Full Transcript Intro: Vegan vs Meat Strength Challenge 0:00 Today I'm with the strongest vegans I know who built insane strength only 0:04 eating plants. And these are athletes who eat a lot of meat. And they'll be 0:09 competing in strength challenges to find out who is stronger. Starting with the 0:14 deadlift. We have arm [music] wrestling, the calisthenics challenge, higher 0:18 wrestling. >> Let's go. We pull up. 0:23 Let's go. [screaming] 0:26 >> I told you I was here for the entertainment. 0:30 >> [laughter] 0:35 >> So, we all know the misconception in society that you need meat for protein. 0:39 We also know that that is kind of >> total BS. 0:42 >> But we came across these clips featured on Brandon Williams' YouTube channel. 0:47 Now, Brandon is a popular YouTube content creator and fitness influencer 0:50 known for his body transformations, calisthenics challenges, and lifestyle 0:55 experiments. He has over 2.5 million YouTube subscribers. And in the clips 1:01 we're going to watch, vegans and meat eaters battle it out over a series of 1:05 different weightlifting challenges. Who do you think is going to win? 1:08 >> Well, knowing what I know about plant-based strength, I'm going to say 1:11 the vegans, but I really hope I'm not wrong. But Shamnam, our former figure 1:16 competitor, what's your take? >> Here's my take. I'm not sure if this 1:19 video is going to tell us everything about diet, but 1:24 I will tell you this. I'm here for the entertainment and I want to make sure 1:28 our audience knows that this isn't a randomized controlled study, 1:34 but [snorts] let's see what the talent has. And I'm of course going for the 1:38 vegans. >> You guys excited having you? Let's do 1:42 it. 1:45 >> How you feeling right now? >> Uh, I'm feeling 30% confident. 1:49 >> You know, if you ate some meat, you'd be maybe 60% confident.
Deadlift and First Reactions 1:52 >> All right, you got this. >> Okay. No, I don't. All right. Okay. I 1:54 [laughter] take it back. >> I'll take the 70% he doesn't have. 1:57 >> Okay, >> I'll run with that. 2:07 >> Oh my god. >> Okay, Austin, it's all you. If you lift 2:11 this, we win this event. >> This is easy. 2:13 >> Got it. >> Let's go, Austin. 2:17 >> Come on. 2:22 >> Get it, Austin. Come on. 2:33 >> Okay, so for the deadlift, uh, team meet actually won. Um, and I believe they 2:40 picked up a whpping 675, which is fairly impressive. So, fair play. Credit where 2:46 it's due. Okay, so I'm going to bring in the first comment that I noticed, which 2:49 was actually in the first challenge, the meat eater was wearing straps and the 2:52 vegan actually didn't wear straps. So maybe we could sort of notice that. 2:55 Maybe that's why they won. Not saying it is, but it could be. And another person 2:59 said, "Much respect for the vegan on deads. Use no straps, lighter body 3:03 weight, and was still pulling up crazy numbers. What a beast." 3:07 >> We have arm wrestling. It's going to be Michael. Oh, shirt's coming off. Versus 3:11 Rick. You want like steak or a sausage or something? I would definitely like 3:15 some meat. 3:19 >> Here we go. Let's grip up >> in three, two, one, go. Let's go. 3:25 >> Come on. 3:29 Keep going. 3:41 >> Hey, but here's the thing that I just thought of. Don't you think it's pretty 3:44 remarkable that the vegans are actually competing? I mean, if you think about 3:48 it, vegans make up what, one or two, maybe 3% of the population. So, it's a 3:54 much smaller pool of people to recruit from, and they're still competing. 3:58 >> So true. >> Next, we have [music] tire wrestling. To 4:01 win, you have to either rip the tire from your opponent's hands or drag them 4:05 across your red line. Three people from each team will compete, and best two out 4:08 of three wins. 4:12 That's one for team meat. 4:19 >> NO. >> LET'S GO.
Arm Wrestling and Tire Wrestling 4:21 >> It all comes down to this round right here. We've got Jordan versus Rick. 4:25 Gentlemen, want some veggies? >> You see this? 4:29 >> Yeah. >> That's you right there. 4:31 >> YEAH. 4:44 Come on. >> Yeah, 4:45 >> I'm getting pumped up watching it. >> I told you I was here for the 4:49 entertainment. [laughter] 4:52 >> Love it. >> The calisthenics challenge. The first 4:56 person to complete 10 muscle-ups, 10 dips, 10 pull-ups, and then 50 push-ups, 5:01 all in that order, wins. It's going to be me versus Romulus. 5:06 Got to fuel up really quick. Got some beef jerkys. 5:08 >> I got a banana. >> What the 5:12 >> What kind of vegan are you? >> In three, two, one. 5:15 >> Let's go. Let's go. 5:30 >> There you go. 5:34 >> N Come on, go 5:38 1 2 3 4 5 10 5 5:48 10 6:25 Keep going. What are you doing?
Calisthenics Challenge 6:36 >> Five more. >> Come on. COME ON. 6:41 6 49. >> I'm going let it drag out. 6:49 [screaming] >> COME ON, BOYS. 6:51 >> YEAH, those carrots don't feel muscle, buddy. 6:53 >> I know this isn't a randomized control trial, but I still think this is 6:56 actually useful for people to watch and it kind of bridges the gap between both 7:00 communities. There's not this divide. People having fun, having a laugh 7:03 together, and I think it's just hilarious to watch. 7:06 >> Yeah. What I did think was quite easy or interesting though was that the meateers 7:10 were way more interested in insulting the vegans. I thought like they were the 7:15 ones that wanted to do all the like, yeah, I'm so much stronger than you. 7:18 Whereas the vegans kind of just like used their strength to prove the point. 7:22 So, I kind of like that. >> I like the camaraderie. I agree. I think 7:26 it's so nice to just like see competition but actually see people 7:31 really enjoy themselves. I don't know. Like I said, I'm here for the 7:35 entertainment. >> It all comes down to this. The Hercules 7:38 holds Brady and Michael competing in this event. The shirt's already coming 7:42 off. Look at that. Whoever can hold on the longest will win this event. But 7:46 there's a twist. The team that is going second will be blindfolded, so they will 7:50 not know what time the first team got. And in order to decide who's going 7:53 first, we're going to flip a coin. Heads or tails? [music] 7:55 >> Heads. >> The eagle is heads and the flag is 7:58 tails. >> Tails. All right, we got the vegans all 8:00 blindfolded. You guys ready? 8:05 Okay, they're probably ready. In 3 2 1 go. Here we go. Michael, we have 150 lbs 8:11 on each end. So, he's [music] holding 300 lb right now. 15 seconds in. He's 8:15 got a little hook grip, too. All right, 30 seconds. 8:17 >> Come on. You're doing good. >> Come on, 8:20 boy. >> All right, this is the time we got. All 8:25 right, guys. You're good. You're good. You're good, guys. 8:27 >> Only 10 seconds, bro. >> Yeah, only 10 seconds. That's crazy. All 8:31 right, Brady. You feeling ready? 8:34 >> Yes, sir. >> You don't know what time to get right 8:36 now. We're going to start in 3 2 1 go. >> Let's go, buddy. That's ready. Okay, go. 8:42 >> This is it. This is all right here. >> You can let go. [music] It's okay. 8:45 >> All right. >> You just sink down into that and you 8:48 just hold it. Okay. >> Just let go already.
Hercules Hold Showdown 8:49 >> No. No. Don't Don't listen to me here. >> All right. You got 17 seconds. All day. 8:53 All day. All day. All day. >> 30 seconds. 8:56 >> Represent that beacon strength, brother. >> 35 seconds. 9:01 He passed it. >> Too late. It's too easy. 9:03 >> You passed it. You can let go. Let go now. 9:05 >> Yeah, you won. >> Let's go. 9:10 >> So good. >> I mean, there is evidence that showcases 9:14 that vegans do have greater muscular endurance and cardiovascular endurance 9:21 due to the foods that they eat. So, I'm excited that we may even be talking 9:26 about a little bit more of that science and why we're seeing some of this stuff 9:29 down the line. But, um, 9:33 150 lbs on each side. Could you imagine holding that? 9:36 >> No. >> In a fully extended arm position. It's 9:39 like a I think my arms would just snap off like 9:44 twigs. >> Same. To be honest, Claus, you down for 9:48 that? >> I'd love to see that. 9:50 >> Oh, wow. I agree. I agree. What I'm thinking is if I was like a 14year-old 9:55 boy, I would be entranced. This would be like the greatest ever 10:01 YouTube. If I was like one of those fitness 14y olds, maybe my parents 10:04 brought me up vegan or they maybe brought me up in the carnivore diet or 10:08 something. I'd be like so engaged with this 10:11 >> inspirational. Like I'm not even into bodybuilding or anything like that. And 10:15 I find it so inspiring. I'm just like, how is that even possible? We know some 10:19 of our greatest vegans like Patrick Babumian, one of the greatest world 10:24 strong men in the space and he's fully plant-based. So, you know. 10:28 >> Yes. And speaking of Patrick Babumian, somebody left a comment that I thought 10:32 was similar to something that he said, which was like, "Of course vegans will 10:36 win this round. Elephants, rhinos, hippos, horses, buffaloos, gorillas are 10:40 the strongest. How much longer do we need to prove that vegans are stronger?" 10:43 I mean, it sounds like one of those ones where as a vegan, I've heard that 10:46 argument so many times, but it's true. It's literally true, right? And 10:51 sometimes, Shapnam, I don't know what you think about this because you're kind 10:54 of, you've come from the academic world. Sometimes I feel like plantbased 10:58 proponents lean too heavily perhaps into you know randomized control trials and 11:04 big data and actually human intuition and common sense and first principles 11:10 thinking is actually sometimes more effective than delving into academic 11:15 studies. >> Maybe more effective at times and this 11:18 is where we talk about why the storytelling is so important, right? but 11:23 it may not be as evidence-based. And the evidence is what really guides our 11:29 decisions here. And I think that that's a really important aspect to be making 11:33 is science is here to support those ethical considerations that we're also 11:39 making in our daily decisions. And I think it's important to note here that 11:44 what we're showing here is the entertainment and it's it's not showing 11:48 proof that vegans are secretly stronger, right? 11:52 It's also not showing proof that meateers are secretly stronger. Neither 11:56 is true. Six different people came to work out and collegiately compete on one 12:02 afternoon. And what we saw here was that they both can produce great outcomes. 12:10 But I think it's the evidence that shows that what we saw this year, there was a
Debating the Results and Vegan Strength 12:15 state-of-the-art review that plant-based eating is not inferior to omnivore diets 12:21 to increase strength and hypertrophy. And I think that's a really important 12:26 aspect that evidence brings to the table. Right? What we're showing is that 12:30 if you're eating enough protein, enough calories, eating plant-based is not 12:35 technically inferior, right? What we're showing is that it could be a really 12:41 efficient way of meeting those performance outcomes while still 12:46 holding true to your ethical ground. And I think that's where it's really 12:51 important to have the evidence. >> Yeah. And we are going to get to that 12:55 study that you spoke about as well. We've got a little clip of that coming 12:57 up. But Claus, do you want to actually reveal what the results of the whole 13:03 competition were? >> Oh yeah. Let's go through it. That's the 13:05 objective. Deadlift. Team meat won. Credit where works due. Arm wrestling, 13:10 as we saw, Team Vegan won that. Calisthenics, at that point, Team Meat 13:15 were leading 2-1. Thai wrestling though was where team vegan brought it back to 13:20 two all. And then dumbbell press, Hercules hold, team vegan won, and kind 13:25 of took it away. So, it's 42. Four to team vegan, two to meat eating. So, what 13:30 does this tell us, Shabnam? not a randomized control trial, but I think 13:33 it's a little bit compelling. >> As someone who's used to complete and 13:37 someone who really depends on evidence, again, this is just really 13:41 entertainment. What really wins a deadlift is things like limb length, 13:46 tendon insertion points. We're talking about uh training capacity, uh training 13:52 age, um nutrient timing. It's a multitude of variables and factors. And 13:57 so I think as a scientist I can't really come to a conclusive factor of saying 14:01 like yes 14:03 >> but but the evidence shows that if you are on a vegan diet and are still 14:09 meeting the caloric isocaloric needs protein requirements and you're training 14:15 adequately you can beat a meat eater. [laughter] 14:21 There you go folks. You do it right. >> You can do what you want. I mean, I 14:25 can't say you could beat a meat eater because who knows who you're going to 14:27 compete against. So, again, >> again, you know, 14:32 >> oh, the layer. >> Also, what I want to say is the meateers 14:36 were going into it acting like they were just going to clean up. That's the thing 14:39 I think that is the most fun part about it is they clearly thought they were 14:43 going to win and they were all giving it the big one, slagging all the vegans off 14:47 as if they were weak and the vegans weren't weak. So, that's the part I like 14:51 about it. I'm like, at least the vegans stood their ground and they did 14:55 technically win. Whether it's a scientific, you know, study or not, they 14:59 still won. >> They they took this one. 15:03 >> Yeah, >> they definitely took this one. I'll give 15:05 you that. >> To add into the point that I was saying 15:07 about how the meat eaters seem to be the ones that were trying to insult the 15:10 vegans. Someone else highlighted it and they said, "I mean, the vegan men didn't 15:15 even utter a word to discourage the opponent. They did what they did. Vegan 15:19 men are real men. It's kind of it reminds me of that 15:23 Gandandy line um that you should judge a nation by how it treats it most 15:26 vulnerable, right? If men are treating the planet's most vulnerable, which 15:31 animals are with more care, then that's more integrous in my opinion. 15:36 >> I mean, just like a really nice comment to add in is we do not need to hurt 15:40 animals to become strong. And that's another good point, isn't it? Because 15:44 the meat eatating side obviously all are fine with eating animals and vegans are 15:49 saying we can do the same stuff as you. Whether or not they're better is kind of 15:52 irrelevant. It's like we can do the same as you but we don't have to hurt animals 15:56 to do it. So that's kind of a nice thing. I think 15:58 >> I think we've got Matthew Nagra. Sarah you um found a clip from Matthew Nagra 16:03 and then Alan Aragan on the Andrew Huberman show. So let's go to those 16:07 clips because they uh kind of corroborate what you're saying. Shadnam. 16:11 If it is the case that animal protein and plant protein result in the same 16:14 muscle and strength gains, provided you're consuming the same amount, then 16:17 who cares about all that other stuff. But if we were to go straight to those 16:19 randomized control trials to start here, we have two clinical trials that we 16:23 have. So, one of them was a Brazilian study done by Hamilton Rochelle and 16:26 Heavy Lraine and colleagues. And in this study, they had 19 vegans and 19 meat 16:30 eataters. They had them up their protein to 1.6 g per kilogram of body weight, 16:33 either exclusively from plants or mostly from animals. And they had them 16:36 resistance training twice a week for 12 weeks. And then they measured the 16:40 changes in strength and muscle gains from the beginning to the end and there 16:43 were no significant differences between groups. And so that suggests that both 16:46 can support similar performance or or similar improvements. Now following that
Research Clips on Plant-Based Muscle Gains 16:49 there was another study out of the UK by Montaigne and colleagues where they 16:53 actually did randomize most people. They had them up their protein now aiming for 16:57 2 g per kilogram. They also had both groups consume creatine because that can 17:00 also further bolster gains. And they had them training a lot more this time five 17:03 times a week for 10 weeks. And once again, no differences in muscle or 17:07 strength gains. And so those two trials show that actually there are no clear 17:10 significant differences in muscle and strength gains as long as you're 17:13 consuming the same amount of protein. And that's ultimately what matters. And 17:16 we can get into the nitty-gritty of again those other details I mentioned, 17:18 but that's the end result. Finally have studies where we're looking at 17:22 completely vegan regimen, a group who's totally vegan, no no animal products at 17:27 all in in the diet versus an omnivore group and uh put them on a resistance 17:34 training regimen 12 weeks. This was uh done by Lraine and colleagues. This was 17:38 a few years back. And so they optimized protein or at least made it at the 17:44 bottom of optimal at 1.6 g per kilogram of body weight per day in both groups. 17:51 Okay. And so but the unique thing about this study, it was the first time ever 17:55 we're compare comparing vegans with omnivores. So there were no significant 18:00 differences between groups in muscle size and strength gains by the end of 12 18:04 weeks where they put on a progressive resistance training program. 18:07 >> It was isocaloric. So >> isocaloric meaning uh for those that 18:11 don't know what that means is total number of calories ingested per day. 18:14 Same in the vegan versus omnivore group. >> Yes, that's right. Isocaloric is 18:18 macronutritional, you know, isoproaic. Everything everything is equated between 18:23 the groups macronutrition wise. no significant differences in the size and 18:28 strength gains. And um they're suspecting Oh, and by the way, the vegan 18:33 group, their protein intake was boosted up to 1.6 g per kilo or.7 gram per 18:38 pound, it was boosted up by uh soy protein supplementation. 18:43 So apparently, I mean, we're beginning to see that at a dose a total daily 18:48 protein at 1.6 six gram per kilogram of body weight. The totally vegan group was 18:54 able to hang in there against the omnivore group. 18:58 >> The aragon clip here is really useful because what I'm seeing here is the 19:01 nuance isn't can plants build muscle. It's actually leucine threshold. You 19:06 need to hit a certain leucine threshold per meal to maximize what we call muscle 19:11 protein synthesis, right? And plant sources like soy and pea can absolutely 19:18 get you there. You just may sometimes need a slightly bigger portion or you 19:23 may need to combine different sources throughout the day. But the end of the 19:27 day, you can still get what you need isocalorically, protein wise, 19:32 macronutrient density wise by eating plants. And so the scientists, the 19:38 meateers are seeing it, and I don't think they really like it. Huberman, 19:41 though he's a brilliant scientist, he also has his biases, right? and he's a 19:47 huge advocate for eating meat. I think he also is sponsored by a meat company. 19:53 I think we've discussed this before >> or like some sort of natural jerky 19:57 company. So, we have to also consider those aspects in the arguments that we 20:03 hear from certain individuals, right? >> I love hearing that though because I'm 20:08 like, you know, I want to lift. I want to become strong. Like, I don't want to 20:11 be a weak person. So hearing that I can just continue being a soy girl is 20:16 awesome. [music]
Comments