kind of liked it because the story was, "Oh, because of Kevin 15:42 Hall's study, they're going to gain weight. 15:44 Because of the saturated fat, their cholesterol go up. 15:47 Because of the sodium, their blood pressure will go up." None of those 15:49 things happened. And TMAO went down. So, it was a win for 15:53 the plant-based meat. If the question is instead of what 15:56 instead of red meat. >> Hey all say guys, there's another um 16:00 really cool clip that I saw from Dr. Matthew Nagra that I think is really 16:03 relevant here. So, he was talking about a meta-analysis from 2025 that looked at 16:07 the difference in plant-based meat and animal meat. 16:10 >> And just earlier this year, there was a meta-analysis on plant-based meats and 16:13 heart health, and they looked at seven randomized controlled trials at the 16:16 time. Again, like I said, I think there's been even a couple others uh 16:19 since uh since they wrote up this meta-analysis. And they found that there 16:23 was the plant-based meats reduced total cholesterol, LDL cholesterol, and body 16:28 weight. And there were no significant differences in glucose, triglycerides, 16:32 or blood pressure. And again, that blood pressure finding is interesting given 16:35 the the sodium content. >> What I got away from this from Dr. Nagra 16:38 is this doesn't mean that every plant-based burger is a health food or 16:43 healthy food. Some are actually really genuinely high in sodium. But 16:47 ultra-processed? Well, it really isn't the own that 16:52 people think it is. There's plenty of animal products that are also 16:56 ultra-processed. The thing to remember here is the 16:59 category really isn't the enemy. The nutrition profile is what really
Industry backlash and the future of plant-based meat 17:04 matters. >> So, if I had to come up with a summary 17:06 myself on this topic, it's that Beyond Meat burger is most definitely healthier 17:11 than regular burgers, but it's not going to be the cross I die 17:15 on. It's not going to be the argument I spent ages researching because I just 17:19 think we're swimming against the tide. I just think it's not worth spending loads 17:24 of effort educating people about how, you know, Impossible Foods or Beyond 17:28 Meat, companies like that, um, are producing products that aren't 17:32 that much healthier than regular burgers. They might be marginally a 17:35 little bit healthier, maybe significantly healthier, but I don't 17:38 really think that's going to win people over in my opinion. 17:41 >> I don't think burgers are a health food, but if you see me at a barbecue this 17:44 summer, yes, I will be having a plant-based burger. 17:47 >> [laughter] [snorts] 17:50 >> And around 2019, a group of industry representatives, and I refer to them as 17:55 the merchants of doubt, which is a reference to a book that was written on 17:58 that subject, uh, when they were doing this around tobacco and climate change. 18:03 And the the merchants of doubt got money together, and they started to fund 18:08 campaigns against our industry and against Beyond Meat. So, every time we'd 18:12 have a quarterly call with investors, they would publish something in the 18:15 paper, they'd run TV ads, they would do big social media campaigns, and they 18:19 were brilliant. They were smarter than us. They beat us. 18:23 They said, "Fake meat, real chemicals." 18:27 They said, "This food is ultra-processed." 18:31 And those that didn't want to make a change didn't make a change. 18:35 But what was so dangerous, King says, "Every society will have its protectors 18:41 of the status quo, but he also says in the fraternities of 18:45 the indifferent." And it's the fraternities of the 18:47 indifferent that we found so frustrating. 18:50 Because here we were building beautifully clean products 18:54 that took protein right from the farmer's field, 18:58 and instead of running it through factory farms and through animals to the 19:02 plate, we ran it directly from the field, 19:06 and we separated the protein from the fiber, and we put that protein through 19:09 heating, cooling, and pressure, and we landed that protein right on the center 19:13 of the plate. Clean, efficient process, but it became 19:17 demonized. And we knew that the people that didn't 19:20 want to make the change would accept that argument. What we didn't know 19:25 is that the enlightened omnivore would also accept that argument. That the 19:28 progressives would also accept that argument. And they'd say, "You know 19:32 what? That food's processed. I don't want it." 19:34 So, we started to fight back. We started to create products that we 19:38 thought would be unassailable. The challenge is 19:42 this narrative, this negative narrative has a very long tail. 19:46 And it has folks that are willing to keep spending to 19:50 make sure that people believe it. But, here's the truth. 19:54 The system we're going up against is also challenged. So, I work with meat 19:59 providers in Europe and I say, "Why are beef prices going up so much in Europe?" 20:03 They have the foot-and-mouth disease. Why are they going up so much here in 20:06 the United States? They have drought. This system that we're going up against 20:11 is held together by duct tape, antibiotic, and subsidies. We just have 20:16 to survive and advance. >> [applause] 20:21 >> And if we do that, we will prevail. 20:25 This system will perish and we will be successful. We have to survive and 20:30 advance to get there. We have to pull together. So, if you're a plant-based 20:33 eater and you're buying in and you're posting 20:36 on our site, "Oh, just have legumes." You're perpetuating a belief system 20:42 which is false. So, that protein doesn't have to go through a factory farm. 20:47 That protein has no antibiotics, no hormones, no arsenic, no pus, no feces, 20:51 no death, no fear, not a large amount of methane. 20:56 You can shrink the agricultural footprint. 20:59 We can allow nature to come back. People forget this. 21:03 The 60 billion bison that were here, the wolves, the prairie dogs, the 21:07 cougars, the beautiful creatures that were here, the pronghorns. We can let 21:11 them all come back if we shrink our agricultural footprint. 21:15 And in doing that, in saving nature, we can save ourselves because we're taking 21:19 carbon out of the air. We're bringing cooling the climate. This is enough if 21:24 we do it aggressively to meet the UN requirements to bring the 21:28 temperature down, to stop this climate catastrophe. 21:32 We need to get after this. We need to recruit the people that are closest in 21:35 to help us do this. We can do it, and that to me is the most inspiring part 21:39 about this. It's not between us and the government 21:42 anymore. It's between us and the consumer. 21:44 Let's help them make that choice to take the right type of protein, whether it's 21:48 legume or it's plant-based meat, so that we together can take control of 21:53 our destiny, of our world, of our future, 21:56 and not let this negative narrative prevail. 22:01 >> [music]
Comments