Full Transcript Intro to the Jubilee vegan debate 0:00 Hi everyone, I'm with Sarah and Shabnam and today we're going to be watching an 0:03 epic debate on Jubilee, which vegans are losing their minds over. 0:08 >> think we should reduce the amount of pain that plants are experiencing? 0:10 >> Yes, we should. Plants matter. #plantsmatter. 0:14 You're not addressing my points. You are not addressing my points. You are 0:17 deflecting because I literally backed you into a corner. 0:19 >> You can have sex and it was unethical, non-consensual, but it was great, or you 0:23 can have the consensual sex and it's not quite as good. Which one do you pick? 0:26 Probably a cheeseburger. Okay, it's pretty explosive. You've probably seen 0:29 Jubilee before and this episode of Jubilee doesn't disappoint. 0:32 >> Is eating meat unethical, or has the conversation around veganism and ethical 0:37 dieting become too [music] rigid and moralized? And from Jubilee Media, this 0:40 is Surrounded, where one brave soul faces a room full of disagree-ers. 0:44 Today, we're [music] diving headfirst into veganism, factory farming, and what 0:48 it means to eat ethically. [music] I'm here in the center with our featured 0:51 guest, Dr. Jack Symes. Welcome to the show. Hey, thanks for having me. Are you 0:55 ready to debate the circle? Sure am. I'm looking forward to hearing what reasons 0:59 they've brought for their unethical lifestyles. Are you all ready to bring 1:02 your best arguments? 1:05 All right, let's get into it. First up, let's see what Matthew Nagra has to say. 1:09 They claim everyone should aim to be vegan. You happy with it? No, and here's 1:12 why. So, 1:14 I am a third-year med student and I will actually come out and say that the vegan 1:18 diet tends to be healthier, absolutely. Right. I don't think there's much 1:22 dispute over that. You can look at the evidence. It is It is healthier. 1:25 However, the biggest thing with the vegan diet from a physician perspective 1:29 you have to think about is, and it's been mentioned a couple times, is the
Health, supplements, and protein arguments 1:32 micronutrient deficiencies that you can have. 1:34 >> B12. B12 is one of them. First off, kudos to him for at least acknowledging 1:37 that vegans tend to have better health outcomes than meat-eaters, but I do take 1:41 issue with framing micronutrient deficiencies as an issue with a vegan 1:44 diet specifically. All dietary patterns have some gaps. Those gaps just change. 1:49 For example, vegans may need to ensure they're getting enough of certain 1:52 nutrients like vitamin B12, but then meat-eaters need to focus more on 1:55 getting enough of things like magnesium and folate. And this can be taken care 1:58 of by making sure you're including certain food groups or supplements 2:01 depending on the nutrient. Why would you take the supplement? 2:04 >> Why would I take supplements when I could just have lean meats like chicken 2:06 and fish and turkey and things that There's a study by Junie Wang in 2019 2:11 where she found the fortified and the supplements were more easily absorbed by 2:16 the body cuz they're already taken away from the fibers. 2:18 >> [music] >> So, that's why you take 2:19 >> So, I actually disagree with that because so for instance, omega-3s, fish 2:23 have omega-3s. This was very odd. Dr. Jack Symes cited this study in which 2:27 consuming cereal fortified with vitamin B12, which is similar to taking a 2:31 supplement, resulted in higher B12 levels in the body compared to consuming 2:35 meat with the same amount of B12. And that's without the cardiovascular risks 2:39 of regularly consuming meat. And the reason likely is that the vitamin B12 in 2:43 a fortified food or supplement isn't bound to protein like it is in meat. So, 2:47 its absorption doesn't rely as much on the health of the gut to be able to 2:50 break the B12 apart from the protein. And after that, presumably without ever 2:55 having actually read the study, the med student just disagreed because fish have 2:59 omega-3s. I'm really not sure what the relevance of that is to whether or not 3:03 nutrients from supplements are absorbed as well or better than nutrients from 3:06 foods. Nevertheless, to indulge his concerns over vegans not getting the 3:10 long-chain omega-3s, EPA and DHA from fish, the importance of which is 3:14 debated, I'll mention that algae-based supplements exist. They contain the same 3:18 omega-3s and have been shown to be similarly bioavailable to fish oil. 3:22 Second, let's go to Cheap Lazy Vegan who also is very opinionated about this 3:26 debate and some of the things Dr. Jack Symes had to put up with. This is so 3:30 dumb. Do they have the right to exist? Well, because here's the deal. If you're 3:33 saying that we should not harvest them, then those animals are never going to 3:35 exist. So, I guarantee if they had consciousness and you put them down and 3:38 you said, "Here are the scenarios. You can either exist and you can have one 3:40 bad day and you can serve a purpose and you can have a beautiful life. You can 3:43 make a positive contribution to the environment." So, essentially, he is 3:46 defending the right for animals to be bred into existence 3:51 simply to be killed for our consumption. And what kills me, no pun intended, is 3:58 somehow he is twisting this to try to make it seem as though this is a 4:03 benevolent practice. Like we are doing you a favor by allowing you to exist so 4:09 that we could kill you. So that we could use your body. 4:12 You know? And do they have a right to exist? What 4:15 the hell is a right to exist? If you don't exist, you don't exist. How does 4:21 something that does not exist have a right 4:23 to exist? What about the right to live once you exist? Okay? What about once a 4:29 living sentient being exists, they deserve a right to be free and to live 4:35 their own lives and to not be killed. How about that right? And also if 4:38 animals have a right to exist, then that right shouldn't be predicated 4:44 on the fact that you want to eat their body. If they have a right to exist, 4:49 then we should be bringing them into existence regardless of what we can or 4:54 cannot do with their bodies. Because they have a right to exist, 4:57 right? This is what's so fascinating to me. Humans will do the most evil things 5:03 and turn around and act like they are God's gift on Earth. 5:07 Okay. Humans will breed animals into existence, sentient living beings into 5:11 existence, feed them for a few years, and then slit their throat and act like 5:17 that they are doing them a favor. Okay, so let's go to Dr. Minel Patel who was 5:21 also astounded by clip in this GB debate a little bit later on. Well, my 5:26 experience and the research I've done Yeah. Oh, he's done research. This guy 5:30 has done research. Uh finally, they've got someone who's 5:32 done the research. Amazing. Let's hear what he has to say. 5:35 >> You need at least some animal product to survive cuz like Oh, no. A lot of the 5:41 vegan diet is good. A lot of it's good, the fruits and veggies and everything. 5:45 But What makes you think that though? What makes me think that vegan meat is 5:48 good? Because >> No, what makes you think that you need 5:50 to eat meat to survive and thrive? Because I found out recently, I've been 5:54 doing a lot more of a health getting better shape, and I found that the more 5:57 protein I eat from meat, chicken, steak, it gets me more bulk. An hour and 24
Ethics of animal existence and rights 6:02 minutes in, and finally we have someone using the protein [music] argument. I 6:06 was wondering when we'd hear that. There are plenty of high-protein vegan foods, 6:09 and you would hope a chef >> [music] 6:11 >> would know that. Tofu, tempeh, textured vegetable proteins, seitan, soy milk, 6:16 soy beans, [music] black beans, kidney beans, all the freaking beans, lentils, 6:19 bean and lentil-based pastas, whole grains like quinoa. 6:23 >> [music] >> Not to mention plant-based protein 6:25 powders. It is easy to get enough protein on a vegan diet. And if your 6:29 goal is bodybuilding or athletic performance, then you only really need 6:33 about 1.6 g per kilogram body weight of protein per [music] day. 6:37 For a 70-kg person, that's about 112 g, and that is not difficult provided 6:41 you're eating varied sources throughout the day. When it comes to muscle gains, 6:44 when protein is matched, there is no difference between vegans and omnivores. 6:47 [music] So, stop making excuses, and if you're going to, please leave protein 6:51 out of it. >> Perfectly said. But what Very impossible 6:54 to become full vegan. There is nothing There is nothing really in this 6:57 >> impossible to be What are you wearing by chance? Are you wearing Doc Martens by 7:01 chance? Yeah. Aren't those Aren't those vegan? Yeah. Are you sure about that? 7:05 >> Yeah, they're made of rubber. And rubber is made of? Rubber's not made 7:09 of animals. But there's a lot of vegan product There's a lot of animal products 7:13 in things that you don't >> wearing leather Turn up to one vegan 7:15 versus 20 meat eaters wearing leather shoes. Maybe. You think You think I'm I 7:19 mean, a lot of people don't know a lot of stuff's in there. Oh my days, man. 7:23 She did Yeah. Yeah, it crossed my mind, too. It crossed my mind, too. Thank you. 7:26 He crossed his mind, too. I rest my case, and my time is up. Great to meet 7:30 you. >> Pick up some vegan Doc Martens. 7:32 Thank you. So, I would say veganism is not good for the world. And my number 7:37 one point is burgers. Have you ever had a burger? Yeah, with cheese on it? Yeah. 7:44 Have you had a burger and what do you think? Uh I think that people aren't the 7:48 experts they think about their own mind. Giovanni Savani did a study in 2023 7:53 where he looked at 175 people and gave them blind taste tests and informed 7:57 taste tests. The majority couldn't figure out which one was the beef burger 8:01 and the plant-based burger and when on the informed taste test, they all 8:04 preferred the plant-based burger over the beef burger. So, no, I don't buy it. 8:07 When we look at what people will do when they're not in this debate setting, it's 8:10 not clear that they prefer it. Well, I would say that I prefer Yeah, of course 8:14 you would. like cheeseburgers, like real cheeseburgers and I could tell the 8:17 difference. I have like really good taste buds. 8:20 >> Yeah. So, I really like when it's not like fake cheeseburgers. 8:23 >> Yeah, go for it. I prefer like they taste like But you understand there's 8:26 going to be limits to this, right? You like doing lots of things. I assume you 8:29 like having sex as well, but you certainly you certainly want to 8:33 I imagine that you want to get it in an ethical way. Yeah, obviously. But I I 8:37 think I can get I mean, if I just go to like the store and buy a a burger, 8:40 that's pretty ethical to me. Let me give you this question. You can have sex and 8:44 it was unethical, non-consensual, but it was great or you can have the consensual 8:47 sex and it's not quite as good. Which one do you pick? Probably a 8:49 cheeseburger. I think uh 8:53 Which one do you pick out of the two of them? 8:54 >> Well, you said that >> do you pick out of the two of them? Just 8:56 pick one. The ethical The ethical 8:58 >> pick the non-ethical Well, the ethical one, but I would choose a cheeseburger 9:01 over sex any day. So, the analogy was Okay, and there's another interesting 9:05 clip from Dr. Mati Nagra. Let's go to that. Recent studies have shown that you 9:09 you're way less likely to develop heart disease by having the ultra-processed 9:11 vegan burger over the beef burger. I'm not surprised by this either. The 9:14 ultra-processed vegan burger is better? The Beyond Meat one is significantly 9:18 Contrary to popular belief, plant-based meats do appear to provide some health
Protein, burgers, and taste tests 9:22 benefits compared to animal-based meats on average. For example, in the SWAP-ME 9:26 randomized crossover trial, Beyond Meat products resulted in lower LDL 9:30 cholesterol levels and a little bit of weight loss compared to organic and 9:33 grass-fed meats without any clear downsides. And these findings are 9:37 consistent across the literature as I highlighted in my review that was 9:40 published in the Canadian Journal of Cardiology and which was reinforced by a 9:44 recent meta-analysis. Now, it may be a stretch to say you're way less likely to 9:48 develop heart disease since we don't actually have those long-term studies 9:51 looking at actual heart attack rates, but all else held equal, a lower LDL 9:55 cholesterol level and a little bit of weight loss would be expected to 9:58 translate to a lower heart disease risk. Posy, you've been voted out by the 10:01 majority. Please return to your seat. It's always a pleasure. It calcium is 10:03 very important for um bone density. Yeah. About 30% um if your vegan diet's 10:07 exclusively, you are 30% likely to have um a fracture. I couldn't find any 10:11 studies with the 30% statistic specifically, but what most people cite 10:14 is the EPIC Oxford study in which vegans had a 43% higher risk of fracture, 10:18 largely driven by hip fracture. And that translates to about 19 more fractures 10:22 per thousand people per 10 years. However, I do take issue with using 10:26 these data to suggest that vegans are inherently at higher risk. For starters, 10:30 the risk was only statistically significant in postmenopausal women, not 10:33 men or premenopausal women, as well as in inactive and people with a BMI below 10:38 22.5. That last point is important because there were far more vegans below 10:42 a BMI of 20 than there were meat eaters. And they did not adequately account for 10:46 differences in BMI among people who would be classified as underweight. In 10:50 essence, they could very well have been comparing some vegans who were very 10:53 underweight to meat eaters who barely classified as underweight. And this is 10:56 critical because fracture risk increases substantially once BMI gets below that 11:00 level. They also didn't adjust for vitamin D intake or status at all and 11:04 didn't do adequately so for calcium. with the Adventist Health Study 2, which 11:08 was published just months later. They too found that the vegan women had a 11:12 higher risk of hip fracture than the meat-eating women, but once they only 11:15 included participants who supplemented vitamin D and calcium, that difference 11:18 in risk was abolished. These studies just highlight the importance of eating 11:21 enough to maintain a healthy weight and ensuring adequate vitamin D and calcium 11:25 from supplements or fortified foods. Fortunately, many plant-based milks 11:29 today are fortified and contain as much or more calcium and vitamin D than their 11:33 dairy counterpart. Should children be vegan? Yeah. Why? Doesn't that feel like 11:37 a bit of a risk? I'd I'd say the biggest risks on health outcomes We're talking 11:40 overall health outcomes. Like child obesity in this country, right? Huge 11:43 problem. They can have lower BMI if they're vegan. And they can get all the 11:46 nutrients that they need. Yes, kids can be healthily raised vegan as long as 11:50 some care is taken to ensure they're getting adequate nutrition, just like 11:53 any other diet. And like Dr. Jack Norris highlighted, there may be some benefits. 11:57 For example, vegan kids tend to have a lower BMI and lower LDL cholesterol 12:01 levels. And if you're wondering why that even matters at that age, well, 12:05 cardiovascular disease begins to develop in childhood or even earlier. So yes, 12:09 attention needs to be paid to certain nutrients like iron and vitamin B12. But 12:13 let's not write off the potential benefits of feeding kids at the very 12:16 least a plant-predominant diet. >> two here? These are opposable thumbs. We 12:20 evolved these in order to hunt better. These two pair of legs, bipedal. We are 12:24 bipedal to become better hunters. Even communicating with each other, we've 12:27 evolved to become better hunters. Our entire existence as a as human species 12:31 has been around eating meats. And for you to just say all of a sudden with to 12:36 be like, "Oh, you shouldn't do that anymore." is kind of asinine. We evolved 12:39 these traits like opposable thumbs, bipedalism, and speech for reasons that
Health claims about vegan diets 12:42 extend well beyond just hunting. So suggesting that hunting is the reason is 12:46 asinine. That said, even if we had developed these traits primarily to make 12:50 us better hunters, that wouldn't make engaging in that behavior ethical. 12:54 Similar arguments can be presented around our evolutionary impulse to mate. 12:57 The fact that that impulse exists doesn't make it ethical to mate without 13:01 consent. In fact, one of the things that makes humans unique is our capacity for 13:04 abstract moral reasoning. So we can actually ask whether following our 13:08 biological drive is morally justified. And finally, adaptations that may help 13:12 us survive in the short term, like procuring calorie-dense animal foods 13:16 during times of scarcity, can often be detrimental in the long term. This is 13:20 something known as antagonistic pleiotropy. For example, genetic 13:23 variants that cause sickle cell anemia can help people survive long enough to 13:27 reproduce in areas where malaria is endemic. That's because the sickle cell 13:31 trait protects against malaria, but then it can go on to cause cardiovascular 13:34 issues later in life. Similarly, Huntington's disease can increase 13:38 fertility, but then cause death within 20 years of symptoms arising. These 13:41 traits either increase the likelihood of living long enough to reproduce or they 13:45 improve fertility, so they're more likely to pass their genes on, yet lead 13:48 to long-term issues. So, adaptations to meat consumption may have actually been 13:52 beneficial in the short term when food was scarce. But our ancestors didn't 13:56 typically live long enough to deal with things like cardiovascular disease or 13:59 colorectal cancer, which usually appear at old age. And those are some of the 14:03 health reasons to limit red meat consumption today. 14:05 >> 80% of all of soy is given to non-human animals. Oh, I'm going to stop you right 14:10 there. I'm going to stop you right there. The soy is grown for the oil. The 14:12 soy is grown for the oil. It is literally extracted. The leftover 14:16 product is then fed to cattle. That is a manipulated statistic. He's just plain 14:19 wrong here. According to data from the Food Climate Research Network, 14:22 University of Oxford, and USDA database, 76% of global soy production is for 14:28 animal feed. Only 13% is for oils meant for human consumption and 4% for 14:33 industry use in the form of things like biodiesel. It is literally the 14:36 byproduct. They grow the soy for the oil. Even if it wasn't being fed to the 14:40 animals, they would still grow the soy. >> That is true. That is true. That is 14:41 true. That is true. That is true. That is true. That is true. That is true. 14:43 That is No, it's not true. We can most generously call it a co-product or 14:47 consider the oil to be the byproduct. The demand for soybeans is tied to 14:51 global meat consumption. If we didn't produce so much soy to feed to animals, 14:54 which can also be used to produce oils, we would just shift to producing other 14:58 oils, which could actually save money and resources. That's because soybeans 15:02 actually have a lower oil yield than rapeseed, sunflower, and palm oil. So, 15:06 he's got it completely backwards. >> Okay, so let's go back to cheap lazy 15:10 vegan she cuz she's got something else to say. 15:12 >> We think the dog fighting is bad, don't we? Yes, we do. So, what happens when we 15:14 kill the dog? We eat its flesh and then we fight. Is that wrong as well? What do 15:16 you mean we? I don't speak French. I've never done that. So, I've never seen 15:19 anybody that knows that you can eat a chicken, a A a cow, a chicken. But, you 15:22 saying that in such a negative light. What's the difference? The difference is 15:24 one we raise as a companion and the other one we raise as food. 15:27 >> And that makes a moral difference why? It makes a moral difference because I 15:29 need to feed my kids. You can't feed your kids a plant-based diet? I love 15:33 that he asked, "And that makes a moral difference why?" Because we arbitrarily 15:38 raise animals for food and we arbitrarily assign animals as 15:43 companions. This is all very cultural and literally we just make it up. Okay, 15:49 we make it up. There is no moral difference between these animals, dogs 15:54 and cows for example. They both feel pain, they both have enough intelligence 15:58 to know what's going on, they're sentient beings, they can suffer. They 16:02 have connections to each other, they have connections to other animals, they 16:05 have connections to humans. There's really no moral difference between these 16:10 two animals, yet we assign arbitrarily the roles that they are to play in our 16:18 lives and in the world because we think we are human, we can play God, we can do
Evolution, soy, and factory farming 16:22 whatever we want. Just because we raise an animal to be our food doesn't mean we 16:29 should. We've done a lot of things in the past, a lot of systems have been in 16:33 place in the past that we now recognize as immoral and unethical. There is a 16:37 great movie that I always reference, it's called Never Let Me Go. It's set in 16:42 this school and it looks like just a very normal kind of private school, it 16:47 looks like regular children, regular normal kids, but we very soon find out 16:52 that these kids are actually clones of other humans. So, they are humans 16:57 genetically, everything about them is human except for they are just, you 17:02 know, made in a lab I guess, but they can feel pain, they can suffer, they can 17:07 love, they can uh experience everything a human being can experience and they 17:11 are human by every definition of the word. Now, why were they cloned? We find 17:15 out that they were cloned in order to become involuntary organ donors. From a 17:22 young age, as soon as they're like fully developed, they start having surgeries 17:27 to remove their organs so that those healthy young organs can be donated to 17:32 sick people. And this is all done without them deciding for themselves 17:38 that that's what they want to do. This is just the role that they were assigned 17:42 by other people. They get their organs removed one by one until they basically 17:47 die because they can't survive without their vital organs. They were cloned 17:51 into existence so that humans could use their bodies as organ donors, okay? Does 17:57 that make it okay? Does it make it okay for humans to be killing these other 18:02 humans so that we could use their bodies when they did not decide that for 18:06 themselves? Does it make it okay? Really? I don't think so. 18:10 >> So, I will not defend factory farming. Um there's 18:13 Every time Every time in these videos, they all say, "I don't defend factory 18:18 farming. I'm against factory farming." Yet, they do not acknowledge that 99% of 18:24 animal products purchased and consumed in the United States and probably we can 18:27 extrapolate that number to many other countries in the world, they are all 18:31 produced in factory farms. Majority of animal products consumed are produced by 18:34 factory farms. Why? Because in order to feed this gigantic population of 18:38 billions of people, as many animal products as we consume today, we need 18:42 factory farms. Okay? That is the truth that you do not want to admit. These 18:45 meat eaters do not want to admit that factory farms are a necessary thing if 18:50 you want to have it so that there aren't that many vegans, for example. Because 18:54 if we got rid of all factory farms, which apparently all these people are 18:58 against, apparently none of these people buy meat from the grocery store, and 19:01 none of these people go to restaurants and just just eat steak without asking 19:05 if it's a locally sourced or grass-fed or whatever. 19:09 Apparently, all of them only purchase goods from non-factory farmed places. 19:15 Really? I don't think so. Statistically, no, you are not doing that. All of you 19:20 are purchasing goods from factory farms. I can almost guarantee it. Doesn't mean 19:23 every single thing that you eat is from a factory farm, but I can guarantee that 19:27 they do not avoid factory farmed meat. If you're going to be so against 19:31 veganism, but you're also saying you're against factory farming, I think that is 19:35 very ironic. Okay? Because vegans are actively not participating in factory 19:39 farming. Of course, they're also not participating in other forms of animal 19:42 agriculture, but they are the very few people that are actually actively not 19:47 consuming factory farmed meat. Because again, chances are, even if you say 19:51 you're against factory farming, chances are you still consume factory farmed 19:54 meat. The only people that aren't doing that, guaranteed, are the vegans. And 19:58 let's go back to Dr. Minoo Patel, who found another interesting moment in the 20:02 Jubilee debate. >> Yeah, I get the minerals I need. 20:04 >> Yeah. What are you going to do about the calories? Because, you know, you get rid 20:07 of the mineral the meats. Yeah. And you you cut out that calorie, but you also 20:11 cut out a lot of the the calories that you need to survive. Because if we 20:15 become too malnutritioned and neurodivergent, we will die. 20:20 Did you say malnutritioned and neurodivergent? 20:24 He says you need calories. Excellent. [music] 20:26 You know what contains calories? Food. Potatoes, pasta, rice, oats. Those are
Regenerative agriculture and animal testing 20:31 your sources of carbohydrates, which contain plenty of calories. You want to 20:34 get some healthy fats in as well? Great. Nuts, [music] seeds, avocado, olive oil, 20:38 or even one of my favorites, peanut butter. If only we had some examples of 20:41 absolutely huge vegans. Oh, wait, we do. >> [music] 20:44 >> You've got Jordan Drain, you've got Joe VJ, you've got Nimai Delgado, Patrik 20:47 Baboumian, Brian Cranall, Jon Thomas, aka the bodybuilding vegan. Nick 20:51 Squires, aka Meaty McSorley, and that's just a few off the top of my head. There 20:55 are many, many more. These guys aren't out here making excuses about the fact 20:58 that they can't get enough calories on a vegan diet. They're lifting hard, 21:01 they're eating enough, and they're getting absolutely freaking huge in the 21:04 process. You don't need to eat meat. You need to train and eat enough calories 21:07 and protein. It's that simple. 21:09 >> As a factory farming big for the raising cattle. I'm not defending factory 21:12 farming. You don't need to Are you against regenerative 21:15 agriculture? Are you against chickens, turkeys? 21:18 agriculture? >> Yes. Are you against regenerative 21:20 agriculture? Yes. Because it destroys the wildlife. Because it destroys the 21:23 climate. So, this guy's really big on 21:26 regenerative agriculture. He says regenerative agriculture is better for 21:28 the environment. Remember the claim being argued is about suffering. [music] 21:31 But, is his claim even correct? No. A report by the International Research 21:35 Collaboration, led by the Food Climate Research Network, found that grass-fed 21:38 livestock are not a climate solution. [music] 21:40 Raising livestock are net contributors to the climate problem. 21:43 As are all livestock. Rising animal production and consumption, [music] 21:46 whatever the farming system and the animal type, is causing damaging 21:49 greenhouse gas release >> [music] 21:51 >> and contributing to changes in land use. In fact, you need 150% more land and 21:54 grazing cattle would [music] produce 43% more emissions. Plant-based sources of 21:58 protein use far less land, far less water, 22:02 create far less greenhouse gas emissions, and cause far less water 22:05 pollution as well. Remember what he said, he didn't want to jump around, but 22:07 it seems like that's all he did all debate, and didn't address any of 22:09 [music] Jack's original claim. Perfectly summarized. So, animal testing. Oh, boy. 22:15 Yeah. For all of the devices, immunizations, they need to, per the 22:20 FDA, do animal testing first. >> So, in 2022, the FDA Modernization Act 22:26 2.0 was signed into law. This allows for alternatives to animal testing in the 22:30 preclinical phase of drug development, in part because there's such a low 22:33 translation of results from animal studies to human studies. More on that. 22:38 86% of all of the experiments done on non-human animals transfer. Where's the 22:41 research? It I'm giving it to you now. No, no, no. I want to know the who wrote 22:44 the paper. Oh, Harry Harlow, the editor of the Journal of Comparative and 22:48 Physiological Psychology. >> Really? And you think that's enough to 22:50 prove your point? This is well understood. It's like she's never 22:53 actually looked into the topic, yet wants to debate it. Here's another 22:56 recent review, separate to what Jack is citing, stating that on average, the 22:59 translation rate of animal research to humans is about 5%. He looks at 2,500 23:04 articles and he said, "Quote, most of the observations most of the data is not 23:08 worth publishing and not most of the experiments not worth doing." Wait, so 23:11 you're He's He's strictly No, no, no, no, hold on. So, you're basing what you 23:16 just said on one person's opinion. >> No, I just told you 6% of all the 23:19 research. >> opinion on what a whole bunch of other 23:21 people >> of the experts in the area, yeah. And I 23:23 also said that the biochemical engineer at Cornell said the same. That was just 23:25 cringey. She asked who wrote the paper or where she could find the research, 23:29 but I think it's pretty clear she doesn't actually care. No matter which 23:32 researchers were involved or where it was published, she was probably just 23:34 going to respond with, "Oh, that's all you've got?" accompanied by a fake 23:38 laugh, of course. And I'd be curious to know if she's even aware of the FDA 23:41 Modernization Act that I mentioned earlier replacing the old requirement 23:45 for animal testing from 1938. That aside, we currently live in a world 23:49 where medications have historically been tested on animals. However, moving 23:52 forward because of the poor translation of the animal research to humans and 23:56 advancing technology like AI, I could see a transition, albeit a slow 24:00 transition, away from animal testing being the standard. 24:03 >> is Nicole Ashley. >> Nice to meet you, Nicole Ashley. Jack, 24:05 how you doing? I'm great. I think plants killing plants is murder, though. Oh, 24:10 come on, you're joking. You're trolling. >> ripping it from the ground. You're 24:13 ripping it from its mother. It's murder. Poor Jack here even asks if she's 24:17 trolling. There are actually people that believe this. Yes, plants are living. 24:20 However, they do not have a nervous system. They don't have a brain. They 24:23 don't have pain receptors or nociceptors. 24:25 >> [music] >> So, they cannot actually perceive 24:27 noxious stimuli or perceive pain. There's no plausible reason to believe 24:31 that they have consciousness or that they can experience pain [music] and 24:33 suffering the way humans and animals can. What plants can do is respond to 24:37 physical stimuli [music] such as light, uh changes in chemicals, and even touch. 24:41 Famous are the Venus flytrap or the sensitive plant, also known as the 24:44 touch-me-not. [music] They're both capable of something called rapid plant 24:47 movement in response to a physical stimulus.
Plants, land use, and vegan ethics 24:50 Now, this type of plant biology is absolutely fascinating. So, if you want 24:52 to learn more about it, then check out this article. 24:55 But, responding to stimuli is something even machines do like our [music] phones 24:57 or computers. However, you and I would both agree that our phones and computers 25:02 are not sentient beings. They cannot experience what it is [music] to be 25:05 living. Do you think we should reduce the amount of pain that plants are 25:08 experiencing? >> Yes, we should. Plants matter. 25:10 #plantsmatter. Okay. So, according to Hannah Ritchie 25:14 2022, you get a 75% reduction in all of the land that you need for farming. So, 25:19 if given the fact you're getting 40 to 1 in your calories and 30 to 1 in your 25:24 protein from plants to animals then slaughtered, you get a 75% decrease in 25:28 the plants that you're going to kill >> This is how we reduce it. 25:31 >> So, Jack plays along [music] and asks if he wants to reduce plant pain and 25:33 suffering. Let's grant the premise that plants feel pain and that they can 25:36 suffer. If you want to reduce [music] that, then moving towards a plant-based 25:39 diet is one of the number one ways to do that. 50% of all habitable land at the 25:43 moment is currently used for farming. 77% of that is used to [music] grow 25:47 crops and graze animals that are then used for food. This only provides 18% of 25:51 global calories [music] and 37% of global protein. If everyone 25:54 moved to a plant-based diet, we could free up 75% of all land. We could rewild 25:58 it. We could have much more room for plants. We would kill a lot less plants 26:01 in the process. So, if you're a plant rights [music] activist, you should be 26:05 vegan. I did actually think that that person was trolling. I thought it was 26:09 somebody going on there pretending to say the stuff that anti-vegan trolls 26:12 say, but she was deadly serious. She was completely serious about it. 26:16 >> I think she knew she was trolling, but she represents a viewpoint that many, 26:19 many people believe. That's the point. >> my job at Plant Based News is to respond 26:23 to comments, and we get that all the time where it's like, "Don't you care 26:27 about plants as well?" So, I always respond with the same thing, which is, 26:30 "You know that the majority of the world's crops are being grown to be fed 26:33 to animals who are then slaughtered, so you're not only eating the animal, but 26:36 you're also eating all of those crops. If you actually cared about plant 26:39 suffering, like Dr. Patel said, then you would actually be vegan, too." But 26:44 nobody wants to hear that. >> when we just take a look at the global 26:47 food system, right? Animal agriculture uses 77% of all farmland and produces 26:52 57% of all emissions. To me, that just doesn't seem like a great return on 26:56 investment if it's only producing 37% of the world's protein. 27:01 >> I enjoy the trivial pleasure of doing what the lions, with the hyenas, with 27:05 the tigers have done for history. >> Okay, we're back with crazy plant life 27:09 matter lady. She's talking about what lions, hyenas, and tigers do in the 27:12 wild. So, she's saying that human beings 27:14 should be able to do the same as these carnivorous animals. So, another quick 27:17 biology lesson. Humans are not carnivores, despite what 27:20 your favorite social media influencer has been telling you. We are 27:23 opportunistic omnivores, which means we can eat both animal-based foods and 27:26 plant-based foods. The animals she mentioned are obligate carnivores. They 27:30 have to hunt and eat animals. Biologically, there is no reason that we 27:33 have to eat meat. Also, this is an ethical debate. We 27:37 should not be basing our morality on what wild animals do. But, what about 27:41 the caveman times? The caveman times that caveman lived, they lived off of 27:46 eating meat. So, what is the big deal? So, again, we're arguing from tradition 27:52 here and habit. Just because we've done something for so many years does not 27:55 make it morally right. Human beings have waged war, killed one another, enslaved 27:59 one another for centuries. Does [music] that then make it correct because we've 28:02 been doing it for so long? No. We often hear that our ancestors ate meat, but 28:06 what did they actually eat? As I said before, human beings are opportunistic 28:09 omnivores. We will eat anything [music] we can get our hands on. 28:12 We're capable of eating both animal and plant-based foods. Historical research 28:15 shows that human beings mostly ate a plant-based diet and occasionally would 28:18 scavenge meat that was brought down by live predators. 28:21 With the advent of stone tools, our appetite for meat increased 28:24 >> [music] >> as we began to hunt. It still did not 28:26 make up the majority of our diet. The other issue is basing your food choices 28:29 on what our ancestors ate seems pretty ridiculous when you consider that our 28:32 ancestors had a life expectancy of around 30 years. I don't know about you, 28:35 but I intend to live a lot longer than that. And actually, we now know that 28:39 eating a plant-based diet and actually reducing the amount of meat is 28:42 associated with longevity and reduction risk of chronic disease. So, it makes no 28:46 sense to say that we should be eating meat just because cavemen did. The 28:50 protein argument, the land use argument, the emissions argument, the plants have 28:55 feelings argument, they're all just divesting from an actionable plan that 29:00 could take place. Can we talk about Dr. Jack Shames very quickly? So, what 29:04 amazing guy, what amazing communicative for animal rights. I never knew about 29:09 him until about sort of 3-4 weeks ago, but such an amazing advocate for this 29:13 movement. He handles himself so well. Yeah, I think he's also been on the Joe 29:16 Rogan podcast and a number of other big podcasts because he is just so good at 29:21 advocating and debating in clearly quite challenging situations. Thank you 29:25 everybody for watching another episode of Plant Based News. Please like, 29:29 comment, and subscribe and we'll see you very soon. 29:34 >> [music] 29:40 [music]
Comments