Full Transcript The Vitamin D Reality Check 0:01 Over 90% of 0:01 Over 90% of postmenopausal women are 0:02 postmenopausal women are 0:02 postmenopausal women are deficient in vitamin D, 0:03 deficient in vitamin D, 0:03 deficient in vitamin D, but a study of 0:05 but a study of 0:05 but a study of 34,000 women 0:06 34,000 women 0:06 34,000 women found that it did not 0:07 found that it did not 0:07 found that it did not prevent hot flashes, 0:09 prevent hot flashes, 0:09 prevent hot flashes, mood swings, or 0:10 mood swings, or 0:10 mood swings, or insomnia. Hi, I'm 0:12 insomnia. Hi, I'm 0:12 insomnia. Hi, I'm Dr. Elizabeth 0:13 Dr. Elizabeth 0:13 Dr. Elizabeth Trattner, a 0:13 Trattner, a 0:13 Trattner, a licensed 0:14 licensed 0:14 licensed naturopath practicing 0:15 naturopath practicing 0:15 naturopath practicing in sunny Arizona. And 0:17 in sunny Arizona. And 0:17 in sunny Arizona. And before we begin, I 0:19 before we begin, I 0:19 before we begin, I sincerely thank everyone who has 0:20 sincerely thank everyone who has 0:20 sincerely thank everyone who has recently subscribed 0:21 recently subscribed 0:21 recently subscribed to the channel. I 0:22 to the channel. I 0:22 to the channel. I enjoy reading 0:23 enjoy reading 0:23 enjoy reading your comments and I 0:24 your comments and I 0:24 your comments and I try to 0:25 try to 0:25 try to respond to 0:26 respond to 0:26 respond to as many of them as possible 0:27 as many of them as possible 0:27 as many of them as possible . If you have 0:28 . If you have 0:28 . If you have n't subscribed yet, I'd be 0:29 n't subscribed yet, I'd be 0:29 n't subscribed yet, I'd be happy to see you among 0:30 happy to see you among 0:30 happy to see you among my subscribers. 0:31 my subscribers. 0:31 my subscribers. By the end of this 0:32 By the end of this 0:32 By the end of this video, you'll 0:33 video, you'll 0:33 video, you'll know exactly what vitamin D 0:34 know exactly what vitamin D 0:34 know exactly what vitamin D can and can't 0:35 can and can't 0:35 can and can't do for 0:36 do for 0:36 do for 0:38 perimenopausal symptoms, and what 0:38 perimenopausal symptoms, and what place it really 0:39 place it really 0:39 place it really has in your 0:40 has in your 0:40 has in your health plan. I 0:42 health plan. I 0:42 health plan. I help women during 0:43 help women during 0:43 help women during this period every day to figure out 0:45 this period every day to figure out 0:45 this period every day to figure out what is actually causing 0:46 what is actually causing 0:46 what is actually causing their symptoms and what is 0:47 their symptoms and what is 0:47 their symptoms and what is just optimistic 0:48 just optimistic 0:48 just optimistic claims from 0:49 claims from 0:49 claims from supplement manufacturers. And 0:52 supplement manufacturers. And 0:52 supplement manufacturers. And vitamin D is one of the 0:53 vitamin D is one of the 0:53 vitamin D is one of the most 0:54 most 0:54 most overrated and 0:55 overrated and 0:55 overrated and misunderstood of 0:56 misunderstood of 0:56 misunderstood of them all. We'll start with 0:59 them all. We'll start with why most 1:00 why most 1:02 perimenopausal women are already 1:02 perimenopausal women are already deficient in it, and 1:03 deficient in it, and 1:03 deficient in it, and why it's important 1:04 why it's important 1:04 why it's important even if it doesn't 1:05 even if it doesn't 1:05 even if it doesn't affect your hot 1:06 affect your hot 1:06 affect your hot flashes. Then 1:09 flashes. Then 1:09 flashes. Then we'll discuss the 1:10 we'll discuss the 1:10 we'll discuss the surprising connection 1:11 surprising connection 1:11 surprising connection between vitamin D and 1:12 between vitamin D and 1:12 between vitamin D and estrogen, which 1:13 estrogen, which 1:13 estrogen, which almost no one 1:14 almost no one 1:14 almost no one explains properly. 1:15 explains properly. 1:17 Next, let's analyze 1:17 Next, let's analyze the results of 1:18 the results of 1:18 the results of the largest 1:18 the largest 1:18 the largest clinical 1:19 clinical 1:19 clinical study on this 1:20 study on this 1:20 study on this issue, because this is the 1:21 issue, because this is the 1:21 issue, because this is the real moment of 1:22 real moment of 1:22 real moment of truth. And in the end, an 1:24 truth. And in the end, an honest answer to 1:25 honest answer to 1:25 honest answer to the question of whether it is worth 1:26 the question of whether it is worth 1:26 the question of whether it is worth taking it or is it 1:27 taking it or is it 1:27 taking it or is it better to refuse it. And 1:29 better to refuse it. And 1:29 better to refuse it. And this is not the answer 1:30 this is not the answer 1:30 this is not the answer most people expect.
Why Most Women in Perimenopause Are Low 1:32 most people expect. 1:34 Most 1:34 Most perimenopausal women are already 1:35 perimenopausal women are already 1:35 perimenopausal women are already deficient in 1:36 deficient in 1:36 deficient in vitamin D, and it's 1:37 vitamin D, and it's 1:37 vitamin D, and it's important for your 1:38 important for your 1:38 important for your health whether 1:39 health whether 1:39 health whether it affects your 1:40 it affects your 1:40 it affects your symptoms or not. 1:41 symptoms or not. 1:42 symptoms or not. So, low 1:43 So, low 1:43 So, low vitamin D levels are 1:44 vitamin D levels are 1:44 vitamin D levels are common, 1:45 common, 1:45 common, very common in fact
The Real Connection Between Vitamin D and Estrogen 1:46 very common in fact 1:46 very common in fact . But 1:47 . But 1:47 . But prevalence doesn't 1:48 prevalence doesn't 1:48 prevalence doesn't mean it 1:49 mean it 1:49 mean it explains everything. This is where it 1:51 explains everything. This is where it 1:51 explains everything. This is where it gets interesting. Vitamin D 1:53 gets interesting. Vitamin D 1:53 gets interesting. Vitamin D and your estrogen are 1:54 and your estrogen are 1:54 and your estrogen are more closely linked 1:55 more closely linked 1:55 more closely linked than most people 1:57 than most people 1:57 than most people realize, and 1:58 realize, and 1:58 realize, and not at all in the way you've 1:59 not at all in the way you've 1:59 not at all in the way you've probably heard. 2:00 probably heard. 2:00 probably heard. Vitamin D is not 2:01 Vitamin D is not 2:01 Vitamin D is not just a nutrient for 2:03 just a nutrient for 2:03 just a nutrient for bones. It interacts 2:06 bones. It interacts 2:06 bones. It interacts with the same pathways that 2:07 with the same pathways that 2:07 with the same pathways that regulate the production 2:08 regulate the production 2:08 regulate the production and use of 2:09 and use of 2:09 and use of estrogen in the 2:10 estrogen in the 2:10 estrogen in the body. And this 2:13 body. And this 2:13 body. And this connection works in both 2:14 connection works in both 2:14 connection works in both directions. So, 2:17 directions. So, 2:17 directions. So, the biology is interesting and the 2:18 the biology is interesting and the 2:18 the biology is interesting and the connection to estrogen is 2:20 connection to estrogen is 2:20 connection to estrogen is real, but I know 2:21 real, but I know 2:21 real, but I know what you really 2:22 what you really 2:22 what you really want to know. Does 2:25 want to know. Does 2:25 want to know. Does it help with 2:26 it help with 2:26 it help with my symptoms or not? 2:27 my symptoms or not?
What the Largest Trial Actually Found 2:28 my symptoms or not? Let's look 2:29 Let's look 2:29 Let's look at the 2:30 at the 2:30 at the research results. Here's the 2:31 research results. Here's the 2:31 research results. Here's the part where I have to give an 2:33 part where I have to give an 2:33 part where I have to give an honest answer, even though 2:34 honest answer, even though 2:34 honest answer, even though it's not what most 2:35 it's not what most 2:35 it's not what most people want to hear. 2:37 people want to hear. 2:40 Researchers have studied 2:40 Researchers have studied the effects of vitamin D on 2:41 the effects of vitamin D on 2:41 the effects of vitamin D on bones, mood, and hot 2:42 bones, mood, and hot 2:42 bones, mood, and hot flashes in this group, 2:44 flashes in this group, 2:44 flashes in this group, and the results are 2:44 and the results are 2:44 and the results are much more complex 2:46 much more complex 2:46 much more complex than the 2:47 than the 2:47 than the labels in 2:47 labels in 2:47 labels in supplement stores promise. 2:48 supplement stores promise. 2:51 So, if vitamin D 2:51 So, if vitamin D isn't a direct remedy 2:53 isn't a direct remedy 2:53 isn't a direct remedy for hot flashes or 2:54 for hot flashes or 2:54 for hot flashes or bad moods, does 2:55 bad moods, does 2:55 bad moods, does that mean it 2:56 that mean it 2:56 that mean it should be 2:57 should be 2:57 should be eliminated altogether? Not quite. 2:58 eliminated altogether? Not quite. 2:59 eliminated altogether? Not quite. This is how I actually 3:00 This is how I actually 3:00 This is how I actually look at it in 3:00 look at it in 3:00 look at it in working with my 3:01 working with my 3:01 working with my patients. Before 3:03 patients. Before 3:03 patients. Before I get into my 3:04 I get into my 3:04 I get into my recommendations, 3:05 recommendations, 3:05 recommendations, take a second and 3:06 take a second and 3:06 take a second and like 3:07 like 3:07 like this video. This 3:08 this video. This 3:08 this video. This helps more 3:09 helps more 3:09 helps more women 3:10 women 3:10 women find real, 3:11 find real, 3:11 find real, evidence-based answers 3:12 evidence-based answers 3:12 evidence-based answers instead of assumptions. And 3:13 instead of assumptions. And 3:13 instead of assumptions. And if you haven't 3:14 if you haven't 3:14 if you haven't subscribed yet, 3:15 subscribed yet, 3:15 subscribed yet, please do. I 3:17 please do. I 3:17 please do. I cover 3:18 cover 3:18 cover similar studies 3:19 similar studies 3:19 similar studies about perimenopause and 3:20 about perimenopause and 3:20 about perimenopause and menopause every week. So, 3:21 menopause every week. So, 3:21 menopause every week. So, let's get back to the topic. 3:23 let's get back to the topic. 3:23 let's get back to the topic. The honest, scientifically 3:24 The honest, scientifically 3:24 The honest, scientifically based 3:24 based 3:24 based answer is not “ 3:26 answer is not “ take it” or “ 3:26 take it” or “ miss it.” This is more
The Honest Answer on Taking It or Skipping It 3:28 miss it.” This is more 3:28 miss it.” This is more useful than any 3:29 useful than any of this. That's an honest 3:32 of this. That's an honest 3:32 of this. That's an honest answer, but 3:33 answer, but 3:33 answer, but let me 3:33 let me 3:34 let me summarize. 3:34 summarize. 3:39 Most women 3:41 are deficient in vitamin D during this transition period, and 3:41 are deficient in vitamin D during this transition period, and restoring it is 3:42 restoring it is 3:42 restoring it is beneficial for the bones, 3:44 beneficial for the bones, 3:44 beneficial for the bones, immune and 3:44 immune and 3:44 immune and metabolic systems, 3:45 metabolic systems, 3:45 metabolic systems, regardless of the impact 3:47 regardless of the impact 3:47 regardless of the impact on hot flashes. 3:47 on hot flashes. 3:52 The hormonal connection is 3:52 The hormonal connection is real, but it 3:53 real, but it 3:53 real, but it works both 3:54 works both 3:54 works both ways. This is not a 3:55 ways. This is not a 3:55 ways. This is not a switch that can be 3:56 switch that can be 3:56 switch that can be simply flipped. 3:57 simply flipped. 3:58 simply flipped. The most robust 3:59 The most robust 3:59 The most robust research suggests 4:00 research suggests : Don't expect 4:01 : Don't expect 4:01 : Don't expect vitamin D alone to cure 4:02 vitamin D alone to cure 4:02 vitamin D alone to cure your hot flashes, 4:03 your hot flashes, 4:03 your hot flashes, mood swings, or insomnia. 4:05 mood swings, or insomnia. 4:07 This is not a disappointing 4:07 This is not a disappointing answer. This is a useful 4:10 answer. This is a useful 4:10 answer. This is a useful answer because now 4:11 answer because now 4:11 answer because now you know where to 4:12 you know where to 4:12 you know where to focus your efforts 4:13 focus your efforts 4:13 focus your efforts instead of 4:14 instead of 4:14 instead of guessing. So, if 4:16 guessing. So, if 4:16 guessing. So, if you have a deficit,
The Lab Number to Aim For 4:17 you have a deficit, fix it. 4:18 fix it. 4:18 fix it. I usually 4:18 I usually 4:18 I usually recommend a level of 4:20 recommend a level of 4:20 recommend a level of around 50-60 4:20 around 50-60 4:20 around 50-60 nanograms per 4:21 nanograms per 4:21 nanograms per milliliter based on 4:22 milliliter based on 4:22 milliliter based on 4:24 test results. This is worth 4:24 test results. This is worth doing for 4:25 doing for 4:25 doing for overall health, 4:26 overall health, 4:26 overall health, not just to 4:27 not just to 4:27 not just to combat hot 4:28 combat hot 4:28 combat hot flashes. Just don't 4:29 flashes. Just don't 4:29 flashes. Just don't expect it to 4:30 expect it to 4:30 expect it to fix your 4:31 fix your 4:31 fix your hot flashes, mood swings, and 4:33 hot flashes, mood swings, and 4:33 hot flashes, mood swings, and your sleep on its own. At this time, 4:34 your sleep on its own. At this time, 4:34 your sleep on its own. At this time, research does not 4:35 research does not 4:35 research does not confirm this. If 4:37 confirm this. If 4:37 confirm this. If you want a 4:37 you want a 4:37 you want a personalized 4:38 personalized 4:38 personalized answer instead of 4:39 answer instead of 4:39 answer instead of guesswork, click 4:40 guesswork, click 4:40 guesswork, click on the first link in the 4:41 on the first link in the 4:41 on the first link in the description and we'll 4:42 description and we'll 4:42 description and we'll create your plan together. 4:43 create your plan together. 4:44 create your plan together. If you need 4:45 If you need 4:45 If you need clear, science- 4:46 clear, science- 4:46 clear, science- based 4:47 based 4:47 based answers about what 4:48 answers about what 4:48 answers about what happens during 4:49 happens during 4:49 happens during perimenopause, from a 4:50 perimenopause, from a 4:50 perimenopause, from a doctor who treats it 4:52 doctor who treats it 4:52 doctor who treats it every day, subscribe 4:53 every day, subscribe . I release new 4:54 . I release new 4:54 . I release new videos every week.
Comments