Full Transcript Study on Birth Month and ADHD Diagnoses 0:00 Researchers looked at the insurance records of more than 400,000 elementary school kids. 0:07 They focused on states that require kids to turn 5 by September 1 to start kindergarten. 0:16 That means a child born in August, like I was, walks in as one of the youngest in the room, as I did. 0:22 A child in September, just weeks later, walked in a year later as the oldest child. 0:28 The August kids were 34% more likely to be diagnosed with ADHD than their September classmates. 0:40 and more likely to be put on a medication for it. 0:44 The gap didn't show up between any other neighboring birth months or in states with different cutoff dates. 0:50 It only appeared exactly where the school calendar put a younger child next to an older one. 0:56 One of the researchers estimated that for the August-born kids, roughly one in four of those diagnoses could just absolutely be wrong. 1:05 Think about what a teacher sees. 1:07 A five-year-old who is almost a full year younger than the kid at the next desk is going to be more wiggly, more distractible, 1:15 and less able to sit through circle time. 1:17 That's not a disorder. 1:19 It's being five instead of six. 1:21 But side by side, it looks like a problem. 1:23 Welcome to Vitality Radio, the podcast that helps you make sense of natural supplements and thrive without pharma drugs. 1:31 I'm Jared St. 1:31 Clair. 1:46 I'm going to start today's show by taking a test. 2:06 Disorders. 2:07 Oh, how I despise the word disorders. 2:11 It's the book that every psychiatrist, psychologist, and pediatrician in this country uses to decide whether a child has ADHD. 2:22 The list is split into two halves. 2:25 Nine describe inattention and nine describe hyperactivity and impulsivity. 2:31 If you are a child, you need six in either half. 2:34 If your an adult, You need five. 2:36 I'm going to read each one and I am going answer each out loud for you as regards to me. 2:43 Part 1 Inattention. 2:46 Misses details or makes careless mistakes. 2:50 That one's a little me, but I think I'm better at that now than I once was, we'll say. 2:55 So that was 50-50. 2:57 Struggles to sustain attention in tasks or play.
Jaredu2019s ADHD Checklist Self-Test 3:01 Yes, especially tasks I am not interested in. 3:05 Doesn't seem to listen when spoken to directly. 3:08 That depends on who's speaking to me. 3:11 doesn't follow through on instructions or finish schoolwork, jobs, or chores. 3:18 Absolutely. 3:19 Follow through. 3:21 Definitely not a strength that you could attribute to me. 3:24 Has trouble organizing tasks and activities. 3:28 For sure. 3:29 Avoids or dislikes tasks that require sustained mental effort. 3:34 Often, yes. 3:35 Loses things needed for tasks. 3:38 so often. 3:39 I would dare say almost constantly. 3:42 Is easily distracted by outside stimuli or unrelated thoughts. 3:47 Oh yes, I see squirrels often and number nine is forgetful in daily activities. 3:54 100% definitely. 3:56 That's seven clear yeses and a couple of at least some of the times the adult cutoff is just five. 4:03 So I qualify there. 4:05 How about hyperactivity and impulsivity? 4:07 Fidgets or squirms all the time. 4:10 If you watch me on YouTube, there's a lot of movement going on. 4:14 And if I'm on a phone call, if i'm sitting talking to my wife, If I am playing with the kids, knees bouncing, foots tapping, 4:23 lots of things going, on very fidgety. 4:26 Absolutely. 4:28 if on the phone, call my goodness, Iam pacing constantly, you know, If you're old, like I am old ish. 4:37 Okay, I'm only 54. My goodness. 4:39 But if you are in the age range where you remember when cordless phones didn't exist and landlines were still a thing, we had a 25 foot cord and it was 4:49 one of those, you know, ones that stretches as you go a little. 4:51 I don't know what you call that kind of round. 4:54 I don't know what you call that type of cord, but you know I'm talking about. 4:57 As you pull it, it gets a little longer until it stretches tight, right? 5:01 And I would walk up and down the hallway leading from the kitchen where our phone was and stretch the heck out of that cord to the point where my parents 5:09 were like, Jared, you're going to tear the phone off the wall. 5:11 So yeah, fidgets and squirms. 5:14 Leaves their seat when expected to stay seated. 5:16 I just talked about that. 5:18 For sure I do, unless I absolutely have to be glued to a screen. 5:21 Like when I'm doing this show or when i'm prepping this Show, then unfortunately I can't move around. 5:26 But sometimes I find myself actually reading it on my phone. 5:30 Not while I am recording, but when im preppin. 5:33 So I could walk around, so I get some movement. 5:34 Feels restless, for sure. 5:36 Can't play or do leisure activities quietly. 5:39 Now as an adult, I pretty good there. 5:42 But as a kid, I was told by both my parents that when I played alone in my room, it sounded like there were five other kids in there. 5:49 Number five is on the go as if driven by a motor. 5:53 Definitely talks excessively. 5:55 I hope not, but probably blurts out answers. 6:00 Actually pretty good at not doing that, has trouble waiting their turn. 6:04 Not really, I'm pretty patient in most cases, interrupts or intrudes on others. 6:12 So those numbers are not quite as much me but still enough to make the cut. 6:19 So I was never formally diagnosed with ADHD, but it's only because my parents didn't take kids in for that kind of stuff. 6:29 But I struggled in the subjects that I didn' care about, like math. 6:32 And I excelled in subjects I did, where I could focus and concentrate without too much trouble at all. 6:39 I hadn't finished even one year of college. 6:44 I don't have the greatest vision and I'm a bald guy. 6:47 And yet with all of those things stacked against me, I have found some success in life. 6:53 So let's talk about this checklist one more time. 6:56 It never asks why, it just asks if, and it doesn't ask when.
Square Pegs, School Fit, and Movement 7:03 it counts whether attention drops, but it Doesn't care that my attention Drops on things that bore me to tears and locks in like a laser on Things that 7:12 actually matter to me. 7:14 that's not a deficit of attention, right? 7:17 At least not all the time. 7:19 That's attention with a steering wheel that only turns toward what it cares about. 7:23 Today, and in part two of this two-part series, I'm going to make a case that what we call ADD or ADHD is a brain type, not disorder, 7:34 NOT a disability. 7:36 A brain-type like every other gift you were born with. 7:41 You can work with it to optimize it. 7:43 Or you can try to shut it down. 7:47 If you're the parent of a child who's been handed this diagnosis, or if you yourself have been given this, I want to give you my permission to see your 7:57 kid differently than the label reads. 8:01 This is Vitality Radio, let's get into it. 8:04 You've heard the phrase, a square peg in a round hole. 8:08 School for the most part is a around hole, I think we all know that. 8:12 It was designed for a kid who can sit still at a desk for five, six, seven hours, move through subjects on a bell schedule, 8:21 whether or not they're actually super interested in them, hold a set of instructions in their head, and work quietly through a worksheet on a timer while 8:31 also not talking to the child next to them, not fidgeting, all that kind of stuff. 8:36 Some kids can actually fit in a round hole pretty well. 8:39 And some kids are just square pegs. 8:43 They're curious, energetic, fast moving, and wired to chase what interests them. 8:47 Push a square Peg into a around hole hard enough and something is liable to get damaged. 8:52 And it's usually not the hole. 8:54 It's the peg. 8:55 One of the first things a square peg gets told is to sit still. 9:00 But here's what the research actually says about that. 9:04 Researchers filmed 52 boys, ages 8 to 12 years old, while they did working memory tasks, holding numbers in their heads and repeating them back. 9:16 29 of those boys had an ADHD diagnosis, the rest did not. 9:20 The kids in that group who moved the most physically moved while working performed the best. 9:28 my fidgeting that I talked about. 9:29 For the boys without the diagnosis, it went the other way. 9:33 More movement, worse performance. 9:35 These kids weren't fidgiting all the time. 9:37 They sat fairly still when they watched a movie. 9:40 The movement ramped up when their brain had work to do. 9:45 One of the researchers said the typical approach of trying to reduce hyperactivity is exactly the opposite of what we should be doing for most of these kids. 9:52 His point wasn't to let them run laps around the classroom. 9:55 It was just that they need to move to stay alert enough to think. 10:00 So the squirming, the foot tapping, and the pacing isn't the brain failing. 10:04 it's actually the Brain doing what it needs to do to engage. 10:09 And the round hole punishes that type of brain. 10:13 Other mismatches This brain type runs on interest School runs a schedule It often thinks in big pictures School grades the small details It learns by doing 10:27 School mostly asks kids to listen, remember, and write Recess and hands-on classes are usually the first things trimmed when there's pressure to raise 10:36 test scores. 10:37 And those are exactly the parts of the day where a square peg actually gets time to breathe. 10:43 I've got two of my kids for sure that I think would fit into this diagnosis, especially one of them who's a lot like me in that way, 10:54 and was very much a Square Peg in a round hole at school, just like I was. 11:01 And I can say this with relatively limited bias, relatively. 11:06 I am his father, but he's one of the smartest kids I've ever met. 11:11 As an adult now, he's as intelligent as just about anybody I know. 11:17 It was never an intelligence thing. 11:19 it was always a interest thing and he just wasn't that interested in most of the stuff that they were teaching at school. 11:28 In fact, sometimes he would come home to me and say, you know what dad, I think I'm smarter than my teachers. 11:35 And that might sound arrogant, but I, think he probably was in a lot of cases. 11:40 And that makes it a little tough for some of us square pegs. 11:45 The square Peg isn't defective because it doesn't fit the round hole. 11:49 It's just a different shape. 11:50 the question is whether we keep pounding or we start looking for a square hole? 11:56 Now, if you want to understand this brain type in one image, it comes from a Dr.
ADHD as a Brain Type, Not a Disorder 12:01 Edward Hallowell. 12:02 He's a psychiatrist who taught at Harvard Medical School for years, and along with his colleague, Dr John Rattay, he wrote the book that introduced a lot 12:11 of Americans to this subject way back in 1994. Dr Halllowell also has this braintype himself, He says. 12:18 he describes it as a Ferrari engine for a brain with bicycle brakes. 12:23 Think about what that means. 12:24 A Ferrari Engine isn't broken. 12:26 It's one of those powerful engines ever built, finely tuned, works really, really well. 12:31 The problem isn't the engine, the problem is that the brakes haven't caught up to it yet. 12:35 And nobody looks at a Ferrari with weak brakes and says, this car has a disorder. 12:42 Let's slow this engine down. 12:46 Instead, you got to strengthen the breaks. 12:49 What Hallowell has said is this. 12:52 People with this brain type don't have a deficit of attention at all. 12:56 They actually have an abundance of it. 12:58 The challenge is steering it, not finding it." He has called the name itself a terrible term and said labeling these people with a disorder is a disservice, 13:09 which it is. 13:11 In 2021, he and Dr. 13:12 Rattay proposed a new name, VAST. 13:16 Variable attention stimulus trait. 13:19 I'd never heard of that until I was prepping this show, but I like it variable attention Stimulus trait vast we'll say vastly different maybe but not vastly 13:32 inferior a Classroom a workplace or a family built on fear and punishment is the real? 13:37 Disability more than the brain type itself according to dr. 13:40 Hallowell notice the word in vast Trait not disorder. 13:47 He describes it as a trait that can become a tremendous asset if it's managed well and a disaster if It isn't that's true of just about every strong trait 13:57 a person can have a strong will a big personality a sharp tongue every one of them can build something or Burn something down when he works with a child 14:07 One of the first things he tries to take away is fear because a kid who's afraid of failing has a really really hard time learning So, 14:16 picture your child, or picture yourself as a kid, a Ferrari engine sitting in a round hole classroom, getting told every day to slow down, 14:27 sit still, stop being so much. 14:32 It's no wonder so many of these kids start to believe something is actually wrong with them. 14:37 Let's look at how the label actually gets assigned, because once you see it, it's hard to unsee. 14:42 There's no blood test, there's not brain scan used to diagnose it. 14:46 there is no lab value, no genetic marker, and no biomarker of any kind. 14:51 The diagnosis comes from that checklist that we started the show with. 14:54 I just read it to you, filled out by parents and teachers, plus a clinician's judgment about whether the behaviors are causing enough trouble. 15:04 Trouble for who? 15:05 Oftentimes trouble for the school. 15:08 not necessarily trouble for the child. 15:10 Compare that to something like type 1 diabetes. 15:14 Either the pancreas is producing insulin or it isn't. 15:17 You can measure it. 15:18 There's a clear line. 15:19 ADHD does not work that way. 15:21 And the research says so. 15:25 In 2011, researchers asked one question, are these traits a separate category where you either have it or you don't or a continuum that runs through the 15:34 whole population? 15:36 Using data on more than a thousand kids from a large national study funded by the National Institutes of Health, the answer was a Continuum the way height 15:45 or shoe size is. 15:46 2012, a follow-up study found the same thing in adults. 15:50 Researchers at the University of Southampton in England have described the cutoff for diagnosis as something defined by how much burden the traits create 15:59 for the person and for society, not by a distinct biological state. 16:05 So, think about height. 16:06 I mentioned earlier, I'm 5'6", not very tall for a dude in America. 16:12 Some are 6'5". 16:14 Someone could draw a line and say everyone above 6 foot 4 has a height disorder because they keep hitting their heads on door frames built for average people. 16:24 The line would be real, but it would a choice and the doorframes would actually be part of the problem. 16:32 Having the traits isn't enough for a diagnosis. 16:35 The book requires clear evidence that the trades interfere with your social, academic, or job functioning. 16:42 That's the part that turns the trait into a disorder on paper. 16:47 And that interference depends almost entirely on the environment. 16:51 The same child who interferes with functioning in a fourth grade classroom might be the best worker on a ranch, the most creative kid in the art room, 16:59 or the one who can't be beaten on soccer field. 17:02 Two children can walk out of the same doctor's office with the three letters on their chart and have almost nothing in common. 17:09 One is dreamy and quiet and loses track of time, and the other is bouncing off the walls talking a mile a minute, one label, 17:17 two completely different kids. 17:19 When a label stretches that far, you have to ask how much it's telling you about the individual child in front of you. 17:26 And this one's wild. 17:27 That's another one I learned in prepping for this. 17:30 If you want proof that the classroom plays a big role in who gets this label. 17:34 Here's the study that shows it most clearly. 17:38 Researchers looked at the insurance records of more than 400,000 elementary school kids, They focused on states that require kids to turn five by September 17:50 1st to start kindergarten. 17:51 You know, the cutoff that we talk about a lot. 17:54 That means a child born in August, like I was, walks in as one of the youngest in the room, Like I did.
How ADHD Is Diagnosed and Why Itu2019s Subjective 18:00 A child, born September, just weeks later, Walks in a year later as One of The Oldest Children. 18:06 The August kids. 18:08 were 34% more likely to be diagnosed with ADHD than their September classmates, a third more than likely. 18:18 and more likely to be put on a medication for it. 18:22 The gap didn't show up between any other neighboring birth months or in states with different cutoff dates. 18:28 It only appeared exactly where the school calendar put a younger child next to an older one. 18:34 One of the researchers estimated that for the August-born kids, roughly one in four of those diagnoses could just absolutely be wrong. 18:43 Think about what a teacher sees. 18:45 A five-year-old who is almost a full year younger than the kid at the next desk is going to be more wiggly, more distractible, 18:53 and less able to sit through circle time. 18:55 That's not a disorder. 18:57 It's being five instead of six. 18:59 But side by side, it looks like a problem. 19:01 The teachers and school staff are usually the first ones to raise the flag with parents. 19:06 And I think that's a Teachers ought not to be, in my view, diagnosing any child or suggesting that any children has a disorder. 19:16 I can't get behind that at all. 19:18 The lead author had a son with a birthday close to the cutoff. 19:23 Based on what he'd seen in the research, his family decided to hold his son back a year. 19:27 So if you have a child with the summer birthday, who's been flagged by the school, ask yourself, is my child struggling or is it just the youngest kid 19:34 in this room? 19:36 because they could literally be that. 19:38 Now you might be thinking, this is just one guy on a podcast who could have been diagnosed with ADHD, has an ax to grind, 19:45 and has kids that could've been diagnose with ADHD and he's not an expert any more than the teachers are. 19:52 Well, guess what? 19:54 That is true. 19:55 I'm not a psychologist, I am not an expert in the field of neurological health. 20:04 What I AM is a concerned father and grandfather and frankly this whole podcast stems from a conversation I had with a lovely mother. 20:16 The other night here at Vitality Nutrition, who came in and spent about 45 minutes talking to me about her children. 20:22 One of which was just diagnosed and recommended a amphetamine drug to get on top of it. 20:30 And she wanted to try a natural approach first. 20:33 We had this conversation and I thought, you know, I haven't taken this on in a while. 20:37 I'm going to do it a little bit differently because what I told her is what? 20:41 I tell anybody that asks me ADHD can be a superpower. 20:47 it absolutely can be a superpower. 20:51 It's like I'm five foot six. 20:55 My favorite sport is basketball. 20:57 I am a pretty good shooter, but I not so great at boxing people out under the key and getting the rebound over people that are a foot taller than me. 21:08 Not so good at volleyball either, I love that sport as well. 21:12 These are square peg round hole situations, right? 21:17 but it doesn't mean that I can't excel in other aspects of life. 21:23 I actually probably could be really good at some other sports, not professional level. 21:30 And just not the most athletic guy in the world. 21:32 But I started on our high school basketball team. 21:36 It was just a really, really small school. 21:38 So I was able to get away with it. 21:39 so it worked out. 21:41 but the point is not everyone fits in everything Just like the tall kid who keeps bumping his head on the door frame, right? 21:50 But it's not just my opinion. 21:51 There are experts who agree this way too. 21:54 So let me tell you about the three people who are not on. 21:57 On the fringe of this field, they are in this. 22:01 Keith Connors, a doctor, psychologist and professor emeritus at Duke university. 22:07 He spent more than 50 years fighting to get ADHD recognized. 22:14 So this guy's on probably the other side of this. 22:17 A rating scale used all over the world to evaluate kids carries his name. 22:23 In 2013, CDC data showed the diagnosis had been made in 15% of high school age kids, 2013. And the number of children on medication had climbed from 600,000 22:33 in 1990 to 3.5 million. 22:38 in 2013. Standing in front of a room full of ADHD specialists, he called those rising diagnosis rates a national disaster of dangerous proportions. 22:53 He started part of this and then said, uh-oh, it's gone too far. 22:58 He said the numbers were concoction to justify handing out medication at unprecedented and unjustifiable levels.
Why ADHD Traits Persist and Can Be Strengths 23:06 That's the guy whose name is on the test. 23:09 Dr. 23:10 Alan Francis, chairman of psychiatry at Duke and chair of the task force that wrote the fourth edition of The DSM, that red book I was telling you about, 23:18 published back in 94. He literally oversaw that book. 23:22 Years later, he publicly said his edition helped spark three false epidemics. 23:28 and attention deficit was one of them. 23:30 He pointed to changes in the wording of the criteria, heavy drug company marketing to doctors and the public, pressure from overwhelmed parents and teachers, 23:38 and extra test time and school services that come with a diagnosis. 23:43 In 2013, he wrote that psychiatric diagnoses still rely entirely on subjective human judgment. 23:53 not objective biological tests. 23:55 And Dr. 23:55 Leon Eisenberg, many people have heard of this guy, a child psychiatrist at Johns Hopkins and later at Harvard, and a pioneer in the early research on 24:05 hyperactive kids and stimulant drugs way back in 1960s. 24:09 You may have seen a story online that he made a deathbed confession that ADHD doesn't exist. 24:15 That's not exactly what happened. 24:18 but the accurate version is pretty compelling to me. 24:22 In 2009, about seven months before he died at the age of 87, he gave an interview to the German magazine Der Spiegel. 24:29 He said he never would have imagined his work would become so popular. 24:34 he called ADHD a prime example of a fabricated disorder and said the genetic predisposition is completely overrated. 24:43 He meant that doctors should dig into what's going on in a child's life at home, at school, and in their relationships before deciding the problem is actually 24:53 in the childs brain. 24:54 He said those questions take a lot of time. 24:57 And then with a sigh, he said, it's just much quicker to just prescribe a pill. 25:05 So the man whose name is on the rating scale, the men who chaired the book that defines it, who pioneered the studies from the very beginning, 25:15 they all say it's gotten out of hand in one way or the other. 25:18 They're not saying what I'm saying, but they're saying enough, I think. 25:24 So if these traits were truly a defect, why are they still so common? 25:29 Evolution is ruthless, and getting rid of things that don't help us survive is really what evolution is about, right? 25:37 Traits that stick around in large numbers of people usually stick round for a reason. 25:44 In the early 1990s, an author named Tom Hartman put a name to this idea. 25:49 For almost all of human history, people lived as hunters and gatherers. 25:53 The one who ate was the person who scanned the horizon constantly, noticed every movement in the grass, could drop everything and sprint the moment an 26:04 opportunity showed up, got bored with one spot and moved on to the next spot. 26:08 Then in a relatively short stretch of history, most of us became farmers and later factory workers and office workers. 26:15 Have you ever seen office space? 26:17 Yeah, that. 26:18 That's kind of school too, right? 26:20 Suddenly, the winning traits were patience, routine, and doing the same task in the place for hours on end. 26:27 The hunter's brain didn't change, but the world he lived in changed a lot. 26:33 Researchers studied the aerial people of Northern Kenya. 26:37 Some still live as nomads, herding livestock. 26:39 Others have settled into villages. 26:41 They looked at a version of dopamine receptor, a dopamine-receptor gene linked to novelty-seeking and ADHD traits. 26:49 Among the nomades, men who carried the gene were better nourished. 26:53 among the settled villagers, it was the absolute opposite. 26:57 Same gene, same people, the same genetic background, opposite results based on what? 27:03 environment. 27:04 The researchers suggested a nomad with this gene might be better at defending livestock or finding food and water while the same tendencies just didn't 27:14 serve him as well in the classroom or selling goods in a market. 27:18 Another one, berry picking study. 27:21 457 adults played an online foraging game, collecting as many berries as possible in eight minutes. 27:28 Each bush gave fewer berries every time you picked. 27:30 You could keep picking or spend time traveling to a fresh bush. 27:35 People with more ADHD traits left each bush sooner, moved to the new patches more often and collected more berries. 27:41 People without those traits tended to stay too long at the bushes that were running dry. 27:47 The lead researcher said that if these traits were truly negative, you'd expect evolution to have weeded them out by now. 27:54 Your child's brain may be built for a world that rewards exploring, scanning, moving, and jumping on opportunity. 28:00 That's why so many people with ADHD are entrepreneurs and not working in somebody's office for someone else. 28:07 And other people are much more comfortable working the office, not being the entrepreneur. 28:12 Both are fine. 28:14 It's not that one is wrong or one right. 28:17 They're just different. 28:21 Not broken. 28:23 Not Broken is a big theme on Vitality Radio. 28:27 If you've heard Jen's story, which many of you have, you know that Not broken is what I needed to convince her of her brain initially until she was able
Labels, Childhood Stories, and the Power of Environment 28:36 to convinced herself. 28:38 If you heard the I Am episode that we recently recorded, you know how much weight I put on the labels that were attached to ourselves and to our kids. 28:46 When you say, I am something, You're not describing a passing state. 28:50 You are signing the mortgage on it instead of checking into the hotel for a night. 28:55 And kids do this faster than adults do. 28:58 Hand a seven-year-old a diagnosis with the word disorder in it, and it doesn't take long before he's telling himself, I'm the kid with a broken brain. 29:06 I am the kids who can't pay attention. 29:07 And the bad kid, who causes trouble in class. 29:11 The kid who always gets called at or reprimanded. 29:15 They're not using that word, you know, in trouble by the teacher. 29:21 Let me tell you a story about me as a kid. 29:23 So I went to a little tiny private school and I was in the fourth grade. 29:29 And in fourth, grade I, was the biggest troublemaker in class. 29:34 Hands down. 29:36 Interestingly enough, the principal that owned and ran the school adored me. 29:42 We were almost friends, good friends with all of his kids. 29:48 And his mother-in-law was my teacher, okay? 29:53 Mrs. 29:53 Fox. 29:54 She was an old lady and she was great. 29:58 But I was all she could handle. 30:00 I ended up in the principals office almost every single day in fourth grade. 30:05 But this was an interesting school because this school was very, very small. 30:09 My graduating class as a senior was 18 kids and it was the biggest graduating they'd ever had. 30:14 On average, my classes had somewhere between six to 15 students. 30:21 And while I did get in trouble a lot in the fourth grade, we just didn't jive me and Mrs. 30:26 Fox. 30:27 I got nothing bad to say about Mrs Fox, I think she even liked me. 30:30 It was just a pain in her butt. 30:33 and I was a fidgety mess in her eyes. 30:36 But you know what happened when I went to the principal's office? 30:39 For the most part, Jack, the Principal, kind of just laughed it off. 30:44 He knew what was going on. 30:45 he knew who the teacher was.He knew her well.he knew me because I've been going there since kindergarten and because i wasn't one of hundreds of kids. 30:52 Iwas one dozens of Kids. 30:55 And I was fine. 30:55 And by the 12th grade, I as a student body president, and I did just fine, had the best grades in the senior class. 31:03 Same brain, same kid, but I able to work my way through the program, through system in a very different way because of the type of school that it was. 31:16 The environment worked for me. 31:18 I anticipate I would not have done nearly as well in a big school or especially a Big Public School. 31:25 But it wasn't because I was disordered. 31:28 I Was just Jared. 31:29 Just the same guy I am now talking here into this microphone that a lot of people seem to like listening to. 31:36 but I never made to think even when Mrs. 31:40 Fox sent me to the principal's office almost every day, she to some degree had me thinking, well, maybe I am trouble, but I never was made to think that 31:50 I was really that much trouble by Jack, the principal. 31:54 As I think back on it, I that made a really, really big difference. 32:00 The belief does more damage than the traits ever could. 32:03 A child who believes he's broken stops trying in the places where he could shine. 32:08 He waits for a pill or an adult to fix him. 32:11 a child, who beliefs his brain is a different shape, a powerful one, A Ferrari that needs the right track to run on does go looking for that track. 32:23 In 2006, the education writer, Sir Ken Robinson, gave a talk that's been watched by tens of millions of people, a TED Talk. 32:31 In it, he told the story of a little girl named Gillian in England in the 1930s. 32:35 Her school wrote to her parents saying they thought she had a learning disorder. 32:40 This is way before ADHD was a thing. 32:43 You know, the term ADHD was a thing anyway, she couldn't concentrate. 32:47 She was fidgeting and she was disrupting class. 32:49 So her mother took her to see a specialist. 32:51 The doctor talked with her, with their mother for a while with Jillian sitting on her hands, trying to keep still. 32:58 Then he told Jillien he needed to speak with. 33:00 Her mother privately turned on the radio and walked out of the room with, her mom in the hall. 33:05 He told her Mother to watch the second they left. 33:08 Jillie was up on our feet, moving to the music. 33:10 And the doctor said, Mrs. 33:12 Lin, Jillian isn't sick. 33:15 She's a dancer. 33:16 Take her to a dancing school. 33:19 That little girl was Jillien Lin. 33:21 she went on to dance with the Royal Ballet and became one of the most successful choreographers in history.
Gillian Lynne, Permission, and Part Two Preview 33:30 Ken Robinson pointed out that someone else might have put her on a medication and told her to calm down. 33:36 One doctor looked at the same fidgeting, the lack of concentration, and saw a gift, a superpower, instead of a problem. 33:45 That's the permission that I would like to give you today. 33:50 You might not get that. 33:52 from your doctor, you might not get that from the teacher, but as I was talking to this wonderful mother, this caring, loving mother the other day, 34:05 I wasn't sure, frankly, if I I wasn't trying to push at all. 34:11 I never want anybody listening to my show to feel judgment about whatever decisions you've made for yourself, for your children. 34:19 My perspective, you have yours and we all have the various pressures that we deal with. 34:24 But as I was talking to this beautiful human being, I could just tell how much she loved and cared about her children, felt like she was actually asking 34:32 for permission to see it a different way. 34:35 with her kids. 34:36 I'm not sure if that's what it was, but by the end, she was very, very grateful for the conversation that we had. 34:42 And that what spurred this episode. 34:44 So please, with whatever I've said, agree, disagree, whatever it is, just know this show is about love, about compassion. 34:54 For some kids like me and like mine who can get trapped in a system and then medicated to slow down that Ferrari engine. 35:12 Exactly what's going on and you know how I feel about pharma I would anticipate if you're listening to my show you probably feel similarly at least to 35:21 some degree I just simply refuse to believe that ADHD Should have that last D at the very least that disorder word. 35:30 It is not period And I hope that I've given you enough evidence during the show that you can see it that way as well There's no blood test. 35:40 There was no biomarker. 35:42 The movement isn't the enemy. 35:44 It's actually the brain trying to help do the thing. 35:48 I'll give you just a quick little challenge. 35:50 If you want, if you're not watching this on YouTube, you can normally listen on Apple or Spotify or wherever you listen, 35:55 watch me do my show. 35:58 if You like what I present, Watch me, do My show one time and you'll see there's not a lot of stand still. 36:04 i'm not sitting down. 36:05 stand up when I do. 36:06 My Show it's much less restrictive. 36:09 I am a square peg. 36:12 Episode two, we're going to talk about what this brain type does brilliantly, hyper-focus, creativity, and why IQ tests often miss how smart these kids 36:22 really are. 36:23 This is fascinating stuff. 36:24 We'll also look at a few things that can look exactly like ADHD and are worth ruling out first. 36:30 And we'll get practical about how to strengthen the brakes naturally with food, sleep, movement, key nutrients that the busy brain runs on and may need 36:41 more of. 36:42 Part two next on Vitality Radio. 36:44 I'll see you then. 36:45 Thanks for listening to the Vitaly Radio podcast. 36:48 If this episode helped you follow the show, share it with someone and explore trusted education and resources at vitalitynutrition.com. 36:57 See you next time. 37:00 Hello, everyone. 37:00 I hope you enjoyed this week's episode of Vitality Radio. 37:05 Just a reminder that this podcast is for educational purposes only. 37:10 This podcast has not been evaluated by the FDA. 37:30 Thank you.
Comments