Full Transcript Introduction to Detox Supplements 0:01 [music] >> Welcome to The Trip Lab, kitchen table 0:05 conversations about integrative medicine and psychedelics. [music] 0:08 I'm your host and attending physician, Dr. Mariela Wood. 0:14 Hi everyone, welcome back. Today we are doing part four of five in our detox in 0:19 a toxic world series, where we are taking a deeper, more evidence-based 0:23 look at environmental toxins, how they affect health, and what we can 0:26 realistically do about them. So, quick recap. In part one, we talked 0:31 about what environmental toxins actually are. We went through the major 0:35 categories we are exposed to in modern life, and also looked at how they 0:38 actually affect the body. In part two, we shifted into practical ways to reduce 0:42 exposures, especially in the home, and we looked at the home as a health 0:46 ecosystem. Then last week in part three, we moved into talking more about the 0:51 body, and what the body is already doing 24/7 to detox and excrete these toxins 0:57 and other toxins, and what we can do to support those natural detox and 1:01 elimination pathways through nutrition, hydration, movement, sleep, stress 1:06 reduction, and more. So, make sure to check out those episodes because they 1:09 are definitely the foundation to all of this. 1:12 But today, we are getting into a part of this conversation that I think is super 1:16 important to talk about, especially in the age of social media, and that is all 1:21 about detox supplements, protocols, cleanses, and essentially all things 1:26 being sold in the name of detox. And as a reminder before we begin, I have 1:30 companion guides for all of the parts in the series that you can find on my 1:34 website at dr.marielawood.com/guides. 1:38 That's d r m a r y e l l a w o o d dot com forward slash guides. So, today, 1:45 supplements, protocols, products on the market. So, we're going to get into all 1:49 of that in a really thoughtful way. And I'm actually pretty excited about 1:53 this episode because my specialty, so integrative medicine, is the specialty 1:57 of medicine with a board certification that combines evidence-based holistic or 2:02 {quote unquote} alternative, whatever you want to call it, practices with 2:06 conventional medicine. So that means that I spend a lot of time 2:10 bridging the {quote unquote} hard medicine that we learned in medical 2:13 school and residency with things like nutrition, lifestyle, herbal medicine, 2:17 mind-body medicine, and that also involves supplements and a lot of the 2:21 recommendations you see in the wellness world. So every day I'm posting out what 2:26 actually has evidence and what is just overhyped on social media. And the truth 2:29 is, if you've listened to any of my podcasts, a lot of these {quote unquote} 2:33 alternative practices actually do have a lot of evidence to support them. And if 2:37 you really want to deep dive into where that divide between {quote unquote} 2:41 alternative medicine and Western medicine came into play, check out 2:45 episode number 15 on my podcast called how big pharma led us to call Eastern 2:50 medicine alternative. And spoiler alert, it does have to do with money. But 2:54 anyways, that's not what this podcast is about. Sort of. We'll get into that. But 2:59 what I'm really trying to say is that my passion project is really educating 3:02 people about what they can do to support health and healing in a way that 3:06 actually helps and does not cause harm. And it's crazy that I have to say this 3:10 out loud, but I am a medical doctor. And the reason that I state that is because 3:15 unfortunately the wellness industry is filled with a lot of not doctors that 3:20 are giving personal medical advice. So wellness influencers, 3:25 some medical professionals who are not physicians but put on their social media 3:29 that they are physicians. So a whole slew of people who are not medical 3:32 doctors, not board certified, did not go through residency. You get my point. So
Evidence-Based Supportive Supplements 3:37 I think first and foremost, I just really urge you to be cautious with what 3:40 you hear or read online. At the same time, I actually do think 3:44 that this wellness movement is net positive. If you really look at it, it's 3:48 encouraging people to learn for themselves, to take control of their 3:51 health, to understand their bodies, and most importantly, to advocate for 3:56 themselves. And I think that is beautiful and something that is way 3:59 overdue. And this whole old dichotomy where physicians were the ones that knew 4:03 everything about the body and everyone else did not is just so wrong. So, we 4:08 are definitely definitely moving in the right direction here. But, as we move in 4:12 this direction, I think it's really important to actually parse out the 4:15 evidence. So, don't believe everything that you hear online and actually look 4:19 at where did this data come from? So, today we're going to do just that. We're 4:23 going to look closely at what is actually out there and give you a more 4:27 evidence-based look at supplements, protocols, detox cleanses, coffee 4:31 enemas, yes, we are going to talk about those, and essentially all things 4:36 marketed in the name of detox. So, as we jump in here, I think a really helpful 4:40 way to frame this, that in my opinion kind of changes the entire conversation, 4:45 is by clearly differentiating detox supplements from supplements that 4:50 support detox pathways. And I know that does sound a little bit nitpicky, but I 4:55 really do think that distinction is everything. Because that is what shifts 5:00 this conversation away from overhyped marketing claims and back towards 5:04 actually supporting real physiology. And one last thing that I'll point out 5:09 before we get into all these is that a lot of the products and protocols 5:13 marketed as detox can be convincing precisely because people actually feel 5:18 something happening. So, coffee enemas, detox teas that 5:22 clearly cause diarrhea, aggressive cleanses, really extreme protocols. So, 5:28 all of those things actually do create noticeable effects in the body, which 5:33 then people often take to mean that they are working. But, I think that's 5:37 actually a little bit manipulative because most of the body's real 5:41 detoxification and elimination processes are actually not things that you can 5:45 feel happening in real time. You cannot feel your liver doing biotransformation. 5:51 You cannot feel your kidneys filtering blood and making urine. You also don't 5:56 feel your lymphatic system clearing out waste during sleep. So, just think about 6:00 that. Our bodies are doing extraordinary things for us all day long without those 6:04 processes coming into conscious awareness. So, keep that in mind as we 6:08 go through the rest of this podcast. So, we're going to talk about 6:12 supplements today. Before we talk about them, the other thing that's really to 6:16 know when we're talking about herbs or supplements is that they really should 6:19 be treated like medications. They don't require prescriptions like 6:23 medications do, but they're still biologically active and can interact 6:28 with medications, can be a contraindicated with certain medical 6:32 conditions or certain stages of life like pregnancy. Dose matters. Too high 6:38 might cause side effects or increase chance of medication interactions. Too 6:42 low is probably doing nothing at all. So, I encourage you to really think 6:45 about supplements as medications. And also that they are supplements. So, they 6:51 are meant to support the body after you're already doing things like 6:54 nutrition, mind-body medicine, exercise, etc. The other common misconception that 6:59 I want to say about supplements is that they actually are regulated, but they 7:03 are not regulated like drugs. So, even though you should still think of them 7:06 like drugs, they don't go through the same testing and regulatory processes 7:11 that medications do. So, that means that an herb or a 7:15 supplement does not have to prove efficacy before hitting the shelves. 7:19 Beyond that, third-party testing is not required to sell a supplement. But, I 7:25 personally am going to be here and require you to make sure that your 7:28 supplements are third-party tested before you take them. So, there are 7:31 organizations out there that will test supplements to one, make sure that they 7:36 actually contain what they say they contain and the dose that is listed on 7:39 the bottle. And number two, 7:42 that there are not contaminants or adulterated substances, which is 7:45 probably more important. So, there was actually a recent study that randomly 7:50 tested supplements sold online and found that most of them did not contain a 7:54 single ingredient listed on the bottle. And a lot of them contained prohibited 7:59 substances like medications in them. Beyond that, a lot of the side effects 8:05 from herbs are actually from contaminants, not the herbs themselves. 8:09 So, all over, really make sure that you're choosing a good quality product 8:13 that's been third-party tested. And of course, of course, always talk 8:18 with your personal physician before starting any supplement or herbal 8:21 product. So, overall, this episode is education 8:25 to talk to you about which supplements have evidence, which don't, which can be 8:29 harmful. So, this is an educational-based 8:32 episode. I'm going to start with the more 8:34 supportive supplements, then we'll get into some that have a little bit less 8:37 data, but may actually be helpful and not harmful. 8:41 Then we'll get into the ones that have even less data and potential for harm. 8:45 Then we'll talk about protocols and all those things. 8:47 So, let's start with milk thistle. So, this is an herb that contains silymarin. 8:52 And in herbal medicine, it's considered a liver-supportive herb, which I 8:56 actually think is the right way to think about it. 8:58 So, it has antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, hepatoprotective, 9:02 which means liver-protecting effects, and some evidence that it may actually 9:06 support glutathione activity, which is our body's master antioxidant, and a 9:11 word that you'll hear come up a lot in this episode. And we actually have 9:14 meta-analyses that show that this herb significantly improves liver enzymes and 9:18 metabolic markers in patients with liver disease. 9:21 So, overall, I actually am a fan and I use it in the clinic in certain 9:24 situations. More importantly, it is generally safe and well-tolerated, so it 9:28 can be a great option for a lot of people. That being said, you might not 9:32 necessarily need it, and since it is still an herb, it may interact with some 9:36 medications. So, of course, always talk to your doctor before using it. 9:40 Next, we have NAC or N-acetylcysteine. I also hear people calling it NAC. So, 9:46 this one also has quite a bit of evidence. And it is actually 9:50 FDA-approved for Tylenol overdose and is used in hospitals. 9:54 So, NAC is a precursor to glutathione, which again is the body's master 9:59 antioxidant. And when it's used in the hospital, it's 10:02 used specifically to protect the liver from further injury from that Tylenol. 10:07 And I actually use this one quite a bit in my integrative practice to support 10:10 detox pathways, particularly in patients who have genetic mutations that may 10:15 impact detox pathways, like the MTHFR gene mutation. It's also a mucolytic, so 10:20 can be used for congestion and bronchitis. There's also evidence to 10:23 support its use in women's health conditions like PCOS and fertility 10:27 support. Endometriosis is another one. So, overall, I like this one. It has 10:32 evidence and it is safe if it's used in the right setting and at the right dose. 10:36 So, next, we have glutathione, which I've already mentioned a couple times 10:40 here. So, milk thistle may help support glutathione activity. NAC is a precursor 10:45 to glutathione, so let's just actually talk about glutathione itself. So, 10:49 glutathione, which I've said multiple times, is one of the body's main 10:53 antioxidants. And one of the key molecules that is 10:56 involved in a lot of detoxification pathways, especially in the liver. So, 11:00 it helps protect cells from oxidative stress and plays a major role in how the 11:04 body processes and clears toxins, medications, and waste products. 11:10 So, you actually can take glutathione as a supplement rather than taking milk 11:13 thistle or NAC. But the one issue with this one is it does tend to be a little 11:17 bit more expensive. Because if you're taking it directly, it does need to be 11:21 in a liposomal form in order to improve absorption. So, great option, but I 11:27 personally lean towards NAC over glutathione because it's more 11:30 cost-effective, more stable, and it's giving the body the raw materials to 11:35 make glutathione when it's ready and where it needs it. So, a great one if 11:40 you want to spend the money, I think it definitely can be helpful. 11:43 But, I think a more realistic option is NAC. 11:46 Next, we have alpha-lipoic acid or ALA, which is actually a naturally occurring 11:50 compound that our bodies do make in small amounts, and we can also find it 11:54 in foods like spinach, broccoli, tomatoes, potatoes, and organ meats. So, 11:59 ALA acts as an antioxidant as well and supports mitochondrial energy 12:04 production, which then in turn helps support our body's detox pathways and 12:09 also helps recycle other antioxidants, including glutathione, vitamin C, and 12:14 vitamin E. And we actually have evidence that it may help with diabetic 12:17 neuropathy, lowering cholesterol, and may also help support weight loss. Not a 12:22 weight loss supplement in itself, but may help support a weight loss process. 12:27 And more specific to detox, we have emerging evidence that it may help 12:30 mitigate adverse effects of heavy metals and has a very mild heavy metal 12:34 chelating activity. Next, we actually have a few probiotics 12:39 that are being studied for their effects to support detox pathways, primarily 12:42 through the gut microbiome. So, first we have Lactobacillus rhamnosus GR-1 or 12:48 LGR-1, which has actually been shown to bind heavy metals in the intestinal 12:52 tract. There's actually a really cool pilot study where the researchers gave 12:56 pregnant women and children in Tanzania a probiotic yogurt with this specific 13:01 strain, and they found protection against mercury and arsenic levels. So, 13:05 this one may actually be an amazing treatment for people living in areas 13:08 where exposure to heavy metals is a lot higher. We also have several animal 13:12 studies looking at other probiotic strains as well, specifically 13:15 Lactobacillus casei 13:19 plantarum CCFM 8661. So, to make it simple, just think 13:24 Lactobacillus family. There's animal data that these strains may have 13:28 supportive properties to help excrete heavy metals primarily through their 13:31 action on bile acid metabolism. Next, there are few foundational 13:36 vitamins and minerals that are really important to detox pathways as well. So, 13:39 the B vitamins, especially B2, B6, folate, and B12 specifically help 13:45 support methylation, energy production, and biotransformation pathways. B6 13:51 though, I do want to call out to be careful with because over 13:53 supplementation causing high levels of B6 can actually cause neurotoxicity. So, 13:59 be careful with that one. Selenium is another one that can be really helpful
Plausible but Limited-Data Supplements 14:03 because it helps support antioxidant enzymes including glutathione 14:07 peroxidase. Zinc as well also supports a lot of enzymes. So, for all of these 14:12 ones, micronutrients, most of the time I typically recommend getting from food 14:16 sources, but if you test and a patient has a known deficiency, it can be 14:20 helpful to supplement as well. Okay, next supplement on our list is 14:23 glycine which I really like and I use often 14:26 because it's simple, inexpensive, and it works in a few different ways. 14:31 So, glycine is an amino acid that helps the body make glutathione. It's also 14:36 involved more directly in phase two detox pathways. And it's actually a 14:40 great sleep support supplement as well, which we also know that sleep is 14:44 important for overnight detox and lymphatic drainage. And studies have 14:48 been done for sleep specifically that show when taken before bed, glycine can 14:52 improve sleep quality and next day fatigue. 14:55 Okay, next we have broccoli sprouts or sulforaphane. So, last episode, I talked 15:00 about how much cruciferous vegetables help support detox. So, this would be a 15:04 version that you can actually take in a supplement form. And of course, you can 15:07 always just eat more broccoli or eat broccoli sprouts, but if you're looking 15:11 for a supplement, specifically sulforaphane activates NRF2, which is 15:17 one of the body's major pathways for turning on antioxidant defenses and 15:21 phase two detox enzymes. And more specifically for detox, looking 15:26 at airborne pollutants, a randomized clinical trial has shown 15:30 that broccoli sprout beverages increased excretion of benzene by 61% and acrolein 15:36 by 23% over 12 weeks. Next, we have curcumin or turmeric. So, 15:41 this one I see come up a lot in detox supplement conversations. 15:45 And I would say it's not directly a detox supplement, but it is a potent 15:49 anti-inflammatory, which can help lower the overall total toxic burden. And 15:54 turmeric has a lot of uses. I use it in a lot of different scenarios, but it can 15:58 interact with medications, specifically blood thinners, so also one that you 16:01 want to be careful with. Next, we have psyllium, which is a soluble fiber. So, 16:06 this one again, not a direct detox supplement like some of the earlier ones 16:09 we've talked about, but it can help support regular bowel movements. And as 16:13 we talked about in the last episode, this is super essential. So, once the 16:17 liver processes toxins, hormones, and waste products, they then get sent to 16:21 the gut through bile to get excreted through stool. So, constipation can 16:26 actually lead to reabsorption of those waste products and toxins. So, psyllium 16:30 can help move things along and continue those excretion processes. There's also 16:35 some emerging evidence that fiber specifically can help bind toxins, too. 16:39 So, another supportive mechanism. Okay. So, all of those ones I think have more 16:43 evidence, are safe, supportive, they can help with other things other than detox, 16:48 so all ones I generally reach for. So, next, we're going to move on to some 16:51 supplements that may be plausible, but there's just not a lot of data to 16:55 support these ones. So, first on my list is chlorophyll. So, I see this a lot in 16:59 wellness spaces. A lot of my patients are taking this one 17:03 in the hope that it may bind certain toxins in the gut. So, what is it? 17:07 Chlorophyll is the natural green pigment in plants and algae that absorbs 17:11 sunlight for photosynthesis. And the data to support detox is really emerging 17:15 and at this point pretty theoretical. I think probably the most interesting 17:18 study showed that chlorophyll did show some reduced aflatoxin DNA biomarkers. 17:23 So, aflatoxin is a toxic and carcinogenic compound produced by molds. 17:28 So, it reduced aflatoxin biomarkers by 55% in high-exposed populations. So, 17:33 interesting, plausible, but again, just one specific contaminant in 17:37 highly-exposed populations, so not great data for general use. Chlorophyll is 17:42 actually generally safe and well-tolerated, but I do think the 17:45 benefits are overhyped at least right now. Along those same lines, next on my 17:49 list is spirulina, which is a nutrient-dense blue-green algae that is 17:53 being studied for its antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, and possibly heavy 17:57 metal binding effects. And there is some evidence. I think the 18:01 most notable human study is in chronic arsenic poisoning, 18:05 where they studied a combination of zinc and spirulina, and they did see some 18:10 improved clinical signs and increased urinary arsenic excretion when compared 18:14 with placebo. So, very interesting, but I think still very different from saying
Potentially Harmful Detox Products 18:19 that spirulina is a broad-proven detox supplement for everyday use. And outside 18:23 of very specific contexts like that, the evidence is still generally pretty 18:27 limited. So, again, plausible, interesting, generally safe and 18:31 well-tolerated, but not high enough on the evidence list that would make me 18:35 recommend it to people. The one caveat here that's really important is that 18:39 some spirulina products can vary in quality and have contaminants that can 18:43 be harmful. So, sourcing again, good supplement quality really matters here. 18:48 Next is modified citrus pectin, which is basically a form of pectin that 18:53 has been broken down into smaller pieces so that it's more absorbable and easier 18:57 to use as a supplement. And the reason that it comes up in these 19:01 detox conversations is that there is some evidence that it may help bind 19:05 certain compounds in the gut, and also some interest in its effects on 19:09 galectin-3, inflammation, and tissue repair. 19:13 In one small pilot study, modified citrus pectin did show an increase in 19:17 the urinary excretion of arsenic, cadmium, and lead in children over a few 19:21 days of use. So, interesting, but not a ton of data here. I think the bigger 19:26 concern is that it may actually interfere with absorption of certain 19:29 nutrients or supplements, which again may be preventing detox if you're not 19:34 getting what you need. Okay, so three with some plausible data, probably not 19:39 harmful if you're getting the right product. 19:41 Next, we're going to move into some supplements that have potential for 19:44 harm, so I generally don't recommend it. Some of them have not a lot of evidence, 19:49 some of them have caveats, so this is where we're getting a little bit dicey. 19:53 So, first I'll start with activated charcoal. And this one I really want to 19:56 talk about because it does actually have real medical use. So, it is used in the 20:01 emergency room for certain kinds of acute poisoning or overdose. So, it 20:05 binds substances in the stomach and the gut and reduces how much actually gets 20:09 absorbed into the body. So, mechanism, very real. We actually use it in the 20:13 hospital. I think where things get a little messy is when activated charcoal 20:17 gets pulled into the wellness world and it's added to everything. I've seen 20:20 smoothies, lattes, ice cream, detox drinks, and it's marketed as this magic 20:25 thing that's going to bind toxins. The problem is 20:30 it does not selectively bind only the bad things. It also binds medications, 20:36 supplements, nutrients, and if you take too much, it can cause constipation, 20:41 vomiting, and other GI issues. We've also seen it cause bowel obstructions, 20:45 so for this one, definitely potential for harm if used too much. Kind of along 20:50 the same lines, we see things like zeolite or bentonite clay, which again, 20:55 both are marketed as binders because the idea is that they can bind certain 20:59 compounds in the gut and help carry them out through the stool. However, for 21:02 these ones, the evidence to support these claims is very limited. And many 21:07 clay-based products actually contain heavy metals like arsenic and lead, 21:11 which obviously is the opposite of what you're trying to do. 21:14 And again, just like charcoal, it can cause constipation. So, these ones I 21:17 would say probably just avoid. And piggybacking off of both of those, I 21:22 would say anything that says heavy metal detox kit or home chelation kit. So, 21:26 these are usually products sold as powders, drops, capsules, tinctures, and 21:31 they often contain some kind of mix of binders, herbs, minerals, sulfurs, 21:37 clays, and a bunch of ingredients that are marketed as chelators. 21:42 So, real chelation is an actual medical treatment used for confirmed heavy metal 21:47 poisoning. So, it's really not a casual wellness 21:50 protocol. And the scary part is that a lot of 21:54 these can cause dehydration, kidney injury, and even cases of death. Now, of 21:58 course, that's the dramatic end point, but most people don't actually need 22:02 heavy metal chelation therapy. I think this is really where we need to 22:06 think about the fact that wellness influencers are not doctors. So, they 22:10 did not go through 12 years of formal medical training. So, I really encourage 22:15 you not to listen to them when they recommend home detox kits. That they 22:18 honestly probably have no idea what's actually in them and are probably also 22:22 getting a kickback if you purchase them. So, there are so so many things that you 22:25 can do for your health and wellness, but taking medical advice from a wellness 22:30 influencer that is not a doctor is not one of them. So, unless they can explain 22:35 how glomerular filtration works, tell you what macula densa cells do, explain 22:40 what cytochrome P450 enzymes are, what medications and herbs they interact 22:44 with, or they can tell you what the relationship between the sympathetic 22:47 nervous system and the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone 22:50 system is, I would be cautious. 22:53 Okay, anyways, we'll move on from there. Related to the heavy metal detox kits 22:57 and the home chelation kits, I would also strongly advise against detox tea 23:02 blends, colon cleanse blends, and liver cleanse blends. 23:06 And aside from detox, when it comes to any herb or supplement in my practice, I 23:10 generally shy away from products that are blends, especially proprietary 23:15 blends, because they don't actually list the amount of each ingredient in there. 23:20 And kind of what I talked about in the beginning, a lot of these detox blends 23:23 tend to produce very noticeable physiologic reactions. 23:27 So, people actually feel cramping, urgency, diarrhea, or a flushing 23:31 feeling, so they think that means the product is working. 23:34 But again, feeling something happen does not equal detox is happening. So, 23:39 remember that these detox reactions are working behind the scenes, and they're 23:43 not actually part of our conscious awareness. 23:45 So, all these cleanses contain unregulated doses of laxatives, 23:49 diuretics, stimulants, herbs, and other irritating ingredients that can cause 23:54 dehydration, loss of sodium and potassium, and other electrolyte 23:57 disturbances, kidney damage, infections, even bowel perforations, which literally 24:03 means a hole in your bowel, which is actually life-threatening and requires 24:07 emergency surgery. So, just in general, do your due diligence before you take a 24:12 product recommended by a wellness influencer. 24:15 Okay, next. Coffee enemas. So, people are literally putting coffee 24:20 up their butts. And this is all over social media, like 24:23 all over. As I was doing some research for this episode specifically to see 24:27 what people were doing for detox, this was probably the number one thing that I 24:31 saw. So, let's talk all about it. Where did this come from? Why are people doing 24:35 it? So, the idea actually became popular largely through Gerson style cancer 24:40 protocols, because those protocols theorized that coffee absorbed through 24:45 the colon would stimulate the liver and gallbladder and increase bile flow to 24:49 help clear toxins. Which, okay, okay, plausible. Coffee by 24:54 mouth does impact bile secretion and colon motility. But, when you actually 24:59 look into it, there are actually no studies out there that support this 25:03 theory of coffee absorbed through the colon. And we actually do have one human 25:07 study looking at coffee enemas that found no beneficial effects on 25:11 glutathione or oxidative stress markers. So, what I kept seeing online was this 25:16 claim thrown around everywhere that coffee enemas increase glutathione by 25:21 700%. So, that stat was on basically every 25:24 video, blog post that I saw about why coffee enemas are good. They're great 25:29 because they increase glutathione by 700%. So, I did some digging. 25:34 And where this claim came from was actually one single study in 1982 25:40 where mice were given ground coffee beans, so not coffee enemas, 25:46 and they found that it increased glutathione S-transferase activity.
Detox Protocols and Fasting 25:51 So, not glutathione, but glutathione S-transferase activity by 700%. 25:57 So, not in humans, not coffee enemas, and not actually glutathione itself. So, 26:04 I think this is just a perfect example of a number gets thrown around and then 26:08 it gets taken and transformed and used by hundreds of thousands of people 26:13 and no one actually knows where that number came from. And they think that it 26:16 increases glutathione by 700%, but there's actually no studies to prove 26:20 that. So, all in all, there's no evidence to support the coffee enema 26:24 claims. And in fact, we actually have evidence that debunks those claims. 26:28 Additionally, and I think more importantly, 26:31 is that we do have evidence that coffee enemas can cause electrolyte imbalances, 26:35 dehydration, infections, proctocolitis, rectal burns, rectal perforation, so 26:41 again, a hole in your rectum, and death. Now, of course, those are very severe 26:46 side effects. They're not common, but if we're thinking about a 26:49 risk-benefit comparison, there's no proven benefit, and there is potential 26:54 for harm. So, all in all, my recommendation, just drink your coffee. 26:59 You don't need to put it up your butt. Okay, now let's talk a little bit about 27:03 detox protocols because I actually do think that there are some out there that 27:07 are actually pretty helpful. >> [snorts] 27:09 >> They're definitely some that are harmful, so we'll talk about both types 27:11 here. But, I'll start off with my general 27:14 take. If a detox protocol is depleting the 27:17 body or stressing the body in a prolonged fashion, 27:22 then it is actually undermining the very physiology that it claims to support. 27:27 So, remember, our bodies are designed to detox. So, any protocol should support 27:32 all the organs involved, the liver, the gut, the kidneys, the nervous system, 27:37 not deplete them and then create a scenario in which you have to recover 27:41 from. So, I would say on the more harmful end 27:45 of detox protocols would be things like prolonged fasting, very low protein 27:50 cleanses done over long periods of time, high-dose laxative protocols, which 27:55 we've already talked about, repeated diarrhea-inducing supplements, 28:00 and in general, just very restrictive plans that leave people underfed, wired, 28:04 dehydrated, and then ultimately constipated. 28:08 So, that is not support. That is physiologic stress. 28:13 And if the body is underfed, losing electrolytes, not stooling properly, 28:18 sleeping poorly, and just running on stress hormones, it is very hard to 28:22 argue that detox is being supported during that process. And for liver 28:26 cleanses specifically, they truly are doing the opposite of what people are 28:30 taking them for. So, they may help push toxins out of the liver and into the 28:34 gut, but they're also constipating. So, then those toxins just get reabsorbed 28:38 rather than excreted. Fasting specifically does have some 28:42 benefits, which I'll talk about in a second, but when it is is 28:45 and depleting, it genuinely causes harm, and can lead to longer healing times, 28:51 and a shutdown of a lot of the detox pathways because your body is truly just 28:55 trying to survive and get out of that fight or flight and into a mode of 28:59 safety. Okay. So, what about some examples of 29:02 protocols that I actually do think are helpful? 29:05 So, there are a lot out there that are actually structured around intensive 29:08 periods of eating and living really well. For example, Dr. Hyman's 10-day 29:13 detox is great. It's basically a short, intentional 29:16 reset built around whole foods, no processed sugar, no ultra-processed 29:21 foods, better sleep, hydration, movement, and just in general reducing 29:26 inflammatory inputs. University of Wisconsin also has a detox 29:30 handout with similar principles. I also think programs that have fasting 29:34 mimicking styles and very short-term can also be helpful if done every once in a 29:38 while, because those ones are supporting fasting physiology while still giving 29:42 the body nutrients, and it's done over a short period of time. So, let's talk 29:46 about that fasting physiology. When we fast, the body starts to shift from 29:51 constantly running on incoming glucose and towards using more stored glycogen, 29:56 fat, and eventually ketones for fuel. So, when that happens, insulin levels 30:00 fall, glucagon rises, and the body moves into a more metabolic switching state. 30:07 And that shift helps reduce oxidative stress, improve insulin sensitivity, and 30:12 activates some of the body's own repair and clean-up pathways. 30:16 So, that short time-limited fasting state supports autophagy, mitochondrial 30:21 efficiency, improved metabolic signaling, and in some cases liver 30:25 health, too. There's also pretty decent human data 30:28 showing that time-restricted eating can improve things like body weight, waist 30:32 circumference, fasting glucose, insulin resistance, and some liver markers, 30:36 especially in people with metabolic dysfunction. 30:39 So, intermittent fasting, or more accurately time-restricted eating, is 30:42 one way to do this. So, this can be a 12-hour overnight fast or 14:10 or 16:8. 30:50 So, with 16:8 means that you eat within an 8-hour window. So, we'll say noon to 30:55 8:00 p.m. or 11:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. And then you fast the rest of the 24 hours. 31:01 Another way you can get the benefits of fasting is to do a full 24-hour fast 31:05 very occasionally, like maybe a couple times a year. But, make sure you're 31:09 still drinking plenty of fluids during that 24-hour fast. And of course, this 31:12 too should all be individualized. If you're on medications or have a complex 31:17 medical or psychiatric history, this really should be done under the guidance 31:20 of a physician. Okay. 31:23 So, this episode was a little bit more 31:26 ranting and myth debunking than I've ever done on a podcast, but let me know 31:29 if you found all this helpful. Because integrative medicine really does 31:33 sit at this unique intersection between wellness culture and medicine. So, I 31:38 think it's really important to talk about the claims that people hear online 31:41 and really look at the evidence behind them. And if you got lost in the weeds 31:44 here, just a reminder that I have a companion guide to all of these episodes 31:48 in this detox series that you can find on my website at 31:51 dr.maryellwood.com/guides. 31:55 So, d r m a r y e l l a w o o d.com/guides. 32:01 But, as we close out this episode, I really want to bring us back to the 32:05 bigger picture. My goal here really is to not be cynical 32:08 about supplements or to assume that everything in the wellness world is 32:12 nonsense. My goal is to really get a little bit 32:15 more discerning. So, some supplements and some short-term protocols really can
Closing Thoughts and Next Episode Preview 32:20 be supportive in the right person and in the right context. 32:24 Others may be mostly marketing. And of course, like we talked about, some can 32:28 actually be genuinely harmful. And honestly, the best detox support is 32:33 still the least glamorous option. So, nourish the body well. 32:38 Hydrate, support your sleep, move, sweat, address constipation actively, 32:45 reduce exposures where you can, and if you're going to use supplements, 32:50 use ones that actually support your physiology rather than products that can 32:54 just create a dramatic reaction and give the illusion of healing. 32:59 So, remember, your body's already doing extraordinary work for you every single 33:02 day. It does not need to be punished or 33:05 shocked into detox, and usually just needs support. 33:09 Varying levels of support for different people and for different things, 33:13 but really if you support the body, it's going to do the job. So, with that, next 33:18 week in part five, we're going to tackle a new lens in the world of detox. So, 33:23 we're stepping away from environmental toxins, the liver, the gut, glutathione, 33:28 and we're actually going to talk about digital detox and the new age of toxins. 33:33 We'll dive into a lot of interesting topics, so what we know about screen 33:37 time, overstimulation, EMFs or electromagnetic fields, 33:42 more into stress physiology, red light therapy, all those sorts of things that 33:47 are actually pretty new and wasn't even around just decades ago. 33:50 So, we'll talk all about what it means to protect your health in a world that's 33:54 not just chemically toxic, but also cognitively and energetically toxic as 33:58 well. So, thanks for listening. I will see you next week. 34:03 Thanks for listening to The Trip Lab. If you liked this episode, please subscribe 34:07 and share so we can get the conversation started about integrative medicine and 34:11 psychedelics to destigmatize it and fully explore what this could mean in 34:15 the world. >> [music]
Comments