Full Transcript Plant-Based Movement Origins 0:00 The plant-based movement didn't start as a movement about healthy eating. It 0:05 started as a movement about reversing disease. Those are not the same thing. 0:09 Nobody was arguing about seed oils on podcasts. People were dying. But 0:13 somewhere along the way, something changed. The question stopped being what 0:17 diet reverses disease and became, "What diet is healthiest? Show me the 0:22 long-term outcomes." Because that's what built this movement, not theories. 0:27 Personally, I think the movement was strongest when it was focused on disease 0:31 reversal because that's where the evidence was strongest. 0:38 >> Hi everyone, this is K from the PBM podcast. I'm with Sarah. 0:43 >> Hi. >> And Shadnam. 0:45 >> Hi. >> So today we are going to be speaking 0:48 about Jeff Nelson who's come out with an interesting video on his YouTube 0:52 channel. He's been more active on his YouTube channel. I'll link it down 0:55 below. And just as a bit of background, in 2016, Jeff invited me out to his 1:00 healthy lifestyle expo event in California is brilliant. It was 1:04 responsible for PBN certainly on YouTube growing a huge amount. I was given the 1:08 opportunity to interview luminaries in the space such as the late Dr. John 1:12 McDougall, Dr. Neil Bernard, Dr. Alan Goldhammer, and it was just fantastic. 1:17 But Jeff in a recent video has said the plant-based movement has lost its way. 1:24 So, let's go to some of the clips and we're going to break it down. 1:27 >> I've been thinking about something lately. I've been involved in this 1:30 movement for a very long time. Not as a doctor, not as a researcher, but as 1:34 someone who spent decades interviewing the people who built it. One thing 1:37 strikes me today. The plant-based movement didn't start as a movement 1:42 about healthy eating. It started as a movement about reversing disease. And 1:47 that's a very important distinction because those are not the same thing. 1:51 When Nathan Pritikin began his work, nobody cared about avocado toast. Nobody 1:55 was debating whether olive oil was a superfood. Nobody was arguing about seed
Jeff Nelson's Critique of the Movement 2:00 oils on podcasts. People were dying. Heart disease was killing enormous 2:05 numbers of Americans. And Pritikin asked a simple question. Can this disease be 2:10 reversed? Could the disease that he was personally suffering from, could it be 2:14 reversed? Not managed, not slowed, but actually reversed? The idea that you 2:19 could change the course of chronic disease with food was astonishing. But 2:24 somewhere along the way, something changed. The conversation slowly 2:28 shifted. The question stopped being what diet reverses disease and became what 2:34 diet is healthiest? Then what diet is sustainable? Then what diet will people 2:41 actually follow? Now those are legitimate questions, but they're 2:44 different questions. And once you change the question, you often change the 2:48 answer. A diet designed to maximize disease reversal may not be the same 2:53 diet designed to maximize compliance. A diet designed to maximize compliance may 2:59 not be the same diet designed to maximize popularity. A diet designed to 3:03 maximize popularity may not be the same diet that produced the clinical outcomes 3:07 that made the movement famous in the first place. So he is basically saying 3:12 the reason the plant-based movement and I think he's talking about he's not 3:15 talking about the environment. He's purely talking about plant-based in the 3:19 context of a healthy healthful foodbased intervention to improve people's health. 3:24 That's what he's concentrating on. That's what I know his audience is 3:27 focused on and that's what his conferences were about as well. Um 3:31 obviously Jeff and his family have broader views. I think they got into 3:35 vegan plant-based through John Robbins. Care about the environment, care about 3:39 ethics. But I think this video that he made is focused around health. And I 3:43 think what he's saying is that back in the day, 10 or 20 years ago, uh the 3:47 plant-based movement was bold. It was uh clearcut on its objectives. There was 3:52 evidence from, for example, Dr. Ornish showing in 1990 he could reverse the 3:57 progression of heart disease and then subsequently early stage prostate cancer 4:01 and type two diabetes. And this was through a a quite a rigid ambitious 4:06 protocol. So it encouraged people to completely eliminate animal products, 4:10 completely eliminate oil for the most part, eliminate salt and processed 4:14 sugar. And the results were tremendous. They're amazing results. And I think 4:18 what he's saying is now you go online and when people talking about 4:22 plant-based in the context of health, the message is often more watered down. 4:26 >> Yeah. I want to hear Shamnam's perspective because obviously you're 4:29 working in a field of trying to get people to adopt the diet. So it's be 4:34 interesting to hear what your thoughts on are on it. 4:36 >> I mean I think he makes incredible points here and what I really like that 4:40 he acknowledged was that well if you keep on changing the research question 4:44 you're going to get different outcomes and and that seems to be like what is 4:48 happening here. We're changing the framing of what we're messaging as a 4:53 plantbased diet to get more engagement. I I'd argue that 4:59 the opposite of the risk is kind of what's happening right now, right? Some 5:03 corners of the plant-based space have drifted towards identity and this purity 5:08 signaling like, you know, I'm vegan and if you're not vegan, you shame on you 5:15 and that's not going to help. What we're finding is this identity based signaling 5:20 is deterring people from entering this type of behavior change, right? And what 5:25 we find is the actual disease risk data is still really strong for plant forward 5:30 eating, right? Lower cardiovascular uh mortality, lower cancer incidences, 5:36 but that message does tend to land so much better when it's evidence first 5:41 instead of ideology first. And so I think enticing people into the
Disease Reversal vs Health Optimization 5:46 plant-based sphere has required some pivoting, has required some shifting of 5:52 the research question to see how many more people we can engage. But I think 5:57 for those that are really still seeking healthier lifestyles, healthier 6:00 alternatives, the longitudinal evidence there is to support a plant-rich diet. 6:05 >> He rode the same mountain bike route over and over. At first he had to stop 6:09 seven times because of chest pain. Then six times, then five 4 3 2 1. Eventually 6:15 he no longer had to stop at all. Within 6 months his angina was gone. 9 months 6:20 later he was off all medications. He eventually traveled from England to Los 6:24 Angeles to thank Dr. in person. >> When I said I saw Dr. in this taxi, I 6:30 said, "I'm here because of you." >> Now Peter's story is not a randomized 6:36 control trial. is one person's experience. But it raises an important 6:40 question. If reducing risk is the goal, one conversation follows. If reversing 6:46 established disease is the goal, that's a different conversation entirely. 6:50 Modern cardiology often asks, "What diet will lower my risk?" And the reversal 6:56 pioneers, they added a more ambitious question. What diet gives a patient the 7:00 best chance of avoiding another cardiac event altogether? And that's the 7:04 conversation I want to have today. Jeff seems to think that we've gone too far 7:07 and we've lost our way. But I'm wondering if you do think that or do you 7:10 think it was necessary to evolve that way? 7:12 >> I don't think we've gone too far. I don't think we've lost our way. I think 7:15 we're adapting and that's exact exactly what science is, right? I think Jeff 7:20 comes from a time of like the China era study, these these Framingham adjacent 7:25 data studies where um these big population studies, but nutritional 7:29 science and behavioral science has gotten significantly more granular since 7:34 then. Um, and I don't believe >> I think that's a good thing though. 7:36 Sorry to interject. Is that a good thing for people that are on YouTube or they 7:41 just want to get healthier? Do they need they surely need that that north star, 7:46 right? I don't know if it's I don't know. Maybe it's why we disagree. 7:48 >> I don't really think it's the field losing its way. I think it's just 7:52 science being science and it's just studying another variable and aspect of 7:56 food dietetics and behavior change. Like it's it's changing. Populations are 8:01 changing. The way we think about food is changing. Our food systems have changed. 8:05 The way we grow food has changed. The way we we get food has changed. And so 8:10 the science of that has to also adapt with the times. 8:14 >> Over the last decade, we've seen increasing examples on what are often 8:17 called healthy fats. Olive oil, avocados, nuts, nut butters, seeds, 8:23 Mediterranean style eating patterns. And I understand why. They're appealing. 8:27 They're enjoyable. Most people find them easier to stick with. But here's the 8:32 question I don't hear often enough. Where is the disease reversal evidence? 8:37 Not the epidemiology, not the associations, not the food frequency 8:41 questionnaires, not the people who eat nuts seem healthier. And yes, I know 8:46 about the trials. Predamin Leon, the Mediterranean studies that people love 8:50 to cite. But look at what they actually showed. Fewer events, not reversed 8:55 arteries. Nobody opened a patient back up and watched the disease retreat. 8:59 Ornish did that. Esleston did that. Show me where olive oil did that. Where are 9:05 the clinical outcomes? Where are the equivalent results to what Ornish 9:08 published? What Esleston published? What Pritiken published? What Kempner 9:12 observed and published? Show me the patients. Show me the angiograms. Show 9:17 me the reversal. Show me the long-term outcomes because that's what built this 9:22 movement, not theories, actual results. I can see his point, don't get me wrong, 9:27 but I also feel like as scientists, we need to be showing the differing the 9:32 differing levels and values that we see when it comes to consumer choices and 9:37 behavior change. It's not didactic. It's not it's not black and white, right? 9:42 There's a significant amount of gray matter and if we're not studying and 9:45 researching that, we're doing our populations a massive disservice. Now, 9:50 is it information overload? potentially. Absolutely. And I think we we have that 9:56 with with elements like YouTube where people can put out copious amounts of 10:02 content based off of opinion and anecdotes versus evidence-based 10:08 literature. >> I I remember you said something before 10:11 about the approach at your at your job at Greener by default. It was something 10:16 like, you know, you were getting more people to adopt it by making the food
Simple Messaging and Behavior Change 10:20 taste good rather than talking about specifically what it was. So, it wasn't 10:24 like the plant-based whatever. It was just like a a tofu teriyaki something. 10:29 Do you know what I mean? Um, and I can kind of see that because we spoke about 10:33 this before also, Claus, that as soon as you put plant-based or vegan in front of 10:38 something, then people just go la. I don't want to hear it. 10:42 >> I agree. I agree. I think 10 or 20 years ago, the term plant-based was less 10:46 stigmatized than it is now. And this is something that I think perhaps Jeff 10:50 missed out of his video. There's a lot more headwind in the space. So 10 20 10:54 years ago, if you said you're plant-based, you probably met with less 10:56 suspicion and criticism and what's the word hate than if you [clears throat] if 11:02 you say vegan or plant-based now. So yeah, I think there's something to be 11:06 said about science changing in terms of its message from the plant-based 11:10 community. 10 or 20 years ago, it was very black and white, very clearcut. It 11:13 was a clear prescription of what to do to increase your health. Whereas now, 11:19 people like Dr. Greger's approach where the science has become more specific, 11:23 more fragmented. If you add these nutrients in these superfoods, it can 11:29 really help health outcomes. People like Professor Tim Spectre saying if you eat 11:34 30 different plants a week, this is great for your microbiome. And what Jeff 11:39 is saying is like guys hold on there's people like Dr. John McDougall Dr. Neil 11:43 Bernard, these luminaries who had been for the last 30, 40 years just saying 11:48 rice, beans, frozen veggies, microwave, cycled the same four or five dishes for 11:54 2, three, four, five, six months. It's very simple. You don't need to 11:58 complicate it. You don't need to add any of these superfoods or crazy ingredients 12:02 and you get amazing health outcomes. And I think Jeff misses the glory days of 12:07 his healthy lifestyle expose in the early 2000s where that message, that 12:12 recommendation, that simplicity wasn't questioned. It was the default. Whereas 12:16 now, you go on to Tik Tok and social media and as I said, the message being 12:21 watered down. It's been perhaps over complicated. Maybe in the name of trying 12:25 to inspire, but I think Jeff would argue, and I kind of agree, that it just 12:29 uh muddies the water in terms of giving people a clear, easy to follow message. 12:32 you know, for the everyday person, you're not going to have the time and 12:36 the ability to do the granular, you know, sort of micromanaging of the food 12:41 and all that stuff. So, if there's like a more basic way to describe it, which 12:45 is basically like, you know, don't eat animal products, [laughter] which is 12:49 what I do. Um, that might encourage people to get into it. And then once 12:53 you're in, then you can become more granular, I guess, because I think also 12:57 once people adopt a plant-based diet, they get way more into like the ethical 13:00 side, the environmental side, you know, reversing their diseases or whatever. 13:06 And if that has happened to you, you're going to be like an advocate for it and 13:09 you're going to like start getting more into it. But I feel like the entry point 13:13 maybe is the hard part for people. >> And you have to remember now like taste 13:17 par is a thing when we're talking about consumer research and consumer science. 13:22 What we're looking at is do they like it? Does it taste good? Is it flavorful? 13:28 I I mean, you want instant gratification? 13:32 And like you said, Sarah, when we get dive down into the the rabbit hole of 13:37 why I decided to go plant-based or vegan, right, that comes after the fact 13:41 of serving the ego, >> right? 13:46 It's very rare that we see people enter the vegan space based off of what they 13:53 need to do for others first. >> Right. Right. Right. 13:57 >> Right. The majority will enter for how does this benefit me first? And even 14:01 that framing of how do I improve my health 14:06 >> is about me first. When we talk about identity politics, what it does is it is 14:13 it separates those from who already identify as that from those who feel 14:18 otherred from that. And if someone feels otherred from that, often times the one 14:23 thing that they don't want to do is to fight to be part of that group. Of 14:30 course, >> I also think 20 or 30 years ago, uh, 14:34 arguably you had bigger personalities leading the space. How can you recreate 14:40 the personalities of Dr. Neil Bernard, Dr. John McDougall? These guys were 14:46 formidable. They were forced to reckon with. I also think the simple message 14:52 that was put out 15 20 years ago was more effective even if it wasn't 14:57 technically 100% accurate. China study for example published in 2005 you could 15:03 probably look back through that book and go wasn't perfect there it wasn't 15:08 perfect there but overall because it had such a clear message of lowfat whole 15:16 foods plant-based and made it very easy for people to 15:20 follow even though it might not have been exactly on the money and in 15:24 retrospect we can say well certain data has come out that's made us question a 15:28 little bit here and there that clear message really just has helped people, 15:31 inspired people. It's kind of like um the mind body community, right? I've 15:35 been reading some books recently about neuroscience and like how to tackle had 15:40 a bad neck. I've been reading books on like how to tackle neck pain. I read 15:44 this book in the 20th century by Dr. John Sano and this guy, if you don't 15:49 know him, you got to look him up. If you got back pain or neck pain or anything 15:51 like that, you need to look this guy up. This guy's book healing back pain was 15:55 phenomenal, right? It was because it was written in 20 cents. simple message and 16:00 it healed my neck pain within a couple of weeks. But you can now go through 16:06 that book and you can say, "Well, it was wrong here, was wrong there." But it 16:09 gave me a simple message how to de-stress my life and it worked. And I 16:14 think the same thing can be said of some of these healthy lifestyle pioneers in 16:20 plant-based space in the early 21st century and the late 20th century. 16:25 People like Nathan Pritiken, Dr. John McDougall, Colin Campbell, they were 16:29 just so dogmatically clear about the message. And yes, and now you might you 16:35 might be able to say, well, they weren't quite perfect here and there, but it was
Stories, Science, and Audience Engagement 16:40 clear for people to follow. >> Do you think that's also why the 16:43 carnivore movement has had so much success? Because it's so simple. It's 16:46 just like just eat meat. That's basically all it is. And then they're 16:50 talking about their own disease reversal. I haven't had this chronic 16:53 pain. And it's kind of enticing for people and they're like, "Oo, that 16:56 sounds easy. I could do that." >> People just want a simple message. 17:01 People are busy. They want a simple thing to do to improve their health. It 17:07 has to be simple, right? It just makes sense. 17:10 >> People love entertainment. They love entertainment. They love stories. They 17:15 love to be like zazzed. You know what I mean? Like the 17:19 And I think the carnivore group does that really well. And I also think that, 17:25 you know, the way that we market things, they do that really well. Like marketing 17:31 advertising geniuses, and we know Plant-Based News has some of the best of 17:34 the best on the planet. It works. So, um, 17:42 stories sell. And I feel that if we really want to 17:48 realign with the movement, then maybe we should 17:53 be sharing more stories laden with our scientific evidence. And 17:58 I and I feel like this is where Dr. Neil Bernard like excels. 18:02 >> The US government when it was formulating the dietary guidelines, the 18:06 advisory committee said, "Let's go along with that. Cholesterol is not really 18:09 such a big deal." And we showed that on the committee there were four people 18:11 that had economic ties to the egg industry and they were in charge of this 18:15 policy. We filed suit and as this was percolating the government itself 18:22 said wait cholesterol is a problem. I don't care if it's egg funding or or who 18:27 it's funding cholesterol is a problem. You eat cholesterol from eggs your blood 18:30 cholesterol rises. And the way it came down was the government said you should 18:33 eat as little cholesterol as possible. How do you do that? plant-based diet is 18:38 as little cholesterol as possible as >> I think his most recent book it was just 18:42 laden with stories and then supported by research and I'm like these are the 18:47 types of books that people need to read because they can relate to Sally who's 18:53 their same age and has the same type of career that they have but they're not 18:59 going to relate to large population studies like the China study because it 19:04 is too abstract act much like the concept of like you try and tell a meat 19:10 eater that they're the reason why the Amazon is burning. The concept is just 19:17 too abstract for the individual to piece that together. Does that make sense? So, 19:22 it's almost like teaching an alien to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. 19:27 You have to break it down to the most simplest of simplest terms, right? You 19:33 can't just say like put peanut butter on the knife and spread it on the bread 19:38 without telling them to unscrew the top because stab the knife through the top. 19:42 Anyways, I'm going off on a tangent here and none of this should actually be on 19:46 our podcast. >> No, it's a good point though. It is a 19:48 good point. We've said this before. It's a delivery issue. 19:51 >> It's a massive delivery issue. >> Delivery can be combined with the 19:54 science and you've got the best of both worlds. So, let's hope we have more 19:58 figures like Neil Barard coming to the front. And like, yeah, it's a different 20:03 time. We've we've moved on from the old days of the plant-based movement, but 20:06 that doesn't necessarily need to be bad. >> And that's what I'm saying. I don't 20:09 think it's bad. I think it's just different. It's shifting. And we have to 20:14 recognize the environment around us of what's causing that to shift. 20:18 >> I sometimes wonder if younger people entering the plant-based world if they 20:22 realize whose shoulders they're standing on. John McDougall recently passed away 20:27 and losing him felt significant. Not just because he was brilliant, not just 20:32 because he was entertaining, but because he represented a direct connection to 20:36 that earlier era. An era when doctors were still discovering these ideas. An 20:42 era when nobody knew whether any of this would work. An era when people risked 20:46 their careers arguing that chronic disease could be reversed through food. 20:52 Those men were giants. John McDougall is the reason that we're all here this 20:56 weekend. >> I've been in this business for 44 years 21:00 and I'm the [music] luckiest doctor in the world because my patients get well 21:03 and anyone who says differently is distorting my message. The facts are 21:08 absolutely clear but there's a blindfold here and they lie about it. That 21:12 blindfold is full of dollar bills because that's how you make 21:15 >> they changed the conversation and they changed it through evidence. That's why 21:20 I think the most important question for the plant-based movement today is not 21:23 whether olive oil is healthy or whether avocados are healthy or whether nuts are 21:27 healthy. The more important question is what is our goal? If our goal is simply 21:32 to eat better than the standard American diet, okay, that's one conversation. If 21:37 our goal is to maximize longevity, that's another. If our goal is to 21:41 reverse chronic disease, that's another. And those goals may not produce 21:46 identical recommendations. Personally, I think the movement was strongest when it 21:50 was focused on disease reversal because that's where the evidence was strongest. 21:55 >> And what were the um what were the comments like on this video? Were people 21:59 in favor of Jeff or against him? >> Actually, they're saying, you know,
Legacy of the Pioneers 22:03 about their examples. So, for example, someone said, "It's true. Dr. Eslestein 22:07 and all these incredible doctors reversed my hypertension and my high 22:10 cholesterol, not to mention all the other health issues that I wasn't even 22:13 hoping to fix. That was 10 years ago. I'm 65 years old. nomads because of 22:17 these heroes. So, you know, it it does work for sure. And then there's someone 22:22 else who said, "My husband would be dead now if he didn't decide to turn 22:26 plant-based to a plant-based lifestyle in 2011 after watching Forks Over 22:30 Knives." In October that year, he proposed immediately to make the switch 22:34 and I jumped at the chance. He told me one year later why because he had angina 22:38 every time he ate a pizza, which was too frequent. It said [clears throat] solved 22:43 most of our health issues and most importantly reversed his heart disease 22:47 medical test to prove it. We thank Eselstein Caldwell for all their work 22:50 along with other pioneers in the field. And it's also why we love your content 22:54 Jeff. Thank you from the depths of my heart. So, you know, it's mostly people 22:58 just saying yes, those doctors had it right. It actually did work for them. 23:03 But [clears throat] yeah, it's like you said, Chapdam, can we get that added 23:09 into some more exciting storytelling to get more people to come along with us? 23:13 And I but listen to all of what the comments are saying like in and I I I'm 23:19 getting an understanding of the kind of demographic that is responding to this 23:23 video, right? Um and it's very clear, like I said, the disease risk data is is 23:30 really strong for plantforward eating. That's not what I'm trying to say. But 23:33 we're trying to entice 18y olds to eat to eat plantforward to go away from an 23:41 indulgent t-bone steak or a or an Angus beef burger to something a little bit 23:47 more environmentally friendly, ethically friendly. These are not the same type of 23:52 individuals that are making comments on Jeff's YouTube. And I need to be very 23:57 clear here about that. And so when we're talking about 24:02 bringing in the flexitarians, the omnivores into plantforward eating, 24:06 that's what the research is trying to focus on now. How do we get more of 24:09 those individuals to start eating more plants? Somebody said, someone has 24:15 finally said out loud, I work in a hospital and people sick of the net, but 24:18 the machine keeps on churning. Many in the plant-based community have lost 24:21 sight of this point. Thank you for your commitment to the space. I'm vegan in my 24:24 60s, never taking a pill. Got my mother to go vegan when she was 80. She loves 24:28 Asselin. She's 19, never been on meds. >> Yeah, it kind of just further backs up 24:32 what Shaman was saying. It's a different demographic, isn't it? It's the people 24:35 who found them maybe back at the time that they were the height of their 24:39 careers. But we also as well as those people need to get on board. The people 24:43 who are now saying, "I can't be vegan or plant-based because it's too processed. 24:47 I'm flexitarian. I I love bacon." And you know, we need to get everybody on 24:52 board with the message that plant forward is how you actually get the 24:57 health outcomes that you're looking for and live 25:00 >> without sacrificing. >> Yes. Exactly. 25:02 >> It's not a sacrifice. And I think that's the important thing that we're finding 25:05 in our research is that when we're when we're encouraging behavior change, we 25:08 want people to feel like that they're making that choice for themselves and 25:12 they're doing it without feeling like they're making a sacrifice because that 25:16 is what here's long-term behavior change. [music] 25:25 [music]
Comments