Full Transcript Intro and debate setup 0:00 Hey everyone, I'm with Shabnam. >> Hi everyone. [music] 0:02 >> And Sara. >> Hey. 0:04 >> So Sara found an awesome debate online between Dr. Matthew Nagra and 0:07 nutritionist and fitness coach Arvin Daggubati on the optimal diet for health 0:11 and longevity. Let's go to the clips. >> So so let's jump right into things. I 0:16 guess at a high level and obviously there were you know specific claims made 0:20 throughout, but at a high level what stood out was you made the claim that 0:24 and I have quote, you can reach a high level as a vegan but you can't reach the 0:27 creme de la creme. And then just shortly afterwards you followed that up by 0:32 saying that basically on a vegan diet or plant exclusive diet you cannot quote 0:36 optimize for health. And so I guess what I want to understand is is how how do 0:41 you define that? Like like what would you define as this optimal health? 0:46 >> Well would you agree that 0:48 um supplementing with something like creatine would help optimize health? 0:54 >> Um well depends on what your definition of optimize is. That's what I'm trying 0:57 to understand. Like I don't I don't really I don't really
Defining optimal health 1:00 I don't really behold to this idea necessarily of of quote unquote an 1:04 optimal health. Like for example, I wouldn't say that you weren't at in good 1:09 health because during that debate with Arvin you had back pain, you had to take 1:12 a break, you had to stand up, right? Like I wouldn't take that to necessarily 1:15 mean that you aren't in good health. Um and I [clears throat] I think that 1:20 uh quote unquote optimal health or good health isn't necessarily being free of 1:23 all issues at all time. It's being able to manage, navigate those issues. It's 1:27 it's it's it's in flux. Um and and you know to be 1:31 self-sustaining. So I mean I can I can tell you whether or 1:35 not supplementing with creatine can optimize in certain uh 1:38 certain realms of health, but but first I just like to understand how would you 1:42 define optimal health? >> I'm just saying would it be fair to say 1:47 that supplementing with creatine in all likelihood would 1:51 uh help you maximize health outcomes. You may get a little better performance 1:55 as far as muscular strength is concerned. You may get some cognitive 1:58 benefit improvements. >> Would Would that be a fast day? 2:02 I don't think the evidence for cognition is all that strong and we can get into 2:05 that, but I don't like it depends on how you define optimal health. Like if 2:09 somebody factors in peak physical performance into that, then then sure. I 2:14 I think for strength outcomes, yeah. But I don't know that everybody has that 2:18 goal and so I I'd like to again just understand what is your definition. 2:21 >> It's It's It's not It's not about goal. It's like um 2:25 if someone were to Like Like I said, if someone was to reach the creme de la 2:29 creme of um health and performance, would diet Would Would supplemental 2:33 creatine help them? >> Yeah, if you're considering perform- 2:36 performance, yes, but like I guess let me rephrase. 2:40 How would you measure? Like if you were to take somebody and assess them, are 2:44 they in or have they achieved optimal health? How would you assess that? Like 2:49 what are the actual things you would look at to meet whatever that criteria 2:53 is? >> I'm I'm I'm perfectly happy with 2:56 whatever measurement you would want to share. See, 2:59 >> Well, see No, I already said I I don't have I don't like behold to this idea of 3:04 quote-unquote optimal health, right? So I I want to understand because you made 3:07 the claim. You made the claim about you cannot reach optimal health. I want to 3:11 understand what you mean when you say that. 3:13 >> I'm I'm I'm just I'm just I'm just trying to see if uh 3:16 uh you know, we we we share some common 3:18 ground here. And uh 3:21 so you're you're not of the opinion that supplemental creatine is beneficial for 3:25 human health, is it? >> I think it's beneficial for athletic 3:28 performance. I don't know that it improves other health outcomes, but 3:31 again, that is that is a that is sort of tangential to what I'm trying to get at 3:36 because creatine isn't obviously there's a lot of things that were raised in that 3:39 debate and a lot of it hinges on this idea of you cannot achieve quote-unquote 3:43 optimal health. Now, if your idea of optimal health is the best 3:49 health outcomes in every potential category, full stop. Um then like like 3:55 would you say that that's what it is? Like Is that how Okay. 3:59 >> I I guess that would be a fair statement. 4:00 >> So, would you say that if you don't consume 4:04 tea, that you are not achieving optimal health? Or if you don't consume coffee, 4:09 that you are not achieving optimal health? 4:12 >> Possibly. There are some unique benefits that are associated with tea and coffee. 4:17 Like I'm someone that encourages consuming a wide variety of foods, so 4:20 that whatever unique compounds are present in a particular food, you're 4:24 able to derive that. And 4:26 yeah, so I would say if that is the case for tea or coffee. I'm not that familiar 4:29 with the literature on tea or tea and coffee, perhaps you are. 4:33 And if you were to make the claim that tea and coffee consumption can help 4:36 improve health outcomes, then I would be willing to accept that. 4:40 >> Okay, so so but like let's say I'll just summarize that at a high level. Lower 4:44 risk of certain cancers, lower risk of cardiovascular disease, there's 4:47 compounds in tea and coffee that have unique benefits. So, I see caffeine in 4:51 coffee. Understanding all of that, would you say 4:54 that somebody then, by by your own standard, somebody who doesn't consume 4:58 tea or coffee, is not achieving their peak health? 5:02 >> If there are some unique benefits uh associated with tea and coffee 5:05 consumption, then uh they probably aren't. 5:08 >> I agree with where Dr. Nagra is going here. Unless we define what the actual
Plant-based diets and unique food benefits 5:13 outcome is, we can't continue to support this claim, correct? And so, what 5:17 variables or what facets fall into like optimal health? Are we just talking 5:21 about strength performance, cardiovascular performance? Are we 5:23 talking about longevity, cognition? There's a multitude of factors that go 5:29 into this. >> So, I want to go to the second clip and 5:31 keep watching. I'm intrigued. >> And we keep seeing these new 5:34 breakthroughs, which kind of indicate that it's best if we don't get rid of an 5:39 entire food group altogether, because as vegans, 5:43 vegans don't just get rid of, let's say, something like red meat, which I would 5:46 agree isn't all that great to consume. Perhaps in 5:50 small doses it might be. Maybe a serving a week or whatever it is 5:55 uh the data indicates. But you'll get rid of everything. You'll 5:59 get rid of red meat, you'll get rid of eggs, you'll get rid of white meat, 6:03 uh fish, which by the way, I think you'd agree is a health promoting food. It's 6:08 it's got great great health outcomes from from the data. Uh we got honey, 6:15 um and so on. 6:17 So all of these foods tend to have these array of different compounds, uh which 6:22 are unique to them, um which may conquer health benefits. Uh 6:27 I just want to ask you a small question if that's okay. 6:29 >> Sure. Well, um I also wanted to highlight that I I still want to see 6:33 outcome data on those, but we'll get to that in a moment. But go ahead. 6:36 >> Yeah, sure. Sure, sure. We'll we'll look at that, too. Um 6:40 what's your position on vegan diets? Do you 6:43 consider vegan diets to be the absolute best diet when it comes to maximizing 6:48 health outcomes, or are you fine with consuming 6:52 animal foods, too, in perhaps small doses? Like what do you 6:56 think would be like if a 6:59 omni- omnivore were to consider having some 7:02 fish and red meat and eggs, like how much of that would be acceptable given 7:08 the health outcome data, which I'm sure you're familiar with? 7:11 >> Yeah, so so I mean ethically I don't see a justification, but that aside, right 7:15 looking to just at the health, um I would say that the uh the data 7:19 suggests that anywhere within a plant-predominant, I can't give 7:24 an exact percentage, we'll say 85-90% plant-based or more, up to 7:27 plant-exclusive, can be comparably healthy. I don't think necessarily that 7:31 a vegan diet is going to be more healthy than a a plant-predominant omnivorous 7:36 diet with certain types of animal foods, like maybe fermented dairy, maybe fish. 7:40 Um but I also don't think a vegan diet would be detrimental in comparison to 7:44 those inherently. And so that's where I take issue is the claim that that a 7:48 vegan diet is inherently going to be detrimental, and I just haven't seen any 7:52 data to support that with regard to the low levels of consumption of these foods 7:56 that you you've mentioned. >> I think Dr. Matthew Nagra makes some 8:00 really great points. Let's take the blue zones for example. We're not talking 8:03 about communities that are completely fully plant-based that have some element 8:08 of fish in their diet in some locations like Okinawa and the Mediterranean. But 8:13 what are you saying if the diet is predominantly plant rich, we tend to see
Fish, colorectal cancer, and diet comparisons 8:18 these types of health benefits. >> There's one clip where they talk about 8:23 fish. So let's go to that clip. >> You're familiar with the data on fish 8:26 and colorectal cancer risk? >> Yeah. 8:31 >> So in regards to that, what is your estimate of what the literature 8:35 indicates? Because from what I've seen, it seems like fish is something 8:41 that is protective against colorectal cancer risk. 8:45 >> Also is dairy. Largely in in largely due to the calcium content. 8:50 >> Oh, yeah. Yeah. But what about fish, you know, 8:54 exclusively? >> What like I don't understand what you're 8:57 at like compared to what? If you're See, here's the problem with a lot of the 9:00 fish studies. When you're looking at fish consumption, it's often replacing 9:03 red meat. Um now, I can't recall if those studies adjusted for red meat 9:07 consumption. If they have If you can pull it up, that'd be good. 9:10 Um Now, that aside, I can grant that fish consumption 9:16 in isolation, even after adjusting for red and processed meats, 9:19 is associated with lower risk. I I've no problem 9:22 accepting that. My question is how does that pertain to a discussion of vegan 9:27 diets or or how does that demonstrate that fish 9:30 consumption would be beneficial if added to a vegan diet when it comes to 9:34 colorectal cancer risk simply because they didn't as far as I can see they're 9:38 just for things like overall diet quality. 9:41 >> All right. You see that's the reason why I asked you Matthew. If you have any 9:45 problem with consuming about one to three servings of fish because 9:50 you're of the position that vegan diets and plant foods exclusively can help 9:55 maximize health outcomes. But here we see that consuming about small servings 10:00 of fish perhaps one to three based on what you said has an inverse association 10:05 with colorectal cancer. So my position then is why not consume the fish given 10:10 that we are not entirely sure what it is in the fish that's helping 10:14 reduce that colorectal cancer risk. >> Because we also see that plant-based 10:18 diets are associated with lower risk. >> But not as much as pescatarian diets. 10:23 >> With with for which outcome? >> For colorectal cancer risk. In fact uh 10:29 >> [clears throat] >> I actually hear 10:30 >> Did you mention meta? I'm sure you're familiar with the new 10:33 meta which showed that vegans had a 40% higher risk of colorectal cancer. 10:37 >> Yeah, and we can do a breakdown on that. >> Yeah, 10:40 there's some caveats there like I'm familiar with 10:42 >> There's some major caveats there. For one they didn't adjust for BMI. They 10:46 once they removed people who were diagnosed in the first four years it was 10:49 no longer statistically significant. There's all sorts of problems and in 10:53 that study pescatarians had what appears to be likely a statistically significant 10:58 higher risk of multiple myeloma than vegetarians did. 11:02 So so great. So this this comes back to why 11:05 I was asking at the beginning about the whole 11:08 how do you define optimal health because we can find like even pescatarians might 11:12 have worse health outcomes in certain regards. 11:14 >> They just go in circles. Dr. Nagra tries to like pin him down and be like admit 11:18 it. You're just going to like speculate basically. This is what we always say 11:22 about the carnivore bros as well, isn't it? There's a lot of it is based on like 11:25 speculation or anecdotal evidence and like not actual longitudinal studies on 11:31 what the outcomes actually are for people when they eat these diets. And 11:34 Dr. Nagra is really good at just bringing it back to the science and 11:37 bringing it back to the actual research. So, I appreciated he must have been 11:40 frustrated in that conversation. >> So, is in conclusion fish, is it a 11:45 neutral health food which one probably still to told me, is it a healthy source 11:51 of calories, but then because of the mercury that makes it suboptimal? 11:55 Personally, based on a variety of data, especially all the mercury and toxins, I 12:00 don't think it's a healthy food and certainly from ethical perspective, 12:02 obviously very different conversation. I wouldn't consume it. What's your take? 12:05 >> I mean, that's 100% where I land with you. I think about nuclear meltdowns 12:10 that have happened on the coasts and how long that takes to circumnavigate the 12:15 globe multiple times for it to just enter into your food stream. And why are 12:20 we eating fish? Like, I really want to think about the nutrients that we're 12:24 talking about. Are we talking about omega-3s? Are we talking about ALA? If 12:28 you're talking about omega-3 fatty acids, right? Your EPA, your DHA. Alpha 12:32 linoleic acid, your ALA as another omega-3 fatty acid. We can get this from 12:37 like flax seeds, chia seeds, hemp seeds, walnuts, leafy greens. We can also get 12:43 adequate levels of omega-3 from algae-based sources. So, my question is 12:48 what nutrient reason are you choosing for this option, for this animal 12:53 protein? Because it just doesn't align with me ethically. I think we can 12:56 supplement in other ways. >> My anecdote of the day when it comes to 13:00 fish is more from a direct health perspective. I got a friend who became 13:04 pregnant and then she's like, "Oh my god, the doctor told me to stop eating 13:08 fish cuz it's like meant to be so bad for my baby." And then given birth, now
Mediterranean diet, supplementation, and closing thoughts 13:12 it's back onto the fish and it's like, "If it's so bad for your baby, then why 13:17 is it not bad for you?" >> Mhm. It's a good point. 13:20 >> Which makes an attempt to optimize, but we don't have that data yet. Oh, no, we 13:24 do. We have we have a have RCTs comparing We have two RCTs now comparing 13:28 a vegan diet to a Mediterranean diet. Uh one that's designed 13:31 >> 100% optimized for all the different nutrients that they 13:36 I just mentioned that. >> Let's go well 13:38 optimized as in fault like would you say a Mediterranean diet covers the bases 13:42 that you'd be concerned about if someone's following it adequately? 13:45 >> think so. No. >> What what what would you say 13:48 >> gram dollar gram >> What would be missing? What would be 13:51 missing in a Mediterranean diet? 13:54 >> um a bunch of unique compounds which they 13:58 may not be consuming. You can mention a few foods. 14:02 What what what do they consume? Like what are the largest 14:05 >> a standard Mediterranean? I'll pull I'll pull it up right now. 14:08 um >> Really really really really 14:10 >> hold on. Well let let let's actually do this. Let's do this instead. Design 14:15 because um 14:17 if you have this idea of what is optimal what covers all your bases, what is the 14:21 optimal diet to you that covers all those bases? Design it. 14:24 >> I don't know. >> Well so if you don't know then what are 14:27 we arguing about? You're just guessing. >> Wait wait a second. Wait a second. I 14:30 won't I'm I'm I'm appealing to the fact that I 14:33 don't know everything. I don't know everything about diets but I know enough 14:37 about the track record of animal foods to not get rid of that and all the other 14:43 food groups associated with animal foods all together. That's my position. 14:48 >> But but here's the problem with that. The problem is when I said we have we 14:51 have trials two RCTs comparing a vegan diet to a Mediterranean diet. Hold on. 14:56 Allow me to allow me to finish. Allow me to finish. My main concern or your sorry 15:01 your main concern was that oh well well what were they consuming? We you know we 15:04 don't know if it was optimized. You're how do you know that if you can't even 15:09 describe or define an optimal diet? >> me let me let me let me let me take a 15:12 glance at the diet. >> Okay but hold on. Before I show it to 15:16 you because I here's my here's my concern. I'm going to show it to you and 15:19 then you're just going to try to pick it apart as oh they were consuming too much 15:23 this and that. I want to know Hold on. Hold on. Allow me to finish why I'm 15:27 explaining. I want to know now, do you have even a definition for this optimal 15:31 diet? Because if you don't, I suspect it's an excuse to to bash a vegan diet. 15:36 I suspect it's Hold on. Hold on. Allow me to finish. 15:40 Because no matter what I say, you're going to claim that it's not optimal 15:44 based on speculation. I would like you It is 15:50 It is speculation. Yeah, so it's speculation based on track 15:54 record. You you called it inductive reasoning in the Arvin debate. That is 15:57 speculation. It's hypothesis generating. So, I want to know Can you Can you 16:02 Hold on. Hold on. Can you 16:05 It is speculation and and it's I'm not saying speculation is bad, but it is 16:08 speculation that requires evidence. Now, can you please describe what this 16:14 optimal diet is? Do you have a definition for it? Can you tell me how 16:17 to follow that? >> All these people who you're going to 16:22 Uh you're going to show me the diet. What 16:24 are you supplementing with creatine? >> So so in your view, you need to 16:28 supplement regardless, even if you're on a Mediterranean diet. That takes That 16:31 gets rid of this whole issue with with the vegan diet. 16:34 >> I'm sorry. The way Dr. Matthew Nagra has handled himself is so much better than 16:38 this guy. >> Dr. Nagra is getting a little frustrated 16:41 in the debate because he's like there's a lot of factors at play here. 16:44 >> This is what I was talking about. Did we come to a conclusion of what we defined 16:48 as optimal diet? >> Remember 16:50 >> this debate was centered around veganism. That that was the stance I was 16:53 coming from or that you and Arvin were debating and that's the stance I'm 16:56 coming from. So, if somebody's vegan and wants to be vegan, I see no good reason 17:00 to include fish because I just see no clear evidence of benefit over getting 17:05 getting you know, these compounds or or benefits from 17:08 >> So so so so you're absolutely certain that we won't discover or characterize 17:13 some unique component fish which would 17:17 warrant consumption. >> No, but I'm not absolutely certain that 17:21 the findings from these two substitution analyses showing benefit of plant 17:25 protein over fish aren't actually the stronger data. So, 17:28 like again, that can go in either direction. 17:31 >> Right. So, of course of course Just give me a 17:33 second. I I just have to connect my charger. Yeah. Sorry about that. 17:37 >> So, no. I just have no good reason to suspect that one way is going to be 17:40 better than the other. Um and so So, if you're right like using your epistemic 17:46 framework um and you've again, you've said this. We can we can show clips of 17:49 it where if there is data suggesting potential harm and then there's the data 17:54 showing neutral outcomes, you side with the data showing potential harm. With 17:58 the case of fish, we have that compared to plant proteins. And so, you 18:02 should by your own epistemic framework, you should avoid fish. 18:05 >> Well, that's great. I I I didn't know that. And thanks for sharing that with 18:08 me. I'll I'll update my views. See, my my 18:12 epistemic framework is I mean, I don't know if there's a formal name for this. 18:16 Perhaps it's a it's a Bayesian framework. But I'll I'll keep updating 18:20 my stance on any position based on the data. You shared some data. I'm willing 18:23 to to to modify my views based on the data that you shared. And and that's my 18:28 model. Yeah. And and and and once again, and 18:32 again, see, I'm I'm not going anywhere. I'll I'll be more than happy to continue 18:36 this conversation with you. See the data. And if it the data is truly 18:40 compelling and it does show that there's absolutely no good reason to 18:44 consume small doses of these animal foods, and I'll be the first person to 18:47 accept that yeah, there there isn't any good good reason. 18:50 >> I do appreciate that he said at the end, thank you for teaching me this aspect 18:54 that I didn't know before, and I will take that forward into my research. So, 18:57 I hope that he's being genuine about that because I find it so concerning 19:00 when people spread stuff on the internet that is not fully formulated and not 19:05 backed up by scientific research. That can be concerning for people who follow 19:08 and watch along and listen to these online people. 19:12 >> We should give him some credit in saying that he's willing to adjust his views 19:17 based off of the new data presented. And I think that's what we can hope from 19:21 anyone is that there's continued growth with education. And so if the data can 19:26 showcase a story that maybe doesn't support your view, to be open to it if 19:31 you think that it is a valid and reliable source. 19:34 >> Thank you everybody for watching another episode of Plant Based News. Please 19:37 like, comment, and subscribe, and we'll see you very soon. 19:40 >> [music] 19:48 [music]
Comments