Full Transcript Billie Eilish's vegan comment sparks backlash 0:00 Everyone, this is Clout on the PVM Podcast. Today, we're going to be 0:02 looking at what Billie Eilish said to Elle magazine and how this broke the 0:06 internet. Let's first go to the clip. What's one hill you'd die on? Y'all not 0:10 going to like me for this one. Eating meat is inherently wrong. And then the 0:14 other thing is two things cannot coincide. 0:19 I love animals. I love all animals so much and I [music] eat meat. You just 0:22 They're just You can't do both. Sorry. You can eat meat. Go for it. You can 0:26 love animals, but you can't do both. So, that clip divided a lot of opinion, 0:32 but then Billie Eilish responded to some of the backlash on her stories on 0:36 Instagram. Let's look at what she said. Go watch a documentary, too, and some 0:40 footage of what is done to animals you claim to love and what it does to the 0:43 planet you pretend to love as well. If that footage was hard for you to watch, 0:46 I encourage you to please take a look at yourself. Like, I'm so tired of standing 0:50 up for having empathy for living beings being controversial. Please continue to 0:54 live in a constant state of cognitive dissonance and denial and try to 0:59 convince yourself that you're not living a lie. Wow. Wow. 1:03 Immediate reactions. I get it and I get what she was trying to say. I think the 1:08 problem is it's always a sign by, isn't it? It's always just one little clip. 1:12 She doesn't have time to explain any of the nuance and a lot of people have come 1:15 at her and said, you know, there are plenty of cases where people can't go 1:18 vegan or indigenous cultures where they have to eat animal products and all this 1:21 kind of stuff, but I don't think that's what she was talking about. I think she 1:24 was talking about people where you do have access, you're not in a food 1:26 desert, you're going to the supermarket every single day and you're still 1:29 choosing to say, "No, it's fine. I can love animals and eat them." And in those 1:33 cases, I don't think you can, can you? Agree. I agree. Shabnam, I want to I 1:37 want to lean on you for your perspective. I can't wait. I know you're 1:40 riled up about this. It's certainly divided opinion, right? On both sides. 1:44 PETA have leveraged this to create awareness in Times Square in New York. 1:48 If you're watching this on YouTube, look at the screen. You can see the ad in the 1:51 middle of New York, but there have been other reactions. 1:53 >> You guys have cognitive dissonance and I'm like, 1:56 we have got We We do We do. Says the one who's blaming all the people eating the 2:01 meat and not the people that are abusing animals. Like, why are you mad at us? 2:06 Shabnam, what's your take? Cognitive dissonance. That's exactly what we're 2:10 talking about here. And this term was coined by Festinger in 1957, right? This 2:15 is the discomfort we feel when our beliefs and our behaviors conflict. And 2:20 let's be honest, the mass majority of people in the Western world, globally, 2:25 they love animals and a lot of them eat them, too. So, what I think Billie did 2:29 here is she didn't just share an opinion, she named a contradiction that 2:33 millions, maybe billions of people are actively managing every day. And when 2:39 someone gives dissonance that voice, right? Especially publicly, someone with 2:43 a platform of over hundreds of millions of followers, the anger isn't really 2:47 directed to Billie. She's just the voice, right? It's about that internal
Cognitive dissonance and the meat paradox 2:51 tension that suddenly got externalized. And I think that's what Billie's talking 2:56 about, and she is tired of being a mouthpiece, and I can only imagine how 2:59 exhausting that could be, but she's not wrong, is she? You can eat meat, you can 3:03 love animals, but you can't do both. Incorrect. I think you can do both. 3:09 >> Yeah, you can. I think the notion that humans are anything other than 3:12 hypocrites is just completely wrong. I think we always live in a state of 3:15 hypocrisy. Cuz like, everyone's Everyone just sees the whole world as so black 3:19 and white, I think. Like, you can't love animals Okay, you're eating meat. Okay, 3:22 maybe that's a direct harm. But let's say like you drive a car to work. Okay, 3:26 that's going to be pumping out fossil fuels. That's going to be contributing 3:29 to climate change. That harms ecosystems and animals and potentially future 3:32 generations. And like, there's there's harm in everything you do to a certain 3:36 level. And okay, you can arbitrarily draw a line here and be like, "Oh, if 3:40 you're doing these things, you do love animals, but if you're doing these 3:43 things, you don't." But you're just drawing an arbitrary line somewhere. You 3:46 can love animals, but just love meat more. A lot of vegans say there's no 3:49 ethical consumption of animal products. In fact, I think I had chickens for a 3:53 while and they lay eggs and okay, they've evolved by our 3:57 artificial selection for them to produce way more eggs than they ever would in in 4:00 nature. And obviously that drains them a lot of a lot of micronutrients and 4:04 macronutrients and stressful on their body. Like there's there's a degree of 4:07 suffering there, but we loved our chickens and they, you know, they had 4:10 free roam, they lived relatively decent lives and stuff. And I I love those 4:15 chickens, but I loved their eggs as well. But did he eat the chickens? 4:18 That's a fascinating thing about thinking people that actually reared 4:21 chickens for the use of a product versus the product themselves of the body of 4:26 the chicken. And the fascinating thing is people are horrified. My god, I would 4:31 never eat my chicken. What are you talking about? I love my chicken. Just 4:34 eat their eggs. Even the chickens eat their own eggs. This element of 4:38 displacement. There are bigger problems in the world or moral disengagement, 4:42 right? Like it's natural. Humans have always done this. Animals eat each other 4:47 in the wild. These are just coping strategies, the mental gymnastics that 4:51 people play to acquiesce the cognitive dissonance that they are feeling. 4:55 >> Cuz he says it's an arbitrary line that you draw to say you're not going to eat 4:59 animals. I don't think that is an arbitrary line. It's an obvious place 5:03 where you can personally make a difference and not take a life each time 5:07 you eat a meal. I don't think that is arbitrary. It's like it's tangible. It's 5:12 something that you can actively take control of yourself, right? Whereas 5:15 like, you know, if you have to drive a car to work, you have to drive a car to 5:18 work. I think it's weird to like compare both and say like, well, if you're not 5:21 going to do absolutely everything in every single category, then you may as 5:24 well not be a vegan. I disagree. So Billie Eilish went on an interview and 5:28 said that their hot take is that you can't love animals and eat meat at the 5:31 same time. They said this as a famous vegan superstar. And vegans, please stop 5:34 typing the hate comment. I promise it's not the veganism that is the problem. I 5:38 love veganism for the way that it is practicing divesting from a cruel and 5:42 inhumane industry. Veganism is great for the planet. It's great for your body, 5:46 but there are also structural inequalities that impede people's 5:49 ability to engage in veganism and eat animal-free diets that make it extremely 5:54 problematic to connect an animal-free diet to some sort of moral superiority. 5:58 Cuz think about it like this. First of all, the majority of people that work in 6:01 slaughterhouses are people of color. Do we think that the majority of the people 6:04 working in these slaughterhouses are people of color because people of color 6:07 love animals less than white people? Or do we think that's the case because it 6:10 is a job that is really inhumane that a lot of people wouldn't enjoy. Therefore, 6:14 people that are likely the most desperate and have the most limited 6:17 options in their economy work that job. Like, hello, when we make statements 6:21 like this, blanket ones attached to moral superiority like loving animals, 6:25 you ignore all of the structural inequalities at play that create 6:28 people's realities. And on top of those, the closest in proximity to the 6:32 inhumaneness of the animal industry being people of color, the people most 6:37 heavily impacted by food inequality in this country, again, are people of 6:40 color. Scientists that study public health have created the term food desert 6:45 because access to food in this country is so inequitable and so ass. What a 6:48 food desert is is a place in the country where people don't even have access to 6:53 nutritious produce and diverse food options. When public health researchers 6:57 accounted for class, right? So, comparing white people that are 7:00 extremely poor and people of color that are extremely poor, they found that 7:04 people of color that are just as poor as white people were still less likely to 7:08 have equitable food access and more likely to live in a food desert. On top 7:11 of that, people of color are more likely to struggle with food insecurity where 7:14 you don't even know where your next meal is coming from, let alone if that next 7:17 meal is going to contain meat or not. If you have to get things like WIC, 7:20 government-sponsored food, they get to control what food you have access to,
Food deserts, privilege, and structural inequality 7:24 sometimes only giving you certain items, which will include things like eggs and 7:28 milk. Are you just going to not eat them despite not having an option because you 7:32 love animals? There is absolutely nothing wrong with being vegan. If you 7:35 have the resources to do so, I think it is fantastic. But when you make a 7:38 statement like, "I am better than you. I love animals more than you because I 7:42 don't eat meat. And you don't say anything about the fact that there is 7:46 people in this country who have significantly harder capabilities of 7:49 achieving that goal of having an animal-free diet, then you're putting 7:53 wider and richer people in closer proximity to superiority than people of 7:58 color and poor people. And that's just pretty [ __ ] up. 8:01 >> Being vegan doesn't make anyone better than anyone else. And that is especially 8:04 the case when your activism towards animals and veganism ignores the ways 8:08 that those industries also heavily impact living human beings. I think 8:12 Angela from the block makes so many great points. There's real validity 8:16 here, right? We're talking about food accessibility, food deserts, cultural 8:20 identity, economic restraints. These are real, genuine factors that impact 8:25 people's health, their community health, their public health, their individual 8:28 health. And often times they're not predicated on dietary choices. If we're 8:32 dependent upon government resources like WIC, we are dependent upon how they 8:37 frame what foods individuals can purchase on those programs. But again, 8:41 that's not the source of privilege that we're talking about. And I think we need 8:45 to focus again on the privilege problem itself. It's we're arguing that wealth 8:50 and lifestyle, having access to certain types of properties, international 8:54 tours, this gives access to resources that most people don't have. And I think 8:58 we need to acknowledge that some of the most indigenous BIPOC communities and 9:02 cultures depend on vegan and vegetarian-based protein sources as part 9:08 of their cultural identity. I have to be honest, I've gone to 7-Elevens in places 9:13 that are food deserts and I have seen rice and beans on a shelf. It's not 9:17 cheap, but it's there and it's accessible in places where people often 9:22 will choose the hot dog on the turn versus advocating for making food after 9:27 you've probably worked very long hours taking care of people or taking public 9:31 transportation, have so many variables that are making life difficult and 9:34 challenging then and go have to go home and cook and provide is probably not 9:37 idyllic. So, I think it's loaded with a lot of problems that we're facing in 9:41 society, but that's not the issue. What we're talking about is beans, legumes, 9:45 pulses are cheap, affordable, and accessible in most places where we don't 9:49 often think that we can find them. So, if we shift to having a few more meals a 9:54 week that incorporates these lower cost, more nutritious proteins and grains, we 9:59 have a capacity of leading with compassion on our plate. And so, I think 10:04 there's arguments on both ends, of course. But, the answer is both things 10:08 are true. >> Like in Billie Eilish's world, she has 10:10 the money where she can just go get vegan food or vegetarian food wherever 10:13 she is. But, there are certain areas in this country which are like high-key, 10:16 low-key a food desert. And for a lot of people, they don't always have choice in 10:20 the products that they eat as much as what they can afford to eat. 10:24 >> like we said at the start, we weren't arguing that if you are in a 10:27 circumstance where you can't get access to these foods, that doesn't mean that 10:31 you don't love animals. That's your circumstance, and that is very difficult 10:35 and challenging to overcome, but I don't think those are the people we're 10:38 speaking about. We're speaking about the people who do have access and actively 10:41 choose not to, because like you said, they're leaning on the cognitive 10:45 dissonance to just accept the behavior that they potentially know is wrong, but 10:49 don't want to have to think about it. >> have to remember, it doesn't diminish 10:52 the fact of animal sentience, and that's what we're here to talk about as vegans, 10:57 that there is a a deeper meaning to the work that we do and at ethos that we 11:01 follow. The problem becomes in how we push the narrative, and I think anybody 11:06 in a place of Billie's position is entitled to feeling frustration in a 11:11 place of leadership and advocacy. Everyone's been there. 100%. There's an 11:14 interesting comment from Anthony Ad on his Substack at one says, "I said I read 11:18 an online piece by Vox which claimed that it was unusual that the 11:21 overwhelming opposition to her, Billie Eilish's comments, came from those who 11:25 claim to be part of the progressive left. As someone who spent time in the 11:28 US and debated and spoken at liberal campuses there, I don't think this is 11:32 unusual at all. In fact, I think this is entirely unsurprising and predictable. 11:36 I've been called anti-indigenous, classist, and racist by people offended 11:40 that I set up a debate table with the claim that eating animal products is 11:43 morally wrong. The sad truth is that the progressive left continues to abysmally 11:47 fail when it comes to animals. I also say this is someone who sits on the left 11:51 of the political spectrum. Interesting. And we have the Vox clip as well. Let's 11:55 go to the clip and then I want to talk about it cuz I kind of think Ed is onto 12:00 something, but I want to hear your take. Last week, the pop star Billie Eilish 12:04 said something that set corners of the internet on fire. Eating meat is 12:07 inherently wrong. And then the other thing is two things cannot coincide. 12:14 I love animals. I love all animals so much and [music] I eat meat. You just 12:17 They're just You can't do both. Sorry. You can eat meat. Go for it. You can 12:21 love animals, but you can't do both. Whatever you think about Eilish, her 12:26 logic is sound. You can say you love some species like cats and dogs while 12:31 still eating other species like chickens and pigs. But you can't say you love all 12:35 animals if you also eat some animals. And Americans eat a lot of animals. On 12:40 average, each person eats about 24 land animals and 150 aquatic animals. And 12:46 virtually all of them are raised in truly horrific conditions. Still, Eilish 12:51 faced enormous backlash for her comments. And it didn't come from the
Progressive blind spots and media reactions 12:55 people you might expect like carnivore influencers or right-wing YouTubers. It 12:59 mostly came from people who seem to be like Eilish on the far left end of the 13:04 political spectrum. And the response revealed something weird about meat in 13:07 America. That people will come up with really strange justifications to dismiss 13:12 veganism and ignore the extreme suffering of animals. For example, one 13:16 viral response came from a user who said that they quote stop taking white vegan 13:21 seriously after they watched a documentary about indigenous hunting 13:24 practices. But Eilish's statement was clearly directed at the average 13:28 consumer, not at indigenous groups that hunt animals. There's a psychological 13:32 term for what's going on here. It's called the meat paradox. Psychology 13:36 researchers have found that a lot of people feel an uncomfortable cognitive 13:40 dissonance when their love for animals clashes with their enjoyment of eating 13:44 animals. People then try to resolve this cognitive dissonance, and [music] how 13:49 they do it can look different depending on their political beliefs. Like I 13:52 mentioned before, people on the political left might say things like 13:56 veganism is anti-indigenous, while people on the political right might be 14:00 more likely to say things like God gave us animals to eat. What it all sounds 14:05 like to me, and to psychology researchers, are defense mechanisms to 14:09 avoid an uncomfortable truth, that we are all complicit in the torture of 14:13 animals for food, and we also have the power to reduce the suffering of animals 14:18 by eating less meat or none at all. That might make some people uncomfortable, 14:23 and maybe you'll think I'm an annoying vegan for saying so, but I promise you 14:27 that if animals could speak for themselves, they'd be a lot less polite 14:31 than me or even Billie Eilish. >> Do you guys get annoyed by lot of people 14:35 on the political left? I mean, in the UK, typically like Green Party 14:39 supporters just have a blind spot for animal rights and and veganism. That 14:43 does annoy me a bit as a supporter of the Green Party. I'm like, I do find it 14:47 frustrating that like you can be so focused on climate stuff, but not 14:50 acknowledge the huge part that animal agriculture has in destroying the 14:55 environment. Why is that not more publicized or spoken about? But I guess 14:59 I've just gotten used to it. Like class, I don't know, over the years I get you 15:02 you just kind of get used to everyone having a blind spot for this particular 15:06 movement. >> When we watched Angela from the block, 15:09 who made some really, really good points and has clearly thought about structural 15:13 inequalities and those kind of issues, it makes a lot of sense, but at a 15:17 certain point you're kind of going along with it, and maybe it's just the way I 15:20 think, maybe it's I'm not a expansive, I'm quite simplistic thinker, but it 15:24 kind of seemed like at times it's mental gymnastics. Cuz if nobody is saying that 15:27 if you can't eat vegan products, then of course for survival and sustenance, 15:32 you're going to have to go to animal products. Nobody's got an issue with 15:35 that. The definition of veganism is to move away from animal exploitation as 15:39 much as possible and practical. It just seems like there is this kind of 15:43 intellectualizing of kind of what I think is like a common sense thing. 15:47 That's not been around for 10 or 20 years. This concept of veganism and 15:50 non-violence. Where you are in a place where you don't need to exploit an 15:53 animal, why not like subscribe to that idea? Why are you bringing in all kinds 15:57 of other things which are clearly not relevant in this context? But I think 16:00 like to clarify, we don't believe that people here in those situations should 16:05 have to be forced to be vegan. But there are small faction of the vegan movement 16:10 who suggest that you should be vegan absolutely no matter what and like are 16:13 against those kind of cases and are against any sort of animal exploitation. 16:17 So I feel like we as people are quite like nuanced in our thinking about that 16:21 stuff. I think we've got an attitude that's like, yeah, there are some cases 16:24 where it's impossible and we accept that. But there are some vegans who 16:26 don't feel that way. Yeah, and I think they're just sometimes they're bonkers. 16:31 Often I just don't understand it, but like other times I think they're so 16:34 angry and they are maybe misunderstood. And maybe the people on the other side 16:38 who are like, how can Billie Eilish say this? This is 16:41 Maybe they're just misunderstood and angry and what's coming out of their 16:45 mouths doesn't actually represent what they feel. Billie Eilish thinks you 16:48 can't love animals unless you're vegan and I'm really tired of hearing that. So 16:52 I'm going to explain why that's really stupid logic. I donate to the animal 16:56 shelter every month to show I love animals. So if you don't donate to the 17:00 animal shelter every month, you don't love animals. The idea that eating 17:04 plant-based is morally better is also I think bull because unless you're someone 17:09 who's like living off the land, like your land, like you grew it, that's 17:13 totally different. But someone has to like grow that strawberry you're eating. 17:16 They have to pick that strawberry, they have to ship that strawberry to whatever 17:19 grocery, whatever Erewhon it is that we're purchasing it from. Unless you're 17:22 eating like farm-to-table, like you know the farmer, there are people that are 17:25 being exploited in the process of procuring you that strawberry. With the 17:30 same logic, you can't claim to love humanity or love people if you're 17:34 participating in their exploitation. Why did Billie Eilish just spam post a bunch 17:39 of animals getting abused like that was going to solve something? You just 17:43 traumatized like thousands of people. I mean, isn't that the meat paradox in 17:47 itself, right? It describes like the discomfort people are feeling or 17:51 experiencing when they like to eat meat. They really don't want to think about 17:55 what is required for that meat to be provided to them on their plates, right? 18:00 And I think people normalize this in multitudes of ways, right? Brock 18:03 Bastian, who kind of coined this term meat paradox, said that this comes with 18:07 like the four ends, right? The first is natural, like it's natural to do this. 18:12 Animals eat animals, right? We've evolved to eat meat. It's normal. 18:16 Everybody does it. It's necessary. We need protein to survive. We need meat.
How to advocate for veganism more effectively 18:20 And it's nice. It tastes good. I deserve it. All of those are very ego-driven. 18:25 And I think oftentimes with behavior change, the crux of changing someone's 18:29 behavior has to come from them breaking their ego, you know? It can't come from 18:35 somebody else telling them what's being reflected in their response. It's your 18:39 ego that's talking here. And with veganism, there is that hopeful 18:43 potential death to ego that we all experience, right? Or at least we aim 18:47 for. It's the normalization of the need for it, the want for it, the desire for 18:52 it that doesn't align. And again, it falls into that whole cognitive 18:55 dissonance aspect. So, it's a matter of how we converse with others to break 19:00 that way of thinking. And so, I think that's what this is all about. It's not 19:04 what Billie said, it's almost like how she said it and how it landed for 19:09 everybody. It hurt. When that insult is exacerbated on media, it stinks. I'm so 19:15 sure that if she was having a longer discussion on a podcast, it was just 19:18 like a quick question. And I'm so sure that if she was having a discussion like 19:22 this with us, she would be saying the same things. I don't think she believes 19:25 that every single person in the world has to and can be vegan. I don't think 19:29 she thinks that. >> And she's not arguing that she comes 19:31 from a privileged place. I mean, Billie is been vegetarian since birth and went 19:36 vegan at 12. She comes from privilege. There is no doubt about that. That's not 19:40 the only reason why she's vegan. From that privilege came education, access to 19:45 understanding, which launched her vegan advocacy. And also her mom, who's a 19:49 major vegan activist and has helped her make her tour more vegan, lower the 19:54 carbon footprint, have vegan meals available at the tour dates. They're 19:57 doing amazing stuff. They are trying to be forward-thinking and trying to make 20:00 it accessible for everyone. You know, the judgment of like, "Oh, well, she's 20:03 so privileged so she couldn't understand." She's doing what she can to 20:06 actually have a big impact and to help other people also make that choice. That 20:11 was something that British actress Jameela Jamil said in response to Billie 20:14 Eilish. I don't know if you've seen it. She has access, she says here, to the 20:17 best food and a lifestyle where she's too busy to prepare that food, someone 20:20 else can. So, she might not be in tune with how few people can actually afford 20:24 good vegan protein that isn't highly processed, which is bad for people as 20:27 the body can't digest it properly. And you know, she's talking about other 20:30 health issues that people can have, foods that are high in histamine, people 20:33 living with mast cell. But she's like saying, you know, we should shame the 20:37 farming industry and their practices and they do need to do better, but we 20:41 shouldn't be pushing it onto the people that are consuming that stuff cuz it's 20:44 actually a systemic issue. That's kind of what I got from it. Is that what you 20:47 got that she was trying to say? Having read it now, yeah, but it's still not 20:51 that clear. What Jameela is saying is true that the farming industry obviously 20:55 is abhorrent and like the way industrial agriculture is shouldn't be how it is. I 21:00 don't think we should keep participating in it while it is so bad expecting it to 21:04 get better cuz surely that just drives demand, right? I get obviously she's 21:08 saying Billie's privileged, so Billie doesn't have the same circumstances as 21:11 other people. For the people who do, if you just keep buying from a system that 21:15 you don't agree with, doesn't that send a signal to that system to just keep 21:19 going and never change? >> Listen, I I think they both come from a 21:22 space of privilege, but they also both speak from a place of advocacy for those 21:27 that are, you know, less fortunate. I think that there's a need to neutralize 21:32 what's been happening. I don't know why it's going to pass on its own. Let's be 21:37 honest, the media picks up something, it's going to find something else to 21:41 sink its teeth into, no pun intended. I don't know why we're going up in arms 21:45 about this, to be quite honest. We're talking about a very vocal vegan 21:48 advocate with millions of followers who has done everything. She's actually 21:53 worked with my colleague at Greener by Default, her mother at Support and Feed, 21:56 to help, like you said, green her events. And so, it's understanding how 22:02 they're implementing default nudge-based strategies to encourage her fans in ways 22:09 to eat more plant-based. And the difference between that aspect and what 22:14 she said publicly is just that. One's a nudge, done quietly, it's just setting 22:19 up the system for consumers to see things in ways that they are predicated 22:25 to pick more plant-based options. They don't feel like they're being sold a 22:30 lie. They don't feel like they're being taken advantage of. They're buying 22:33 tickets to go to her concerts, they love her music, and they know that she's 22:37 vegan. They know they've been touting, Support and Feed has been touting that 22:40 they've been doing this greening of their events and concerts. People are 22:43 still buying tickets that aren't vegan, and they're purchasing food while 22:47 they're there. So, what's the biggest difference? She said it how it is, 22:51 basically, instead of being like, "Hey, try this. Maybe it" Do you know what I 22:55 mean? She just was blunt. She vocally said, "You can't love animals and eat 23:00 them." She made consumers feel bad about their choices, right? And that's the 23:05 crux of it. That's not going to change someone's behavior. And what we see is 23:09 people double down. They dig their heels in. They'll eat double the meat for 23:12 every vegan. That does it, right? You've heard that argument. So, I think there's 23:16 a way that could share the message more effectively to bait more people into 23:20 seeing what she really sees. And it's not baiting, but it kind of is. You have 23:25 to feed crumbs. Yeah, but I guess she also just got frustrated and she was 23:29 just like, "This is annoying. I want to say it." And yeah, she stands by it. We 23:32 love Billie, always love Billie. Love her for who she is. I love her music, 23:37 and we PBN stand behind you.
Comments