Full Transcript Introduction and psychedelic science update 0:02 Welcome to the trip lab kitchen table conversations about integrative medicine 0:07 and psychedelics. I'm your host and attending physician, Dr. Mariela Wood. 0:13 Hi everyone, welcome back to another episode of the trip lab. In this 0:17 episode, we're going to go through some updates that have come out in the past 0:20 few years about psychedelic science. So, we have come a long way in our 0:24 understanding of psychedelics. As a quick recap, and I definitely go deeper 0:28 into this in my prior episodes, the classic psychedelics, which we are 0:32 focusing on today, like LSD and psilocybin were first synthesized in the 0:36 midentth century and quickly became the subject of actual serious medical and 0:40 psychiatric research. In the 1950s and60s, they were actually studied for a 0:45 lot of things from alcohol use disorder and depression to end of life distress 0:49 and use during psychotherapy. Then in the early 1970s, for reasons we can 0:53 definitely break down in another episode, these compounds were classified 0:56 as schedule one substances. And as a reminder, to be a schedule one drug, it 1:02 means that the drug has no medical benefit and high potential for abuse, 1:06 which as we have explored on this podcast is not the case for these 1:09 molecules. But you can see why this needs to be a whole separate episode. So 1:14 anyways, they became a schedule one drug. Because of that, research largely 1:18 stopped. And for decades, scientific progress was frozen because these 1:22 molecules became politically and culturally offlimits. Then in the 1990s, 1:27 small groups of researchers began to reopen the door. And over the past 10 1:31 years, psychedelic research has absolutely exploded. We've seen modern 1:35 clinical trials, advanced neuroiming, and a serious re-engagement with 1:40 questions about consciousness, mental health, and healing. But even in the 1:44 past few years, our understanding has deepened even more. Many of our early 1:49 neuroscience explanations we had were very helpful. But we're finding out 1:53 simplified as to be expected when we think about studying consciousness, 1:57 which is what we're really doing when we study these molecules. They did give us 2:00 a framework and a starting point. And if you've listened to my earlier episodes 2:04 when I first started this podcast a couple years ago, you'll definitely hear 2:07 me talk about those models. But today, we're going to do a refresh because some 2:11 of the neuroscience that is coming out is truly fascinating. We're going to 2:15 review what we know, what has changed, and why the newer science is, in my 2:20 opinion, far more interesting than the original story. Not just what's 2:24 happening in the brain, but what that tells us about the body, about healing,
Classic psychedelics and early neuroscience models 2:28 and about how change actually happens. So, to understand what's changed, I 2:33 think it's briefly worth reviewing how we originally explained the neuroscience 2:36 of psychedelics. And this again is the framework that I've used in earlier 2:39 episodes on this podcast. So the classic psychedelics like psilocybin and LSD 2:44 primarily act on the serotonin 2a receptor. They bind to this receptor and 2:49 activate it but they do not increase the release of serotonin itself which is 2:54 very much unlike compounds like MDMA which increase serotonin release 2:57 throughout the brain and the body. The classic psychedelics work more through 3:01 receptor level signaling. So this is one of the reasons that they are generally 3:05 considered physiologically safer and why we often say their effects are primarily 3:10 on perception, cognition, and experience rather than on cardiovascular autonomic 3:15 systems in the same way. This also helps explain why classic psychedelics do not 3:19 carry the same risk of serotonin syndrome that we worry about with other 3:22 serotonergic releasers. Another core explanation we've relied on is reduced 3:27 phalamic filtering. So the phalamus acts as a sensory gatekeeper filtering and 3:33 prioritizing incoming information before it reaches the cortex. Under 3:37 psychedelics, this filtering appears to be relaxed allowing more sensory, 3:41 emotional, and internal information to reach conscious awareness. This has been 3:46 used to explain heightened perception, emotional intensity, and the feeling 3:50 that everything is more vivid or meaningful. We've also talked a lot 3:54 about the default mode network or the DMN. So the DMN is a network of brain 3:58 regions involved in self-referential thinking, autobiographical memory, 4:03 rumination, and maintaining a stable sense of self. So the earlier neuroiming 4:07 studies suggested that psychedelics were associated with reduced activity within 4:11 the DMN, which became a popular explanation for experiences like ego 4:15 dissolution or loss of rigid selfnarratives. So this is where an 4:20 important pivot has occurred. So we'll come back to that because what we're 4:23 seeing now is better described as DMN modulation, not just simple suppression. 4:29 Finally, we've talked about neural entropy. So the entropic brain 4:33 hypothesis proposed by Robin Carard Harris initially articulated in his 2014 4:38 paper and then refined over time most notably in later work by Carl Fryon 4:43 proposed that psychedelics increase the variability and flexibility of brain 4:47 activity moving the brain away from rigid habitual patterns into a more 4:52 fluid state. This idea has even been extended into 4:56 broader evolutionary narratives like the stoned ape hypothesis which has been 5:00 most closely associated with Terren McKenna. So this hypothesis suggests 5:04 that altered states may have played a role in expanding cognition and 5:08 perception in early humans. So they thought that early apes ate psychedelic 5:13 mushrooms which played a role in their brains evolving and expanding 5:17 consciousness into our now human brains. Again this is purely a hypothesis but I 5:22 think a very interesting one. So altogether these ideas gave us a really 5:26 useful starting framework. We have the serotonin receptor activation, relaxed 5:31 sensory filtering, reduced default mode dominance and increased neural entropy. 5:36 And all of these were really helpful. They helped us move beyond moral panic 5:40 and into mechanism. But they shared a common limitation. They all treated the 5:44 brain as static, modular and regionbased. when actually the brain is 5:49 dynamic,worked and contexts sensitive. So let's take this further. I have four 5:56 major conceptual upgrades that have happened in the past few years that I 5:59 want to dive into today. First the DMN. Our understanding has moved away from 6:04 simply DMN down reggulation and towards DMN modulation and network 6:09 reorganization. The second is a shift from static brain 6:14 maps to dynamic functional connectivity. Third is how we are reframing away from 6:19 entropy as disorder and towards entropy as flexibility, constraint relaxation 6:25 and predictive processing. And last, what I am most excited about 6:29 is our understanding that psychedelics don't just work in the mind, but how it 6:33 impacts the body in therapeutic ways as well. So, let's start with the DMN. One 6:38 of the most common explanations you've probably heard and one I've definitely 6:41 used myself in earlier episodes is that psychedelics downregulate the default 6:45 mode network, the DMN. This idea came from early neuroiming studies by Kheart 6:50 Harris in 2012 and 2014 showing reduced integrity or coherence within the DMN 6:56 under psychedelics like psilocybin and LSD. And at that time this was a very 7:01 important insight. It gave us a neural coralate for experiences like ego 7:05 dissolution, reduced rumination, and the loosening of rigid self narratives.
DMN modulation and network reorganization 7:11 But newer studies, including ones also by carart Harris and others, have shown 7:16 that that explanation is just a little too simple. The default mode network is 7:20 not a single structure or a volume knob that gets turned up and down. It's a 7:24 distributed network involving regions like the medial prefrontal cortex, 7:28 posterior singulate cortex, and angular gyrus. regions that as we already knew 7:33 are deeply involved in self-referential processing, autobiographical memory, and 7:37 maintaining a coherent sense of quote unquote me across time. So we understand 7:42 now that psychedelics don't simply suppress the DMN. Instead, they change 7:46 how the DMN communicates with the rest of the brain. So more recent studies 7:51 show that while within network coherence of the DMN does decrease between network 7:56 connectivity increases particularly between the DMN the salience network 8:02 executive control networks and sensory systems. So lots of science terms but 8:06 essentially the DMN doesn't just quiet down it actually instead becomes less 8:12 isolated very parallel to how people often feel 8:15 during a trip and when they feel more connected to nature around them. So 8:19 again, rather than the sense of self being turned off, what appears to happen 8:24 is that the self becomes less dominant, less rigid, and more permeable to other 8:29 streams of information. So emotional signals, sensory input, and intraceptive 8:34 data gain influence. Networks that are usually segregated begin to communicate 8:39 more freely. This helps explain something that the older downregulation 8:43 model never quite captured. People don't technically experience less of what's 8:47 important to them as a personal eye, which again we associate with that ego 8:51 death. They often experience more of other things, memories, emotion, 8:56 meaning, connection. So from a network perspective, this 9:01 reflects a shift from modular processing toward global integration. 9:06 The brain becomes less compartmentalized and more interconnected. Another key 9:10 update is that these changes are state dependent and time varying. Dynamic 9:15 functional connectivity analyses show that the DMN's role fluctuates over a 9:19 course of a psychedelic experience rather than remaining uniformly 9:23 suppressed. This also aligns far better with subjective reports which include 9:28 moments of dissolution followed by insight followed by reorganization. 9:32 So when we say DMN modulation, we're really talking about a rebalancing of 9:37 influence. The DMN still participates in cognition, but it no longer holds the 9:42 same top- down control over perception, emotion, and meaning making. This fits 9:47 closely with predictive processing models where psychedelics are thought to 9:50 relax the precision waiting of highlevel priors, allowing bottom-up signals to 9:55 update entrenched beliefs and narratives. So, seen this way, ego 10:00 dissolution isn't the absence of self, it's the temporary softening of the 10:04 brain's habitual model of self. And that subtle shift from suppression to 10:10 reorganization turns out to be far more interesting than our original story. So 10:14 once we stop thinking about the default mode network as something that's simply 10:18 turned off or on, the next question naturally becomes, well, what is the 10:22 brain doing instead? And this is where another major shift has happened in 10:26 psychedelic neuroscience. Early imaging studies, not just in psychedelics, but 10:30 across neuroscience, tended to rely on static brain maps. You take a scan, 10:36 average activity across time, compare conditions, and describe differences as 10:40 increases or decreases in specific regions or networks. And that approach 10:44 gave us some important early insights. But it also assumed something that turns 10:49 out to not be true. It assumed the brain under psychedelics exists in one stable 10:54 state. We now know that this assumption doesn't hold. More recent analyses using 10:59 dynamic functional connectivity show that psychedelic states are highly 11:04 timevary which means instead of a single altered 11:07 brain state the brain moves through multiple network configurations over the 11:11 course of a session. So essentially the psychedelic brain is constantly in 11:15 motion and this makes sense when you step back and think about how a trip 11:19 goes. But now we actually have neuroscience that is catching up. So 11:23 studies show rapid shifts in how networks couple and decouple including 11:27 the DMN, salance network, executive control network and sensory systems and 11:33 connectivity patterns fluctuate on the scale of seconds to minutes really. So 11:37 this update is crucial because when you listen to people describe psychedelic 11:41 experiences, they don't describe one uniform state. They describe waves, 11:47 moments of disintegration, moments of emotional intensity, than insight, 11:52 clarity, and reorganization. So, dynamic connectivity models align 11:57 far better with this lived experience than static maps ever did. Another 12:01 important implication is that no single scan can fully capture how psychedelics 12:05 work. We can't study psychedelics as a snapshot in time because that snapshot 12:10 is totally different depending on when you look, what the person is doing, 12:14 whether the brain is at rest or engaged, and the individual's baseline network 12:19 organization. So, this makes sense, of course, but 12:22 it's really important that this is now explained neuroscientifically in the 12:26 literature. This helps us explain why results across studies sometimes appear 12:30 inconsistent and why that inconsistency isn't 12:33 necessarily a flaw, but I think actually a feature of psychedelics and it helps 12:37 us understand the mind better, too. So, we're seeing that psychedelics seem to
Dynamic connectivity and shifting brain states 12:41 expand the brain's repertoire of possible states, allowing it to explore 12:46 configurations that are normally less accessible. Rather than pushing the 12:49 brain toward one new pattern, they increase fluidity of transitions between 12:54 patterns. So I think from a systems perspective this is enormous. It 12:58 reframes psychedelic action not as a destination like a particular brain 13:02 state you enter but as a process a period of heightened flexibility in 13:08 which old patterns loosen and new ones can emerge. And as you can imagine this 13:13 has really important downstream consequences. If the therapeutic effect 13:17 were simply about landing in the right brain state integration wouldn't matter 13:21 at all. But if the effect comes from moving through states, then meaning 13:26 making, reflection, and postexperiencing processing become of the utmost 13:30 importance, not something that's optional. This dynamic view also helps 13:34 explain why psychedelic effects are so sensitive to context. The brain isn't 13:39 being forced into a single configuration by the drug alone. It's being nudged 13:44 into a more explorable landscape where environment, expectation, memory, 13:49 emotion, and bodily signals all shape which paths are taken. So when we move 13:55 away from that static brain map and toward dynamic functional connectivity, 14:00 we stop asking questions like what brain state do psychedelics create? And we can 14:04 start asking new questions like what kinds of transitions do psychedelics 14:08 make possible? And once we shift what we're asking, I think the rest of the 14:12 newer neuroscience, especially around entropy, relaxed constraints, and 14:16 prediction start to make a lot more sense. So with that, let's talk about 14:21 that entropy conversation. So early on, the entropic brain hypothesis proposed 14:26 by Kheart Harris in 2014 suggested that psychedelics increase neural entropy, 14:32 meaning greater variability or diversity in brain activity patterns. And this is 14:37 powerful. This helped explain why rigid mental states like depression, 14:41 addiction, and obsessive thinking may loosen under psychedelics. But as this 14:46 theory matured, it became clear that the word entropy was doing a lot of work and 14:50 sometimes being misunderstood. What the newer models clarify is that this is not 14:55 randomness, which is often associated with the word entropy, so not just 15:00 neural noise. Instead, psychedelics appear to increase the range of possible 15:05 brain states the system can access. So, a helpful way to think about this comes 15:10 from predictive processing models of the brain. In this framework, the brain is 15:15 constantly generating predictions about the world and about the self based on 15:19 past experience. So, these predictions or priors help keep perception and 15:24 behavior stable and efficient. This is what allows us to go about our world and 15:29 operate in a shared agreed upon reality with the rest of the people around us. 15:33 And under normal conditions, those highle priors carry a lot of weight. 15:38 They constrain interpretation and they keep perception, emotion, and identity 15:42 within familiar bounds. What psychedelics appear to do is temporarily 15:47 relax the precision of those highle priors. So this was reported in a 2019 15:52 study by Carheart Harrison Fryen. And let me emphasize this phrase, relax 15:58 precision. The priors don't disappear. They just become less rigid. So when 16:04 that happens, bottom up signals like sensory input, emotional states, 16:08 interceptive information from the body gain more influence over the system. The 16:13 brain becomes more open to updating its internal models. So this is where 16:18 entropy gets redefined. Entropy in this context doesn't mean chaos. It means 16:23 expanded flexibility. It means the brain can explore 16:27 configurations that are usually inaccessible because it's constrained by 16:31 habit, expectation, and deeply ingrained narratives. Another important note is 16:36 the system isn't breaking down. It's temporarily becoming more plastic or 16:40 flexible. So again, this also helps us explain why context and meaning matter 16:44 so much. If psychedelics simply just scrambled the brain, similar to, let's 16:49 say, electric shock therapy, expectation wouldn't shape outcomes. 16:53 But if psychedelics loosen constraints on interpretation, which we now believe
Entropy, predictive processing, and flexibility 16:59 that's what they do, then set and setting become biologically relevant 17:03 inputs, not just psychological add-ons. And outside of the neuroscience 17:08 community, people have been talking about the importance of set and setting 17:11 for ages. And now we just have an explanation, at least a current 17:15 explanation that I'm sure will change of why. This also explains why people don't 17:19 just experience altered perception. They experience new emotional associations, 17:25 reframed memories, shifts in identity, and changes in how bodily sensations are 17:30 interpreted. And these are exactly the kinds of changes you would expect if 17:34 highle predictive models were temporarily softened, allowing new 17:37 learning to occur. Importantly, this also explains why the effects of 17:41 psychedelics are not inherently therapeutic. Flexibility can go in many 17:46 directions. So without safety, guidance, and integration, relaxed constraints can 17:51 just as easily reinforce fear or confusion. But when paired with 17:55 supportive context, that same flexibility allows deeply entrenched 17:59 patterns to reorganize. So when we revisit this idea of entropy with all 18:04 this new neuroscience, we arrive at a much more interesting conclusion. 18:09 Psychedelics don't heal by creating disorder. They heal by creating a window 18:13 of increased adaptability. And this leads perfectly into our next 18:18 topic. From not just brain only explanations to brain body context 18:23 interactions. So up until now, most explanations of 18:27 how psychedelics work have focused almost entirely on the brain. So 18:31 receptors, networks, connectivity, predictions. 18:35 And we actually often frame them this way to emphasize the safety of these 18:38 molecules. You know, saying, "Oh, they just work in the mind." And yes, 18:42 primarily what they do is change consciousness. But in my opinion, one of 18:47 the most important shifts in recent years is a growing recognition that 18:51 psychedelics do not just act on the brain in isolation. They act within a 18:56 brain body context system. And this honestly makes sense because people 19:00 report more than just visual or cognitive effects. They express feeling 19:04 things more deeply. We see people report increased intense bodily sensations, 19:10 changes in breathing and heart rate, waves of emotion that feel physical, and 19:15 a heightened awareness of internal states. So, I think these experiences 19:19 point us towards something that neuroscience is actually starting to 19:21 take seriously now, and that's interosception, which is the brain's 19:25 perception of signals from the body. Under psychedelics, interosceptive 19:30 signals appear to gain salience. Sensations that are normally filtered 19:34 out or interpreted automatically become available to conscious awareness. This 19:40 includes signals from the autonomic nervous system, the visceral organs, and 19:44 emotional circuitry that is tightly coupled to the body. So, psychedelics 19:48 may not be increasing heart rate on a receptor level alone, like how we would 19:52 think of a beta blocker directly lowering heart rate or blood pressure, 19:55 but they increase awareness of our bodily sensations that are normally 20:00 controlled beneath conscious awareness. And when we become aware, we are in a 20:05 state where things like heart rate and blood pressure can fluctuate because of 20:09 that awareness. So again, I think this supports what we know in mindbody 20:13 medicine. So I think we really have to reframe the idea that psychedelics quote 20:17 unquote just work in the mind. They actually heighten the brain body 20:21 connection and our ability to access mindbody medicine. This also helps 20:26 explain why psychedelic experiences often intersect so strongly with trauma, 20:30 emotion, and identity. Trauma, as we're learning, is not stored as an abstract 20:35 memory alone. It is deeply encoded in patterns of autonomic response, muscle 20:40 tension, breathing, and visceral sensation. So if psychedelics relax
Brain-body context and integration 20:45 predictive constraints in the brain, they can also relax habitual 20:49 interpretations of bodily signals. So sensations that were once labeled in 20:54 our mind as a threat can be reexperienced, recontextualized, and 20:58 integrated differently. So we know now even more deeply that context shapes 21:03 nervous system state. and safety, trust, relational presence, and environment all 21:10 influence autonomic tone, stress hormone signaling, and interceptive 21:14 interpretation. And in a brain that has become more 21:17 flexible and less constrained under the influence of psychedelics, this matters 21:21 even more. This is why two people can take the same compound, same dose, and 21:26 have profoundly different experiences and outcomes. So essentially what I'm 21:30 saying is it's not just the drug, it's the system in which the drug is acting. 21:35 I think this shift also pushes away from a purely pharmacologic explanation of 21:39 how the healing happens. Psychedelics don't insert new information into the 21:43 brain. They alter how information is processed across the brain body 21:48 interface. So temporarily widening the space in which learning can occur. So 21:53 I'll say this again. This is where integration becomes even more essential 21:57 than we originally thought. If the therapeutic effect were simply about 22:00 receptor activation or network reconfiguration, integration would be 22:04 optional. But if psychedelics open up a window of heightened sensitivity to 22:09 bodily signals, emotion, meaning, and relationship, then what happens before, 22:15 during, and after that window shapes whether the change consolidates or 22:19 fades. This whole brain body context model also helps explain why psychedelic 22:23 research is increasingly intersecting in fields like trauma therapy, somatic 22:27 approaches, autonomic nervous system regulation, and of course, integrative 22:32 medicine. And this opens so many doors to things that we're only beginning to 22:36 explore like how sex hormones, menstrual cycling, stress physiology, and embodied 22:43 experience may actually influence psychedelic responses. And this 22:47 ultimately is where psychedelic neuroscience is heading. Not towards 22:51 simpler explanations, but toward models that better reflect how humans actually 22:55 experience change with or without psychedelics. So when we zoom out and 23:00 look at the full picture, what becomes clear is that psychedelics were never 23:04 doing one simple thing. Our explanations were simplified because the tools and 23:08 language we had at the time were simpler. What we see now is far more 23:12 interesting. Not suppression, but modulation. 23:16 Not a single brain state, but dynamic transitions, 23:21 not chaos, but a temporary window of flexibility shaped by the brain, body, 23:27 and context. So, I think psychedelic science hasn't just advanced by adding 23:31 more data. It's actually asking better questions now, which is why we are 23:35 finding out these new things. And as our models continue to evolve, so will how 23:40 we understand healing, change, and the mind itself. 23:45 Thanks for listening to the trip lab. If you liked this episode, please subscribe 23:49 and share so we can get the conversation started about integrative medicine and 23:53 psychedelics to destigmatize it and fully explore what this could mean in 23:57 the
Comments